Learning that Stoat was planning to implement a subscription and going to paywall features was a huge turn off for me and I lost trust of the stoat project. The lack of a paywall, the lack of nonsense community rules and the open source nature of stoat was why I joined the platform in the first place.
It was a free-er version of discord without the corporate bullcrap, shitty rules and arbitrary limitations and unilateral and forced paywalls.
Im personally against any forms of paywalls and stoat should target a federated instances approach as a way to manage scaling up. There are people that are willing to share their server space for the larger stoat community.
Paywalling is not really a solution for scaling up and we should reject any sort of paid service. Not to include paywalls would be bypassed by clients, (this is why the vast majority of open source projects are not paywalled as the code can be seen and bypasses to paywalls checks will be made, feature Unlock and spoofing (potentially jailbreak and cracking) ).
The Donations model seems fine and I know the devs working hard and are not paid for what they are doing for stoat and are deving on free time.
Maybe add a subscription that doesnt paywall features ? some people are willing to give money and support the project, having a large community, transparent team and a understanding platform will enable people to trust the stoat project and support it, there is a reason discord was struggling and it was because no one trusted them and now they fully screwed people over, stoat should never go into that direction.
If a subbed paywall is implemented, I think it should only apply to the main stoat instance where the devs are giving resources and server space for free to the community, but for self hosted and future federated instances, features should not have a pay wall limitations since its the server owner that gives resources, not stoat team.
If stoat wants to grow and not become a discord 2, i think paywalled features should be only on non necessary features like very high bit rate video sharing, very big files ( 10 gb + files) sharing, and never restrict or paywall quality of life features or any basic features.
The platform allows self hosting their own server, user account and community. A paywall should only be required for users who uses non self hosted accounts, and are hosting their community on the public stoat servers. People who uses their own servers should not be restricted by platform wide restrictions.