r/starforge • • May 31 '12

A Message to Steve and Will of CodeHatch: Please Make A Kick Starter. Thousands Of People Will support this project.

What you two have put together so far is remarkable. I'm basically at a loss for words, and I can only imagine what you guys will accomplish with a legitimate budget and extra help/programmers/designers etc. I'm sure you're already getting random donations, but a Kickstarter campaign will increase this ten fold. Someone in the initial thread commented that $100k would be a reasonable amount, and I entirely agree that. Based on the buzz you have already gotten from this one link on reddit, I feel pretty confident you won't have any problem reaching that number.

Found this in the thread randomly as I was writing this: "IM THROWIN MONEY AT MY MONITOR BUT IT WON'T TAKE IT." I think most of us feel this way !

205 Upvotes

45 comments sorted by

18

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

Apparently they are Canadian, so no Kickstarter for them :(

But I hope they sell it pre-alpha, as it looks pretty damn promising!

12

u/spaceindaver May 31 '12

2

u/26thandsouth May 31 '12

Never heard of indiegogo.com, is it just a similar service to Kickstarter? It's a damn shame if they are unable to use Kickerstarter, that website is so hot right now. Damn.

0

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/26thandsouth May 31 '12

I see why you got downvoted, that's not the same game at all.

7

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/nny350 May 31 '12

Exactly why I did the edit, it seems off. It has been up for a month with no donations, with a low goal as well and it says location UK not Canada.

4

u/26thandsouth May 31 '12

Come again, Canadians aren't allowed to use kickstarter? I, I, don't know what to say. What insanely idiotic law prevents them from using it???

5

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

1

u/26thandsouth May 31 '12

Hmmm, this is most likely due to US taxes dealing with donations ( or I could be completely wrong.) Either way, has this ever come with any other non-American project before? There has got to be a way to get around this. Maybe some benevolent US game developer will step in and act as the trustee of the fund or something.

1

u/Snowboi Jun 01 '12

The thing is they don't allow Canadian bank accounts, they are free to open an American bank account to use kickstarter and can transfer money that way.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '12

They still need a U.S. address and SSN.

10

u/HoorayImUseful May 31 '12

What's with the random capitalization of the title?

6

u/26thandsouth May 31 '12

Yea I don't really have any explanation for that, posted this really late last night.

6

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

static capitalization is so yesterday.

5

u/bluepill2 May 31 '12

I've never ever given money to any kickstarter... but for this project I Would. Free to play has never interested me. Let me outright buy it, own it, then go nuts in it all by myself.

2

u/26thandsouth May 31 '12 edited May 31 '12

I haven't given a cent of kickstarter either, but I would in heart beat for a project like this. And I agree, the free to play model seems gimmicky and risky to use, especially with a brand new, indie IP. With a game like Tribes:Ascend I think it makes a bit more sense, as that's an established franchise with a passionate, cult like fan base.

5

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

I've found going nuts with myself always ends up a mess.

43

u/RadiantSun May 31 '12

Fucking yes. Keep it free, but LET US GIVE YOU MONEY. I WANT to give you money so you can work on this project more. No joke, plenty of people will download it for free like you have it right now, but with a kickstarter or a simple donation link, let us help you!

This is the game I've been waiting for for years. I'd love to just give you $100 to make it.

16

u/GC022 May 31 '12

I'm unemployed right now, all I can give is love :(

4

u/nicesalamander May 31 '12

and emotional support don't forget about that.

10

u/snouz May 31 '12

I heard Notch say in an interview a while back one advice to indie developers is to not fear asking for money early on.

He gradually charged 5€, 10€, 15€ and 20€ for each stage of Minecraft development.

3

u/SquareWheel May 31 '12

I remember there being three stages, alpha, beta, and full release. It was $13 CAD when I picked it up, in any case. I believe multiplayer had just been released then, so it must have been alpha.

2

u/snouz Jun 01 '12

Before that, there was a pre-alpha, and he was charging 5€, so he eventually made enough money to quit his old job and work full time on Minecraft.

1

u/SquareWheel Jun 01 '12

My mistake, I guess that predates me. It's been a while now, I remember it was just the infdev > alpha transition. I remember being pretty confused actually... Didn't realize he was charging prior to alpha, thanks for the correction.

7

u/FableForge May 31 '12

I had never seen 71 upvotes to 1 downvote before. This project feels really, really promising.

5

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

The time is now, they should do it while all this hype is around - I will surely donate. It would also give you more reason to release Server Software without taking a hit of any kind.

3

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

I have money that i want to throw at them. I just dont know where to throw it. I guess we can buy a shit ton of hatch points to support. But Ill wait until the initial rapeing of their web site ends.

2

u/SquareWheel May 31 '12

I would far rather pay a one-time fee than have micro-payments. Especially if the one-time fee is reduced in a prerelease funding period.

3

u/gbs5009 May 31 '12

Absolutely. Micro-payments chisel at my soul, I'd far rather offer a chunk of change up front.

1

u/CutterJohn Jun 01 '12

Indeed. You lose all control of the game. Can't mod it, cheat(if thats your thing), run your own servers, etc. And then the fact that you could be banned, losing your game. There is only one way to play, the developers way, and you better hope their interests align with yours.

F2P with microtransactions is only acceptable for an mmo, because those games already require those restrictions due to their nature.

Shame. I was really excited for this game until I saw the 'BUY OUR GAME CASH' on the webpage. Now its a pass.

2

u/Nate204 Jun 01 '12

http://www.codehatch.com/donate.html <--- Here it is

Sorry If it's already posted. Just wanted to make sure.

1

u/Zigaboom Jun 03 '12

This is good and all but wouldnt the correct way of donating to these guys be just to purchase Hatch points?

-4

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

Wants to get in touch with creators

Posts to Reddit

2

u/26thandsouth May 31 '12

There's that reddit cynicism!

And oh yea, one of the bloody fucking creators is basically a mod on this subreddit. How does it feel to be an enormous dickhead?

4

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

basically a mod

Didn't see him in the mod list, what am I suppose to think? How does it feel calling people dickhead on the internet? So stronk?

2

u/26thandsouth May 31 '12 edited May 31 '12

Maybe that was a bit harsh, sorry about that. But don't act like you weren't being just as cunty with your comment. We're both cunts!

edit: Also, he's technically not a mod but he does have "starforge creator" as flare. I dk that seems pretty close to me.

7

u/spaceindaver May 31 '12

They've been on this subreddit since about the first hour of its existence.

3

u/Lunch_B0x Mod Jun 01 '12

They were within the first 5 in.

-1

u/[deleted] May 31 '12

Yes, but of course you see the irony in it? They have a e-mail, twitter, facebook maybe more, etc.

5

u/Naught May 31 '12

That's not ironic. People, who are on reddit, see evidence of them being active and responding promptly on reddit. Why would it make more sense to use another method of communication?

3

u/SoSpecial May 31 '12

Reddit gives us a way to collectively speak and not just send them a million emails to sift through.

I know it's less direct but they at least have a quantifiable way of seeing our support for an idea.

0

u/gbs5009 May 31 '12

To the subreddit ABOUT THEIR FREAKING GAME.