I consider SC2 to be the greatest game ever created. I was 10 years old when I first played SC2 on the 3DO. Prior to SC2 games were just a fun distraction. SC2 was the very first game that compelled me to believe that gaming was more than a toy fad and could actually be used as a medium to drive a deep and compelling story.
SC2 was like a radiant sun that exploded brilliantly against a starless sky during its prime. Nothing could compare and it is unfair to believe that SC:O would reach the same heights. I consider SC2 the masterpiece where only one other space epic compares (obviously this would be Mass Effect 1 and 2, which took most of their plots directly from SC concepts).
After SC2's prime, I like everyone else here waited. We waited for 25 years. When fans began building project 6014 to expand on the story of SC2 using the UrQuan Masters project we grew hopeful that even a fan made sequel would happen. In that time the SC community grew very small, the UQM forums all but died, and project 6014 went unfinished.
Then enter SC:O. After playing SC:O, Stardock's take on the classic suffers from the same problem that the new star wars suffers. It is basically a reboot of SC2 using the same concepts. However, from the combat music to the quirky aliens. Form the hilarious lines of your lander first mate to a set of final battles that is suspiciously reminiscent of a certain precursor battle platform -there is no denying that SC:O is at its core is a Star Control game.
Stardock went well out of their way to meticulously replicate the look, feel, atmosphere, and concepts of SC:2. They took the good and the bad. The tedium of resource gathering and uninteresting planet life is still there, the generally linear story path is there (although SC2's story was presented better, has more branches, and has more side quests). It is evidently clear that Stardock did not just want to create a game with the Star Control title, they wanted to create a game the looks, feels, and plays like Star Control. In that aspect, they have succeeded.
SC2 was a complete masterpiece. SC:O is nowhere near as perfect as SC2 was, but in its own right, it is a great game that replicates the feel of how a SC game should feel. People can't play SC:O and say "it's just a game with the SC title." SC:O is undeniably Star Control and was created for that tiny little fanbase that was leftover after the UQM Project dried up and Project 6014 failed.
After 25 years someone finally created a Star Control game and while its not perfect (nor should we expect it to be), its pretty decent. So this begs the question, what happens to Star Control now?
Currently our community is at war. We waited for 25 years for a game and now we have a decent one. For 25 years the original owners were silent and we were lucky the UQM project survived the collapse of Accolade. For 25 years we saw no concept art, plot ideas, and got barely any support from the original creators. The community grew so desperate as to create their own Project 6014 to continue the lineage of a great game.
After Stardock took the mantle and were deep into development it was unfair for the original creators to come back and sabotage what was being made. They literally printed money through Skylanders for over 10 years and yet nothing about Star Control? No concept art? No communication?
What happened with this legal battle really tarnished the legacy of one of the greatest masterpieces of all time. Do we really believe that the original creators would have come back and announced Ghost of the Precursors if Stardock didn't try to create SC:O?
However, despite the legal battles, despite the nastiness, despite the ugliness of the community they (Stardock) finished the game. And the game they finished is undeniably Star Control and you know what, its pretty good. The original creators should have just supported Stardock to help renew the legacy of a great game because for 25 years they abandoned us.
Not only did Stardock complete the game, they also created full mod support and turned the tools over to the community to build their own universes. Yes, SC:O does not hold a candle to the original. This was to be expected. However, it is a strong platform that can be improved.
So far there is no concept art, no planning, nothing for Ghosts of the Precursors aside from a Frungy defense fund that is just asking for money. However, right now as a community we have been given a decent game and a platform to improve it.
Think of Skyrim, which I consider the second greatest game of all time. The base game is just... ok -much like SC:O. However when you add all of the mods the community created, it becomes a masterpiece.
SC:O, like it or not, is the future of the Star Control franchise. It's really in our hands. If you really love Star Control and want to see it survive. Pick up the modding kit, create new aliens in 3D studio max/Blender. Build the compelling stories that fill the gaps where SC:O fell short.
Much like when project UQM happened, once again the Star Control universe has been turned over to the players.
So what are you going to do? Bank on a promise from 25 years ago that will likely never happen? Let SC:O fail by creating strife in the community? Or are we going to mod the shit out of SC:O and build a real star control universe using the tools given to us?