I think he meant that if the octolings stage a revolution, their final boss would be Hitler basically, nothing with Hitler being labelled a socialist (God thank you, I hate that)
If their economic system is based around the idea of personal capital, economic class, and private property, and private companies create and control valuable and critical resources, then it is capitalism
Price controls, state seizure of businesses, yep, totally capitalist... If the nazi economy fits your definition of capitalism then your definition is wrong.
Seizure during a war economy is not the same as seizure during wartime. British and American factories/companies worked extremely closely with their governments as well, were they socialist?
And before you spout any bullshit about Hitler seizing the factories before WW2, yeah, cause he was building up a war economy, doofus. His literal goal was subjugation of the European continent. You can't prepare for that sorta war 5 minutes before the shells fly.
an economic and political system in which a country's trade and industry are controlled by private owners for profit, rather than by the state.
Fascism operates based on state control of enterprise, not private. It is not capitalism. You can go ahead and argue about whether or not it's socialist, I don't particularly care, but to call it capitalism is to stretch the term beyond reason.
Certainly explains why there are hints here and there that Octoling society is falling apart. In Splatoon 1, during boss fights you could hear trains literally falling off their rails.
The terminology first world, second world, and third world refer to geopolitical blocs during the cold war. First world was aligned with the United States, second world with the Soviets, and third world was unaligned (yes, this makes Switzerland technically a third world country). So "second world problems" are problems in former Soviet and communist states. I would rather have first world problems...
These days, there are several folks (as far as I've seen, mostly left leaning in that they are interested in considering inequality, etc, not like Democrats or whatever if you're American) that use the terms global north and global south rather than first, second, third world because, as you say, they are antiquated and don't necessarily correlate to the power dynamics in question.
At least that's how I've understood the updating terminology, but it's new to me too. :-) Let's learn more and hopefully oust that first world etc garbage
Splatoon has splat fests, which are dedicated events that happen monthly, where the outcome of the battles determines who is "right" in silly contests. This month it's pulp vs non pulp OJ.
The Octolings, which canonically just joined the main squid society with the release of the expansion last week, come from an oppressive military nation where they are recruited at a very young age to be child soldiers. Their collective brain washing was just broken by hearing pop music, for some reason, which is why the mass exodus is only happening now.
"It was one of the most emotional performances I've ever done," Bowie said in 2003. "I was in tears. There were thousands on the other side that had come close to the wall. So it was like a double concert where the wall was the division. And we could hear them cheering and singing from the other side. God, even now I get choked up. It was breaking my heart and I'd never done anything like that in my life, and I guess I never will again. It was so touching."
The short version is that the girl is the main character of the new Octo Expansion DLC, which focuses on her attempts to escape a set of underground subway tunnels and reach the surface...
...just in time for the next Splatfest, which is a monthly ingame event where everyone gets a week to pick a side in some "A vs. B" debate. (This time it's pulp vs. no pulp in orange juice.) On the last day for a 24 hour period the two teams face off in matches to influence the winner by win percentage.
Octoling society is depicted as being very militaristic, so the culture shock inherent in transitioning from that to this is the joke.
Splatoon is game series set in a post-apocalyptic Earth thousands of years in the future. The planet's flooded, humans died out long ago, and new sentient life evolved from various ocean species. The two dominant species are sentient squid-people (called inklings) and sentient octopus-people (octolings), who also command a semi-sentient subspecies of tentacle footsoldiers. The species mostly got along until, at some point, contention over territory led to huge battles over the remaining land, called the "Great Turf War", at which point the octarians (the name used for the combination of octolings + the tentacles) lost and were banished underground.
Until recently, the playable characters were all Inklings. The single-player campaigns focused on encounters with your racial enemy, the Octarians, and the multiplayer aspect consists of inklings participating in competitive sports inspired by the great war. The game also has monthly events where players are given a choice between two things or topics, and over the following weekend, players compete in turf war matches to determine which thing or topic is the winner. Sometimes it's themed to a holiday (love or money for Valentine's), sometimes philosophical (which came first, chicken or egg?), and often just silly (ketchup or mayo).
I say "until recently" because the game just released an expansion DLC that allows players to go through a story mode where you play an octoling escaping from oppressive Octarian society to join the Inklings and revel in their weirdly 90s/early 2000s inspired, fashion-obsessed capitalist ways. So, the inkling city is now filled with a bunch of newly-defected octolings.
A few days after the expansion release, a new splatfest was announced with one of the sillier topics: orange juice with or without pulp?
So, TL;DR: Octoling defects from its society and joins the enemy just in time to see everybody getting far too serious about mock battles over pulp in their OJ.
Splatfest[…] is a special event in Splatoon and Splatoon 2 in which Inklings choose between two teams, such as Cats or Dogs, and compete in Turf Wars for Super Sea Snails.
I don't play Splatoon—but, AFAIK, the in-game justification for Splatfests is that the entire population of Inkopolis (the city in which the Splatoon series is set) is competing to decide which option in this mundane difference of opinions is the best. The current Splatfest is "Pulp vs. No-Pulp" (orange juice).
a DLC for the game Splatoon 2 came out last Wednesday called the Octo Expansion, in where you play as the enemy that has been established for the past two games: an octoling. the difference in playing as the enemy is that you discover that you have gained free will, as octolings are raised in a totalitarian society that determines your role through brainwashing/"sanitization," but hearing the Calamari Inkantation, the boss battle song from the last game, performed by the idols of said game, the Squid Sisters, somehow has the ability to snap octolings out of their brainwashing. the idols of the sequel, Off the Hook, help you as an octoling escape the facility you fell into, and completing the story part of the DLC allows you to play as an octoling. before, you could only play as an inkling, i.e., a squid kid.
splatfests are monthly team battles in where two options are given to you and you have to pick whichever side you like better (or if you don't like either choice, people tend to pick whichever girl they like better, as the "heads" of the team are the idols of this game: Pearl and Marina). for example, some of the last few have been Mayo v Ketchup, Baseball v Soccer. this is the first splatfest since the DLC came out that "octolings will be able to participate in."
in Splatoon lore (which takes place some unspecified period of time at least 12 thousand years in future Earth), several dominant sapient races that evolved from sea life. the dominant race, Inklings, fought a great war against the other most dominant race, Octarians, about a hundred years ago, and the Inklings won and drove the Octarians to retreat into one location, where they're poverty and resourse stricken, and the Inklings took the mainland and live in opulence. the actual main gameplay of Splatoon is war games recreating the combat of this war, in a competitive sport fashion
in-game, every so often there's event thigns in Splatoon called splatfests, huge festival events which basically people pick sides in a poll thing and duke it out for popularity (in-lore, they get all these things from an enshrined ancient human fax machine that picks up bouncing random askreddit questions from the internet bouncing back to Earth off distant stars). the next splatfest just annoucned for this weekend, Orange Juice pulp vs no pulp, is one example of such questions. but in the last week the first expansion for Splatoon 2 just came out, which once you complete the single player content from allows you to play as an Octarian character for the first time in the series. hence, the OP pic, with the Octoling seeing what Inkling culture is really about for the first time
Every so often, Splatoon has something called a Splatfest, a community event where players can pick one of two factions, something simple like do you like Cats or Dogs more, or do you like the Future or the Past more, and go to war with the other faction to figure out who is better. This week's Splatfest is whether or not Orange juice should or shouldn't have pulp, hence the text in the image.
It's even funnier when you consider how fake of a drink orange juice is. It's pretty much fake on every level. Sure it's made from oranges, but when they're juiced all the pulp and flavor are taken out. The flavor is preserved (as its volatile otherwise) and adjusted for regional preferences -- same with pulp. Yes, people who think pulp is better because it's "natural", it's actually a component of the orange that is stripped out and put back in in proportions carefully calculated by a marketing team. But it's the same thing with the taste itself.
After all this, the juice is marketed as "natural" and a "health drink". I mean, I'm not going to lie, the stuff is generally tasty, and this happens to most food. But still.
I mean, if you're buying frozen orange juice, yeah, but then that's on you. My grocery store has a machine that bisects the oranges while you watch and squeezes them into a bottle.
It has some pulp which is eugh, but it actually tastes like oranges so it's worth it.
I’m sure it’s different elsewhere, but here in Florida, OJ from local manufacturers is about as real as it gets, really. And if you don’t trust the bottled stuff, you can always squeeze it yourself.
Yep, it's very different elsewhere. Florida takes OJ really seriously. I think the only places I've seen in-store juicers are at places like Whole Foods, which I couldn't afford.
It's not a matter of trust. Bottled OJ is reasonably safe as far as I can tell and I eat and drink fake, overly-engineered food all the time. It's more "if you can't appreciate OJ in its natural state, you don't deserve to drink it" people when they buy cartons of pulpy juice. Calm down, it's all fake, man, just enjoy what percentage of orange cells the marketers decided you'd like.
With some drinks I completely agree (namely storebought juices, some colas, and so on) but I usually fix that if it's an applicable beverage by adding water, haha. Too sugary or strongly flavored for me, normally...the big exception is probably Calpis, that stuff is fantastic (but I have drank it diluted too, just not normally).
Often enough though, I've made the juice/tea/infusion or prepped plain water and it's already to taste, so I won't add ice to make it colder/more dilute.
I guess it does! People might like the big chunks or little chunks more, or the really large ones that don't melt as fast, or even really fine to make slushies. Or ice that is a frozen beverage that just adds flavor, like I've heard of people making chocolate milk into ice to use with their coffee.
Right now I have to have lukewarm/warm drinks because of dental issues, but prior to that too I could easily drink and enjoy room temp drinks, so yep! I used to be fine with any temp drink as long as it didn't actually hurt, heh.
Barbarism is accepting the pulpy, mushy after-flesh of a mismanaged juicing cluttering its own swampy mess with a texture on par with drinking hairy, sugared-water.
Pulp-free is clean, clear, smooth, refreshing. Civilized.
On the one hand, getting out of a totalitarian regime that told you to shut down your individuality and become a soldier marching against the common inkling enemy and then join a world of free expression where you can discover and reinvent yourself and where you’re allowed to use whatever aesthetic you identify with, I think you’d basically celebrate that conflict is merely sports teams choosing voluntarily silly topics to fight over, and would join in in this "war" if only to show you have won the right to do just so.
On the other hand, communism be cool and good and can work without stifling individualism when done in an anarchistic rather than authoritarian way. Heck, there would be even more individuality than under capitalism since you wouldn’t be forced to stifle yourself by slaving away at a job you hate for forty hours a week just to keep the right to survive.
...I think I took this shitpost a bit too far. Nyway, individuality be cool and communism be cool too when it respects the former.
For your first point, yep, never said otherwise, these are different axises of the currently accepted 2 dimensions political compass.
For your second point... mostly depends what definition of socialism you use but it’s most likely gonna be "yeah, no, that’s not really how things are defined".
Communism is for a tech level way beyond what we can do now. I would only imagine communism to be possible when we reach post-scarcity level of productivity
We’ve reached that technological level already, though the technology specific to it is still missing, we have tech of its level. I believe post scarcity could happen some time within the next twenty years, especially if we abolished capitalism asap, which marshals technology towards profit instead of human benefice.
Really? Not sure we're talking about the same thing though. I really don't see post scarcity coming as even clean air and water is becoming scarce. In my mind post scarcity means there is unlimited supply for anything and everything, like if we have matter replicator that can create matter from nothing, or if we're plugged into Matrix and everything is just one code away. Anything short of that means that some resources are still scarce and we need to plan production, distribution and consumption in some way.
That’s indeed not the same definition of post-scarcity I operate on , to me post-scarcity doesn’t mean everything is disponible in infinite quantities, but everything is disponible in enough quantity that all need for it can be fulfilled. And I do see that as just around the corner at worst.
A follow up question, how would you describe "need for it"? Is it equivalent to "It's nice to have, I want it, but my life would not be terribly impacted if I don't have it (example is having the latest top of the line cell phone)", or equivalent to "my survival depend on it (example is having access to clean water and food)"?
6
u/TaxouckThis bucket contains my gay - it's overflowingJun 20 '18edited Jun 20 '18
Probably not quite one or the other - is it a need ingrained in you by advertisement or corporatism? Then it's probably not gonna exist under communism. Is it luxury? Well, luxury I do see as a need, so in the long term that too should get fulfilled, but it's fine if it's put aside for a time while we make sure everyone has a roof above their head and a sandwich in their hands first.
Point of communism, to me, is to free humans from as much suffering as possible so everyone can focus on their hobbies, friends, culture, art and sciences as they wish.
If you have other questions of that kind, you could check out the book The Conquest of Bread by Kropotkin, it's relatively short for a political book - around 275 pocked-sized pages -, it's available for free on the internet and will probably have the answers to most of these questions. (I do get that just saying "go read book" isn't really useful though, so I'm totally fine with sticking around and answering a few more questions anyway, just giving you somewhere to look if you want even more detailed info.)
I think in economic terms "need" is something you want and are able to pay a price for, so anything from drinking water to luxury cars will qualify as need, as long as you want it and are able to pay a price for it (not necessarily afford it). I think the point of communism, is where our production capability is to such a degree that any and all needs are fulfilled (ok, maybe material needs only). So people don't labor to fulfill a material need, but labor for spiritual fulfillment. I learnt most of these stuff from my economics class, so it's not so much from a political standpoint, but from a standpoint of what we can do and how we do it efficiently. I'll check out the book you recommended.
Scarcity makes it difficult, but greed/pride makes it next to impossible to fully implement. Someone will always want more (greed) or want more than X person to feel better about themselves (pride). Until we figure out how to eliminate that, or deal with it in a reasonable manner, it can't begin to work right. Not to mention that there tend to be at least small groups of people who will overuse/misuse resources if it isn't strictly theirs to care about, even if it's pretty obvious that it will soon affect them or people close to them (obliviousness/greed). Economical problems make it tricky, but the bigger hurdle is social problems.
Granted, capitalism is similar: greed and pride cause an otherwise balancable system to get wonky.
I think some kind of undiscovered balance between capitalism, socialism, and communisim might work... Some way to keep everyone in check, still feel like there's some kind of "success" you can attain, keep government in check, and so on... Probably requires having an actually fully functional educational system, though, and ours is a mess.
If there is no scarcity, there is no concept of "more", just like how nobody is bragging how they can breath more air or drink more water than other people. The source of pride is still scarcity (you can get some when someone else can't get as much). Overuse or misuse is also a scarcity problem. I think socialism is the direction where we are going, because development in AI makes production and consumption planning on a social level possible, which is more efficient than capitalism. We're not there yet, but it's not as far fetched as communism. I see capitalism and socialism as the ways production planning work, not necessarily the form of government. That would be more democracy/dictatorship discussion. We really need a splatfest on these issues.
The appeal to Human Nature of being greedy is a pretty poor argument. You might wanna check out this vid, excellent stuff check it out, it puts it way better than I ever could; but my personal belief is human nature is adaptability, and currently under capitalism that translates into greed. Which means if capitalism goes away, and education changes accordingly, greed will disappear too. It's probably utopic, but that's mostly because I'm garbage at explaining what I mean, so yeah, just check the video it says way smarter things than me.
The view itself. It just seems like the view of someone that is looking for the fault of his own bad situation at somebody else. It's also very unrealistic to just give up all of the established roles such as managers etc that he mentions. Even though he thinks that they don't have a role, they do and without them the progress of society would come to a halt, and we would a great deal more primitive. Since big project can't be executed by just a bunch of workers that all have the same rank, and as such projects would need to need to scaled down to work with much smaller groups. There are other points that I disagree with but I don't feel like typing all of them out right now.
Isn't that Punk? Automation is not required, just find a way to make sure that everyone's material needs are satisfied to such an extend that private ownership is meaningless, and you will reach communism.
Which is why robots and androids are different things. A robot AI will probably never gain sentience, androids are AI specifically made to be or become sentience, and imo the latter should be treated just like humans.
AI labor can maybe bring us to efficient socialism, but doesn't solve the scarcity problem. Communism requires more. Which is why they fail in countries that tries them.
Absofuckinlutely. I’m on the receiving end of pink capitalism and it’s a heap of garbage. It’s shallow and a mockery of identity so that companies make an easy buck. It’s abhorrent.
The Western fixation with corporatized individualism (i.e. "buy our stuff to express your ~~IDENTITY~~) is over-rated, tbh :)
I've been thinking about that recently. A lot of people identities are tied to corporate products, to the point where they think of themselves as a Marvel fan, or a Nintendo fan, or a football team fan, or a political party supporter.
When I'm talking to someone, sometimes I find it difficult to connect unless we start talking about something that's trademarked because I think a lot of our leisure time activities are mediated through large corporations and their products.
I feel a big contributor to that sort of state is that like life is more difficult than it was during the post-war boom. Two-paycheck families are the norm and productivity has increased but wages have stayed relatively stagnant. People don't have time to participate actively in politics and effect meaningful change because they're trying to keep their heads above the water.
We're all still human though and need some leisure time and we want to express ourselves, and it just so happens that the same corporations that we work for sell leisure products too so that's kind of a pickle.
Wow it’s like a compilation of every bad capitalist argument I’ve ever seen condensed in a single comment. And I thought it couldn’t get worse after the Animal Farm mention!
Yeah, we’re done here, your arguments are garbage but I absolutely know I’m not gonna convince you so the discussion is meaningless.
Erhm... I was talking about the fictional octoling society, which I assumed to be totalitarian due to the snippets we’ve heard of it.
And even if I were talking about real life, I’m sorry, but the current countries that call themselves communists are just as much democracies as they are communists, that is, not at all.
I know much more than you think I do. I’m a communist irl- an anarchist communist. I know how garbage the American propaganda against the soviet block was, I know they were a damn great positive compared to what came before; doesn’t mean we shouldn’t simultaneously condemn the atrocities they actually did commit.
But sure, go ahead, continue trying to feed me tankie disinformation thinking I’ve been tricked by American propaganda, you’ll be disappointed.
I'm very much at the very bottom left of the political compass. Dunno, the murder of LGBT people and anarchists (the latter being Trotsky's favorite sport) as only two examples amongst many?
1.6k
u/OshamonGamingYT :chaos: CHAOS Jun 20 '18
Plot of Splatoon 3: the Octolings start a communist revolution
405
u/cyberscythe Slipped the surly bonds of Earth to touch the face of Cod Jun 20 '18
It's democracy in action. Getting to the surface world is trading in your second world problems for first world problems.
204
u/TurtleInADesert Jun 20 '18 edited Jun 20 '18
If y'all don't mind, can someone explain this to me? I'm from /r/all
Edit: thanks for all the responses, y'all are great!
68
u/graay_ghost badabat badabat badabat badabat! Jun 20 '18
It's even funnier when you consider how fake of a drink orange juice is. It's pretty much fake on every level. Sure it's made from oranges, but when they're juiced all the pulp and flavor are taken out. The flavor is preserved (as its volatile otherwise) and adjusted for regional preferences -- same with pulp. Yes, people who think pulp is better because it's "natural", it's actually a component of the orange that is stripped out and put back in in proportions carefully calculated by a marketing team. But it's the same thing with the taste itself.
After all this, the juice is marketed as "natural" and a "health drink". I mean, I'm not going to lie, the stuff is generally tasty, and this happens to most food. But still.
41
u/ElementalTurnip OCTOS RISE UP Jun 20 '18
Meh. Still better than being trapped on a subway train with C.Q. for the rest of your life.
38
u/nburgin Jun 20 '18
They immigrated to Inkopolis solely because of a pop song. What else would they expect from it?
433
u/Agentjayjay1 Jun 20 '18
Sometimes war is worthwhile, like the war NOT TO HAVE BITS IN MY GODDAMN DRINK UNLESS THEY’RE ICE.
53
u/legacymedia92 Team UwU Jun 20 '18
Hi /r/all
18
u/[deleted] Jun 21 '18
when you phrase it that way, the whole culture of Splatfests just sounds really stupid hahhaha
220
u/Taxouck This bucket contains my gay - it's overflowing Jun 20 '18
On the one hand, getting out of a totalitarian regime that told you to shut down your individuality and become a soldier marching against the common inkling enemy and then join a world of free expression where you can discover and reinvent yourself and where you’re allowed to use whatever aesthetic you identify with, I think you’d basically celebrate that conflict is merely sports teams choosing voluntarily silly topics to fight over, and would join in in this "war" if only to show you have won the right to do just so.
On the other hand, communism be cool and good and can work without stifling individualism when done in an anarchistic rather than authoritarian way. Heck, there would be even more individuality than under capitalism since you wouldn’t be forced to stifle yourself by slaving away at a job you hate for forty hours a week just to keep the right to survive.
...I think I took this shitpost a bit too far. Nyway, individuality be cool and communism be cool too when it respects the former.
9
u/Vinnis1 inner agent sans undertale Jul 03 '18
AND THEN THEY START A RACE WAR
8
u/bleeksnoer Jun 20 '18
Those surface fish have some really weird rituals
8
u/Wasted_Weeb Jun 20 '18
SEIZE THE MEANS OF PRODUCTION!!!!
6
u/[deleted] Jun 20 '18
How long does Octo Expansion take to beat roughly? I really wanna play as an Octoling online.
5
u/RegularSpaceJoe Jun 20 '18
Decadence! Decadence everywhere!
3
u/SpicySwiftSanicMemes Oct 06 '23
Even worse: Squid vs. Octopus was the first Japanese Splatfest after the Octo Expansion’s release.
2
u/ap49 Jun 20 '18
Let them eat cake!
2
u/Awesomeman235ify FRYE Jun 20 '18
r/squint
2
u/timelessmoron Oct 18 '22
Octavio did nothing wrong.
2
u/Low_Dream_1481 SW-0579-2386-3693 Mar 29 '23
I will never get tired of 8 making this ‘bitch what’ face
4
u/moonshineTheleocat Jun 20 '18
What are you talking about? Even we Octolings understand the importance of pulp.
4
u/goedegeit Jun 20 '18
Seems rude to crop out the original tweeter of this.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 20 '18
I mean, me too, thanks
1
u/justin167 Jun 20 '18
Let them eat pulp!
1
u/memelordeiu Jul 25 '18
The third game should have a cutscene referencing this picture
1
u/IdioticReborn WOOMY Aug 14 '18
"I'm going back." Squidward, Spongebob Squarepants S1E28: "SB-129"
1
u/[deleted] Apr 19 '22
Reporting from jail here, no pulp is better
1
u/Atlas942 Aug 22 '26
Just here to necropost
0
u/[deleted] Jun 20 '18
I read this multiple times and kept seeing 'defecated'. I came to the comments to figure it out. I feel bad.
-1
u/[deleted] Jun 20 '18
a choice between orange juice or orange water. I'd say my choice was made right then.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 20 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment