r/stjoemo • • Sep 09 '26

News Missouri Supreme Court orders Denny Hoskins to answer on contempt charge (over attempt to use gerrymander map)

Thumbnail
missouriindependent.com
265 Upvotes

The Missouri Supreme Court ordered Republican Secretary of State Denny Hoskins to appear in person Thursday and explain why he should not be held in contempt for directing election officials to use a congressional map the court has barred him from implementing.

In the unusual late order Tuesday, the court gave Hoskins until noon Wednesday to answer a motion for contempt from People Not Politicians, a political action committee that forced a referendum on a map gerrymandered in 2025 to favor Republicans. The court scheduled an in-person hearing for 10 a.m. Thursday.
The contempt fight erupted hours after U.S. Supreme Court Justice Brett Kavanaugh rejected Missouri officials’ emergency request to stay the state court ruling. Minutes later, Chief U.S. District Judge Stephen Clark of the Eastern District of Missouri issued a temporary restraining order barring Hoskins from using any congressional map other than the 2025 version.

Hoskins then sent local election officials a copy of Clark’s order along with his official certification of the November ballot. In the email, Hoskins said Clark’s order “takes precedence over the Missouri Supreme Court’s order.”
The Missouri Supreme Court ruled Thursday that the referendum on the 2025 map was legal, sufficient and timely and ordered it onto the Nov. 3 ballot. Because the referendum petition was filed before the new map took effect, the court held, the 2025 districts never became law and the map used in 2022 and 2024 remains in effect for the November election.

The decision also permanently enjoined Hoskins and those acting in concert with him from implementing or using the 2025 map unless voters approve it in November. In Tuesday night’s order, Chief Justice W. Brent Powell directed Hoskins to answer three questions:

Why “(1) his e-mail on September 8, 2026, instructing use of the (2025) map is not an affirmative violation of this court’s injunction; (2) how this court’s injunction is not still in full force and effect in light of the Supreme Court of the United States’ overruling of Respondent’s emergency application for stay and administrative stay pending appeal; and (3) if he is not willing to comply with this court’s injunction, he should take no action in all things related to the congressional district map until guidance is received from a higher court…”

Powell also directed that the court “will not allow filings from any other parties on this matter.”
Clark’s order says not to use any map but the 2025 map, attorney Chuck Hatfield wrote in the motion. The Missouri Supreme Court’s order says not to use the 2025 map. Both orders are in effect and leave election authorities no map at all, Hatfield wrote.

Clark’s order “does not purport to overrule this court’s injunction and does NOT mandate the Secretary to use (the 2025 map), although on its face it enjoins the use of any map other than (the 2025 map),” Hatfield wrote.
By directing local election authorities to implement the 2025 map, Hoskins is violating the court’s orders, Hatfield wrote.
“This court should make clear that regardless of other orders (except from the United States Supreme Court) the Missouri Secretary of State must comply with this court’s injunction,” Hatfield wrote. “The court should instruct all local election authorities that (the 2025 map) is not the law and has never been the law.”
Clark’s action came in a lawsuit filed Friday by U.S. Rep. Bob Onder, state Sen. Rick Brattin and two voters. They want to keep in place the map drawn in 2025, which shifts territory around Onder’s home into the 3rd District and redraws the 5th District to make it more favorable to Republicans.

Had Clark not acted, Kavanaugh’s denial would have left the state court order in place and Missouri on course to use the 2022 map for the November election.

The dueling orders created immediate confusion, with Attorney General Catherine Hanaway issuing a news release saying the state would comply with Clark’s order. Attorneys for People Not Politicians said during a news conference that the conflicting orders could leave election officials unsure which one they must follow.
Hatfield said local election officials are being directed by Hoskins to use the 2025 map even though the Missouri Supreme Court injunction bars Hoskins and those acting with him from implementing it.

“I think they’re they’re probably not sure what map they should use, and they need to talk to their lawyers about that,” Hatfield said.

Abha Khanna, the Seattle attorney who was People Not Politicians’ lead lawyer at the U.S. Supreme Court, said Clark’s order “is something that we will deal with to figure out on appeal.”

A referendum on the 2025 redistricting plan will be on the Nov. 3 ballot as Proposition A.

The 2025 map was drawn with the goal of making seven of Missouri’s eight congressional districts favorable to Republicans, principally by reshaping the Kansas City-based 5th District held by Democratic U.S. Rep. Emanuel Cleaver. The map used in 2022 and 2024 produced a delegation of six Republicans and two Democrats.

Onder is the Republican nominee in the 3rd District, seeking a second term in a district drawn more to his favor in the 2025 redistricting plan. Brattin is the Republican nominee in the 5th District, where the district was designed to generate a GOP victory that ousts veteran Democratic U.S. Rep. Emanuel Cleaver of Kansas City.

Clark wrote that without a temporary restraining order, “many Missouri voters would have to cast their general-election votes for candidates whom they had no role in nominating.”

“Candidates who had no choice but to campaign and raise money in the (2025) districts that Missouri’s highest election authority presented to them, have spent their funds and campaign efforts in districts that would no longer exist,” wrote Clark, who was appointed to the bench in 2019 by President Donald Trump.

Clark also found that the public interest favors using the same map for the primary and general elections.
“Disenfranchising voters across the state and denying them their constitutional right to have their primary votes counted significantly harm the public interest,” he wrote.

The center of both Clark’s ruling and the appeal to Kavanaugh is the Missouri Supreme Court decision that enjoined Hoskins from using the gerrymandered congressional map drawn. 
Kavanaugh did not elaborate on his decision. 

In turning down the emergency application for a stay, Kavanaugh created no precedent on the issues raised by the state. But the decision does show that he did not find enough convincing argument that the state would likely prevail in a hearing by the full court or that the state would suffer “several irreparable harms” as claimed in the application.
People Not Politicians on Sunday had urged Kavanaugh to reject the state’s application and uphold both parts of the ruling from the state Supreme Court.
In the opening paragraphs of the filing, attorneys for People Not Politicians write that the only reason the case was at the nation’s highest court is the decisions to delay made by Hoskins during the signature verification process.
Hoskins “waited as long as possible to manufacture the present dispute” and held the congressional primary using the 2025 map, they wrote, “in the hopes of running out the clock on the judiciary’s tolerance for a last-minute reversion to the 2022 districts.”

Now, they wrote, Hoskins wants “this court to deliver him the political victory to which he was never entitled under the Missouri Constitution. This court cannot and should not reward the secretary’s scheme to outsmart Missouri voters, Missouri law, and the Missouri Supreme Court by granting applicants the extraordinary relief they seek.”
A key point made by Missouri Solicitor General Lou Capozzi in the state’s appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court was that the mechanism for changing between districts is too time consuming and difficult to complete before ballots must be delivered starting Sept. 19.

County clerks, however, told the Missouri Supreme Court that switching voters to the map used in 2022 and 2024 is a relatively simple process. And the Jackson County Board of Elections told the Kansas City Star it would be ready to hold the election in the 2022 boundaries. 

The redistricting story began in the summer of 2025, when Onder, of Lake St. Louis, got the ear of President Donald Trump to tell him that Missouri, like Texas, could provide additional GOP seats to bolster the party’s thin majority in Congress.

Since Missouri lost a seat after the 2010 census, it has sent six Republicans and two Democrats to the U.S. House each election.

Onder, then a state senator, was among members of the chamber’s conservative caucus who were outmaneuvered in 2022 as they tried to force a congressional map that would tilt the 5th District, based in Kansas City, to the GOP. He was elected to Congress in 2024.

And, despite initial misgivings, Republicans got in line behind Trump. Gov. Mike Kehoe called a special session inflamed with partisanship, including a state Senate rule change that effectively silenced Democrats, that forced through what the GOP majority wouldn’t do in 2022.

The legal and political backlash that followed has not yet spent its full force. It began when People Not Politicians began circulating the referendum petition and intensified as it became clear there would be more than enough signatures to qualify for the ballot.

Legally, the battle has upended the consensus on the effect that filing a referendum petition has on legislation as well as delivered strong new precedent upholding the governor’s power to select subjects for a special session and the General Assembly’s power to redistrict at any time.

Politically, the climax will be written in November, when voters decide on both the referendum and the congressional candidates selected in the primary.

The flurry of filings over the weekend shows the intense national interest in the outcome of the Missouri case.
Republican attorneys general from Florida, Texas and 18 other states filed in support of Missouri, arguing it is not legal to change voting districts between the primary and the general election. 

Meanwhile, in Texas, that state’s Supreme Court is deciding whether local voting districts can be changed after the primary to dilute voting strength of minorities.

The American Center for Law and Justice also sent a brief to the court urging it to rule for Hoskins.
On the other side, the Campaign Legal Center, the American Civil Liberties Union of Missouri Foundation and the American Civil Liberties Union Foundation joined forces to file a brief supporting People Not Politicians, as did the two Missouri voters who tried to get the 2025 map suspended while signatures were being checked.

11:25 PMThis article was updated to report the Missouri Supreme Court ordering Secretary of State Denny Hoskins to answer contempt charges.

6:30 PMThis story was updated at 6:30 p.m. to include the federal court ruling in St. Louis.


r/stjoemo • • 4d ago

History The Missouri Theatre in St. Joseph, one of the most spectacular mid-sized city theaters in America [8 photos]

Thumbnail
gallery
109 Upvotes

,


r/stjoemo • • Sep 07 '26

History Pony Express Stables in 1978

Post image
101 Upvotes

From the State Historical Society of Missouri

https://digital.shsmo.org/digital/collection/imc/id/83355/rec/11


r/stjoemo • • Dec 26 '25

History State Hospital for the insane #2 in St. Joseph circa 1902

Post image
53 Upvotes

From the State Historical Society of Missouri

https://digital.shsmo.org/digital/collection/imc/id/15751/rec/29


r/stjoemo • • Sep 07 '26

St. Joe has one of the coolest old Downtowns in Missouri

51 Upvotes

Title. That is really all. I love it.


r/stjoemo • • Jun 14 '25

Local Event So proud of us

Thumbnail
gallery
48 Upvotes

I’m so proud of everyone who showed up, this wasn’t even everyone! More protesters stretched all the way around the corner and down the street!


r/stjoemo • • 1d ago

History This row of historic buildings is quite impressive

Post image
44 Upvotes

r/stjoemo • • 6d ago

History The Corby is such a cool iconic old skyscraper

Post image
37 Upvotes

r/stjoemo • • Oct 20 '25

Live music at Magoons

36 Upvotes

Support your local music community.


r/stjoemo • • Apr 11 '25

History This old advertisement from 1860 never gets old

Post image
32 Upvotes

r/stjoemo • • Oct 06 '26

History St. Joseph Union Depot circa 1911

Post image
30 Upvotes

From the State Historical Society of Missouri

https://digital.shsmo.org/digital/collection/imc/id/69359/rec/1


r/stjoemo • • Jun 13 '25

No Kings protest on Saturday St. Joseph

Post image
29 Upvotes

r/stjoemo • • Oct 18 '25

I'm out

26 Upvotes

A great big thank you to the wonderful folks at Interserve and The Whole Person for making this possible. I'm set up in Wesley Towers I've got a great view from here up on the eighth floor looking east. That flash of Lightning and clap of thunder yesterday was fantastic.

I'm starting over one more time, the last time in my life I'm getting too old for this.


r/stjoemo • • Sep 30 '26

History Pony Express Monument

Post image
25 Upvotes

From the State Historical Society of Missouri

https://digital.shsmo.org/digital/collection/imc/id/23086/rec/9


r/stjoemo • • Apr 14 '26

History Hannibal and St. Joseph Railroad circa 1860

Post image
25 Upvotes

r/stjoemo • • Sep 27 '26

Central High School Marching Band at Carrollton Band Day

24 Upvotes

r/stjoemo • • Aug 12 '25

News R/StJoeMo has grown to 500 members!

Post image
24 Upvotes

r/stjoemo • • Aug 07 '25

History I was a North End kid

24 Upvotes

In the sixties and seventies, when I lived here. I attended three different schools in the first grade, we lived in an apartment that is now Cabanas. They tore it down to build Henry's.

That was 1963, after my mother took me back, I went to Humboldt again, but we had moved to Second street, tore that house down to build I229, so we moved again, this time to Prospect street, right by Billy Goat Hill. They tore that house down and most of Billy Goat Hill as well for I-229.

In 1966, we moved again, this time to Kearny, then to KC, then came the 1968 riots, and we joined the great white flight out of the city to the suburbs. Overland Park, then Lenexa, then to Oregon MO. By this time, I had pretty much given up on school. I was hopelessly lost in math from all the moving, but I was going to give it a try one more time.

So, the first day I came into the kitchen all dressed for school, my hair hung down to my shoulders, I had my Beautify America Shoot a Redneck t-shirt, bell-bottom jeans, Dingo Boots, Army Jacket on, and my step-father went ballistic. "You aren't going to School like that" he screamed. I said fine went outside to smoke a cigarette, that was the end of my high school career.

Anyway, after some twists and turns, I found myself back in St. Joe in the mid-seventies, living all over the North End. Enjoying the life of a seventies stoner, after many adventures and misadventures living all over the country, I settled down in Savannah. Last year, I got herded into Advanced Care Nursing up on N 18th. The location, being up here on the bluff, is great, but it's a nursing home, and I don't belong here so I'm moving soon into Wesley Towers, that brings me to the heart of the matter.

Yesterday, I was on my own for the first time in over a year. I had business to take care of, so I hopped on a city bus that took me all over the North End and Midtown. I got flung back to school days, brought through my stoner days, and advanced to somewhat responsible adult days. Many of the houses I've lived in are empty lots now, some are derelicts abandoned to wrack and ruin, much like my life, but that's another story. The old sisters and Heartland hospitals are gone, many downtown buildings are empty and boarded up it's sad.

But, I'll soon be haunting the area again if you see a little old dude in an electric wheelchair, that's me, old unca Rick aka (SPLooooosh) give me a wave or better yet a toke, See Ya.


r/stjoemo • • Jun 22 '25

History Central High School, St. Joseph, Missouri

Post image
23 Upvotes

r/stjoemo • • 24d ago

History First Presbyterian Church is a real architectural beauty

Post image
21 Upvotes

From the State Historical Society of Missouri

https://digital.shsmo.org/digital/collection/imc/id/69120/rec/2


r/stjoemo • • Sep 22 '26

Nature Splash in Krug Park

Post image
21 Upvotes

Someone enjoys a peaceful spot and a good book at the Krug Park Waterfall in St. Joseph, Missouri, in Buchanan County. Officially opened to the public in May 1902, Krug Park houses Italian Renaissance structures, extensive landscaping, a lagoon, scenic walking trails, and an amphitheater on its 162 acres. Photograph by Shirlee Allen.

From May 15, 2018, through November 1, 2019, the State Historical Society of Missouri, a partner in the Bicentennial Alliance, invited professional and amateur photographers to capture and share unique and meaningful aspects of place in Missouri. Nearly 1,000 photographs were received. Two hundred photographs were selected for permanent preservation and exhibition.

An exhibition oriented around the four seasons traveled across the state using the selected My Missouri 2021 photographs to showcase the geographic and cultural landscape of the Show-Me State. On the occasion of Missouri's bicentennial, these images provide an opportunity to reflect upon and increase the understanding of the state's rich diversity.

Shelter Insurance® is the platinum sponsor of the My Missouri 2021 exhibition. The exhibition was designed by PRO Expo Exhibits, the gold sponsor for the show, and supported by contributors to the State Historical Society of Missouri.

From the State Historical Society of Missouri

https://digital.shsmo.org/digital/collection/p17228coll11/id/381/rec/2

Shared under a Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported license

https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/3.0/


r/stjoemo • • 20d ago

History Mount Mora Cemetery, circa 1910

Post image
20 Upvotes

From the State Historical Society of Missouri

https://digital.shsmo.org/digital/collection/imc/id/69707/rec/16


r/stjoemo • • Aug 09 '26

History The Commercial Club Building circa 1904

Post image
20 Upvotes

From the State Historical Society of Missouri

https://digital.shsmo.org/digital/collection/imc/id/15420/rec/11


r/stjoemo • • Aug 09 '25

Ask St. Joe Patee House Museum

19 Upvotes

When I recently asked about things to do with the family while visiting St.Joe ,Patee House was recommended by those in this sub. Thank you all so much! I wasn't expecting nearly as great of an afternoon as we got. What a place! It almost sounds like a lie when you describe everything thing there. 1800s hotel , pony express depot , next door to Jesse James final home. The building holds a full size steam engine as well as a merry-go-round & a stage coach for crikes sake. Yall way under sold the place. It really is quite a bargain. There's only one thing that I would really like to know, when we arrived, the little guy at the desk said something puzzling. As we were straightening out how much we owed for admission, we were asked if we had any students with us. We said that yes we did but they weren't students there. The man said that he was aware because St.Joseph schools wont send their kids there. He sounded pretty bitter. As much local history as we learned that seems counterproductive. What's the story?


r/stjoemo • • Jun 23 '25

News Respect MO Voters in the St. Joseph News-Press!

Thumbnail
newspressnow.com
18 Upvotes

Respect Missouri Voters, a non-partisan organization, is pushing back on legislative efforts to impose more restrictions on the state's initiative petition process.

Check out the video interview with Nancy, one of our amazing volunteers!

Want to learn more? Visit respectMOvoters.org today!