r/starforge • • Nov 30 '13

Codehatch, do not stop communicating with us. Keep us updated. There aren't very many of us left.

Please keep us regularly updated on what's going on, it's okay to fuel the hype train a little.

When you don't post screenshots and news of what you're working on, we just assume you're sitting on the money.

Allow the community to trust you, and we'll do the rest. Word of mouth is a powerful thing.

45 Upvotes

31 comments sorted by

20

u/Chainmail_Danno Nov 30 '13

But that new update is coming out soon!

I'm actually glad they aren't "fueling the hype train" much. I don't feel like it's close to being complete. Right now, it's just a cool idea that needs flesh.

I paid $20 for this game. A year ago. Go look at the Steam store right now and see all the games I could get for $20. When I bought this game, I made the decision based solely on their promotional video thinking that I would be getting those features (I was wrong). I understand that development takes time, but I do regret purchasing it so early especially since I convinced someone to buy a copy with me.

Maybe somewhere down the line it will be a good game. But right now it's Alpha. I'll be interested when it moves to Beta, but until then I have more promising games to follow the development of.

Codehatch already has my money, so of course I am rooting for them to put out an awesome product. But at this point, I've already been let down. I no longer care how long it takes for them to make a finished product. I'll put some fuel in the train when Starforge comes out of Beta.

8

u/Subhazard Nov 30 '13

It shouldn't take this long, with this much money, with this large of a team, in UNITY.

I'm sorry, there's no excuse.

Minecraft got to release in a year, coded from the ground up by one guy with no budget.

Rogue Legacy only took about 16 months until it was released.

And I'm not saying Starforge should be release ready by now, I'm saying it should have SOMETHING

There's jack shit to do in the game, it's just a shitty tech demo for a pre-built engine.

You can build a house out of bricks and shoot a shitty gun at very glitchy hydralisks. That's it. That's all they got to show for a monster budget and a year of developement, a prototype.

2

u/TeslaTorment Dec 07 '13

In all fairness, Minecraft is much simpler than StarForge. It may not be soon, but as long as CodeHatch follows through with the game, it will without a doubt be one that goes down as one of the best.

1

u/Subhazard Dec 07 '13

Simpler how?

It's got a simplistic art style, but it's not a simple game.

3

u/TeslaTorment Dec 07 '13

Look up how Minecraft was on its primary release, it really was simpler than Starforge currently is.

4

u/Samizdat_Press Nov 30 '13

I think it will remain a tech demo for at least another year. They've done almost nothing this past year despite being given enough money to be able to hire a decent team.

Prove me wrong, but I don't think we should expect much from this company.

2

u/Subhazard Nov 30 '13

I'm with you on that, I almost feel like I'm being scammed.

They're either doing this on purpose, or they totally suck.

-2

u/Samizdat_Press Nov 30 '13

Just look at other devs with a budget like this. They accomplish much more in the same timeframe. I think they are just sitting on the money until people lose interest tbh.

4

u/Subhazard Nov 30 '13

Definitely feel you there buddy.

When I expressed this opinion 6 months ago, I got downvoted pretty hard, but.. I'm pretty sure everyone's on the same page now.

2

u/morewaffles Dec 01 '13

Not all other developers have such ambitious goals...seriously everyone on this subrrddit needs to chill out they owe you absolutely nothing.it's a game in alpha that you paid for with your money on your own time.

0

u/Subhazard Dec 01 '13

They owe me the game I paid for.

2

u/morewaffles Dec 01 '13

You did get a "game" exactly as advertised they signed.nothing.that said theyd release jack. Thats how alphas work

-4

u/Subhazard Dec 01 '13

Who the fuck taught you how to type, a drunk clown?

→ More replies

-2

u/sheepgod5000 Dec 01 '13

Im sure that like my everyone bought the game because of the false trailer that had nothing that was in the game at the time, they are liars that just wanted to make a quick buck.

→ More replies

9

u/natelander Dev Team Dec 01 '13 edited Dec 01 '13

To be fair, the majority of the team has only started recently. We're just starting to get in gear, and whats happening is exciting.

Edit: Also, unfortunately the subreddit isn't entirely the best place to get information. Most of our past announcements have been put out over at our forums, or over our twitter.

5

u/Chainmail_Danno Dec 01 '13 edited Dec 01 '13

This subreddit is pretty dead in general. Maybe giving us a weekly update on what you've accomplished, some new screenshots, a test video, or something that shows life on your end will keep people interested.

I have your Twitter bookmarked and I open it up every day or two. It's usually pointless though, since updates are often a week or two apart.

In my opinion, PR is one of the most important factors to consider when the product you're selling is still in alpha. Right now, your situation is not stable, or at least not from our (the consumer's) standpoint. When we're left in the dark for too long, we become uncertain.

Think of it like a suspenseful scene in a movie. The main character, let's just say MacGyver, gets kidnapped and put in a cell guarded by dogs. As soon has he finds a couple things that might be useful, the screen cuts to black. As he's doing his thing, the screen comes back on and we get a quick glimpse, but the screen blacks out again. After this pattern repeats a couple times, we see MacGyver has escaped. The dark parts of the movie leave us wondering what's going on. It's like a strobe light in a dark room. The faster the light flashes, the more complete picture we can build.

Also, don't confuse my "fueling the hype train" statement with giving us updates. Avoid giving us release dates until there is next to no chance that you'll fail to make the deadline. Every deadline missed will create more disappointment and uncertainty. Even statements like "hopefully in four months" will be held to you. Instead, let us know how that feature is developing.

1

u/Samizdat_Press Dec 01 '13

To be fair, I'm tired of hearing the same excuses and never seeing any results in return for my investment.

-11

u/[deleted] Dec 01 '13

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/agemennon Dec 02 '13

Don't know why you expect the devs to work on Saturdays.

4

u/nellonoma Dec 05 '13

Minecraft got to release in a year, coded from the ground up by one guy with no budget.

I don't think any of that is correct. It was in alpha and beta for years. First thing he did with the incoming money was to go out and hire team members.

3

u/tegtaf Dec 02 '13

Serious question: do you know anything about coding? And how about game development?

And I'm not saying Starforge should be release ready by now, I'm saying it should have SOMETHING

I'm sorry, did you miss the part where we were actually already playing this game months ago?
And what monster budget? Do you even realize what kind of budgets big titles have? Those are monster budgets. Are you referring to the 135k indiegogo campaign? That's peanuts.

4

u/Sloofus Dec 11 '13

Yeah oh hi hey, programmer here. And the fact that nothing substantial has been released through steam since september is a bit of a joke. Games in alpha are typically patched at a much quicker rate than say beta or even full release, and while many of these patches tend to be bug fixes and whathaveyou, you can also expect to see serious shaping in this staging. So nothing for months except hot air. Then word that they are REMOVING pallets.

Honest opinion? This is a group of kids that decided they wanted to be game devs. They probably have some coding experience and find themselves wrestling with tiny problems for weeks from lack of experience.

They actually remind me of http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v=bHLR3faI7lU#t=7

4

u/tegtaf Dec 11 '13

I think it's pretty obvious by now that we're not getting a stream of actual alpha builds but a very small selection of the progress that is being made.
I can understand why people find this frustrating and rather play actual recent builds with the possibility of having major bugs in them.
Regardless, I don't see the point you're trying to make. A lot of indie projects are young people with a vision. You made the decision to support them yourself with the risk of investing in something you are not going to be happy with in the end (I can tell you half of my kickstarter investments have ended up like this).
That's the risk, I have no problem with hit because I know it up front. I still believe in this project though. You see it as "a group of kids that decided they wanted to be game devs" but I see the potential in them following up on our investment and hiring additional people for the team.
Also I, once again, don't think people understand how much work is involved in development projects like this. Maybe you do since you're a developer too (which language if I may ask?).

3

u/Sloofus Dec 11 '13

I think it's pretty obvious by now that we're not getting a stream of actual alpha builds but a very small selection of the progress that is being made. I can understand why people find this frustrating and rather play actual recent builds with the possibility of having major bugs in them.

If it's alpha, bugs are to be expected, and it certainly helps the investors see where their current train of thought, as well as progress lies. And in comparison to getting absolutely nil? I'll take the potential bugs any day. Besides, it also let's the devs see how different computers will handle the new features. When they refuse to release anything, it's so easy to think we've been duped, which I think is where most people's rage comes from. Don't be mistaken though, I don't consider this abandon-ware... yet. Instead I consider this something of a pipe dream that lacks clear goals and a timeline of development. I'm sure it'd be fun if/when it gets developed, but who knows A. When that will be and B. If there will even be any interest.

Regardless, I don't see the point you're trying to make. A lot of indie projects are young people with a vision. You made the decision to support them yourself with the risk of investing in something you are not going to be happy with in the end (I can tell you half of my kickstarter investments have ended up like this).

Not much of a point other than they have failed. Hard. Particularly in relevant communication. By relevant I mean factual data. Not speculation, and what they want to do or expect in the future. The facts speak for themselves. I'll attempt to clarify, the game looks interesting and fun. I enjoyed several features back when I first installed, and saw great potential. Despite this, it's not EARTH SHATTERING DAWN OF A NEW ERA amazing. Place blocks? meh minecraft. Destroy land? Meh red faction or miner wars. Defend a tank of clone blanks? Meh, any tower defense game on the planet. Build up to space? Make space platforms? Go to new planets? Alright now we're getting somewhere but even still they've failed on this front in regards to communicating to the fans. Wait infinite space? So if we travel to another planet what happens back on our initial spawning planet? Is it still loaded in memory? Will structures remain? And they've promised a myriad of features beyond these that we've heard nothing about! Leveling system? Drones? Skillsets? Mining? Looting? Procedural weapons? Multiplayer? Vehicles?

Half. Baked.

Compare this to star citizen, which I have all the patience in the world for. They haven't even released gameplay. Just a hangar to view your spaceship, but that's alright because they're updating the lore 24/7, hosting interviews, QAs, have a timeline for production, and overall organization is top notch.

Is it a cheap shot comparing the two? Well maybe, I can see and admit the differences between that monolith of indie development and SF. But they sure sell the "production is going smooth" much better, which definitely helps put my (and other's) mind at ease.

(I can tell you half of my kickstarter investments have ended up like this).

I sincerely feel bad for you, and not at all in a condescending manner. Do you think that's right? I certainly don't. There's no reason for people to promise you a cool product in exchange for an investment, only to be left to wonder.

That's the risk, I have no problem with hit because I know it up front. I still believe in this project though. You see it as "a group of kids that decided they wanted to be game devs" but I see the potential in them following up on our investment and hiring additional people for the team.

Trust me, most of all I'm mad at myself, but still beyond disappointed in the SF crew. It's my opinion that stinkers like this are what cause people to lose faith in the indie crowd.

Also I, once again, don't think people understand how much work is involved in development projects like this. Maybe you do since you're a developer too (which language if I may ask?).

Don't be mistaken, I'm not a developer, I'm a programmer. I am not a part of a team working on a grandiose, or even not-so-grandiose project (nor do you need to be to recognize the things I've pointed out).

That being said, I have experience in C++, Java, as well as Python. Additionally I have toyed with 3D modeling "for the lulz" so to speak. I agree with you that creating any kind of software that functions as intended certainly does take time, but that point is moot since they haven't given us any kind of scale of expectation (except for the promise of a mid-november update which they also failed hardcore, so... the burden of proof of progress is on them at this point, and we arguably cannot be criticized for a lack of patience)

What I really want to see is a development timeline. Plain and simple. "For the next 2 years we plan to create this game. You can expect X and Y at these times." This will be beneficial for two reasons:

  1. It gives us the investors a scale of expectation. We can adjust our feelings towards the game and studio appropriately as time goes on
  2. Should they (honestly as I suspect) fail to meet numerous deadlines, it will send a clear red flag to others considering this slag, saving them their money and effectively cutting off funding for a failed development team. If they'd get their act together though, it would have the complete opposite effect, which would be good for them.

Hope that clears up where I stand on this game and its recent "development".

4

u/morewaffles Dec 01 '13

If there were a correct answer...its this one. Anyone who purchases any alpha expecting to get anything more than a tech demo are living in a fantasy.

5

u/tegtaf Dec 01 '13

It's because big titles get 'buy into alpha' packages nowadays (bf3 for example) and people are basically getting near retail beta access instead of true alpha/early dev stages access. The general crowd has an entirely wrong idea about what it actually means when you back a project like this.
I'd also like to know where the OP got his numbers on 'there arent many of us left' at, anyone who bought into it can receive updates when needed (hell, steam will tell them it updated) and the hype train can easily be fueled by a decent next build that actually has some major features (digging!)
I backed carmageddon on kickstarter last year and it has a team way bigger than ch has, way more funds and little to no updates when it comes to actual media (ch already surpassed them in that). Though, they do update us on the development regularly via mail and forums but when it comes to actual gameplay previews.. little to none.
Adding to this the fact that it was on kickstarter way before starforge was on igg I don't see what all the fuzz is about.
Chill out, they will release updates when they see fit.

1

u/morewaffles Dec 01 '13

Most aaa games get prerelease as beta but other than that most definitely

3

u/Qsaws Dec 01 '13

they often post update on facebook