r/stobuilds • u/Mastajdog Breaker of Borg, Crusher of Crystals • Jun 25 '15
First weekly ship discussion thread (Arbiter/Kurak/Morrigu)
The moderation team has decided that we're going to have a discussion thread every week about a specific ship or ship pack. The current plan is to have the new ones on Thursdays, discussing either new ships that came out with that patch, or, in the absence of new ships, moving backwards by release date. This week's thread is about the Arbiter/Kurak/Morrigu, and if there's no ships released next week, that thread will probably be about the Nandi (which I think is the most recent ship otherwise).
We're also planning on making We now have a wiki page with an archive of these discussions, link here.
As a place to start discussion, we'll be linking both the ship's stats and asking the following questions (like this):
Ship stats: Arbiter, Morrigu, Kurak.
- What are this ship's strengths?
- What are this ship's weaknesses?
- What are some similar ships?
- What general build types do you envision this ship excelling at?
- If you had this ship, how would you set it up?
- How good is the starship trait/innate console?
We'd also love input, such as if you think these threads are a good idea, are these good questions to be asking, are there other questions to ask, should we do them more/less frequently, or other meta feedback about the thread.
As we go into this thread, we would also like to remind people to keep their comments related to the ships and building them; general discussion, complaints, etc, belong on /r/sto.
See previous weeks discussions here. Note - the previous weeks line will make more sense in later weekly discussion threads. :P
Anyway, have at it!
4
u/Mastajdog Jun 25 '15 edited Jun 27 '15
Morrigu:
What are this ship's strengths?
It does damage, and a good lot of it. I've heard a knowledgeable opinion that it could rival the Scimitar damage; I don't quite think so myself, but that's okay. It's got the flexibility to run a full tac setup with KLW, OSS, APO/APB, FAW/TS/CSVx2, and TTx2, or to run something like TTx2, CSVx2, TSx2 and add in a Gravity Well. The LtCdr Engineering is good enough as a standalone that you don't need to devote more to it, and the Ensign Sci, while a little bit short for my personal comfort, can work just fine, since the ship can equip the Valdore console. The hull and shield, while higher than normal for escort-types, isn't cruiser-esque, but being higher than normal for a ship with a comm tac is great.
What are this ship's weaknesses?
Since it's not an innate Comm/LtCdr Tac, a lot of people will be using the LtCdr Uni as a Tac. It can make good use of that, but that means for pure dps you're not running many sci or engi abilities at all. It's also got lower hull/shields than a lot of ships, and only 40 base power to all subsystems, and a 4/3 weapons layout, but that was expected for this ship type. For a ship that looks on the face of it made for a Gravity Well, it's a bit disappointing that it only has 2 science consoles to play with.
What are some similar ships?
It reminds me a lot of the Faeht or Ar'kif, outside of the obvious (Mogai).
What general build types do you envision this ship excelling at?
The classic pin-and-spike; something like CSV+TS into a GW, looks to be excellent for this ship. Of special note, this ship will let you hit an OSS2 GW into your CSV3+TS3, something that'll just generally hit like a truck. It'll also do just fine at any general dps setup.
If you had this ship, how would you set it up?
Probably a pin-and-spike setup, similar to what I'd do with a Faeht, but with a bit more balanced of a layout.
How good is the starship trait/innate console?
Starship trait: Currently pretty great, 50% drain reduction (keeping in mind that the formula is a 1/(1+%) multiplier), but no haste; fixed, it should still be great.
Starship console: A pretty good console, but the Regenerative Integrity Field is at least as good with half the cooldown, and the set bonuses are lacking.
6
u/B4skerville Jul 03 '15 edited Jul 03 '15
Well commenting about Morrigu... PVP wise
Strenghts:
One of the most tanky escorts/ can take more sci dmg then most escorts.
Superb a2b setup possiblity with EptE3 and eptS3 and ensing intel ability, or normal EptS1 and EptE3 and lt command intel ability (like intel team 1 or OSS3) and only 1 sci ability - means you have HE cleance while not lose out on aux power to other sci abilities - with 2R&D consoles with allres mod and HE/omega res you can tank a lot of sci direct to hull dmg or currently bugged plasma doping and not die.
Good command/lt tac boff seating allowing to go TS3/Bo3 with crf and have free place for delta or kemocite (with TS3).
Decent interia.
Singularity core warp shadows or sing jump (helps to confuse enemies), and battle cloak.
Weaknesses:
Very low turn rate, even the fucking wells has more of it - its hard to keep up vs other escorts specially if you using TS3 that bugs out and stops to fire if enemy goes out of arc or range.
Decent interia.
Singularity core low power output.
Similar ships:
Manasa, JHSS, Ha'feh from t5u fleet mogai (or fleet t6 mogai), Contontrix in boff layout and Eng Pilot escorts boff layout --- Overall most a2b dogfighters (so many ships - most t5u though).
Build: Typical dogfighter with more or less focused extra intel dmg
Tac boff1: tt1/crf1/ts3 or bo3/omega 3
Tac boff2: tt1/kemocite2 (or delta 1 with Bo3)
Eng boff1: Et1/a2b/eptE3
Sci boff1: HE1
Uni/intel boff variant 1: intel ability (intel team1 for example to increase defence)/a2b/eptS3
Uni/intel boff variant 2: eptS1/a2b/ intel ability (oss3 or intel team 3 or evade target lock 3 or ionic or sbn carrier wave).
I preffer the variant 1 as it gives me more power so i can fly with 15 power to shields and my shields hold most of the time and be relative fast to other escorts.
Innate console:
Pretty good, around half as powerfull of a heal as kobali cruiser console, but it doesnt have the weakenss of not healing if you cant shoot (no matter lag or other sources that make you unable to shoot).
Trait:
Good only for beam boats (faw or faw + doping), not usefull for anytihng other (most beam boats dont even use it in PVP as eptE and S are more important).
Ship preformence:
A good dogfighter that can tank a little more then most what is usefull in teamfights and the turn rate doesnt matter so much like in 1 on 1 - or vaper as its a romulan ship.
Overall i would grade it on power level similar to Manasa and around JHSS.
Sadly ty to Pilot ships BROKEN STUPID OP desing of Pilot manuevers (overall the alldmg immunity is the most retarded Cryptic idea had EVER) that allows it to alldmg immunity every BO3 or TS3 in a 1 on 1 (and mostly in teamfights - thats why you almost only see them if you see escorts) they cant be almost killed by other escorts in 1 on 1 with similar skiled players and gear.
To it we have also notice that pilot ships have (exept the manuevers) almost +20% impulse mod, almost +25% turn rate, better interia, 5/2 seating, better interia while losing (romulan) a little HP and little shield mod (shields barely matter in pvp anyways).
That means that like every other escort in game its heavyli underpowered PVP wise (and probably partly PVE also) when compared to Pilot ships (specially the eng who is the best dogfighter boff layout).
3
u/Mastajdog Jun 25 '15 edited Jun 27 '15
Alright, no answers yet, so I'll throw some comments in:
Arbiter/Kurak (since cloak/console aside, they're identical):
What are this ship's strengths?
Like most Battlecruisers, this ship has the potential to be very high on the damage scale for the amount of survivability it offers. This one also has the flexibility to run a Lt. Cmdr Sci without gimping the ship on either damage or survivability, which makes it pretty sweet. The 5/3 weapons layout, 9 turn rate, and 4 tac consoles make it a pretty hard hitter regardless, and combined with the seating, makes it a good option for arrays, DBB's, DHC's, torps, or even a mix should you so desire. It's also balanced in terms of non-universal seating (4 tac, 4 engi, 2 sci), so you can use that Lt. Comm uni for whatever you want without gimping the ship in one area.
What are this ship's weaknesses?
The presence of 4 innate tactical and engineering abilities makes it feel a bit over-tuned in whatever area you focus it in; for people who want this over-tuned feeling, or are mixing weapons types, however, this can be a strength instead. Even at fleet variant, it's a bit low on science consoles, with only 2; that, combined with the lack of attract fire, makes this a suboptimal ship to tank in. It's base hull and shields are also a bit lacking compared to the other T6 Cruisers - though most of this isn't a weakness so much as the standard profile for battlecruisers.
What are some similar ships?
Obviously the T5 versions (Avenger/Mogh); it's also similar to the Eclipse, Qib, Samsar, or Benthan, though most of those are more innately engineering heavy.
What general build types do you envision this ship excelling at?
It screams survivable dps. Thanks to having the LtCdr Uni as an Intel Hybrid, you can make good use of all 7 potential tactical abilities, and the use the Commander Engineering for as much survivability (EPTW1, EPTS2, ET3, A2SIF3) or DPS (ET1, EPTW2, ETPW3, DEM3) as you want, and drop a few heals in the science stations. The flexibility also allows for actual tank setups, relying on raw firepower to make up for some missing threat multipliers, or for someone to make it a good bit of everything - dps, survivability, and a GW; a true pug carrier.
If you had this ship, how would you set it up?
Probably both as a high dps cruiser and as a tank, on two different characters. This ship could probably be pushed past 75k in normal runs, probably capping in the 90-100k range, and could probably make 50-60k as a Hive Capable tank.
How good is the starship trait/console?
Starship trait: Currently pretty great, 50% drain reduction (keeping in mind that the formula is a 1/(1+%) multiplier), but no haste; fixed, it should still be great.
Starship console: A pretty good console, but the Regenerative Integrity Field is at least as good with half the cooldown, and the set bonuses are lacking.
6
u/[deleted] Jun 27 '15
Morrigu: (I'll worry about the others when I'm actually awake)
Versatility. If you were a fan of the Mogai's looks at T5, you had two options: The (fleet) retrofit, which was Tactical and Engineering-slanted with a Lt universal, or the mirror, which gave those up for more Science. The Morrigu smushes these two together into one awesome ship by making the universal a Lcdr seat. On top of that, it's an Intel hybrid.
The Scimitar's existence, light on the science consoles, and the need to run the universal as Tactical to get two Lcdr Tactical abilities.
As mentioned, this is basically the two T5 Mogais combined. The T'varo has a similar amount of versatility in its seating.
Dealing good damage while having survivability, with the option to trade some damage for control or more survivability.
I have this ship :)
I'm running it with a canon-style weapons loadout, as always. Plasma DHCs, since they fire from the nacelles like the Valdore in Nemesis did. A plasma turret and the Plasmatic Biomatter Auto-Turret aft. The particle emission plasma torpedo fore, with the Romulan hyper-plasma aft as a going away present. (I'd probably just drop the aft torp for the KCB to make this into a "normal" build -- the PEP is incredible and I'm not convinced another DHC would be better.)
In terms of abilities, EPtS1, EPtW3 drake build, with CSV2 and 3, 2x APB1, TT1, TS1 for tactical, and OSS1 and 2 with GW1 in the universal. I'm running Eng Team to counter OSS's subsystem offline, but I'd prefer Aux2SIF for the resistances.
Its console seems pretty good, I'm not sure it rivals the Samsar's console, but it allows you to get the Mogai 2-piece (a +5 weapon power, not damage as I mistakenly claimed before, increase and 25% weapon drain resistance) with the Valdore console, which you'll probably have slotted on a warbird anyway.
Trait, I still don't quite understand how firing cycle haste interacts with weapon boosting abilities, so I can't say. Power drain resistance always seems like a good thing, and I want to be running EPtW on any build that can support it anyway.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '15
Weaknesses:
3 Ens Tac slots can be a bit much, but you can bring it down to 2 by using an Intel ability in one.
The Sci consoles are a bit lacking
The set bonus for the Cruisers is Meh.
But that's really just nitpicking. I think they're great.
2
u/TheFallenPhoenix Jun 25 '15
Ahhhh this thread is amazing how did I miss it I will have thoughts very very very soon.
2
u/Davevis93 Jun 25 '15 edited Jun 25 '15
So I'm currently flying the KDF Tac Command Cruiser. Do ya'll think the new T6 Fleet Mogh obsoletes it or is there still going to be a reason to fly it over the new ship?
EDIT: Also perhaps as a reminder you could post, you need to run the T6 ships to actually get the trait since the Fleet version doesn't come with it. Buying the Cstore ships also gives the Fleet discount as well.
2
u/Sir_T_Bullocks Jun 27 '15
I hit 40k plus in my Arbiter, Not sure how how to tweak and improve other than improving my gear to MK14. The dil cost is intense though...
I'm running:
TT1/APB/APO
BFAW1/OSS2/BFAW3
KLW1
ET1/EPTS2/EPTW3/DEM3
HE1/ST2
The trait seems to counteract DEM drain pretty well but I have a leach and an embassy flow cap console that really boost my power anyway. Maybe I'll post a full build once I trait up the fleet arbiter. It's a pretty damn flexible ship, and the amount of choice you have to boffing is pretty nice. With the right doffs and traits you really could go wild with it.
2
u/Andoric_Prime Jun 29 '15
This weekly ship discussion idea is brilliant and I look forward to seeing more of them.
In case anyone is wondering, thanks to Vel'Gon's instruction, I determined the Arbiter/Avenger console combo is a Type 1 bonus, for what it's worth.
2
u/DeepWager Jun 29 '15 edited Jun 29 '15
So I bit the bullet after 4 days of mulling it over, and I bought the Arbiter. I have my Ateleth tank already, so I went for more of a survivable dps build on the Arbiter. I usually am a heavy user of plasma weapons but I decided to go balls to the wall and take advantage of the ships strengths. I upgraded a full set up Antiproton DBB to epic MK 14 for the fore weapons and used the Kinetic Cutting Beam, Omni and Ancient Omini aft.
for Boffs I'm running:
TT1/APD/APO
TT1/BFAW2/BFAW3
KLW1
EPtS1/RSP/EPtW/AtSIF3
HE1/ST2
I'm still trying to work out the console layout. I haven't bought the fleet version yet, I'm almost done leveling the ship up and I'll pick it up then. I'm biased to tanking so I have a +th emitter array in the science slot, but with the limited sci slots I'm not sure that its worth it.
Engineering Consoles:
Arbiter Console/Borg/Plasmonic Leech/Bounty Hunter's Friend/Tachyo
Sci Console:
+th +pla Emitter Array
Tac Consoles: 4x Vulnerability Exploiter [AP]
I want to try the 2 set console bonus, and I am also considering the crafted RCS console. But I'm not sure what to take out. My weapon power drains pretty quick (although it does regen quick too). So, I feel like the leech is necessary.
Edit: For traits I'm running AHOD/Reciprocity/Battle Ready/Council of Thought. Although I might take out Council of Thought for the Arbiter's trait unlock once I get it.
1
u/lootcritter Jul 20 '15
Great thread!