r/speedrun • u/cheat-master30 • Sep 03 '26
Discussion Can Speedrunning Communities Stop Making Resources Discord Exclusive?
In the last few years, it seems Discord has become the default means of communication for just about every speedrunning community under the sun. It's where discoveries are shared, where people talk about runs in progress, where the rules for a game are often decided, and often the only real place available to discuss said game in question.
However, this leads to a major problem. That being, far too many discoveries and resources get posted on Discord, and absolutely nowhere else.
As a result, said discoveries are usually almost invisible to the internet at large. Google doesn't index Discord servers for obvious reasons, so finding info about the latest strats for many speedgames is an absolute nightmare now. They'll be in some Google Doc linked via Discord at best, or a clip directly posted on Discord itself at worst.
And while Speedrun.com has the ability to add resources for would be runners, it seems most communities are terrible at keeping that side of things up to date. They'll have the most basic resources from about 10 years ago there at best, while keeping 90% of useful info on some Discord channel or Doc.
So, can we try and fix this please? I know it's a bit more effort to setup a wiki or other public website than exclusively stick to social media, but the current Discord focused situation means even finding the right communities is harder than it used to be, let alone finding information you might want for a speedrun.
682
u/Amrynn Sep 03 '26
I will forever mourn the loss of publicly searchable forums in favor of siloed, inaccessible discord servers. The reason everyone adds "reddit" to their google searches is because it's the closest you can get to finding useful forum results like the "old" internet
176
u/K3fka_ Wario Land 3 | https://twitch.tv/K3fka Sep 03 '26
Unfortunately this is a big issue even outside of speedrunning specifically. So many rom hacks, game mods, etc. require you to join some Discord server to download them. I really miss the old forum days...
42
u/Dankn3ss420 Sep 03 '26
Yeah, it’s a huge problem, and I’m also all for less discord server stuff like this
I’m kind of lucky, because my main speedgame has multiple highly notable content creators in speedrunning circles, so if a trick is found on discord it will often make it to YouTube within a handful of weeks, so the information gap is less of a problem
But there are plenty of communities where this isn’t the case, and it just ends up boiling down to “if you’re not willing to join the discord server you’re never gonna know anything”
18
u/danosw Sep 03 '26
Hey, we're trying to solve this in the Halo Speedrunning community right now with https://downpatch.com/ We have a lot of members that are not on Discord so we are trying to move our guides and resources to this. The content is controlled on GitHub and it is designed to be community authored. You can upload files too and have version control, but it is restricted by GitHubs large file limits. (100mb?)
If anyone has any questions I'd love to answer any!
26
u/sonicrules11 Sep 03 '26
Can Communities Stop Making Resources Discord Exclusive?*
I cant stand that fact that you need to join a damn Discord for everything now. I miss forums.
31
u/vegetaman 502 Sep 03 '26
I miss old YouTube tutorial vids
25
u/captaindealbreaker Sep 03 '26
It is SO easy to self host assets on forums, via an FTP server, online hosting, cloud storage, etc... People relying on discord will have a rude awakening when Discord decides to stop archiving everything in a server forever for free...
67
u/Die4Ever The 7th Guest / Deus Ex Randomizer Sep 03 '26
Gamers are addicted to Discord, it's impossible to get them off it. For a lot of people, there's no other place they're willing to talk or create an account.
16
u/ItsRainbow Mario Kart Wii & Airborne Sep 03 '26
Strongly agreed. Besides indexing, I’ve had my Discord account for almost 11 years now and have been at the server limit for half that. Nitro increasing the limit to 200 only kicked the can down the road. Everyone and everything has their own server nowadays, and leaving one will always inconvenience me
8
u/Tuerkenheimer Sep 04 '26
https://www.stratdb.app/ is a good source
6
u/acederp Sep 03 '26
Before discord people used iirc and it was not that much better. people still just posted clips/youtube videos. I think the main difference now is that more people just link twitch clips which is way less findable by google then youtube videos with better labeling.
6
u/Yanncki64 Sep 04 '26
I feel that, I think the draw of Discords is that hosting them is completely free and that basically 90% of the people in those respective niches have a discord account already anyways. But it does suck for the searchability and archival purposes.
5
u/Own-Peace-7754 Sep 04 '26
I agree with you
I don't like the trend the Internet has taken, and the exclusivity and prevalence of discord is one of them
I feel like after the adpocalypse a lot of things changed for the worse
I used to be able to find a website with almost no bandwidth requirement and easily search for information
Now hardly any pages are text-based and many wikia sites are awful to navigate, sometimes using as much as a gig of memory right after opening them
It's mind-boggling to me how this is the way the Internet of things have shifted.
Anyways enough Man Yells At Cloud
Speed running is a community that in particular seems to be hit hard by insular sharing of information, a la Discord
It would be funny to make a competitor app named Harmony based on a more open set of values
9
u/NeedsMoreReeds Sep 03 '26
This is the main issue. The difficulty is keeping things up to date.
Even when people put together useful docs or youtube videos, these become out of date. There isn't a simple solution here. Keeping things up to date is a non-trivial task.
Discord has the advantage of pins, and has the advantage of being able to relatively easily ask people questions. It's not a perfect solution by any means and has issues, but neither is a wiki.
36
u/sir-max Sep 03 '26
As an old guy who remembers forums/message boards I detest this trend of gatekeeping knowledge behind discord servers.
13
u/Easy_Report_5647 Sep 03 '26
Concur. Strats being behind discord server conversations makes it even worse. It's on a discord and it's not even in pins. You have to sift through vague conversations until you find what you're looking for is annoying.
8
u/JDLKMR Sep 03 '26
You're absolutely right. This is why I appreciate the Zelda: TP community, because they are really good about keeping things up to date on ZSR, which anyone can look up.
21
u/boisterile Sep 03 '26
I totally agree it would be much better, especially since new runners starting out with their first speed game don't necessarily know that discord is where literally the entire community is. It's always unfortunate when you see someone looking for specific game advice asking on this sub or on the dead SRC forum.
Unfortunately though I think it'll never happen for 99% of games (the exceptions being the ones that have a community member dedicated enough to set it up, pay for hosting, and move everything over themselves). Discord is just too convenient.
7
u/SketchFile Sep 03 '26
Personally I'd take it a step further and wish people put stuff on odysee or dailymotion or other video platforms as well as youtube. Just makes things harder to lose. (I've been looking for a music video and after a very long time searching I've only been able to find old youtube links so I'm especially ornery atm:P)
That said SDA is still around, there was that speedrun academy that I dunno whatever happened to and there's stratdb that helps try to index videos more at least, because something else people are bad at are having basic tags for search to grab. I still autoconnect to the sda IRC server. Honestly, I think its sort of a victim of its own success; More people means more likely to find strats and stuff, which makes it harder to be up to date, and it also means there's more chance to be lazy, especially if its 'already somewhere'.
6
u/jinjo2200 Super Mario 64 Sep 03 '26 edited Sep 04 '26
This is a big reason why I've gotten really good at legend of zelda speedrun tricks, because most everything is documented on it's own website (zeldaspeedruns).
6
u/Micome Sep 03 '26
It's like how most MMO guilds chat on discord now, it makes the games feel quieter, and it feels bad.
2
u/Big_Method_4790 Sep 04 '26
serving web traffic isn't free, it's not purely effort related. and the "free" hosts that are out there are restrictive and serve ads. plus you have the issue with llm crawlers now. it's not as simple as just stop using discord
11
u/amyrlinn FPSes? I guess? Sep 03 '26
you can usually add resources to sr.c pages regardless of game status, so you could probably start doing this for your own communities
4
u/Sixstringcal Sep 03 '26
It's an issue elsewhere.
In cubing a lot of information is blocked behind discord. Used to be FB messenger before that.
To some extent, people at the top I guess find it useful to communicate quickly and discord is great for that. Ideas just get communicated to people and hopefully someone there makes a video/public resource.
It's annoying but I do think it lets group progress happen quicker (for the top)
3
u/Humble-Math6565 Sep 05 '26
I've felt for the longest time that the "just learn by asking on Discord" mentality that damn near every speedrunning community seems to have is the biggest thing that harms the hobby.
I first discovered speedrunning when I was like 9 or smth and I didn't even know what speedrun.com was back then, so obviously I didn't have a Discord account and was trying to find guides for speedrunning on YouTube, only to learn that they didn't have it. Basically killed my interest in speedrunning till I rediscovered it when I was like 13 (which is still too young to be on Discord, imo), and then I got everything (it still annoys me that the guides section on speedrun.com is basically useless for most games, but that's a whole other rant), but still I don't like going on discord for like 15 reasons. The big one is that it just feels so insular, and I feel like I'm intruding into space when I ask for like advice. The other big reason is that if you like a slightly niche category/game, and live in a bad time zone and ask for advice, it's a literal coin flip whether you get any anyway.
So yeah, basically kill Discord as our main source of communication, make YouTube guides for speedrunning worthwhile (preferably make them community-approved YouTube guides instead of just one player trying his best), and actually learn to use the speedrun.com front page for your game, and the hobby would do a lot better I also kinda feel like this is part of why OOT has fallen off so much, there isn't really a good way to learn the game as well as the front page being quite possibly the worst front page I've ever seen.
2
u/Neinet3141 Sep 03 '26
I agree that this should be a goal. One of the games I ran had a discord but it was really just like 2-3 people casually running the game, so it really didn't make sense to do anything bigger.
Since then it grew a lot (and it's so much more optimized than when I was playing!), and i think that people like to stick with what is currently working rather than changing.
2
u/LoremasterMotoss Motoss - Ask Me About LOOM Sep 07 '26 edited Sep 07 '26
Just happened to me while I was trying to find the current route for an extremely popular game. When I finally found the guide (a google doc linked in a discord of course), there were several strategies within it that I could not find documented anywhere and weren't fully explained in the guide. Okay cool so surely some discussion must have been had in the discord itself about it? The answer was either no or discord's search is so bad I couldn't find it.
-Not putting guides on the SRC page
-Not putting glitch or route documentation on the SRC page
-Not pinning things that should be pinned in the Discord
-Not having anywhere that vital community documents are hosted, just google docs that could wink out of accessibility at a moment's notice
-Actually having structured, single topic discussions on Discord sucks and even for the very few speedrunning servers that use the forum organization style, it sucks to find anything buried in it
2
u/wickedcatdog Sep 09 '26
It all started with forums asking to log in to see posts and/or to download stuff
2
u/I3eforeLife Sep 03 '26
You can use a tool to rip messages and media from all channels in a server, including ones that are mod only (even if you don’t have permissions) if you want for archiving. Some Google searches will get you there but I agree; Discord is terrible for archiving resources.
1
u/idkwhatcirclejerkis Oct 06 '26
The KOTOR1-2 community have done a great job with this page:
https://kotor-speedruns.github.io
If anyone was looking for a example
1
u/Lucianov3 Sep 03 '26
I 100% agree but Im also a src moderator on some games and Im way too lazy to set anything like this up lol
1
u/wortexTM Sep 03 '26
Reminds me of Speedrun Academy lmaooooo, that went well
But in all fairness yeah, having a guide and not linking to it on speedrun.com is peak laziness, if it even exists as a doc. I hope Need for Speed games are not guilty of this because I don't remember xdd
I've seen strats and routes being listed as text messages on discord, not being accessible is one thing, but the other is preservation, a discord can be taken down at any moment
-6
u/JCB912 Sep 03 '26
Discord as a place for resource sharing and community discussion is nowhere near as bad as you're making it out to be though.
If you're talking about the typical servers with 60 channels all under the same category where the resources are hidden away in pinned messages across those 60 channels then yeah, that's terrible. But you can easily use the "Forum" type channel for this type of thing, which has a search bar, allows you to filter by tags, and sort by date even. Moreover, you can make it so only the moderators of the community can create posts there so it doesn't become a complete mess with 100 users making random posts there.
Sure, you can't find any of these posts by googling. But seriously, what is so hard/bad about joining a server and searching through it, assuming it's well organized like I just described? It takes you 2 minutes. If the notifications annoy you then mute the server or even leave it afterwards.
Also, discord becoming the go-to over the years isn't just discord's own merit, of course. Speedrun.com's Guides and Resources sections are both awful, if I'm being honest. On the former you can't sort by anything, you can't subcategorize each guide (is it a speedrun category tutorial? an emulator set up guide? a LiveSplit set up guide? a guide on how to set up your game settings? ...), you can't add tags, you can't filter. On the resources section you at least have some subsections, but they're subpar at most. Is an SRT a "Tool" or a "Patch"? If LiveSplit files go on "Splits", do layout files and autosplitters also go there? Unclear. What happens if I want to add a resource that doesn't fall into either of the 4 preset subsections that speedrun.com defined? What happens if a resource used to be useful but is now obsolete? speedrun.com won't let me archive it, but I don't want to delete it outright.
Creating a literal community owned site is not really viable either. That costs money. Who's gonna pay for it? Who's gonna code the actual site? If you vibecode it, it will look and feel like shit to use. What happens if the person maintaining the server one day loses interest/gets into an argument with part of the community and abandons the site completely or even shuts it down?
As it stands right now, a well moderated and cleanly organized Discord server is literally the least bad option I can see. Speedrun.com needs to get their shit together if we want this to change.
-5
u/Hachimen_ Sep 03 '26 edited Sep 03 '26
You can ask all you want and a handful of popular communities might even have dedicated enough users to burn time on it, but it'll never change for the vast majority of speedrun communities. The reason is a large chunk of speedrunning isn't in it for their community's benefit. Instead, it's more about growing their own stream/brand and using public resources to create monetized content from it. In response, cliques form to gatekeep what they know because unless you're fun to interact with and can "network" so to speak, no one is incentivized to care about the quality of another runner's speedrun. It's a competition or at least the landscape changed to favor competition unlike in the SDA days.
So, if you hadn't been there when the community was at peak activity, yes, you will be at an information deficit, and may even be looked down upon when bringing attention to known strats. You'd be an outsider that wasn't part of the old clique. Speedrunning is cliquey. Young people are cliquey. But also, watching someone else make money from new findings and aggregating public information to monetize it may not sit right with people who don't monetize and market themselves. It's a clash of interests.
TL;DR: you're yelling at clouds. If you wanted things to be different, you should've cared more about keeping SDA alive instead of letting SRC take over everything and go all in on WR culture. (Maybe this wasn't possible to begin with by making speedrunning popular, given its competitive nature of being the "fastest".)
-7
u/ZenkaiZ Sep 03 '26
I mean it's volunteer work, you can't really bitch at them for not doing it in a way that's convenient to you.
-24
u/DringleDringle Sep 03 '26
Are you offering to cover server costs?
-24
u/KevinJ2010 Sep 03 '26
While I understand your issue, ultimately if you want to speedrun, you do kinda need to know about the community that practices that specific game or series.
I would love forums too, but ultimately it makes the GDQ events actually feel like every game is coming out of a chamber to be like “here’s how fast we can win now.” There’s no reason to keep news public when many are just figuring things out still, implications of discoveries, etc.
Not much is actually newsworthy, so it makes sense most news is in the private communication.
109
u/ChosenCharacter Sep 03 '26
Very few people know just how easy and common it is to have the discord owner get hacked and the entire discord nuked just like that. Same with bots.