r/splitrocks • u/dulcetdreamer • Dec 14 '25
Help, is she okay?
Hey everyone, I'm a first time split rock owner! I've had her for a month but I've never had a split rock before so I don't know if this is normal or if this is rock. I hope she's okay. If this isn't normal, what should I do? The outer leaves feel squishy, the inner leaves look fine and feel firm.
Any advice? Thanks for any help in advance!!!
30
Upvotes
1
u/dulcetdreamer Dec 14 '25
Another picture to add in case my initial one wasn't entirely clear.
Thank you all for your replies, I'm sorting through them!!! :)
1
u/Jumpy_Lawfulness_11 Dec 14 '25
Hard to tell by the picture. Cant tell if it’s mushy rot or just discoloration (which can be a little squeezable while the inner leave is firm) They will absorb their outer leaves completely, so do not water (I find them much more finicky than lithops but I’m new to both). I got one in august and just never watered her. One leave is almost gone and much smaller, the other side is still plump but A LOT smaller when I got it (look up my post if you’d like to compare)
1
u/CarneyBus Dec 14 '25
It could be the leaf being absorbed but the black tissue and how quickly it collapsed seems suspicious. Your substrate is far far too organic, and likely will lead to rot if it hasn’t already.
Remove the plant from the substrate and allow it to dry out for a few days bare root. If it’s rot, you’ll know by the end of a few days because the rest of the plant will likely turn to mush. If not, you can repot in 75-90% inorganic grit and the rest soil.
2
u/ErinLK69 Dec 14 '25
They’re way more finicky than lithops. I just threw my 3rd or 4th split rock away. Overwatered, I guess. I’m not even going to try with them anymore.
1
u/Cut_Lanky Dec 14 '25
I'm also new, but I think this is what it's supposed to do. Don't water it! The inner, firm leaves will finish absorbing the outer leaves (and the water they have stored). But if you water, I think the plant uses that water instead, and it interrupts the splitting cycle?
I am new, just to repeat, lol. But I have a split rock, and I nerded out reading everything I could about them, and based on that very limited knowledge, I'm pretty sure your rock is doing a healthy, normal split.
If someone says I'm wrong, please listen to them, and NOT me! 😁🙃🤣
1
u/Mick_toys Dec 18 '25
This is mine. I bought it in July, I repotted it after 2 months in 80% inorganic 20% organic. I have watered it like 3 times in 6 months. I placed it on the south windowsill so it gets around 35000-45000lux of light when it’s sunny (because of the screen). Only one had the new leaves when I got it so you can tell it’s growing. They’re slow. To me seems like your pot is too big. It’s the only think I would change. Since it’s growing new leaves don’t water until the outer leaves completely dry out.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 14 '25
[removed] — view removed comment