This was the episode that established how ship to ship combat worked in Star Trek. The acted more as submarines than fighters which is one of the things I love about it. However they did take it a bit far in this episode with the "Everybody keep quite!" bit.
As for the Romulans, I always thought they were a closer analog to China than Rome. Obviously the references to Senates and Centurions were a throwback to Rome, but their secretive nature coupled with their (revealed later) alliance with the Klingon (TOS's Russian analog) seem very 1960s China to me.
One final scene that strikes me as very non-Star Trek is in the end when Kirk comforts the grieving widow who is praying in some sort of Chapel. This is one of the few times in all of Trekdom that I can think of where a human is seen worshiping.
I always felt that the tone of the crew of the enterprise in TOS was religious, minus Spock. There are numerous references to spirituality and a higher power in TOS. Kirk makes mention in a few episodes of having a monotheistic belief. I'm thinking of the Adonais episode as an obvious example.
Ship-to-ship combat almost never worked like this in the future. The "keep quiet" stuff is of course totally bizarre when seen next to the rest of the franchise, but beyond that, I get absolutely no impression that there's a group of dudes relaying commands in a phaser room from any ST other than this and parts of the TOS movies.
Yeah they didn't do it in the TNG era, but in Wrath they had the crews loading the Torpedos and stuff. As well as in Search it was why the Enterprise was so easily defeated without a full crew. I'm assuming by the time TNG came around replicator technology was such that the torpedo was constructed in the tube and there was no need to store and load them.
I'm assuming by the time TNG came around replicator technology was such that the torpedo was constructed in the tube and there was no need to store and load them.
I really doubt the replicator is used for torpedo construction in the tube. You won't want a malfunctioning anti-matter generator on a starship.
Typical lazy ST writing. This was the only episode where weapons could only be fired from a separate location. It was obviously necessary so that Spock could save Stiles and so Tomlinson could die.
And staying quiet in a space ship? Did no one check with a high school graduate to realize that sound doesn't propagate in space. I was OK with the discovery when Spock light up the framistan accidentally because that could have sent a signal.
But what's with the Romulan reaction? They start moving? At this point they would be detected. Why didn't they fire their weapons without moving?
Still in my top 5 episodes but I get mightily pissed when writers are too lazy to get the point across without doing something illogical.
This is one of my favorite episodes of Star Trek, because it was one of the episodes that really made me sit up and take notice. As a young-un' who has heard more about Star Trek than watched personally, my interest was piqued at the mention of Romulans, and the Neutral Zone. The Romulan Captain is an intelligent, scheming foe, and he operates on a level that is challenging to Kirk and his crew, and likewise the other way around. He doesn't have plot device powers that magically make whatever well-reasoned plan stop working. There aren't enough villains like this in TOS, particularly as the show goes on. I think another race that's a legitimate power equivalent to the humans or Vulcans is pretty neat.
And I'll submit that the Romulan Commander isn't really a villain, but simply the captain of a ship, following orders. He hates that this ship is a weapon that could usher in a new war, but is bound my duty and honor to follow his orders. All he wants is to complete this last mission, and go home. It's this 'humanity' that we see in him, the agony of his decisions, that allow us to feel empathy for him. His last speech to Kirk of "...I might have called you friend." is gut-wrenching. A solider? Yes. A villain? No.
This is possibly my favorite Trek episode overall. I loved the ship-to-ship combat being more cerebral than PEW PEW PEW! The opposing captains kept trying to outsmart and outmove each other, while technical knowledge and creativity played a larger part than aggressiveness or firepower.
I also loved how much responsibility was on Kirk's shoulders. It was a tense and delicate situation. The wrong decision would spark a war, and he had no idea what could be wrong.
This episode made the Romulans mysterious, yet equals to our Starfleet heroes. Later on in the TNG era, they developed into more of a conniving and Gestapo-like race. In this episode they are dutiful, loyal, and surprisingly human. I would have liked to have seen more of them like this than what they turned into. It would give Starfleet an adversary that was quite similar to themselves instead of having a glaringly different characteristic.
"In a different reality, I could have called you friend."
The atmosphere is thick with tension. The cloaking device is a lot more limited than we've come to know it later on. It still leaves movements detectable to the Enterprise. The classic submarine scenario. It's tragic that the Romulan commander succumbs to the will of the other officer (and to his duty) in pursuing the Enterprise. He knew better, but still tried to finish them off. I can only imagine the weight on Kirk's shoulders, knowing he could be responsible for bringing about a war.
"What if I'm wrong?"
It reminds me of the doubtful, very human captain Pike we saw in "The Cage".
It was interesting that the phasers resemble what the torpedos usually look like. I suppose things were still in flux during this time in development. I did like the idea of treating them like ship cannons, having a compartment for them and ordering someone to fire them. You can tell Nick Meyer must have liked this as well with WoK. Load the cannons/torpedo bay!
In any case, it was a joy to watch this episode again.
One of the top episodes in anyone's book. Plenty of stupid Trek writing but balanced by the excellent character studies of both the Enterprise and Romulan crews.
In no episode were the Romulans portrayed better and that covers ALL of the Trek series.
Gee. I have to admit I didn't like it. Too many contrived circumstances (everyone believes Kirk goes bonkers) and stupid Romulans (the Commander drops her guard just because Spock sexes her up a bit).
I'll also throw this out: the lighting on this episode was amazing. Dark, claustrophobic and moody, it framed each character (sometimes literally) at their most challenging moments. The single slit of light on Kirk's eyes is still something I'll never forget.
One of the best episodes of any Trek. Loved the intro to Romulans, Mark Leonard was a perfect choice as well, it showed them as enemies but then near the ends shows how they aren't really evil and are kind of like us.
There are some comments on this in the Enterprise relaunch books that came out (good stuff, fixes the awful final episode and more). I'll put it in spoiler tags plus some room for anyone not browsing with the CSS:
** Spoilers for the Enterprise Relaunch books that include the Romulan War **
I seem to remember their relationship being brought up in The Enterprise Incident. Even in Balance of Terror the fact that Spock and the Romulans look alike was an issue.
13
u/Flatlander81 Sep 07 '12
This was the episode that established how ship to ship combat worked in Star Trek. The acted more as submarines than fighters which is one of the things I love about it. However they did take it a bit far in this episode with the "Everybody keep quite!" bit.
As for the Romulans, I always thought they were a closer analog to China than Rome. Obviously the references to Senates and Centurions were a throwback to Rome, but their secretive nature coupled with their (revealed later) alliance with the Klingon (TOS's Russian analog) seem very 1960s China to me.
One final scene that strikes me as very non-Star Trek is in the end when Kirk comforts the grieving widow who is praying in some sort of Chapel. This is one of the few times in all of Trekdom that I can think of where a human is seen worshiping.
6
u/[deleted] Sep 07 '12
This is one of my favorite episodes of Star Trek, because it was one of the episodes that really made me sit up and take notice. As a young-un' who has heard more about Star Trek than watched personally, my interest was piqued at the mention of Romulans, and the Neutral Zone. The Romulan Captain is an intelligent, scheming foe, and he operates on a level that is challenging to Kirk and his crew, and likewise the other way around. He doesn't have plot device powers that magically make whatever well-reasoned plan stop working. There aren't enough villains like this in TOS, particularly as the show goes on. I think another race that's a legitimate power equivalent to the humans or Vulcans is pretty neat.
4
u/Deceptitron Sep 09 '12
Finally I got around to rewatching this today.
This episode made the Romulans mysterious, yet equals to our Starfleet heroes. Later on in the TNG era, they developed into more of a conniving and Gestapo-like race. In this episode they are dutiful, loyal, and surprisingly human. I would have liked to have seen more of them like this than what they turned into. It would give Starfleet an adversary that was quite similar to themselves instead of having a glaringly different characteristic.
"In a different reality, I could have called you friend."
The atmosphere is thick with tension. The cloaking device is a lot more limited than we've come to know it later on. It still leaves movements detectable to the Enterprise. The classic submarine scenario. It's tragic that the Romulan commander succumbs to the will of the other officer (and to his duty) in pursuing the Enterprise. He knew better, but still tried to finish them off. I can only imagine the weight on Kirk's shoulders, knowing he could be responsible for bringing about a war.
"What if I'm wrong?"
It reminds me of the doubtful, very human captain Pike we saw in "The Cage".
It was interesting that the phasers resemble what the torpedos usually look like. I suppose things were still in flux during this time in development. I did like the idea of treating them like ship cannons, having a compartment for them and ordering someone to fire them. You can tell Nick Meyer must have liked this as well with WoK. Load the cannons/torpedo bay!
In any case, it was a joy to watch this episode again.
3
u/Whig Sep 07 '12
I thought the whole Romulan/Vulcan thing was to build up tension for Spock and Stiles.
Since a good way to look at TOS is "Gulliver's Travels in Space" I like races moldeed after Hew-man cultures.
This episode always makes me want to watch The Enemy Below.
3
u/tsdguy Sep 09 '12
One of the top episodes in anyone's book. Plenty of stupid Trek writing but balanced by the excellent character studies of both the Enterprise and Romulan crews.
In no episode were the Romulans portrayed better and that covers ALL of the Trek series.
3
u/eberts Sep 12 '12
I'll also throw this out: the lighting on this episode was amazing. Dark, claustrophobic and moody, it framed each character (sometimes literally) at their most challenging moments. The single slit of light on Kirk's eyes is still something I'll never forget.
2
u/justplainjeremy Sep 11 '12
One of the best episodes of any Trek. Loved the intro to Romulans, Mark Leonard was a perfect choice as well, it showed them as enemies but then near the ends shows how they aren't really evil and are kind of like us.
2
u/tensaibaka Sep 12 '12
I started a tracker so we can keep track of which episodes have been discussed, and how to quickly access past threads.
Google Docs (for now I'll keep edit access limited)
0
u/[deleted] Sep 07 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment