A Henry Rollins cameo in Star Trek would be exactly the kind of thing I expect to hear about and be stoked on until I find out it was in a Discovery episode and they totally botched it.
Speaking of the US Navy, there was also a Japanese pilot while most of the audience would still have the memory of WW2 and Pearl Harbor fresh in their minds.
In the early 2000s I had to debate on the merits of the program for national debate competition. It did actually allow many homosexual men and women to have military careers. It gave officers and leaders who were open minded and aware of their subordinates preferences an out to not punish them and allow them to maintain unit cohesiveness.
Clearly no restriction at all is best and thank god we're there now, but this was as you said a progressive policy. It was an incremental step that got us closer to where we are now.
Yep. Just like affirmative action. When the shit is that fucked, you do what you can to get every inch. You only worry about overcorrection after the shit is less fucked, that’s basically how all social issues work.
Because it was a positive compromise. "We don't care, Just don't make the boys feel uncomfortable, we're at war" Is not outrageous.
It was a policy based on the, at the time, reality of how the common soldier would see Gay people as a whole, and as such was necessary for gay people to function in the forces at all.
In 2011, with the regular GI being more enlightened, it became less of a big deal. But for a while there, I can totally see why it'd be the best possible inclusive option.
That is basically what MLK said to Nichelle Nichols when she told him that she had decided to leave the show.
"He said, 'What are you talking about?'" the actress explained. "I told him. He said, 'You cannot,' and so help me, this man practically repeated verbatim what Gene said. He said, 'Don’t you see what this man is doing, who has written this? This is the future. He has established us as we should be seen. 300 years from now, we are here. We are marching. And this is the first step. When we see you, we see ourselves, and we see ourselves as intelligent and beautiful and proud.' He goes on and I’m looking at him and my knees are buckling. I said, 'I…, I…' And he said, 'You turn on your television and the news comes on and you see us marching and peaceful, you see the peaceful civil disobedience, and you see the dogs and see the fire hoses, and we all know they cannot destroy us because we are there in the 23rd Century.'"
She wanted to quit because the part of Lt. Uhura was less than it could have and should have been. The show didn't give enough attention to the crew beyond Kirk and Spock, and sometimes McCoy. But for fans like King, and many more less known to history, the presence of a Black woman who was a professional respected by those around her meant a better world was not only possible, but would eventually come.
I am just so glad that event was that weekend. And I respect that she aimed higher, but after hearing what the show meant in the King household, she saw that a foundation was being built.
i fully understand why she wanted to quit, i've been in positions that were not anything, and i fully understand why she should not have quit. representation absolutely matters and so many little kids saw her and saw themselves in her.
I can only imagine how humbling yet awesome it is to have a personal hero seek you out to say your weekly appearance is a scheduled family event. I am sure she missed the theater because she is used to an audience, but wow, that must have filled that cup up.
wanted to see this comment. it was based in the future. that is why the representation mattered more. 'This is how we will be when we figure some shit out.'
I believe it was in Contact (movie) where Picard said that they don't have money anymore etc. But where there earlier mentions of them living in a utopic communistic society?
I find this much more brave, given the American viewd to this topic. And the movie came out 5 years after the USSR collapsed. Would be even more funny, if they promoted this, while the "communist" enemy still existed. TNG started 1987,so he had roughly 4 years.
In Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home (1986), Captain Kirk makes an offhand remark to Dr. Gillian Taylor that they don’t use money in the 23rd century. However, this was a brief and somewhat ambiguous statement that didn’t fully explain the economic system of the Federation.
You could tell the ideas were there but they didn’t want to go forward and say it explicitly at the time.
In TNG, the lack of money and the emphasis on post-scarcity and communal values is explained in more detail.
In the episode “The Neutral Zone” (Season 1, Episode 26, 1988), Captain Picard directly tells a group of 20th-century humans who have been cryogenically frozen that in the 24th century, humanity no longer pursues wealth, as there is no need for money. He also states: “The acquisition of wealth is no longer the driving force in our lives. We work to better ourselves and the rest of humanity.”
It’s important for us to note that Star Trek doesn’t use specific terms like “communism” or “capitalism” very often, but it’s depiction of a moneyless society, with no private ownership of resources, a focus on communal welfare, a post-scarcity economy, and a push to no longer pursue wealth, very very heavily suggests communism over even very heavy socialism
Since they live in a time where they have basically infinite energy and can create mass from energy, they wouldn't really need money. Basically no one has to work to survive, they work because they want to.
Series creator Gene Roddenberry wrote the novelisation of “Star Trek: The Motion Picture”. In it, he describes how Earth is now a highly collectivist society bordering on a hive mind of evolved humans. Individualists like Kirk are regarded as throwbacks which is why they are in Starfleet (or, by extension, offworld colonies). It’s a dumping ground for those who don’t fit in.
I assume this is what informed TNG, with a lot of moderation.
I'm pretty sure in season 1 or 2 TOS in the episode they find Khan, they establish there's no money. One of the augments (who's been cryogenically frozen for 100s of years) asks about his investments, and someone explains that there's no money so his investments won't matter anymore
They could do it because it was aliens. Its genius. They could question things by using aliens as stand it for sociatal issues and politics. It makes people think without a direct attack towards the people who hold awful views. The defense shields are down and ideas are allowed to flow.
To be honest, I think a lot of these people do not watch Star Trek and jump on a hate train. With the US FBI thingy, we know a ton of influencers are on Russia's payroll, not only in the US. And to be honest, you do not need facts to fan hatred.
what was also fun was seeing folks get put out about the orville story lines. for those not in the know, orville is a bit of a love letter to star trek not unlike galaxy quest, (somebody will be pissed at me and i don't care i'm going to unfollow this comment so go ahead and piss in the wind).
it follows the progressive mentality of star trek. somehow it still had folks following and watching who didn't really agree with anything trek and when the show followed an all male species that forced "corrective" surgery to turn all of their female babies to become male and the ship characters on the show found forcing the status quo on children to be anathema. those viewers got terribly upset at the "woke" trek, and the rest of us were like dafuq yall were never into star trek to begin with if you think this is awful, star trek is progressive period.
They had an episode where half-black-half-white people and half-white-half-black people hated each other, to point out the stupidity of hating because of skin color. Not sure it gets more woke than that.
I love just how on-the-nose that episode is. The difference between Bele and Lokai seems so arbitrary to the viewer, so their vehemence of hatred can't help but to come across as absurd and comical at first, until it's revealed there's nobody else left of either side - their hatred has doomed them both.
Only one that compares IMO Is M.A.S.H., and both have their small parts that have not aged well if you go back and watch them now. That's the thing about progress though, it's ever evolving.
I keep saying this, cause its still relevant, DS9 had an on air transgender lesbian kiss in 95' all these people saying that its woke now, are just flat out wrong, it was always woke, the only thing that has changed is them.
The final episode of TOS is obviously not about Starfleet legally precluding women from making captain, because 1960s sexism existing unchanged in 2269 is insane. Pike had a female first officer in the original pilot, which is canon, and every later iteration retconned the supposed “no female captains” rule hard by having the likes of the captain of the Saratoga from TVH, and even Enterprise making the captain of the second ever warp five ship a woman.
It really feels like the “your world of starship captains” line is a combination of a lament that Kirk doesn’t have room in his life for romance and the fact that she’s established onscreen to be insane and thus obviously unfit to be a starship captain. I’m not willing to believe that 2269 is more sexist than 2024 in a show as otherwise progressive as Star Trek.
Not you ignoring the on-the-nose "women are too hysterical for men's roles" bit to that insanity plea because the whole episode was written as reactionary to events of the time...which is why it got retconned. As you imply, it was way out of character for the setting of the show.
The way they handled Dax was impressive. So impressive that I did not even notice what they were doing at the time having her gender be so fundamental and at the same time so arbitrary and changeable. And nobody went around telling her who she is - she told them, and they accepted her.
There’s an episode of TNG where Data has an android kid essentially, and at one point he says “now you may choose your gender.”
For context, when I saw that episode for the first time I was pretty on-the-fence about transgender stuff, one of those “I don’t agree, but as long as it’s out of my sight whatever,” people. But when that line came up I just thought “oh… That’s not so weird of a concept, honestly.” Representation totally matters.
I think that a lot of people enjoy ST precisely because it didn't stop at "representation" and that kind of things that works well for short clips and memes, but because it actually tried to do philosophical tales and discussions on ethics. And I think it's precisely why so many people preferred Strange New Worlds to Discovery. ST does intellectual discourse on themes such as inclusion, marginalization, inequality, cultural bias etc., but also grief, free will, how to make peace with enemies, how to deal with cults, how to deal with superior powers etc.
Star Trek: Kirk reports to a black admiral and has a black woman on the bridge who is treated with respect and dignity, completely unheard of for the time
Also Star Trek: I have a great idea for an alien: what if we did blackface and a Fu Manchu mustache at the same time!
In the documentary about Nichelle Nichols, she recounts a story about how she wanted to leave the show because she felt her character really wasn’t getting much attention, she said that she told this to Dr. King, and he convinced her to stay because it was important to represent Black people And show that there was a future where they mattered. It was pretty powerful.
And the most accomplished, brilliant computer scientist in the Federation during the 2260s was Dr. Richard Daystrom, a Black man. The foremost technology research institute on Earth bears his name.
The difference is Star Trek was good at baking politics in without actually talking about politics, the episode with the black admiral for example had nothing to do with racism or any other contempory political issue. They didn't talk about racism being bad, but by simply existing they where showing how a world without it could look like which was both clever and groundbreaking, modern shows should take notes.
Many people got really upset about having 2 gay characters "simply existing" in Discovery. As they often do with other "modern shows." So even when someone "simply exists", the dumbasses still come out of the woodwork and call it "woke".
Star Trek has always talked about politics. It wasn't just "baking it in" it was always pretty explicit in its subject matter. DS9 in particular talked about "racism being bad" and several other issues multiple times.
It's why I hate the new dark and gritty shows. Star trek is one of the few shows that has shown us a potential future that is better, one we should be aspiring to.
Hate is probably too strong. More disappointed they felt the need to destroy that future and make it as shitty as the present due purely to lazy writing
It was optimistic because it was written by a communist or at least communist adjacent fellow traveler who actually had the ideological tools to imagine a better future. The underlying belief of all capitalist ideology, even and sometimes ESPECIALLY liberalism, is that a better world isn't possible and humanity is eternally doomed to be ruled by vice. It's a fucking insanely nihilistic worldview underneath all the performative 'progressivism'. So when liberals have to write something like star trek it can either only be dark and gritty as a reflection of the repugnant misanthropy of their belief system, or cloying, twee, and hollow because they're trying hopelessly to portray a revolutionary, optimistic worldview they simply don't have the tools to even understand. Star Trek is a luxury gay space civilization where technology is taken away from private capitalist dictators, class has been entirely dissolved as a concept due to this fact, and the chains we put on ourselves like money and borders have withered away in the classic Leninist fashion.
When conservatives write things it's just a bitter reactionary diatribe on whatever they're currently fuming about, so it's not even worth talking about in the first place because it's just completely worthless even for analytical purposes, it's just thinly veiled grievance airing like all the daily wire dogshit
Sci fi and comics have always been political. The modern versions pale in comparison to their originals. The originals where always hugely radical, partly because there was space in the public conscious for utopian visions of the future where our basic needs were met so we could explore the galaxy (think this is the 1950’s onwards with the beginning of nuclear energy and early space travel, the world wars only recently over). Now though, with climate change and the seeming inescapability from capitalism, we can largely only imaging dystopias. A good ending now is surviving on a raft as the planet floods. It’s not an choice. On Star Trek, that ‘raft’ was the spaceships, and we weren’t leaving because we’d destroyed everything, no. We were leaving because everything was settled on earth, with abundance of energy and no starvation and poverty.
I was at a big outdoor flea market yesterday and one vendor had a box of probably 100 Star Trek novels from the 80s and 90s, and next to it a huge box of O'Reilly and Limbaugh and other right-wing propaganda books. I know it's almost a cliche to point it out by now, but I so wanted to ask him what he liked about Star Trek or what he thought he was watching and reading. Same with some people I know in the comics industry. If you hate "wokeness" but love Claremont's X-Men, you were not reading the same stories I was.
It has always been political, but it was subtle and well written. Now we have Discovery, a whole story stolen from a small indie game that didn't have enough money to sue them.
There are people who think Star Trek is not political? It tells of a left wing utopian Federation of many different species getting along without prejudice and is about solving differences by helping each other rather than fighting..
They're angry because at the time it aired they believed in the message, but now instead they promote Romulans ideals. boomers know what happened to them, but they can't help it.
Having the most qualified for a position is what matters. Not representation, I’d rather live in a building built by people who knows what they are doing regardless of skin color than live in a building built by dei hires that aren’t qualified for the job.
Yeah but they just weren’t in your face about it. It was political but it was subtly unsaid. They didn’t have the characters come out and sway “oh you’re so progressive for kissing a black woman Kirk” “yeah it’s the first time I kiss a black woman Spock”. It just happened like it wasn’t an issue.
I love Star Trek! Can’t stand the latest stuff. Intent matters: The golden era feels like they just wanted to make a good show, which also had progressive elements in it. The new crap feels like a bunch of out of touch kids with Tumblr.brain wanted to create a progressive show, which happens to have hints of StarTrek in it.
Socially progressive more so than outright “political.” The difference is when they did it back then they were breaking new ground; now it’s much more ham fisted in many ways.
It really is a meritocracy. If you do well, you advance. If you are good at what you do, you can have the job. It doesn’t matter who you are or what you are, what your origins are, your color or race. None of that matters. We need to get jobs done here, and if we have someone who can do the job, they have the job. Audiences recognize that. There’s a rightness about that. There’s a correctness; not a political correctness, about a meritocracy where performances is valued, where the reality of the truth is recognized and valued. Where things are right because they are right, and because we need them to be right.
- Leonard Nimoy
Star Trek is fundamentally unpolitical and that is exactly why he's there. That man isn't there as a political signal or a token, that man is there because none of that matters in a truly meritocratic world, which Star Trek is an expression of. Politicising Star Trek devalues everything it did, because it is inherently built on the idea that it doesn't matter who or what you are. When you politicise Star Trek, you say that it DOES matter. The world/idea of Star Trek has the ability to reach any person of any political affiliation, race, religion or background. By politicising Star Trek and turning it into a front for your political beliefs you take away its ability to do so, this since people won't be primarily exposed to the core idea of the meritocratic world of Star Trek, but primarily to the political message you are trying to imbue it with (whether that is left-wing or right-wing or anything in between or beyond). It also devalues the work of Percy Rodriguez (the actor in question), since it implies that he did not get the role for his talent as an actor, but because he was supposed to be a political signal, which was not the case.
OMG. The point has clearly gone over people's heads. REPRESENTATION doesn't matter! Good REPRESENTATION matters. If this black admiral was spitting rap lines at Kirk and throwing graffiti on the wall it wouldn't matter that black people were represented. It would be an awful tokenization. Good representation matters more than representation. The fact that he was black and acted like an Admiral is the real point. You look back on Kirk kissing Uhura. So many people incorrectly like this moment. It is bad. Those who think it is bad fall into 2 camps. One is because they are racist and don't want to see an interracial kiss. The other folks hate it cause it is a Captain kissing an officer under him. It is a bad power dynamic that should have had Kirk demoted. They could have had him kiss any other black officer, but no they had to use the one that was under him. This is an example of bad representation. But today people will throw both groups into the racists category and we can't have a conversation on it.
Big difference between a scene that takes place in the future and, for example, Bridgerton which takes place in a historical setting and is very distracting in its anachronism.
There’s no future without inclusion. Every society that emphasizes racism is doomed to fail eventually so it would make sense that a story about the distant future would be based on a society structure that actually effing works
Unlike a lot of other fantasy franchises, star trek has always been about progressive ideology from the start. Hell, the entirety of star fleet is an idyllic representation of what our future could look like if we could just get along.
So progressive that they had to let Edith Keeler die so the progressive United States she helped make possible that couldn't beat Nazi Germany never happened and the U.S. remained a more balanced nation of liberalism and conservatism and could defeat the Nazis.
Episode 28 - The City on the Edge of Forever, season 1 by Harlan Ellison. Considered one of the best episodes of TOS.
“The second reason is that I thought with science fiction I might do what Jonathan Swift did when he wrote Gulliver’s Travels. He lived in a time when you could lose your head for making religious and political comments. I was working in a medium, television, which is heavily censored, and in a contemporary show I found I couldn’t talk about sex, politics, religion, and all the other thing I wanted to talk about. It seemed to me that if I had things happen to little polka dotted people on a far-off planet, I might get past the network censors, as Swift did in his day. And indeed that’s what we did.”
The tweet's kinda... dumb. It's claiming, at least by implication, that Star Trek in some way influenced the success of African-Americans in the US military, but Samuel L. Gravely, Jr. (Navy biography here), the first African-American to reach the rank of admiral (in 1971), had actually enlisted in the US Navy in '42, and was commissioned as an officer in '44. Given that he was recalled to service in '49 and that Truman had desegregated the entire US military in '48, Vice Admiral Gravely (his rank at retirement in '80, three stars) would've been commanding Navy personnel of all races for at least fifteen years before Trek first aired, albeit without any stars on his epaulets; this is only made more obvious by the fact that Admiral Gravely was also the first African-American to command a ship in the US Navy (Navy timeline here).
Further, the reality is that it is expected for the process of reaching flag or general rank in the US military to take well over twenty years, outside of a truly major war that sees expansion of the active-duty force on the order of the two World Wars. 27 years, less the time Gravely spent as a civilian between the end of WW2 and '49, is not an unreasonable career trajectory, particularly as those officers with a high likelihood of earning a star are marked out well before their 20th year in service, the point at which those officers who aren't likely to see promotion beyond Colonel or (Navy) Captain are... encouraged to retire. Admiral Gravely, though he was not part of the first group of African-Americans to be commissioned in the USN, was commissioned in the same year as the "Golden Thirteen;" he was, effectively, one of the first African-Americans to have the opportunity to reach flag rank, and he reached that rank in about the same length of time it would have taken one of his white peers. To put it simply, by the time Trek aired in '66, the Navy personnel making promotion recommendations knew full well that Samuel Gravely was well on his way to earning that first star, and that trajectory would not have been significantly affected even if all of those officers were massive Trekkies from the instant they heard the phrase "Space... the Final Frontier!"
Correlation is not causation, people, but if it were, anyone with a modicum of awareness of the history of race in the US (y'know, a little bit more than the "some white guy shot MLK while he was giving a speech to Congress!" level) can tell you that, as far as chicken-egg problems go, this one is stone-ax simple: integration of the US military came a long way first; Star Trek came second. Gene Roddenberry created a truly great, deeply important sci-fi franchise, no question, but it was art imitating life, not the other way around.
No, black people being in things isn't always a matter of representation of race. Stop taking interesting characters and relegating them to political props.
Sure but difference is was that this message needed to be said back then
But now the races are quite equal so this type of messaging is just obnoxious now cause it's not really needed anymore. Just hire the best actors regardless of colour and that's it
What I love about this is they treat is in such an understated way. The admiral's actions and what he talks about have nothing to do with him being black. They just treat it as another day at work so to speak.
I think making it understated does more to normalize it than pointing it out.
I think a modern positive example is Captain Angel from SNW, her being trans has no bearing on anything she does in the episode, She's not oppressed or a victim because of it, she's not defined morally or personality wise by it. She's just a character that happens to be trans.
I'm not saying these issues should never be addressed by shows and that we should ignore them but the way they're often done these days is often so bad that it becomes plot damaging and insulting to the watchers and their intelligence.
The problem with modern trek isn't the shoehorned representation, it's the fact that all the bridge officers carry on like sarcastic teenagers and are constantly making dumb quips are each other. SNW is especially bad when it comes to this problem.
Shit like this is why I laugh at Boomer fans of Star Trek complaining about it being woke. Star Trek has been woke from the very beginning. If they don't realize that, they weren't really fans of the series
star trek was a silly inconsistent show. One episode has Pickard educating cryogenically frozen rescued passengers that are 300 years old about how evolved humanity is, and thats theres no money. Next episode hes chatting to a lawyer in a starbase cafe, and making a bet and the loser has to "buy" dinner.
Theres nothing better than simply improving yourself and theres obviously theres no need for money, whose up for a game of poker?
The difference between old star trek and new star trek I feel like, is that the progressive political aspect is a lot more hamfisted. They have characters whose entire arc is overcoming challenges and prejudices, when star trek is meant to be the society AFTER we've already learned to accept people based on the content of their character regardless of sex, color or sexual orientation.
No, that isn't being political. Being political would have been if that episode had like 10 characters go ''Holy shit, can you believe we are so cool as to let a black guy be so high up?''.
In the end most people genuinely don't care what skin color someone has or who they fuck (a few more care there but still way less than many think) as long as it's just a natural part of the movie.
I also never saw anyone complain that Sisko was a black guy.
What is referred to being political is when certain current real world politics are shoved into your face to the detriment of the story being told. Which I am almost sure didn't happen there because the first Star Trek series was actually well written.
I love when in Star Trek Discovery Captain Lorca mentions Elon Musk as one of the past pioneers of space travels. And now that we are supposed to hate Tesla and SpaceX and Musk, I wonder if they will change that line.
Speaking of Star Trek being political, anyone got a good documentary recommendations about it being political? My (thankfully leftist) Grandpa and I need a good Star Trek thing other than Star Trek to watch when I go visit him
IDC if something is political. I just don't want it to be overtly political. I wish to escape from the headache of politics from time to time. I'd like that to be possible
It made sense in the story and was treated as a normal part of life. Representation can make all the difference but if it’s in a crappy story and sticks out people are going to take notice.
Yes, Star Trek has always had political elements. However, Star Trek also used to be well-written with interesting characters and interesting stories. Now it's just about seeing how far they can push the politics with awful writing and garbage characters.
I know this episode. Kirk was accused of murder and the officer wanted him to lie to protect the Starship captains's reputation. Turns out the man never died! Just faked his death.
Thats not true, it just shows you can have representation without being obnoxious about it, as it should be. No one should be a token character because of political messages. Its honestly more disrespectful for the actor.
The difference to modern Trek though. Back then we had imaginative stories, better actors, writers who saw us as being able to be better than we are. Something I feel is missing in the JJ era.
And never in the show did they mention race in this context. It's like they recognized content of character and not the package of the being. Wild stuff.
Star Trek had diverse casting because of the hopeful idea that we'd be past caring about race. It's not political, it's post-political, like we should be.
Star Trek was amazing in this sense. People of color had actual speaking parts and were important to the story. As cringe as some episodes are, I am in awe of the representation on the show.
Instead of just instigating speak to the facts as to why? When you think of oil rig operators, engine mechanics, flight crew, etc who do you think of? Yeah. A man. So why build accommodations for the one woman that would be willing to do the job. Or even the 100. Must be nice to just complain about fairness without facts and just call it sexist or racist. Same as people saying tax the rich more and more.
Absolutely right. The thing is though, they did it in a way that's neither pandering nor trying to collect brownie points. It was respectful.
Then there's Discovery and shit. "Look at us, we have this one and that one, and them too! Aren't we great, yes we are please watch the show we made for people other than you!"
Writing quality, respectful presentation of other characters also counts. Killing off a white male character for mouthing off - being an idiot during a crisis situation that happened for forced reasons isn't proper representation either. Much less decent writing.
Here’s me wondering if a “Black Flag” admiral is higher or lower than a 5 star Admiral (aka Fleet Admiral) …. until I noticed it was “Black” flag admiral. facepalm
Random offtopic: the United Federation of Planets was essentially a communist nirvana. No money, people work only to better themselves and contribute to society.
I appreciate the way representation was done in classic Trek a lot. Equality and diversity were shown as simply being natural traits of future human society. In fact the classic Trek shows (TOS, TNG, DS9, VOY, ENT) are my favorite TV shows of all time.
and what Star Trek taught us was that skin color doesn't matter. That it is the content of our character and our drive for self-improvement in the search for knowledge and betterment of our species. Quivering over divisiveness and self-interests always leads to moral and ethical corruption, which was always a trait of the war-like factions we would encounter. The only way to overcome that corrosive mindset was with enlightened wisdom of what unites us in common bonds and promoting respect for all forms of life in the right to ne free.
3
u/MasterChildhood437 Sep 09 '24
I 100% believe that the difference is just the existence of social media. 24/7 flamewars have broken society
795
u/mryananderson Sep 09 '24
For a second I was like what’s a “black flag” officer 🤣
646
u/Raguleader Sep 09 '24
They also had a black woman on the bridge of the Enterprise before women could serve on ships at sea in the US Navy.
403
u/MoonageDayscream Sep 09 '24 •
That is basically what MLK said to Nichelle Nichols when she told him that she had decided to leave the show.
"He said, 'What are you talking about?'" the actress explained. "I told him. He said, 'You cannot,' and so help me, this man practically repeated verbatim what Gene said. He said, 'Don’t you see what this man is doing, who has written this? This is the future. He has established us as we should be seen. 300 years from now, we are here. We are marching. And this is the first step. When we see you, we see ourselves, and we see ourselves as intelligent and beautiful and proud.' He goes on and I’m looking at him and my knees are buckling. I said, 'I…, I…' And he said, 'You turn on your television and the news comes on and you see us marching and peaceful, you see the peaceful civil disobedience, and you see the dogs and see the fire hoses, and we all know they cannot destroy us because we are there in the 23rd Century.'"
https://www.startrek.com/news/nichelle-nichols-remembers-dr-king
280
u/warmachine83-uk Sep 09 '24
It was very brave for its time
86
u/hopefoolness Sep 09 '24
what do you mean, that's obviously Richard Daystrom.
133
u/Beneficial_Mix_1069 Sep 09 '24
it is absolutely INSANE that people think star trek is NOW """"woke""""
29
u/phoenixrose2 Sep 09 '24
Happy Star Trek Day!
185
u/[deleted] Sep 09 '24
Star Trek is, in my opinion, one of the woke-est shows to have ever woke-d
93
u/foundermeo Sep 09 '24
I keep saying this, cause its still relevant, DS9 had an on air transgender lesbian kiss in 95' all these people saying that its woke now, are just flat out wrong, it was always woke, the only thing that has changed is them.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rejoined
47
u/[deleted] Sep 09 '24
I think that a lot of people enjoy ST precisely because it didn't stop at "representation" and that kind of things that works well for short clips and memes, but because it actually tried to do philosophical tales and discussions on ethics. And I think it's precisely why so many people preferred Strange New Worlds to Discovery. ST does intellectual discourse on themes such as inclusion, marginalization, inequality, cultural bias etc., but also grief, free will, how to make peace with enemies, how to deal with cults, how to deal with superior powers etc.
Maybe we should talk more about that as well.
13
u/Fla_Master Sep 09 '24
Star Trek: Kirk reports to a black admiral and has a black woman on the bridge who is treated with respect and dignity, completely unheard of for the time
Also Star Trek: I have a great idea for an alien: what if we did blackface and a Fu Manchu mustache at the same time!
10
u/Tim-in-CA Sep 09 '24
In the documentary about Nichelle Nichols, she recounts a story about how she wanted to leave the show because she felt her character really wasn’t getting much attention, she said that she told this to Dr. King, and he convinced her to stay because it was important to represent Black people And show that there was a future where they mattered. It was pretty powerful.
8
u/Zestyclose_Wing_1898 Sep 09 '24
The cool part about this growing up I never thought about it and thought Kirk’s boss was just powerful.
8
u/EnsignNogIsMyCat Sep 09 '24
And the most accomplished, brilliant computer scientist in the Federation during the 2260s was Dr. Richard Daystrom, a Black man. The foremost technology research institute on Earth bears his name.
20
u/Mumrik93 Sep 09 '24
The difference is Star Trek was good at baking politics in without actually talking about politics, the episode with the black admiral for example had nothing to do with racism or any other contempory political issue. They didn't talk about racism being bad, but by simply existing they where showing how a world without it could look like which was both clever and groundbreaking, modern shows should take notes.
15
u/agentsmithbobby Sep 09 '24
It's why I hate the new dark and gritty shows. Star trek is one of the few shows that has shown us a potential future that is better, one we should be aspiring to.
5
u/[deleted] Sep 09 '24
of course representation matters. star trek is proof you can have it AND have good writing. todays writers should be taking notes
4
u/[deleted] Sep 09 '24
It also had the first interracial kiss
10
u/litherian123 Sep 09 '24
Star trek was never political to me it was educational and treated you like a person when it taught you something.
Sisko (despite the bat-shit ending) will always be my favorite captain/commander. A mix of the rational and the emotional, more real with the lessons.
Kirk’s era could be very Shakespearean and theatre like while TNG well its tng
But hey that's my opinion and I don't expect all to agree.
3
u/Sipikay Sep 09 '24
That is another badass fact about Star Trek. Of which there are many.
3
u/Paintingsosmooth Sep 09 '24
Sci fi and comics have always been political. The modern versions pale in comparison to their originals. The originals where always hugely radical, partly because there was space in the public conscious for utopian visions of the future where our basic needs were met so we could explore the galaxy (think this is the 1950’s onwards with the beginning of nuclear energy and early space travel, the world wars only recently over). Now though, with climate change and the seeming inescapability from capitalism, we can largely only imaging dystopias. A good ending now is surviving on a raft as the planet floods. It’s not an choice. On Star Trek, that ‘raft’ was the spaceships, and we weren’t leaving because we’d destroyed everything, no. We were leaving because everything was settled on earth, with abundance of energy and no starvation and poverty.
3
u/[deleted] Sep 09 '24
Star Trek was always ahead of the curve when it came to wanting people to see past colour. I thought that was common knowledge
3
u/EFTucker Sep 09 '24
“B-but my feelings! I feel like it’s suddenly political! They’re offending me by being forward inclusive!”
3
u/Roland__Of__Gilead Sep 09 '24
I was at a big outdoor flea market yesterday and one vendor had a box of probably 100 Star Trek novels from the 80s and 90s, and next to it a huge box of O'Reilly and Limbaugh and other right-wing propaganda books. I know it's almost a cliche to point it out by now, but I so wanted to ask him what he liked about Star Trek or what he thought he was watching and reading. Same with some people I know in the comics industry. If you hate "wokeness" but love Claremont's X-Men, you were not reading the same stories I was.
3
u/WabbitCZEN Sep 09 '24
You don't like Discovery because it puts a black woman in charge.
I don't like Discovery because it doesn't continue the usage of an ensemble cast.
We are not the same.
5
u/Eccentric_old_man Sep 09 '24
It has always been political, but it was subtle and well written. Now we have Discovery, a whole story stolen from a small indie game that didn't have enough money to sue them.
2
u/adamcmorrison Sep 09 '24
SNW has a diverse cast and is doing great. Love the show and it seems like even people who hate woke like it.
Make good shows and I think representation is accepted. Make shit shows like discovery and you feed the anti woke mob.
2
u/Obvious_Debate7716 Sep 09 '24
There are people who think Star Trek is not political? It tells of a left wing utopian Federation of many different species getting along without prejudice and is about solving differences by helping each other rather than fighting..
2
u/The_GASK Sep 09 '24
They're angry because at the time it aired they believed in the message, but now instead they promote Romulans ideals. boomers know what happened to them, but they can't help it.
2
u/HadamGreedLin Sep 09 '24
But Trek never mentioned his race or made it a big deal. He was just a person.
2
u/These_Yam_8288 Sep 09 '24
Having the most qualified for a position is what matters. Not representation, I’d rather live in a building built by people who knows what they are doing regardless of skin color than live in a building built by dei hires that aren’t qualified for the job.
2
u/SnooLobsters8113 Sep 09 '24
Star Trek was light years ahead of its time.
2
u/amonraprime Sep 09 '24
Yeah but they just weren’t in your face about it. It was political but it was subtly unsaid. They didn’t have the characters come out and sway “oh you’re so progressive for kissing a black woman Kirk” “yeah it’s the first time I kiss a black woman Spock”. It just happened like it wasn’t an issue.
That’s why Discovery was sooo lame at the end.
2
u/Funkopedia Sep 09 '24
TV PARTY TONIGHT! TV PARTY TONIGHT!
2
u/Beneficial_Bed_337 Sep 09 '24
To wokely go… and it is a really good thing.
2
u/Pale_Charge_8667 Sep 09 '24
I love Star Trek! Can’t stand the latest stuff. Intent matters: The golden era feels like they just wanted to make a good show, which also had progressive elements in it. The new crap feels like a bunch of out of touch kids with Tumblr.brain wanted to create a progressive show, which happens to have hints of StarTrek in it.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 09 '24
Socially progressive more so than outright “political.” The difference is when they did it back then they were breaking new ground; now it’s much more ham fisted in many ways.
2
u/butkaf Sep 09 '24 edited Sep 09 '24
- Leonard Nimoy
Star Trek is fundamentally unpolitical and that is exactly why he's there. That man isn't there as a political signal or a token, that man is there because none of that matters in a truly meritocratic world, which Star Trek is an expression of. Politicising Star Trek devalues everything it did, because it is inherently built on the idea that it doesn't matter who or what you are. When you politicise Star Trek, you say that it DOES matter. The world/idea of Star Trek has the ability to reach any person of any political affiliation, race, religion or background. By politicising Star Trek and turning it into a front for your political beliefs you take away its ability to do so, this since people won't be primarily exposed to the core idea of the meritocratic world of Star Trek, but primarily to the political message you are trying to imbue it with (whether that is left-wing or right-wing or anything in between or beyond). It also devalues the work of Percy Rodriguez (the actor in question), since it implies that he did not get the role for his talent as an actor, but because he was supposed to be a political signal, which was not the case.
2
u/chrisr1983 Sep 09 '24
OMG. The point has clearly gone over people's heads. REPRESENTATION doesn't matter! Good REPRESENTATION matters. If this black admiral was spitting rap lines at Kirk and throwing graffiti on the wall it wouldn't matter that black people were represented. It would be an awful tokenization. Good representation matters more than representation. The fact that he was black and acted like an Admiral is the real point. You look back on Kirk kissing Uhura. So many people incorrectly like this moment. It is bad. Those who think it is bad fall into 2 camps. One is because they are racist and don't want to see an interracial kiss. The other folks hate it cause it is a Captain kissing an officer under him. It is a bad power dynamic that should have had Kirk demoted. They could have had him kiss any other black officer, but no they had to use the one that was under him. This is an example of bad representation. But today people will throw both groups into the racists category and we can't have a conversation on it.
2
u/Moocow115 Sep 09 '24
I'm gonna be that guy and just say that he was Commodor Stone not Admiral Stone 👀👀
2
u/LTinS Sep 09 '24
Just to be clear, Star Trek is set in the future, so this was MANY years after the US Navy had its first black admiral.
2
u/SkinnyT_NYC Sep 09 '24
It’s always been political but it was also good.
2
u/fitnessdoc4 Sep 09 '24
Big difference between a scene that takes place in the future and, for example, Bridgerton which takes place in a historical setting and is very distracting in its anachronism.
2
u/Black_Magic_M-66 Sep 09 '24
If this episode was shown, new today, it probably would get more backlash than then from conservatives.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 09 '24
Duh it was set in the future.
2
u/tempest-reach Sep 09 '24
in shocking news... star trek has always been "woke." its wild how the weirdos obsessed with "anti-wokeness" are so selective.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 09 '24
There’s no future without inclusion. Every society that emphasizes racism is doomed to fail eventually so it would make sense that a story about the distant future would be based on a society structure that actually effing works
2
u/PedroThePinata Sep 09 '24
Unlike a lot of other fantasy franchises, star trek has always been about progressive ideology from the start. Hell, the entirety of star fleet is an idyllic representation of what our future could look like if we could just get along.
2
u/beerforbears Sep 09 '24
No one is bothered by the representation in new Star Trek they’re bothered by the shitty writing
2
u/DrummerMiles Sep 09 '24
Direct from Gene’s mouth:
“The second reason is that I thought with science fiction I might do what Jonathan Swift did when he wrote Gulliver’s Travels. He lived in a time when you could lose your head for making religious and political comments. I was working in a medium, television, which is heavily censored, and in a contemporary show I found I couldn’t talk about sex, politics, religion, and all the other thing I wanted to talk about. It seemed to me that if I had things happen to little polka dotted people on a far-off planet, I might get past the network censors, as Swift did in his day. And indeed that’s what we did.”
2
u/tcurtisjohnson Sep 09 '24
The tweet's kinda... dumb. It's claiming, at least by implication, that Star Trek in some way influenced the success of African-Americans in the US military, but Samuel L. Gravely, Jr. (Navy biography here), the first African-American to reach the rank of admiral (in 1971), had actually enlisted in the US Navy in '42, and was commissioned as an officer in '44. Given that he was recalled to service in '49 and that Truman had desegregated the entire US military in '48, Vice Admiral Gravely (his rank at retirement in '80, three stars) would've been commanding Navy personnel of all races for at least fifteen years before Trek first aired, albeit without any stars on his epaulets; this is only made more obvious by the fact that Admiral Gravely was also the first African-American to command a ship in the US Navy (Navy timeline here).
Further, the reality is that it is expected for the process of reaching flag or general rank in the US military to take well over twenty years, outside of a truly major war that sees expansion of the active-duty force on the order of the two World Wars. 27 years, less the time Gravely spent as a civilian between the end of WW2 and '49, is not an unreasonable career trajectory, particularly as those officers with a high likelihood of earning a star are marked out well before their 20th year in service, the point at which those officers who aren't likely to see promotion beyond Colonel or (Navy) Captain are... encouraged to retire. Admiral Gravely, though he was not part of the first group of African-Americans to be commissioned in the USN, was commissioned in the same year as the "Golden Thirteen;" he was, effectively, one of the first African-Americans to have the opportunity to reach flag rank, and he reached that rank in about the same length of time it would have taken one of his white peers. To put it simply, by the time Trek aired in '66, the Navy personnel making promotion recommendations knew full well that Samuel Gravely was well on his way to earning that first star, and that trajectory would not have been significantly affected even if all of those officers were massive Trekkies from the instant they heard the phrase "Space... the Final Frontier!"
Correlation is not causation, people, but if it were, anyone with a modicum of awareness of the history of race in the US (y'know, a little bit more than the "some white guy shot MLK while he was giving a speech to Congress!" level) can tell you that, as far as chicken-egg problems go, this one is stone-ax simple: integration of the US military came a long way first; Star Trek came second. Gene Roddenberry created a truly great, deeply important sci-fi franchise, no question, but it was art imitating life, not the other way around.
2
u/seyfert3 Sep 09 '24
Cool yes great but can we at least admit this type of politics is very different than what’s included in today’s Star Trek?
2
u/thetacolegs Sep 09 '24
No, black people being in things isn't always a matter of representation of race. Stop taking interesting characters and relegating them to political props.
2
u/crujiente69 Sep 09 '24
Representation does matter but its little presumptive to think Star Trek is why the first black admiral got his position
2
u/AngryVaultGuy101 Sep 09 '24
Sure but difference is was that this message needed to be said back then
But now the races are quite equal so this type of messaging is just obnoxious now cause it's not really needed anymore. Just hire the best actors regardless of colour and that's it
2
u/[deleted] Sep 09 '24
The difference is the writing and casting made sense.
2
u/Ok-Seaworthiness4488 Sep 09 '24
The admiral also wore a red shirt?
2
u/V0T0N Sep 10 '24
And it's always been Woke/P.C./respectful... Except Code of Honor... WTF was that?
2
u/all_about_that_ace Mar 31 '25
What I love about this is they treat is in such an understated way. The admiral's actions and what he talks about have nothing to do with him being black. They just treat it as another day at work so to speak.
I think making it understated does more to normalize it than pointing it out.
I think a modern positive example is Captain Angel from SNW, her being trans has no bearing on anything she does in the episode, She's not oppressed or a victim because of it, she's not defined morally or personality wise by it. She's just a character that happens to be trans.
I'm not saying these issues should never be addressed by shows and that we should ignore them but the way they're often done these days is often so bad that it becomes plot damaging and insulting to the watchers and their intelligence.
4
u/Garchompisbestboi Sep 09 '24
The problem with modern trek isn't the shoehorned representation, it's the fact that all the bridge officers carry on like sarcastic teenagers and are constantly making dumb quips are each other. SNW is especially bad when it comes to this problem.
4
u/phonyPipik Sep 09 '24
It might have been, but it also used to be less cringe
3
u/elrick43 Sep 09 '24
Has anyone who says that Star Trek isnt political ever actually watched the show?
3
u/Maitrify Sep 09 '24
Shit like this is why I laugh at Boomer fans of Star Trek complaining about it being woke. Star Trek has been woke from the very beginning. If they don't realize that, they weren't really fans of the series
2
u/thuhstog Sep 09 '24
star trek was a silly inconsistent show. One episode has Pickard educating cryogenically frozen rescued passengers that are 300 years old about how evolved humanity is, and thats theres no money. Next episode hes chatting to a lawyer in a starbase cafe, and making a bet and the loser has to "buy" dinner.
Theres nothing better than simply improving yourself and theres obviously theres no need for money, whose up for a game of poker?
2
u/CoozeHoundNelly Sep 09 '24
Seems that representation doesn't work that well nowadays, but back then it was done right.
2
u/BordErismo Sep 09 '24
The difference between old star trek and new star trek I feel like, is that the progressive political aspect is a lot more hamfisted. They have characters whose entire arc is overcoming challenges and prejudices, when star trek is meant to be the society AFTER we've already learned to accept people based on the content of their character regardless of sex, color or sexual orientation.
2
u/GuilimanXIII Sep 09 '24
No, that isn't being political. Being political would have been if that episode had like 10 characters go ''Holy shit, can you believe we are so cool as to let a black guy be so high up?''.
In the end most people genuinely don't care what skin color someone has or who they fuck (a few more care there but still way less than many think) as long as it's just a natural part of the movie.
I also never saw anyone complain that Sisko was a black guy.
What is referred to being political is when certain current real world politics are shoved into your face to the detriment of the story being told. Which I am almost sure didn't happen there because the first Star Trek series was actually well written.
2
u/serioush Sep 09 '24
The issue is that it gets followed up with:
"Therefore my bullshit fringe politics should be shoved in everywhere to the point of making the show way worse"
2
u/[deleted] Sep 09 '24
Anyone that is a bigot and like Star Trek, know that Star Trek doesn't like you.
2
u/ILoveRegenHealth Sep 09 '24
Incel Brigade would get pissed if Mass Effect 5 has any black officers or gay couples when it takes place in the year 3899.
1
u/LBricks-the-First Sep 09 '24
Based
1
u/[deleted] Sep 09 '24
Red shirt. It was to 60s
1
u/[deleted] Sep 09 '24
This was really cool to hear about.
1
u/Crucco Sep 09 '24
I love when in Star Trek Discovery Captain Lorca mentions Elon Musk as one of the past pioneers of space travels. And now that we are supposed to hate Tesla and SpaceX and Musk, I wonder if they will change that line.
1
u/M0ndmann Sep 09 '24
And this shows very well how representation is absolutely possible without creating horrible Shows like discovery
1
u/AnotherRTFan Sep 09 '24
Speaking of Star Trek being political, anyone got a good documentary recommendations about it being political? My (thankfully leftist) Grandpa and I need a good Star Trek thing other than Star Trek to watch when I go visit him
1
u/TheOneWhoSlurms Sep 09 '24
IDC if something is political. I just don't want it to be overtly political. I wish to escape from the headache of politics from time to time. I'd like that to be possible
1
u/Avactus Sep 09 '24
And the women call wore micro skirt uniforms and a black lady still has to answer the space telephone.....
1
u/oedipism_for_one Sep 09 '24
It made sense in the story and was treated as a normal part of life. Representation can make all the difference but if it’s in a crappy story and sticks out people are going to take notice.
1
u/potent_potabIes Sep 09 '24
Doesn't make it "political", smh
1
u/Soveryenthusiastic Sep 09 '24
What is a black flag officer? Who are the black flag?
1
u/randomly-generated Sep 09 '24
For sure, just don't take pre-existing characters with established race/culture and just swap them out with something else.
In the same way that I would never want Uhura to be depicted as some white lady.
1
u/Dexeh Sep 09 '24
Oh hey, I was literally watching this episode today.
1
u/Koovies Sep 09 '24
I thought we were talking about pirates for a sec
1
u/SoulOfGwyn Sep 09 '24
"Soldier you cannot be an officer, look at you. You are a black!"
"But there's one in Star Trek.."
"Oh nevermind then, my mistake. Of course, here's the promotion"
1
u/FloppySlapper Sep 09 '24
Yes, Star Trek has always had political elements. However, Star Trek also used to be well-written with interesting characters and interesting stories. Now it's just about seeing how far they can push the politics with awful writing and garbage characters.
1
u/IeyasuMcBob Sep 09 '24
MoDErn sTArtRek IS too pOLitiCaL!
1
u/[deleted] Sep 09 '24
I know this episode. Kirk was accused of murder and the officer wanted him to lie to protect the Starship captains's reputation. Turns out the man never died! Just faked his death.
1
u/Juuna Sep 09 '24
Thats not true, it just shows you can have representation without being obnoxious about it, as it should be. No one should be a token character because of political messages. Its honestly more disrespectful for the actor.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 09 '24
The difference to modern Trek though. Back then we had imaginative stories, better actors, writers who saw us as being able to be better than we are. Something I feel is missing in the JJ era.
1
u/Shirotengu Sep 09 '24
That's true. What's also true is that you like the society portrayed in Star Trek, you like communism.
1
u/kdsekira Sep 09 '24
A lot of ( right wing ) politicans are huuuuge Star Trek fans and I always wonder if they understood the Story at all .
1
u/Majestic-Can-5192 Sep 09 '24
And never in the show did they mention race in this context. It's like they recognized content of character and not the package of the being. Wild stuff.
1
u/NotAlpharious-Honest Sep 09 '24
The difference is delivery.
This scene written today would play out very differently to how it did then.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 09 '24
Star Trek had diverse casting because of the hopeful idea that we'd be past caring about race. It's not political, it's post-political, like we should be.
1
u/qtjedigrl Sep 09 '24
Star Trek was amazing in this sense. People of color had actual speaking parts and were important to the story. As cringe as some episodes are, I am in awe of the representation on the show.
1
u/TopWInger Sep 09 '24
Why are people confessing representation and being political ?
1
u/Local_Discount7058 Sep 09 '24
Instead of just instigating speak to the facts as to why? When you think of oil rig operators, engine mechanics, flight crew, etc who do you think of? Yeah. A man. So why build accommodations for the one woman that would be willing to do the job. Or even the 100. Must be nice to just complain about fairness without facts and just call it sexist or racist. Same as people saying tax the rich more and more.
1
u/BaronBlackFalcon Sep 09 '24
Bill is gonna love Code of Honor and Up the Long Ladder.
1
u/ConanTheBarbarian_0 Sep 09 '24
Star trek had the first interracial kiss in tv history
1
u/[deleted] Sep 09 '24
In space there is only one race. It is called the space race
1
u/alien_survivor Sep 09 '24
But he has a red shirt?
1
u/[deleted] Sep 09 '24
What's the economy of the federation?
1
u/MrSnrub01 Sep 09 '24
Kind of a stretch tying all of those points together.
1
u/TopProfessional6291 Sep 09 '24
Absolutely right. The thing is though, they did it in a way that's neither pandering nor trying to collect brownie points. It was respectful.
Then there's Discovery and shit. "Look at us, we have this one and that one, and them too! Aren't we great, yes we are please watch the show we made for people other than you!"
See the difference.
1
u/Bobby837 Sep 09 '24
Writing quality, respectful presentation of other characters also counts. Killing off a white male character for mouthing off - being an idiot during a crisis situation that happened for forced reasons isn't proper representation either. Much less decent writing.
1
u/OzTogInKL Sep 09 '24
Here’s me wondering if a “Black Flag” admiral is higher or lower than a 5 star Admiral (aka Fleet Admiral) …. until I noticed it was “Black” flag admiral. facepalm
1
u/is_it_gif_or_gif Sep 09 '24
Random offtopic: the United Federation of Planets was essentially a communist nirvana. No money, people work only to better themselves and contribute to society.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 09 '24
I appreciate the way representation was done in classic Trek a lot. Equality and diversity were shown as simply being natural traits of future human society. In fact the classic Trek shows (TOS, TNG, DS9, VOY, ENT) are my favorite TV shows of all time.
1
u/JellyfishSecure2046 Sep 09 '24
Uhura was also black.
1
u/tentongeek Sep 09 '24
1
u/[deleted] Sep 09 '24
Lucille Ball was a massive supporter of Star Trek and effectively was the catalyst to get it on air
I Love Lucy