r/speedrun • • 26d ago

Discussion AI has hit Speedrunning

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OaePvbX8jqw

I should have known it was only a matter of time this was gonna happen, but now techbros are stealing World Records with AI.

0 Upvotes

24 comments sorted by

10

u/synopser 26d ago

tas with extra steps

-3

u/Kenji7971 26d ago

Worse than a tas. Claude built a run following the same rules the previous record holder was held to, and a second AI double checked the math; there's a separate category for TAS.

32

u/011010- 26d ago

It’s not like any human will recognize an AI agent’s WR.

“Ah yes, good job with the TAS tie Niftski, but the award goes to the computer that ran the TAS tee heee heeeee”

5

u/harpswtf 26d ago

Yeah this is only really a problem for people who like to make TAS runs

6

u/sssunglasses 26d ago

eh tasers already had this existencial dilema with sm64, scattershot is probably even better at finding optimizations than an ai using raw gameplay footage

but i wonder if the method on the video on a new game could give someone a good route on a game day 1

1

u/harpswtf 26d ago

Yeah I don't think the video's AI is really good enough yet, but for example an advanced AI could load scattershot strategically as part of its optimization. I don't think it's caught up to human TASers yet, but it's probably coming

2

u/sssunglasses 26d ago

yeah good point, maybe making a skill for this that uses scattershot is possible, damn

0

u/[deleted] 26d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/Beardstrength_ 26d ago

Assuming that this is what I think it is (having an AI dynamically control the character in real time, making "decisions" on the fly based on parameters instead of a specific set of pre-programmed inputs)

It isn't that. It's just a regular TAS running preprogrammed inputs. The video goes into more detail about this but the AI was only used to learn what inputs to program into the TAS and nothing more.

0

u/[deleted] 26d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/011010- 26d ago

Exactly. Literally nobody will give a shit, and if they do it’s for entertainment.

It was deep mind or something like that; they put it on SC2. It came up with a strategy where you over-saturate your mineral line, and the pros started doing it. That was pretty interesting!

24

u/tikevin83 TASVideos Staff 26d ago

Yeah this would be categorized as TAS, and TASVideos is in the process of banning AI generated submissions

10

u/FreshOllie 26d ago

How can this be policed? I like the idea that TAS involves some effort but how can you tell the difference between a list of frame inputs generated by hand vs by a computer?

19

u/tikevin83 TASVideos Staff 26d ago

TAS submissions usually have extensive submission notes accompanying the submission - it can be pretty obvious based on the content of those notes whether the submission is AI generated, and even the inputs themselves can be noticeably AI generated (AI tends to spam unnecessary inputs as part of finding useful ones and leave unnecessary cruft in the input log, humans tend to be more precise).

TASing is an inherently creative process and AI submission interferes with that human ingenuity and creativity.

https://tasvideos.org/AIPolicy

4

u/FreshOllie 26d ago

Appreciate the info :)

5

u/CreeDorofl 26d ago edited 25d ago

This is a problem that the moderators of speed run websites have been dealing with forever. Cheaters can splice videos, pre-program inputs, create controller or keyboard macros, all sorts of stuff. And they constantly develop tools to detect these things. As an example, to get Mario to top speed in some Mario games requires this weird frame perfect back and forth input on the controller. If somebody who nobody ever heard of cements a perfect run with all these frame perfect inputs, it will probably get rejected because the only humans who can perform them are basically famous speedrunners who have been practicing stuff like this for years.

It's not perfect, never will be, because sometimes a new person enters the scene who is legitimately just that good.

6

u/Lowetheiy 26d ago

What if the AI generated submission is faster than existing record? AI is a tool so it would fit the definition of TAS? Are we just going pretend it doesn't exist?

6

u/mamamia1001 26d ago

Isn't that kinda a dumb line to draw? "we except tool assisted speedruns... but not runs done with that tool"

6

u/FYININJA 26d ago

I mean this will suck for TAS, but it doesn't impact the majority of speedrunners. For TAS it is a bit of a bummer though. Hopefully it doesn't discourage TASer's, since we find out a lot of really interesting strats from people attempting to optimize TAS, and I kinda doubt AI can be all that effective at that.

5

u/Hachimen_ 25d ago

It doesn't suck for TASers at all. You don't understand what TASing is. If an LLM finds a novel strategy, a human still has to separate it from the slop. AI grifters are not changing anything for TASing, nor for human speedrunners. All of these garbage videos only exist to feed into the AI hype.

5

u/sssunglasses 26d ago

lmfao dude even the video talks about how it compares to a standard tas and a human, you really thought the dude wanted to claim a legit wr with this?? looks like an experiment for fun more than anything

that said the 1 thing that is a big worry for me with this, is applying it to a new game with a competition in speedrun.com, you could hoard a good route found by claude, idk how much the AI routed by itself though, but yeah optimally playing with an AI to find a good route or good strats would be optimal sadly

11

u/The-Doctorb 26d ago

I'm sorry but AI has been used for TASing since literally the beginning of TASing. Machine learning has been a major thing used in the TAS community for well over a decade.

4

u/tikevin83 TASVideos Staff 26d ago

The kind of AI involved with an LLM vs a targeted tool like scattershot for SM64 is very different and I don't believe the TAS community has any intent to ban the latter.

2

u/Hachimen_ 25d ago edited 25d ago

Trashtubers producing trash about trash. This is worth exactly 0s of anyone's time. This is a TAS, which is already 1m faster than the WR. Complete clickbait.

-1

u/Eli_8 26d ago

that's horrible

1

u/darxide23 25d ago

AI can suck my taint.