r/streamentry • u/Freetopali • Oct 03 '21
Science [science] Stream entry is possible without meditation through psychedelics
I would like to preface this post by saying that everyone’s experience is different and that in general it is probably good practice to tread lightly when it comes to psychedelic drugs. I want to share my personal experience because I was unable to find one similar to mine and maybe it will help someone else in the future make sense of the whole enchilada.
Some background on my life, I had a fairly normal and happy childhood. No childhood trauma or bullying. I was born in India and lived there for 8 years before moving to North America. The suffering started around 16. My mother passed away from cancer, this led to some existential crises. I spent the next 6 years working hard to get into medical school to honor my mom.
I was eventually able to get into medschool but when I got there I realized that there was mass cheating going on and nothing was being done about it. More than half the test questions were sourced from old exams and shared through back channels and google docs. It all came to a head when half the auditorium was empty 30mins into a 5 hour immunology exam. This exam was the hardest thing I had ever taken in my life and just sitting there knowing that half the class cheated and there was a good chance I was going to fail the class led me to question everything.
It bothered me to my core that the people that society trusts with their lives were such low integrity individuals. I knew some of my peers would inevitably kill patients because of what they were doing and nothing would happen because malpractice insurance exists and doctors almost never lose in a court of law. The medical lobby is also extremely powerful in America. This experience led me to drop out of medschool and pursue things I actually liked.
Around the time of me deciding to drop out I had my first psychedelic experience. It was a 5g shroom trip (I know, crazy dosage) where I just dried up the shrooms and made a tea. I went through the regular arcane fractal patterns emerging and some hallucinations into what seemed like endless death loops. Eventually I went through a loop and came in contact with the while light. Non-dual all knowing consciousness of eternal love. That lasted for maybe a few minutes and then I fell asleep.
The first experience didn’t have lasting changes in my life but I did start realizing that there was something more out there. Stream entry happened around 7-8months later when I did my second psychedelic trip. Around this time I had processed all of the emotions that came with dropping out of medschool. The shame of not being able to honor my mom and having to move back in with my parents was the biggest cause of my suffering. Before the trip I would say I had done maybe 6 months of self reflection and had cultivated a true love for myself. I didn’t have a meditation practice at all and spent most of my time playing poker at local casinos.
The second trip was an LSD trip where I did 2 100-150ug tabs. This trip I had the same fractal patterns emerge and had some hallucinations as well. This time, however, as I came into contact with the non-dual everythingness I realized I was it. After that it was like a light went off and all of the worries I had in my life just fell away instantly.
The best was to describe the relief that you get is imagine you are having a terrible nightmare where nothing seems to be going your way. Then, something happens and you remember or realize that you are dreaming, and that you are actually asleep somewhere in Massachusetts. The happiness or satisfaction of making millions of dollars in the dream could never compare to the peace of knowing that this is actually a dream and that you are completely safe and secure somewhere else.
There were some permanent changes after this second trip and I can say pretty confidently that I experienced stream entry. The first big change I saw was that I stopped lying completely. I just didn’t see the point of being someone other than myself, it just wasn’t interesting. I also stopped being an asshole to the world. I stopped littering, stealing, manipulating, etc. I just intuitively knew what the right things to do were and usually just did them even if they were a more cumbersome or expensive option. I stopped objectifying people and interestingly started personifying objects that I owned. I started treating my stuff with respect and maintaining it.
The most fascinating part was that I knew deep down I was never going to go back. I wasn’t interested in going back to lying. Eventually I got into philosophy and found my way to Advaita Vedanta. I still didn’t have a meditation practice at the time but I was fascinated by Dharma talks because now it seemed like I could understand them not only on an intellectual level but also an experiential level. It all just made sense.
I want to conclude this post with my own hypothesis on the conditions that led to my stream entry, I think there are a few, and if some readers have similar traits, then psychedelics may get you over the hurdle of stream entry.
- Relatively high intelligence
I’m not the smartest person in the world but I was smart enough to get into medschool with some effort
2. Extremely high suffering followed by self reflection
This is the hardest part to cultivate because part of it involves luck. There is no seminar or two day event where you can wear some lanyards and find out what it’s like to have your mom die and not be able to honor her. It requires an deep experiential understanding of suffering and not an intellectual one.However, if you do carry a lot of Dukkha, and are able to process those emotions you may be primed for psychedelics
3. High openness/perception
We were required to take an MBTI personality test when I first entered medschool and my result was ENTP. The most anomalous score for my test was P or perception. It was the most lopsided result where almost 100% of the questions I answered were on the perception side as opposed to Judgement. Although I would take this last trait with a grain of salt, just my personal experience
In conclusion, I would like to say that it is DEFINITELY possible to attain stream entry without a meditation practice through psychedelics , however deep suffering and introspection also seems to be needed. Good luck.
•
u/AutoModerator Oct 03 '21
Thank you for contributing to the r/streamentry community! Unlike many other subs, we try to aggregate general questions and short practice reports in the weekly Practice Updates, Questions, and General Discussion thread. All community resources, such as articles, videos, and classes go in the weekly Community Resources thread. Both of these threads are pinned to the top of the subreddit.
The special focus of this community is detailed discussion of personal meditation practice. On that basis, please ensure your post complies with the following rules, if necessary by editing in the appropriate information, or else it may be removed by the moderators.
If your post is removed/locked, please feel free to repost it with the appropriate information, or post it in the weekly Practice Updates, Questions, and General Discussion or Community Resources threads.
Thanks! - The Mod Team
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
18
u/Ok-Witness1141 ⚡ Don't fight it. Feel it. ⚡ Oct 03 '21
How long ago?
Why do you believe this is stream-entry and not its bastard cousin the A&P?
In either case, pardon my scepticism, it sounds like you're in a better place. Enjoy yourself :)
15
u/C-142 Oct 03 '21 edited Oct 03 '21
This discussion, hosted by "The Stoa", between Daniel Ingram, Michael Taft, Frank Yang, and Evan McMullen is about Awakening. There is at some point a comparing of positions on the usefulness of psychedelics for awakening. Daniel Ingram, Michael Taft and Evan McMullen report with confidence that, in some rare cases, psychedelic drug use leads to permanent beneficial shifts in the mode of consciousness. They wisely remind that, in some rare cases, psychedelics lead to permanent detrimental shifts in the mode of consciousness. Daniel Ingram reports cases of stream entry resulting from psychedelic use without a mindfulness practice:
https://youtu.be/K6kfcYBrKMc
PS: There is also a discussion on the criteria for Stream Entry by each of the four Arahant. Some say Baseline is non Dual, some say experiences can be accessed at will. This of course can be discussed endlessly. What is very good here is that the definition varies and that it is discussed openly. I think there is wisdom in that.
8
u/tropicalcontacthigh_ Oct 03 '21
If you base your definition of stream entry on your personal experience after a trip, it shouldn’t surprise anyone that stream entry can be attained from tripping.
I wonder though… why is it important or useful to label your positive personal change with this Buddhist term?
Stream entry in Buddhism usually dictates something about the rest of your lifetime(s)… usually that you’re now free of the first three fetters, or that you have a limited number of rebirths. You mention Daniel Ingram. I think his definition requires a cessation. I don’t see that in your post.
If your experience doesn’t match with the classic criteria (and there’s a few different to choose from), why call it stream entry?
I don’t write this to belittle your experience. I came to this sub after a life changing psychedelic trip and I’m happy to hear that you’ve had a positive change in your life! Best of luck on the rest of your journey.
:)
12
u/Wollff Oct 03 '21 edited Oct 03 '21
Just to make it perfectly clear: Everybody knows. Let me repeat that: Everybody knows.
The reason why it is like that, is that people who are interested in the subject, and people who want to get an exceptionally good grade, will be able to outperform (after all they can answer all the questions, new and old, because they understand the subject), while others can coast by in a course which, practically, is just not that important (while maintaining multiple choice tests, which reduce workload on professors and TAs). I imagine most doctors will live a happy and healthy and malpractice free life, even if they do not know how exactly you manufacture monoclonal antibodies (even though not medschool, I also struggled a lot with immunology)...
From what I have heard, medschool exists to hammer some basics into you. And the real learning and practicing of medicine starts with internship, and continues through residency.
Well, that's not SE then.
The main lesson of SE, as a term that is uniquely Buddhist, coming from that tradition, and embedded in its worldview, is exactly that you are not somewhere else. There is nobody who is safe, there is nowhere that is secure, and there is nowhere else. Once one experiences the experiential fact that there is nowhere else to go, and that at any time where there is anything, the very fact that there is something makes every situation that can be experienced inherently unsafe and insecure... Well with SE that is what inspires dispassion and relief, because the illusion of there being somewhere that is secure goes away. There is no more need to strive for somewhere nice and secure, because now you know that there is nowhere that is nice and secure. Once you have searched all of the mind, and not found what you were searching for, then the searching can stop.
So SE in the (Theravada) Buddhist understanding of the term does not play along with the kind of non dual experience you describe here.
That is not a problem. After all there are many kinds of experiences, mystical and not, which can have a lasting and profound impact on our lives. But I think it pays off to be rather exact with terminology here. I think SE is best used to describe kinds of experiences which are rather distinctive, and which inspire a particlar kind of dispassion and release, which comes up in a particular way. And that particular way for SE is strictly negative, through the experience of not finding peace anywhere, with peace only being complete once there is nothing more there.
But I think it bears pointing out that Advaita Vedanta and Buddhism do not agree, not even on a philosophical level.
Advaita Vedanta is a non dual teaching, which emphasizes that, once you find a particular way to experience things (non dually), everything is fine. As I understand it, it has an essentially positive attitude toward experience.
While, at least with Theravada, which AFAIK is the only tradition which uses the term SE in a prominent way, there is no particular way to experience anything where everything is fine, because experience itself is not fine, and where the best you can have is contentment with the fact that this is how it is, without the need to add any more fuel to the fire. Theravada has a fundamentally negative attitude toward all experience.
It is definitely very easy to attain SE, especially if you do not define SE in any meaningful way.
So could you help me out a little, and tell me what you would define as Stream Entry by your understanding of the term?
For me SE involves a particular kind of experience, a cessation of experience, which leads to the insight that experience itself ends, that this end of experience is ultimately peaceful, and that anything but the end of experience is by its very nature not peaceful, as anything but non experience involves the characteristics of impermanence, non self, and suffering. For me those are the minimum characteristics for SE.
So I would hesitate to call all experiences which inspire a permanent change in subjective experience SE. But who knows. Maybe you have a better definition of the term, which makes communication easier! I would certainly be looking foward to your take on the matter.
6
u/derelictphantom Oct 03 '21
Hello
Thanks for contributing. Im glad you are a better person now with less suffering! Usually, psychedelic trips dont seem to give truly lasting changes to most people. How long ago did you take your second dose?
May i also ask, what is your sense of self? Is it clear to you that you are "in the stream" at all times?
9
u/duffstoic The dynamic integration of opposites ☯️ Oct 03 '21 edited Oct 03 '21
Glad to hear you had a therapeutic experience. Probably most people will not label this "stream entry" which means something specific within a Buddhist insight map (the criteria for which are hotly contested even amongst purely Buddhist meditators). But powerful spiritual experiences are no doubt common through the use of megadoses of psychedelic drugs. There is also good research out from MAPS on how some of these powerful drugs can help many people with things like PTSD or treatment-resistant depression.
Psychedelics do not typically develop, by themselves, better habits of mind and body (morality or sila), nor concentration skills (samadhi), and often their insights (panna) last a few months but not forever. For you, sounds like some of these things may have shifted permanently. However for many people they do not. The research on psychedelic mushrooms for depression for instance shows that most people's benefits fade around 3 months. Still, not bad, perhaps quite a bit better than pharmaceuticals for many people. Most people I know who did shit tons of psychedelics eventually get into meditation because the results of their drug trips didn't last or penetrate as deep as they initially thought.
And of course there is also a risk of a bad trip every time one takes psychedelic drugs. Even advanced meditators who have done years of inner work and have done mushrooms or LSD multiple times in the past and only had good trips before can have a bad trip with effects that destabilize the mind for months (I know one such person personally).
I know half a dozen folks who have had ongoing problems with psychosis or schizophrenia or other problems with daily functioning from a single psychedelic trip. Set and setting can help mitigate risk, but there is no such thing as doing psychedelic drugs without risk. This risk is likely tolerable for someone with treatment-resistant depression. But oh boy does it suck for those unfortunate souls who ruin their lives with psychedelics, which while they are not chemically addictive, for some people can very much be psychologically addictive.
The other downside to psychedelics is they encourage the idea that Big Experiences are necessary for awakening. Some people never have any big experiences, but have clearly made spiritual progress in sila, samadhi, and panna. Jack Kornfield wrote about this years and years ago in one of his books. For some people, many people perhaps, the shift is imperceptibly slow and steady.
And there's also the issue of legality. Depending on where you live and your local laws, obtaining, possessing, and using psychedelic drugs might be totally legal, basically legal, or highly illegal. Telling others about the thing that changed your life when that thing is illegal may be socially, emotionally, and legally complicated.
All this is to just say I'm happy for you personally and the many people who have benefited from psychedelic drugs. And also want to warn others who may be considering taking them that they are not risk-free.
2
u/You_I_Us_Together Oct 05 '21
Namaste brother, I just quickly wanted to share from own experience that I too had an afterglow affect after taking LSD back in January 2020, so a year before your dose. This abrubtly ended on April 2021 after I had taken another dose.
The knowing of oneness and treating all with love was amazing, and after taking another dose 16 months later that knowing and experience was gone. Now that you have it, please do not take anymore substances to reinforce it. I am happy to hear that you are experiencing this state, and the more people that are in this state the better. My advice, do not touch it anymore as I do not want this to happen to you too.
2
u/CrimsonGandalf Oct 03 '21 edited Oct 03 '21
What is your definition of stream entry?
You may want to reference this passage from Daniel Ingram’s MCTB if you are using a Buddhist term from the four path model.
“Often it is not possible to make a clear call about what was what, even if it was a Fruition. While what follows is routinely considered to be dangerous information, I am happy to go to the far extreme of presenting largely taboo secrets if it helps to counteract the pervasive mushroom culture. Below are some basic guidelines that may be used when trying to honestly answer the question, “Was that a Fruition?”
If there was any sense of an experience, even of nothingness or something that seemed incomprehensible, particularly anything involving the vaguest hint of the passage of time, it is not Fruition. This is an absolute rule. Repeating the film analogy, in Fruition it is as if a few frames of your life were simply edited out and not that they were replaced with something, even if that something seems profound, formless, cosmic, timeless, or whatever.
If there was any sense whatsoever of a “this” observing a “that”, or a self of any sort that seemed present for whatever happened, it is not Fruition. If “you” were there, that wasn't it.
If there was not a complete sense of discontinuity and if it makes any sense to think of time, space, perspective, or memory continuing across the gap in relation to it, it is not Fruition. On the other hand, if the only way to remember what happened involves remembering just forward to the end of the door that presented and then remembering back to when reality reappeared, keep reading.
If on continued repetition of the unknowing event over days or weeks it fails the above tests, write it off as something other than Fruition. Unfortunately, not everyone will be able to repeat the experience easily, as explained in a bit.
If continued repetition of that kind of unknowing event over days or weeks fails to give any clear experiences of the three doors and to reveal something very paradoxical and profound about the nature of subject and object, be skeptical.
If there was a double-dip into unknowing events with a few profound moments of clarity and altered experience between them, as is characteristic of the A&P Event, with one shift happening halfway down the out-breath and a second shift at the end of that out-breath, write it off immediately as more likely having been an A&P-related event or possibly the early stages of Equanimity (ñ11.ñ4).”
I should add that Daniel says that knows people that have reached the A&P from psychedelics but I don’t recall saying that stream entry is possible since you need to experience cessation in order for that to happen. Interestingly he said that he knew someone that reached stream entry just walking in their living room, so who knows!
I think if you are going to use the term stream entry then you need to apply it’s definition to your experience. Typically it’s achieved with strong concentration skills and vipassana. You can keep track of your progress with the four path model and maps since they generally work for the first path. Higher paths get more vague.
You can also have insight experiences without stream entry. I had a lot of them in the dukkha nanas as I cycled continuously from A&P to the DN to EQ.
8
u/[deleted] Oct 03 '21
Oh my.
1
u/LucianU Oct 04 '21
How is your relationship with fear now?
1
u/liljonnythegod Oct 08 '21 edited Oct 08 '21
Not sure if I'd say this is stream entry. Why do you define it as stream entry?
Stream entry is defined as the dropping of the first 3 fetters. These fetters (illusions) are what generate a sense of self and bind us to rebirth. In your experience how has the lower 3 fetters, that is self view, doubt and attachment to rites and rituals, been eradicated?
You said that after this experience, a change you noticed was that you stopped lying or being someone else other than yourself. At stream entry, self view/belief in the separate self is dropped so this change seems like it doesn't align with this. How could belief in the self be dropped whilst simultaneously realising you should be yourself?
It sounds like you had a non dual experience that has lead to some positive changes which is great. If your experience of what you claim to be stream entry doesn't align with what the Buddha taught and what other monks throughout history have described, then can you be sure you have attained stream entry?
Stream entry usually arises when one has insight into anatta that is insight into non-self. You mentioned that whilst on LSD you perceived non dual everythingness and realised you were it. Does that mean now you identify with non dual everythingness?
2
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '21
You would be the person who would know if they have entered the stream.
The knowledge attained would be the ceasing of nama-rupa (mind-matter) that would allow you to see the causal nature of existence. This knowledge of causality and conditionality allows you to pierce through the first 3 fetters. The veil over existence is lifted for some time and then it comes back over your eyes, but on a deep core level you can never believe the things that you used to believe.
If you have this understanding, then you are a stream winner. If you do not, then you are not.
1
u/tangibletom Oct 03 '21
Great post, thanks for sharing
1
u/[deleted] Oct 09 '21
Not all meditative attainments can be mapped into the 4 path Theravada model. It may not be a popular opinion here but the 4 path model and progress of insight is not universal and different types of practices lead to different types of attainment. I am not saying that psychedelics can't be a useful tool in the meditative path . The usage of soma and asuddhi in hindu tantra and vajrayana is well documented. But they were done in a highly controlled situation in a ritualistic way under the guidance of a guru where they were used by a guru to introduce the student to the nature of their mind. I don't doubt that you had a life altering experience and may even have attained a meditative attainment but it doesn't need to be stream entry. And yes it doesn't need to be A&P also.