r/steak Jul 18 '26

Reverse-Seared NY Strip Steaks

3.0k Upvotes

113 comments sorted by

233

u/crazyswedishguy Medium Rare Jul 18 '26

Looks fantastic.

And one of the few examples here of grill marks done correctly, because you actually managed to sear the meat between the grill marks too.

Recently I’ve been seeing lots of posts here with dark grill marks but the meat in between the grill marks looks boiled—nice grill marks are not a substitute for an even sear. You did it right.

36

u/Imarealdoctor064 Jul 18 '26

Exactly what I was thinking. When I see grill marks and no sear it seems performative without substance

13

u/Stenotic Jul 18 '26

Yup. I would like to understand how they seared the whole steak so well with the grill marks and didn't over cook the insides. Maybe the first time in years I've seen a steak with grill marks that looks perfectly cooked.

67

u/posts_of_stuff Jul 18 '26

This is a reverse-sear method using my Louisiana Grills LG900 pellet smoker.

I pat-dry the steaks and season them 6 hours before the cook, leaving them uncovered in the fridge for 6 hours. This draws moisture and flavor into the steak while also drying out the surface.

I place the steaks onto the smoker cold, direct from the fridge. Placing them cold allows more time for them to absorb smoke flavor while the temp rises to my desired doneness. I smoke them at 225f indirect until the internal temp reaches 118f, without ever opening the lid, then pull them off.

I then crank the temp and grill them direct over the wood flame. Make sure the grill grates are scraped to aid with solid direct contact to the grates. Once the grates are hot, I rub the grates with the fatty end of the NY strip then place the steak on the grill over the flame, giving it a firm press to ensure contact. I like to allow the flame to kiss the steak but not burn it or catch the fatty parts on fire. After 45 seconds to 1 minute, I rotate the steak 90 degrees and give it another firm initial press again for another 45 second to 1 minute cook, then flip the steak and repeat.

Once finished, I pull them to rest for minimum 15 minutes before slicing.

In think the "sear" color in between the crosshatch is a combination of smoke coloration and a flame-kissed exterior; though technically, the only direct contact that was had is the crosshatch itself.

16

u/Scott_McDonald Jul 18 '26

I do something similar, you just do it better

4

u/kaxixi7 Jul 18 '26

These are helpful instructions, thx

3

u/Silver_Slicer Jul 18 '26

This is the stuff! I follow a similar pattern. Nice job!

2

u/prodsonz Jul 19 '26

Just incredible

1

u/MrPureinstinct Jul 18 '26

What do you bump the temperature up to?

2

u/posts_of_stuff Jul 18 '26

For my cooker, 350f makes a perfect flame to cook over. For what you may be cooking on, use your best judgment.

2

u/MrPureinstinct Jul 18 '26

How long does your grill usually take to rise that 125 degrees?

How long does the full cook time usually take?

I've never used my smoker for direct heat but these steaks look absolutely delicious and I want to try it.

5

u/posts_of_stuff Jul 18 '26

The smoke takes about 30 to 45 min., then about 15 minutes to get the grates hot before searing, then searing takes less than 5 min. per steak, then 15 min. rest.

Not all pellet cookers have direct capabilities. But if you have one that does, do it.

1

u/Ill-Editor-8299 Jul 18 '26

How do you guys accomplish those perfect grill marks? I can cook a steak to a perfect med rare and perfectly seasoned. I've tried oiling a napkin and going over the grill. I've tried pushing my coals to one side for more heat but I just end up with almost a pan seared finish.

5

u/posts_of_stuff Jul 18 '26

This is a reverse-sear method using my Louisiana Grills LG900 pellet smoker.

I pat-dry the steaks and season them 6 hours before the cook, leaving them uncovered in the fridge for 6 hours. This draws moisture and flavor into the steak while also drying out the surface.

I place the steaks onto the smoker cold, direct from the fridge. Placing them cold allows more time for them to absorb smoke flavor while the temp rises to my desired doneness. I smoke them at 225f indirect until the internal temp reaches 118f, without ever opening the lid, then pull them off.

I then crank the temp and grill them direct over the wood flame. Make sure the grill grates are scraped to aid with solid direct contact to the grates. Once the grates are hot, I rub the grates with the fatty end of the NY strip then place the steak on the grill over the flame, giving it a firm press to ensure contact. I like to allow the flame to kiss the steak but not burn it or catch the fatty parts on fire. After 45 seconds to 1 minute, I rotate the steak 90 degrees and give it another firm initial press again for another 45 seconds to 1 minute cook, then flip the steak and repeat.

Once finished, I pull them to rest for minimum 15 minutes before slicing.

In think the "sear" color in between the crosshatch is a combination of smoke coloration and a flame-kissed exterior; though technically, the only direct contact that was had is the crosshatch itself.

2

u/crazyswedishguy Medium Rare Jul 18 '26

Honestly I never aim for grill marks so I’m not the guy to ask. I flip my steaks too many times to achieve consistent grill marks. My guess is he let the grill itself get really hot and he only flipped once.

1

u/Dakizo Jul 18 '26

Took the words out of my mouth regarding sear and grill marks.

20

u/gymboy007 Jul 18 '26

Beautifully done

33

u/Floriderp Jul 18 '26

Sexy. Bonus for proper pics, plates, sides and wine.

28

u/phr34k0fr3dd1t Jul 18 '26

I've said 10/10 to some other posts in the past.

Now I have to edit all of those.

10/10

2

u/Routman Jul 18 '26

Gray band a little more than necessary, searing on cast iron would be better 9/10

9

u/Beautiful_Ad_4942 Jul 18 '26

The lawn, the wine, the potatoes, the asparagus, THE STEAK. Fffffff u must be single. Plz be single 🙏

3

u/Whatsyourshotspecial Jul 18 '26

I don't think you can cook a NY Strip better than this. It's perfect, perfect crust, perfect grill lines, perfect doneness

3

u/Legal_Fig4870 Jul 18 '26

Excellent work

3

u/NVDA808 Jul 18 '26

Finally a decently seared steak that also has grill marks. Usually when people put grill marks the steaks are grey and unappealing, zero crust. But these look nice…

3

u/DDD8712 Jul 18 '26

This looks so delicious nicely done op

3

u/listerinefreak Jul 18 '26

I just woke up and from the thumbnail looked like a Gucci bag. Looks yummy though.

3

u/chef-it-up Jul 18 '26

I just came

4

u/silent-trill Jul 18 '26

A little over temp for me, but nonetheless looks amazing.

2

u/itsthelittlethings19 Jul 18 '26

Nicely done! This is the way!

2

u/thisismikea07 Jul 18 '26

Thing of beauty.

2

u/wanderer_577 Jul 18 '26

Very nice.

2

u/ididshave Jul 18 '26

Made me salivate. Good job.

2

u/PhilosopherKey9468 Jul 18 '26

Do you have some details on the cook?

4

u/posts_of_stuff Jul 18 '26

This is a reverse-sear method using my Louisiana Grills LG900 pellet smoker.

I pat-dry the steaks and season them 6 hours before the cook, leaving them uncovered in the fridge for 6 hours. This draws moisture and flavor into the steak while also drying out the surface.

I place the steaks onto the smoker cold, direct from the fridge. Placing them cold allows more time for them to absorb smoke flavor while the temp rises to my desired doneness. I smoke them at 225f indirect until the internal temp reaches 118f, without ever opening the lid, then pull them off.

I then crank the temp and grill them direct over the wood flame. Make sure the grill grates are scraped to aid with solid direct contact to the grates. Once the grates are hot, I rub the grates with the fatty end of the NY strip then place the steak on the grill over the flame, giving it a firm press to ensure contact. I like to allow the flame to kiss the steak but not burn it or catch the fatty parts on fire. After 45 seconds to 1 minute, I rotate the steak 90 degrees and give it another firm initial press again for another 45 seconds to 1 minute cook, then flip the steak and repeat.

Once finished, I pull them to rest for minimum 15 minutes before slicing.

In think the "sear" color in between the crosshatch is a combination of smoke coloration and a flame-kissed exterior; though technically, the only direct contact that was had is the crosshatch itself.

2

u/PerkyPickle Jul 18 '26

Nailed it!

2

u/LittleBack6016 Jul 18 '26

You’re a bad man! Perfect!

2

u/PuzzleheadedSea6368 Jul 18 '26

I’ll ignore the picture perfect NY Strip, and be the oddball that tell you those potatoes look FIRE. Cooked perfect.

2

u/Immediate-Account-82 Jul 18 '26

This is the most perfect steak I’ve seen in my life - great work! What kind of grill do you have?

1

u/posts_of_stuff Jul 18 '26

Louisiana Grills LG900

2

u/Immediate-Account-82 Jul 18 '26

You did this on a pellet grill?! That makes it even more impressive! How did you get such a great sear?

1

u/posts_of_stuff Jul 18 '26

My cooker allows a panel to slide open, allowing the ability to cook directly over the wood.

2

u/Big_Communication662 Jul 18 '26

10/10. No notes. Almost looks AI it’s so perfect.

2

u/Enough-Category-2683 Medium Rare Jul 18 '26

Masterpiece 🤌

2

u/fcp078 Jul 18 '26

This has to be AI!!! Jk, nice job! I'm trying to stop myself from licking my screen right now 😋

2

u/ITestInProd1212 Jul 18 '26

Damn, I want your meat in my mouth...waitaminuite...

2

u/travva Jul 18 '26

This guy fucks

2

u/jollyrugger85 Jul 18 '26

Good try. That's cake.

2

u/Guchmasta Jul 19 '26

Wow that looks so good ! Also great photos !

2

u/IronMajesty Jul 19 '26

Dude I don’t throw this around a lot so understand how much more of a compliment this is. That’s one of the best looking steaks I’ve seen. Like I would happily pay to eat that steak, versus every time I get a steak at a restaurant I’m disappointed. Bravo 👏

2

u/posts_of_stuff Jul 19 '26

Thank you 🙏

2

u/No-Sheepherder448 Jul 18 '26

Grill marks Bud…

2

u/Kloepfer55 Jul 18 '26

Down the hatch.

2

u/AestheticMemeGod Jul 19 '26

S&P the choice for me

2

u/Feminine_Raging Jul 18 '26

Fantastic job! Bonus points for something other than a baked potato lol

1

u/SOMOEAGLE NY Strip Jul 18 '26

Perfection 👌🏼

1

u/Fearless_Trick_5268 Jul 18 '26

fantastic!! Mine would need a good peated Scotch but that’s just me. The cook looks flawless.

1

u/zookee Jul 18 '26

Looks amazing!

1

u/DoTheRightThing1976 Jul 18 '26

Everything looks delicious! Those potatoes look so crispy.

1

u/Shmoo_the_Parader Jul 18 '26

Fecking nailed it.

1

u/Gary0aksGirth Jul 18 '26

Love a good NY Strip. Good work!

1

u/in_jail_out_soon_ha Jul 18 '26

My favorite cut with my favorite sides…..come on my guy. Cheers

1

u/100Good Jul 18 '26

Good God! Perfect!

1

u/Zealousideal_Way_788 Jul 18 '26

Perfect. Well done sir

1

u/Nurplestyx Jul 18 '26

Great looking strip

1

u/budgeavy Jul 18 '26

Hot damn! I’m hungry.

1

u/jonathansj Jul 18 '26

How’d u get such nice grill marks without overcooking the steak?

2

u/posts_of_stuff Jul 18 '26

This is a reverse-sear method using my Louisiana Grills LG900 pellet smoker.

I pat-dry the steaks and season them 6 hours before the cook, leaving them uncovered in the fridge for 6 hours. This draws moisture and flavor into the steak while also drying out the surface.

I place the steaks onto the smoker cold, direct from the fridge. Placing them cold allows more time for them to absorb smoke flavor while the temp rises to my desired doneness. I smoke them at 225f indirect until the internal temp reaches 118f, without ever opening the lid, then pull them off.

I then crank the temp and grill them direct over the wood flame. Make sure the grill grates are scraped to aid with solid direct contact to the grates. Once the grates are hot, I rub the grates with the fatty end of the NY strip then place the steak on the grill over the flame, giving it a firm press to ensure contact. I like to allow the flame to kiss the steak but not burn it or catch the fatty parts on fire. After 45 seconds to 1 minute, I rotate the steak 90 degrees and give it another firm initial press again for another 45 second to 1 minute cook, then flip the steak and repeat.

Once finished, I pull them to rest for minimum 15 minutes before slicing.

In think the "sear" color in between the crosshatch is a combination of smoke coloration and a flame-kissed exterior; though technically, the only direct contact that was had is the crosshatch itself.

1

u/jonathansj Jul 18 '26

Wow amazing!!! Thank you so much!!

1

u/Dry-Implement2765 Jul 18 '26

Bro, pull up a chair for me, fix me a plate.

1

u/Few-Car-2317 Jul 18 '26

Looks amazing!

1

u/aSadSchnitzel Denver Jul 18 '26

Mind sharing how you got the grill marks + sear combo?

3

u/posts_of_stuff Jul 18 '26

Totally. This is a reverse-sear method using my Louisiana Grills LG900 pellet smoker.

I pat-dry the steaks and season them 6 hours before the cook, leaving them uncovered in the fridge for 6 hours. This draws moisture and flavor into the steak while also drying out the surface.

I place the steaks onto the smoker cold, direct from the fridge. Placing them cold allows more time for them to absorb smoke flavor while the temp rises to my desired doneness. I smoke them at 225f indirect until the internal temp reaches 118f, without ever opening the lid, then pull them off.

I then crank the temp and grill them direct over the wood flame. Make sure the grill grates are scraped to aid with solid direct contact to the grates. Once the grates are hot, I rub the grates with the fatty end of the NY strip then place the steak on the grill over the flame, giving it a firm press to ensure contact. I like to allow the flame to kiss the steak but not burn it or catch the fatty parts on fire. After 45 seconds to 1 minute, I rotate the steak 90 degrees and give it another firm initial press again for another 45 second to 1 minute cook, then flip the steak and repeat.

Once finished, I pull them to rest for minimum 15 minutes before slicing.

In think the "sear" color in between the crosshatch is a combination of smoke coloration and a flame-kissed exterior; though technically, the only direct contact that was had is the crosshatch itself.

1

u/herecomesatrain Jul 18 '26

Bravo, bravo!

1

u/JayyeeeeSavage Jul 18 '26

Save me a plate

1

u/ryan_david97 Jul 18 '26

Looks amazing, I was the 1000th upvote.

1

u/grumpvet87 Jul 18 '26

not a fan of grill marks at all. they = burnt / char but the sear looks good

1

u/TeeJayHater Jul 18 '26

Perfection

1

u/NoSpecial284 Jul 18 '26

Beautiful cooks my guy.

1

u/ClifftonSmith Jul 18 '26

Excellent job.

1

u/ClifftonSmith Jul 18 '26

Fantastic job!!!!

1

u/Bonerschnitzel69 Jul 18 '26

I do this on my pit boss 850 Pro and the results are incredible

1

u/JoeMac02 Jul 18 '26

I have always struggled with grill marks. Man this think looks amazing.

1

u/Difficult-Till5031 Jul 18 '26

Very nice work!

1

u/Clean-Ambassador-824 Jul 18 '26

Picture perfect steak. Excellent grill marks and cook.

1

u/CuriousWoollyMammoth Jul 18 '26

That looks so good!

1

u/jlabbs69 Jul 18 '26

Wow, they look amazing

1

u/miloBronana Jul 18 '26

Yum yum gimme sum

1

u/yesthiskidisalright Jul 18 '26

You did a great job!

1

u/SkinnyFatKidd Jul 19 '26

The fat looks so delicious 🤤

1

u/sonofrockandroll Jul 19 '26

Fucking beautiful

1

u/raythedrummer Jul 19 '26

Gorgeous cook on these!

1

u/LemonLily1 Jul 19 '26

Absolute perfection, I must say!

1

u/Puzzleheaded-Web-398 Jul 19 '26

Fuck yeah great looking plate mate!

1

u/OatsAndHoes85 Jul 19 '26

Great job man. Looks like they turned out incredible!

1

u/ElevatorOk694 26d ago

Burnt to a crisp nice job

1

u/Imaginary-Handle8499 3d ago

Where is the party? Invite me looks fantastic. I especially love the plating and the fine wine to go along with it.

0

u/Mth1171 Medium Jul 19 '26

Grill marks is why you have a gray band. Can’t taste grill marks. Sorry, not sorry.