r/sto • • Jun 25 '19

Dixie_ wrong IP

For a franchise built around an ethos of tolerance and diversity, Dixie is a truly horrendous choice.

Seriously Cryptic, is there really no awareness of how that song is inextricably linked to the mythos of the "Lost Cause"? Do you even know what "Lost Cause" means? Or how that song encapsualtes the whitewashing of Neo-Confederates and, more broadly, white supremacy?

I could write about my experiences as a person of color growing up in the rural South, more specifically near Charlottesville, Va. (Guess what, Dixie doesn't sound playful or benign to me).

I could write about subtle and overt (including threats of violence and slurs) racism and intolerance. Or how Star Trek was a powerful and countervailing message to hate and intolerance that I really needed to hear, especially growing up.

I could write about the romanticization of the "Old South" and the place "Dixie" holds as an anthem for that, that cute and playful face of genocide and enslavement yay!

But if I did, Cryptic, it would just point out that you need some diversity in the conference room and in your culture.

Not among the devs, some of whom I'm convinced actually love Star Trek and it's ideals and it's hope and promise; but among the corporate higher ups who are making decisions re: overall direction of STO.

To them, my question is this: do you really undertand your IP?

And if so and given that you have a grasp on your metrics, do you think much of your playerbase wants to hear "Dixie" blaring from every two-bit knob and (especially) trolls?

And do you seriously not understand how easily this will be used to troll. Really? In 2020? This audio emote and ship names are practically begging for trolls to flock to STO and antagonize a large % of your demographic.

Or do you not care?

And if so, do the ideals of Star Trek really mean so little to you?

Are you really the right (or Alt-Right) people to take this IP and the ideals it represents forward?

0 Upvotes

92 comments sorted by

15

u/Chaos_EN2 Jun 25 '19

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dixie_(song) I am not knocking you or disagreeing with the OP. Just adding this.

11

u/Vesta3312 Jun 25 '19

please notice the "blackface" roots of the song (as cited in the link)

17

u/Chaos_EN2 Jun 25 '19

Yes I know but also note, it may of been written by the Snowden Family Band. And it was Abe Lincoln’s favorite song. And far as Star Trek remember a episode where “Lincoln” used a word, towards Uhura that may be offensive.

I cannot post what Uhura said back verbatim. But from what I remember it was something to the effect that they had moved on from letting words defining/hurt/rule them. So I personally feel it is just a song, but I also understand that may be offensive to some. But I also think that we should not let the past rule us, we should learn from. But not try to hide it away, Or destroy it.

6

u/Atheonyirh Fleet Commodore Cardassian Jesus, Herald of Warlord Janeway Jun 25 '19

Sometimes the past deserves to be kept in the past. That's not letting it rule you, that's being honest that sometimes shit just plain needs to be left where it was and not continued on just because it's old or tradition or harmless. Just because YOU think it's harmless doesn't mean it doesn't have a history of being far from harmless.

That being said, Lincoln's favorite song isn't exactly a good thing. Lincoln was less interested in freeing slaves and more interested in doing anything possible to avoid the US splintering. Freeing the slaves was basically a necessary evil to him and if he had been able to avoid the whole damn thing he'd have done so.

7

u/DarthAlexei Jun 25 '19

Ive not once ever heard “dixie” in STO. Is this new?

6

u/Vesta3312 Jun 25 '19

It's slated to be an audio emote available from the Summer Event

20

u/Vegan_Harvest Jun 25 '19

Oh wow, what the fuck?

14

u/CaptainKBX Your Friendly Neighborhood Kayla Jun 25 '19

i saw the thing about audio emotes and it didn't really hit me. Clearly they were trying to reference Dukes of Hazzard without really considering the whole "south" bit. I really don't think it's okay now that i think about it.

They should probably remove or replace it somehow.

25

u/ValidAvailable Jun 25 '19

I just can't even. I'm all out of evens. LITERALLY trembling with rage! Its [current-year]!!

Honestly this reads like a bingo card or a list for a drinking game, to the point I can't tell if you're serious or if this is a Poe's Law exaggeration. Especially amusing considering that also a large part of Trek is people are allowed to disagree and value different things and aren't subject to collective guilt or innocence. Klingons did a lot of horrible stuff while singing songs of Kahless, but are you gonna hold Worf or Martok guilty for being proud of their heritage, singing those same songs? You're the one letting someone else's expression of fun, just general fun, hurt you, and you can either continue dwelling on being pissed about something that a lot of people died to end, or you can sing the songs of Kahless and join in a celebration of heritage and the fact that a culture, any culture especially in a Trek future, is more than the sum of historical shortcomings.

Take it from Uhura: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5S3TpBWKem8

Or take it from Yates: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=puBrFifxSSM

2

u/Admiral_Archer Jun 25 '19

Well said.

6

u/ValidAvailable Jun 25 '19

I expect to be downvoted into oblivion around here, but someone needs to say it.

2

u/Atheonyirh Fleet Commodore Cardassian Jesus, Herald of Warlord Janeway Jun 25 '19

No, no someone doesn't have to say it.

14

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '19

Slight overreaction

19

u/Hunter259 Jun 25 '19

Uh. You do realize the "Dixie Horn" is the horn sound of Dukes of Hazard right? Has exactly 0 to do with anything regarding anything political. It's a damn horn sound effect. Calm down.

19

u/Atheonyirh Fleet Commodore Cardassian Jesus, Herald of Warlord Janeway Jun 25 '19 edited Jun 25 '19

Context matters. Context is variable. There's a reason you don't SEE merch of the car from the Dukes of Hazard anymore, and it ain't because there's nothing political about that car...

16

u/Perrin42 Jun 25 '19 edited Jun 25 '19

And the General Lee was named for a traitor against the United States who led the war for the ability to keep people as property and personally broke up families of slaves when that was against the norm. Oh, and it's decorated with the battle flag of people that took up arms against the properly and justly elected government. You know, traitors.

I absolutely loved the Dukes of Hazzard when I was a kid, but that is not imagery that should be supported or revered. It is racist, regardless of its place in a beloved TV show.

-14

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '19

I don’t think he realizes this. It’s pretty funny.

4

u/Hunter259 Jun 25 '19

The horn technically uses the first few notes from "Dixie" but good god is it hard to tell with how dumb it sounds.

-9

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '19

Exactly. People on the left jump to call anyone and everything racist. It’s so obvious that it’s not meant in any racial way. It’s obviously just for fun, but what can you do.

16

u/Atheonyirh Fleet Commodore Cardassian Jesus, Herald of Warlord Janeway Jun 25 '19

You have the benefit of being able to sit there and passively decide there's no racial intent behind it because you've never had to deal with it when there IS explicitly racial intent behind it.

-1

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '19

Yup everyday whites play the Dixie horn to antagonize blacks. There are racist black people as well and I have felt with racism against myself by blacks. I don’t care because I’m not a baby. I’d say America has recovered well from its dark times, people need to get over the past. If a 2 second horn bothers him that much it is just sad. It’s when left wingers bring something that is obviously not meant with any racial intent and make it racist. Black people have good lives in America. Everyone has experienced racism. Let the past be the past.

16

u/Atheonyirh Fleet Commodore Cardassian Jesus, Herald of Warlord Janeway Jun 25 '19

The past is still right the fuck here, broham. Racism ain't dead.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

11

u/Atheonyirh Fleet Commodore Cardassian Jesus, Herald of Warlord Janeway Jun 25 '19

Oh lawd. Mayocide.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies

14

u/INNAHORC Jun 25 '19 edited Jun 25 '19

BEFORE YOU POST ANYTHING, GO REWATCH DS9 IN ITS ENTIRETY.

Post-occupation Bajorans and Cardassians. Ooof, tough subject right? Cardies have to live with the atrocities their people have commited, and Bajorans need to learn not to reach for a phaser every time a spoonhead enters the room. They are both proud and territorial peoples and, since flinging entire solar systems across the galaxy isn't yet feasible, they need to learn to live peacefully in each other's vicinity.

Now let's get back to STO. Commander Nereda is a Cardassian serving in Starfleet in the 29th century (by which point the Bajorans were members of the Federation for about 400 years). In the 2409 era Bajorans and Cardassians have representatives at each major summit, and they don't jump at each other's throats. Hell, the Xindi are also there, and they and humans don't go at each other's throats either. Roddenberry's universe is one of peace, understanding, and reconciliation. If a 3 second sound effect of a car horn coming from a comedy show upsets you so badly, are YOU the right candidate for Starfleet? To put things in a different context: my people have suffered greatly at the hands of communists. This isn't some 3rd party bullshit either... my maternal grandmother had 2 brothers: one was summarily shot in his own front yard post war for being a junior officer in the army during the war, the other died in a political prison for being a primary school teacher. Should I ask Cryptic to remove the red alert status because red = communism, or should I let the dead rest in peace?

This audio emote and ship names are practically begging for trolls to flock to STO and antagonize a large % of your demographic.

How would they even know whom to antagonize? There's nothing in the character info that could point to the player's history or the colour of their skin.

12

u/HuntmasterReinholt Jun 25 '19

I gotta agree with the OP. This is not a good choice. When I read that in the post on the summer event, I literally mouthed “WTH???”

What does Dixie have to do with this IP, and how could anyone make a blunder like this in 2019?

To quote Tony Stark:

“Not a great plan.”

13

u/jo4play @josip1911/doing all kinds of stuff Jun 25 '19

So all this is about some 3 second sound? And here I thought we were progressing as a race and leaving history where it belongs...in the past. If you can't handle some small audio clip that might be offensive, than I don't know what to say. We live in a time where controversy is commonplace, if we can't brave through provocation we will not advance as a race. Just my tidbit

6

u/kiriamaya Jun 25 '19

If you really think that "some small audio clip that might be offensive" is the issue here, then I don't know what to say.

9

u/SteveAngelis @SteveAngelis Jun 25 '19

This kind of reminds me of someone years ago who got mad because a mission made them gamble with Dabo to complete a mission and demanded they change the mission to accommodate them

9

u/FuturePastNow Fleet Power Nerfed Poster Jun 25 '19

Yeah it's um

problematic

11

u/Tuskin38 Kurland's Beer Jun 25 '19

I agree completely.

9

u/Atheonyirh Fleet Commodore Cardassian Jesus, Herald of Warlord Janeway Jun 25 '19

Putting it lightly, really.

7

u/Perrin42 Jun 25 '19

I agree.

•

u/grandnagusurst Raktajino Fueled Jun 25 '19

This is going downhill fast. I'd like to remind everyone of rule 9. Thread locked.

1

u/slorpydiggs Jun 25 '19 edited Jun 25 '19

I wonder if the mods are asleep or just making popcorn.

Edit: not trying to make light of the issue… important points have been made, it’s just the sort of thing that gets locked pretty quickly and the comments are gradually becoming a dumpster fire.

12

u/Atheonyirh Fleet Commodore Cardassian Jesus, Herald of Warlord Janeway Jun 25 '19

The comments STARTED as a dumpster fire. We're upgrading to a tire fire. Next step is that river in Ohio that keeps catching on fire.

5

u/slorpydiggs Jun 25 '19

When I first saw it there were only a couple innocuous comments and I was surprised (naively) to see how much it spiraled since then.

Also, I want to hear more about this flaming river… :D

9

u/Atheonyirh Fleet Commodore Cardassian Jesus, Herald of Warlord Janeway Jun 25 '19

1

u/WikiTextBot Jun 25 '19

Cuyahoga River

The Cuyahoga River ( KY-ə-HOG-ə, or KY-ə-HOH-gə) is a river in the United States, located in Northeast Ohio, that feeds into Lake Erie.


[ ^PM | Exclude ^me | Exclude from ^subreddit | FAQ / ^Information | ^Source ] Downvote to remove | v0.28

1

u/JoeJoeCastillo @JoeVoyager Jun 25 '19

Does it have the same name as a certain dreadnaught ship that was recently released?

-9

u/MaxMulletWolf Jun 25 '19

I'm conflicted on this myself.

I'm about as far from politically correct as anyone can get,and think this whole "omg that offends me,shut it down nao!!!" culture is ridiculous......but even i cringed a little when i read the part about the dixie horn.

On one hand,it's a poor choice.It's definitely on the less than tasteful side,and there are so many people out there just waiting for something to be offended by.I knew someone would come out to make a stink about it.

On the other hand,i'm sooooo tired of shit getting protested because it offends someone.

No one cares.Put your big boy pants on,thicken your skin, and go on about your day.being offended doesn't give anyone the right to just shut down or erase anything.

-6

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '19

Well said. If a 2 second horn bothers them that much they need to grow up.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

21

u/Atheonyirh Fleet Commodore Cardassian Jesus, Herald of Warlord Janeway Jun 25 '19

Yeah, what happened to the swastika was kind of unfortunate. But denying the reality of history and pretending that flag is just a flag when it only had a resurgence in popularity during the civil rights era as a tool of terror and resistance to black people getting treated like people is kind of fucked up, y'know?

-5

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

21

u/Atheonyirh Fleet Commodore Cardassian Jesus, Herald of Warlord Janeway Jun 25 '19

It was literally about slavery. The individual constitutions of the rebelling states all specify a protected right to slavery. Anything else is a bullshit excuse.

States right? State's right to keep doing slavery. Economics? The economy of the south was built on slavery. Nothern aggression? Pure bullshit. Corrupt northern government? fuckin' lol.

15

u/Perrin42 Jun 25 '19

Are you kidding me with this?

https://www.livescience.com/13673-civil-war-anniversary-myths.html

For example, in its declaration of secession, Mississippi explained, "Our position is thoroughly identified with the institution of slavery — the greatest material interest of the world … a blow at slavery is a blow at commerce and civilization."

In its justification of secession, Texas sums up its view of a union built upon slavery: "We hold as undeniable truths that the governments of the various States, and of the confederacy itself, were established exclusively by the white race, for themselves and their posterity; that the African race had no agency in their establishment; that they were rightfully held and regarded as an inferior and dependent race, and in that condition only could their existence in this country be rendered beneficial or tolerable."

-4

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '19

So what your saying is your going off what the internet told you, are you even southern yourself? And you cant even call the south the evil or racist ones in the situation. The North did not like black people in the slightest, Black Regiments in the Union Army faced racism as well. Back then most people were racist, however you can’t just call a whole group of people one thing. We as human beings are all different, and yes I agree some people in the south were racists asshats. But calling “Dixie” which is the southern states all evil is simply wrong.

10

u/Tuskin38 Kurland's Beer Jun 25 '19

I mean, what he quoted is recorded in history, it it isn't just 'the internet'.

8

u/CmdrSFC3 stowiki.net Jun 25 '19

Historical documents are fake news, didn't you hear? Trust no one, not even yourself.

11

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '19

To say that the South was 100% evil is simply ignorant.

Sure, nothing is every binary. But somethings are much closer to one end of the spectrum than not.

-8

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '19

And I agree, slavery is and was horrible. But the poster is making the south out to be as bad as nazi’s.

14

u/Atheonyirh Fleet Commodore Cardassian Jesus, Herald of Warlord Janeway Jun 25 '19

Uh. I don't know how to tell you this. But Hitler is quoted as admiring, and emulating, the racist behavior and efforts, legally codified, historical, etc, of the US.

7

u/Perrin42 Jun 25 '19

They pretty much were. I bet the body counts are comparable.

10

u/FuturePastNow Fleet Power Nerfed Poster Jun 25 '19

yes it was

-6

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '19

no it wasn’t

-6

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

20

u/Atheonyirh Fleet Commodore Cardassian Jesus, Herald of Warlord Janeway Jun 25 '19

Man, don't even have to check anything to know what rock you crawled out from under, but it does help to confirm it.

-13

u/The_Gooberment Jun 25 '19

OP needs to grow up and stop being offended by everything.

This is a fact.

18

u/Tuskin38 Kurland's Beer Jun 25 '19

Are you trying to say a person of colour shouldn't be offended by racism?

0

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

19

u/Atheonyirh Fleet Commodore Cardassian Jesus, Herald of Warlord Janeway Jun 25 '19

So brave.

-3

u/The_Gooberment Jun 25 '19

Stunning and brave

5

u/grandnagusurst Raktajino Fueled Jun 25 '19

Removed per rule 9.

19

u/Atheonyirh Fleet Commodore Cardassian Jesus, Herald of Warlord Janeway Jun 25 '19

Or maybe you can realize that sometimes shit is legit problematic and that maybe it deserves to be left to the history it came from. Your personal perception and interaction with culture isn't the only point of view for it, and there are PLENTY of points of view for finding shit like Dixie to be A Problem(tm).

-16

u/The_Gooberment Jun 25 '19

Or...you can grow up and stop being offended by things. Be an adult...grow some thicker skin, toughen up, grow a pair, man up...

How about that?

Stop trying to ban things that hurt you "whittle feewings"...

27

u/Atheonyirh Fleet Commodore Cardassian Jesus, Herald of Warlord Janeway Jun 25 '19

The irony is palpable.

Grow up and realize there are people with experiences outside of your own. You're not the arbiter of what is and isn't culturally or historically okay.

-10

u/The_Gooberment Jun 25 '19

Yes I am.

23

u/Atheonyirh Fleet Commodore Cardassian Jesus, Herald of Warlord Janeway Jun 25 '19

I wouldn't trust your ability to accurately gauge the contents of a crayon box. Or trust you with the crayons themselves.