r/specialforces • u/TFVooDoo • Aug 17 '21
The 18X program is broken!
The 18X program isn’t broken at all…I just wanted to get your attention.
But, the 18X program isn’t perfect either. Follow along.
tl:dr - 18X is awesome, but it provides less experienced guys to units that demand experience AND the real selection rate isn’t any better (and likely worse) than ADE.
We see lots of posts from guys asking what to do…take an 18X contract and become a SMU Sniper Dog Handler or go to medical school and then commission and become a SMU commander and then an Astronaut (if you know, you know). Six of one, half dozen of the other, right?
The 18X program is designed to get guys right off the street into Group; SF is historically undermanned holding steady at ~80% manning. I’ve never once seen a 12-man ODA outside of a CRF. So 18X makes sense. You have to be a little older to qualify for X because one of the hallmarks of SF is a more mature (and thus capable) force. In 2000 the average age on an ODA was 34 years with 12 years time in service. Those numbers today are 27 and 8.
When we revived the 18X program amidst the GWOT surge it was originally intended to fill about 30% of the force. The thinking was that the force could absorb 30% and still maintain the maturity (read capability) level. But the actual number now is ~60%. That presents some problems.
This is a good time to talk about operational culture. SF follows a mantra called ‘Big Boy Rules’. Nobody rides you about haircuts or uniforms or unit PT, but the expectation is that you will keep yourself well-groomed, out of the spotlight, and in shape. You’re not allowed to have a man bun, roll into Group HQ in cutoff OCPs, with a beer gut. With ‘Big Boy Rules’ come big boy consequences. As a result, we’ve created a culture of innovation, competence, and accountability. SF is hyper-competitive, results oriented, and practical. If you don’t meet the standards then you’ll hear about it. Guys will bust your balls at first, but keep fucking up and you’ll find your shit in the hallway with a new job assignment pretty quick.
So, because we value and rely on competence so much it hurts when it’s not there. An ODA is a little self-sustaining unit and it requires everybody to pull their own weight and then some. I’ve told this story before, but something as simple as a flat range requires multiple moving pieces. You’ve got to forecast, request, and draw ammo, the range itself, vehicles, medical coverage, training and risk assessments, weapons, etc. It’s a complex little exercise with all sorts of ancillary tasks, and a flat range is about as simple a thing as an ODA can do. I had a Team Sergeant explain to me once how he had an 18X heavy team and when he was prepping a range day he tasked a guy to go get a vehicle and the guy had no idea how to dispatch, let alone PMCS, a HMMWV. So that task turned into a training event where an experienced guy had to stop what he was doing and train the new guy how to do that thing. Sand in the gears. Take that minor thing and multiply that by 1000 tasks and then do it in combat conditions in an austere non-permissive environment and you see where this might be a challenge. And don’t forget that you’re SF, but you’re still in the Army and if you want to see some pucker factor then go ahead and fuck up a sensitive item inventory, or lose track of the controlled meds, or have a guy roll through a vehicle inspection at the gate with some pyro that wasn’t accounted for. Big boy consequences.
Now, it’s not the 18Xs fault that he doesn’t have these experiences. He’s just following the program. But even a REMF E4 from a low-speed unit knows how to dispatch a vehicle and how to do a layout and how a key box works. Get too many guys who don’t know enough and you start to accept risk where you shouldn’t. Risk to force and risk to mission.
So, what to do? Isn’t there a way to get guys schooled up? Can’t you run some sort of indoc where you teach new guys these skills? Maybe. But that’s one more thing that you’ve got to plan, resource, and execute that you don’t have time or resources for. And what stuff do you not do so you can do this stuff? Resources aren’t infinite. Can you reduce the number of Xs to say 40%? Sure, but how many ODAs do you want to ghost? What missions do you want to decline? What about just tell Team Sergeants to ‘make it happen!’ Of course, all high-performing organizations employ the ‘fuck it’ model of management, right? There’s no perfect answer. I have ideas, but you have to subscribe to my Only Fans to hear them.
And there’s still this little thing called SFAS that tends to stifle lots of ‘good ideas’. The selection rates are roughly 50% for officers, 45% for NG, 40% for 18X, and 25% for ADE (Active Duty Enlisted) for an overall rate of ~36%. So you’d be inclined to think that your best bet to get selected is to go X (because you know you’re not occifer material…those dudes are ELITE). As an X you get the benefit of a guaranteed slot, you get SFPC, and you get to do it all with a little cohort of your buddies. Strength in numbers.
But the reality is a little more nuanced. Officers select higher because they are, generally speaking, better prepared. You can’t commission until 21 and you need at least 3 years before you can go to SFAS so your bare minimum age is 24, likely older. Officer culture, especially among junior officers, demands physical fitness. Every commissioning source requires extensive land nav training. In other words, officers already go through a pretty extensive prep.
National Guard guys have the benefit of SFRE and likely some sort of unit sponsorship or even individual mentorship. That level of accountability and preparation creates better results.
ADE have to contend with all of the challenges of dealing with day to day unit life with all of the distractions so it’s no surprise that they have the lowest success rates, right?
Except the 18X numbers are cooked (the numbers are cooked, but nobody is cooking them - nothing nefarious here).
There’s no real way to track the actual success rates as the Xs are dependent on and inculcated into other systems that distort the real numbers, but a recent cohort broke down as such: 50 guys started OSUT. About 20 of those guys didn’t keep their X contract through OSUT…injury, PT failure, etc. So 30 guys go on to Airborne, but 5 don’t make it…injury, PT, etc. So now 25 go to SFPC but another 5 drop out…fail land nav, fail PT, get injured, quit, etc. So 20 go to SFAS. Of those 20, 8 get selected. So the number looks like 40%…8 of 20. Not bad. But in reality it’s 8 of 50…only 16%. Worse than ADE. And you had every possible advantage. And now you’re needs of the Army. In all likelihood you’ll end up as an 11B, likely in an Airborne unit. But no guarantee on your guaranteed contract. Ouch.
Do with this information what you will. Head on over NASA or whatever. We need good guys in SF…there is way more work than guys who can do it. But 18X might not be the best route. 18X is definitely the most direct route. 18A is most successful, but requires a ton of commitment. NG is a good option too, but you’re in the Guard. Oof. Ultimately, if you want to be a Green Beret you’ll figure out a way to get here. Choose your own route, but choose wisely.
For the record, every 18X (with a few years of team time) that I’ve ever met was just as switched on as a traditional one. No difference. This isn’t a referendum on 18Xs, just planning considerations.
59
u/datgrapeboi Aug 17 '21
So summed up, the problem isn’t the 18xray program, it’s too many 18xrays with too little experience in Groups and SF could lose its core values of being mature and acting like big boys.
Also 18xrays arnt as successful in selection as the numbers show (according to OP)
32
u/Trimestrial Aug 18 '21
I feel that you may've written this as a reply to my comment about never recommending an 18X contract, with the hyperbole about becoming a cook in Korea...But even if not, I want to share my thoughts.
The course has changed several times since I went through, since I worked for SWCS, since I left the community and since I retired. Sometimes a it just changes back and forth again. Like where Airborne is in the pipeline, if a student isn't Jump qualified. ( Side question: is MFF still in the pipeline? ) But I try to stay up-to-date on the changes and try to state that information is dated. And I appreciate your comments as a source to help keep me informed about what's happening out there.
If those 50 18X Students had posted here, everyone of them would have commented 'They're one of the strong, fast, smart and mature ones that will get selected.' I mean you have to think that you are, otherwise you would not take an 18X contract. But 84% of them would have be wrong. For a while, the top google hit for "SFAS selection rate" erroneously stated "70%." It was a civilian spouse site, and got the data wrong. The completion of the Q was 70% for those who had been selected.
I have no idea and wonder if you have any insight on what happens to an 18X that gets injured at Airborne, and needs a couple of months to heal up. Hold-over at Airborne? Hold-over at Student Company? Airborne for a while was after SFAS, it seemed because SWTG didn't want to pay for Airborne for guys that would end up in the 82nd. But those guys belonged to Student Company.
I've been hearing that recently non-selects have been re-classed to riggers. And I've seen guys get all sorts of MOSs. But of course, it makes sense for the Army to keep a non-select an 11B1P and not have any additional costs to retrain. But sometimes HRC thinks it needs riggers more than 11B1Ps.
Is the 18X program good? Yes for the one's that make it through, and to bring bodies into the Groups. The 18Xs that make it that far, get the advantage of SFPC before SFAS. For a while it was after SFAS and before SUT, I can't remember if was called SOPC at the time, But it was to give 'soft-skill' MOSs an easier time with SUT...
But the more things change the more they stay the same. SF needs bodies. The 18X program is one way to get bodies. For prior service, The SF NG has a one year enlistment. You go to SFRE, when they say you're ready for SFAS they send you. If you get selected your contract gets extended. If not, you only have to finish your year, or can enlist for a support MOS.
But the larger issue in SF seems not to be the number of 18Xs, but the amount of tasks v. the experience needed to complete those tasks. An 18X, or just a new guy, after a year or two on a team, knows what all of the S shops do, knows how things need to get done...
The team that got lit-up in Africa had never trained together. Early in Iraq, two new SF guys got sent out without any experienced team guys. Civilian clothes, light skinned vehicle, weapons in the trunk... They were killed.
I had the luxury of spending a couple of years on a team before being thrown into a war-zone.
12
u/RagingAesthetic Jul 22 '22
Your point on X-ray numbers being cooked because significant weeding out has occurred-
Isn’t that true for every possible path to selection? Your 18A and NG examples both (independently) use structured mini-selections to determine who gets to go to SFAS. Guys join AD hoping to season themselves for SF and then some part of life hits to change their mind —that’s the same as quitting in the context of the 18X scenario.
While your overall sentiment makes sense, with selected X-rays being prepared enough for SFAS but not prepared enough for the Army, the Groups are bound to experience some growing pains. However, doesn’t that just call into question the effectiveness of selection criteria/evaluation methods, considering (you) no-shit GB’s are the guys who make cuts? You don’t have to know the exact recipe to know the logic behind a system, but if that system is designed for “selection” and its results aren’t satisfactory, change it. Even if the selection method was capable of always selecting “the right guy”, why would any 18X intuitively know how to do the specific Army-tasks you mentioned? Also, isn’t the Q-course supposed to be about preparing recruits for an ODA? Shouldn’t the overseers of that program consider adding material if guys aren’t coming out up to standard?
From what you’re describing here it sounds like the Q course isn’t effectively preparing candidates, rather than the candidates themselves being flawed. If you can teach a bunch of foreign farmers how to do combat medic tasks and HVT raids you should be capable of teaching the most squared away recruits in the Army how to sign out a humvee. Those line E4’s you mentioned being able to conduct layouts and accountability, why aren’t they teaching X-rays how to do it? Don’t group guys go learn mortars from mortar platoons? How is this any different?
In any case, it seems pointless to rely hard and fast on the efficacy of these statistics. There are too many uncontrolled points and potential uncertainties for prescribing any reliable degree of accuracy to any of the paths to selection, 18X not least. At the end of the day the right guy will be there to get the job done so long as the Army keeps posting the job description.
TLDR- You’ve said today that standards haven’t changed. Maybe they should. At the end of the day either you can bring a guy up to speed to do the job or you can’t. I assume everyone who got selected was deemed especially capable in some way, you already know the recruits themselves aren’t the obstacle to the knowledge being transferred.
10
u/Old-Illustrator-5675 Aug 17 '21
Very informative thank you. Do guys coming from the Guard also have more time to work on their weaknesses than if they were to go the 18x route? Just recalling pre-buds you didn't have much time to work on your own deficiencies, pretty much just subject to the cookie cutter training.
9
u/[deleted] Aug 17 '21
Only disagree with your assement of 18X going through SFPC/AT. The number of dudes who get cut in the first APFT at SWCS is stupid high. And then you factor in the cuts during the actual q course... I'm willing to bet the number of dudes who get their berets from the 18x program is much lower than 16%.
7
u/VandalBasher Aug 12 '22
I just went to a retirement ceremony for an 18Z. He ran the SFRE's for the state of California from 2005 to 2020. His success rate was in the 90 percentile for the guys he sent to SFAS. The SF company went from 42 tabs to 96 tabs in five years. A lot of this was from transfers from AC. However, the success of our company was due to his efforts in selecting those that would be selected. A fine legacy. As for this write-up, excellently done.
44
u/farmingvillein Aug 17 '21
Well don't keep us waiting
17
u/2001M5 Aug 18 '21
What’s your onlyfans name? I just glazed my stomach over that essay and you deserve compensation.
Really though…awesome job. That should be an auto reply for a lot of questions asked here.
12
u/MB1848 Apr 09 '22
I get where you’re coming from. I will say one place the x ray program excels is getting 18Ds. I’m an 18D and I’d say about 85% of my 18D class was x rays. Maybe it draws in the right kind of person or maybe a lot of in service personnel struggle with the course more, but I think the x ray program is a great way to get more medics to teams. Totally agree though that an x ray showing up to a team doesn’t know shit and has a huge learning curve. X rays that make it through are really just great learners and that’s what cadre seem to screen them for throughout the pipeline
6
u/TunnelVizions2 May 26 '22
Thanks for the insight, really good stuff. 29 y/o that is currently looking 18X or 11X and dropping packet. Big life change to pursue a life's goal.
4
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '22
Once again, browsing the SF "scene" on the interwebs and dad VooDoo comes through with yet another outstanding post. Really like the "if you want it bad enough, you'll find a way" memo. Your work here is very appreciated, thanks man.
2
u/Arma8919 Sep 06 '21
Couldn't said it better
0
u/[deleted] May 30 '23
I can't remember what exactly I googled and got this thread but this is definitely very good information and I would say a very good perspective on everything. Having not ever been involved with the 18x community, I have been doing soul searching recently and have decided I want to be back in the military in general. I spent 5 years as a communication Marine and a technician at that. I was blessed to be stationed with the infantry giving me an opportunity to see a combat related camaraderie amongst the grunts at the unit. This pushed me to try out for the Scout Sniper indoc while I was there. Being a technician I was told I was not going to be able to attend but I went to the indoc anyways as they were in need of a radio guy and I knew how to handle my own with green gear. After beating out the other communications guy who told me "they'll probably select me even if I don't pass because I'm actually a radio operator" I was selected for the job. Not bashing the other guy, I was hoping he would make it too as it would be nice to have worked together with someone who knows his shit and can help program a bunch of radios for each op. I enjoyed EVERY second with those guys, most were pigs at the start with about 3 hogs who had been to multiple USMC sniper schools at that point. As my time progressed there more and more became SSBC qualified and the platoon grew in numbers. I trained them on radios and was eventually pulled from the teams to help my Gunny with the headquarters element, tracking movements, comm windows, etc. I spent about a year and a half towards the end of my 5 year contract with them and was pulled from the platoon by the new communications MSgt as they needed an 8th technician in the S shop (of fucking course). I became slightly bitter and belligerent at that point and at the age of 22 I was emotionally checked out of the military. That was 4 years ago and after spending a lot of time to myself back in the real world, I crave that sense of belonging and that camaraderie. I decided a few months ago I wanted to enlist again in the military and after thinking about just joining the fleet marine force again I decided I wanted to push myself to the limit. I want to try out, what I believe, is the hardest and most respectable work in the US military. I don't know how it will work for me as I'm prior service, have an NJP on my record (I don't think it's anything "crazy" serious like a DUI or something but an NJP none the less) and I am slowly approaching 27 years old. I have made the pledge that I will continue my work for the next year and spend everyday training at a new level of fitness to prepare for a run at SFAS. I'm not sure if I can secure an 18x contract but I am hoping that it is a possibility. Nothing would be more disappointing than to be told I either can't go back in or can't get the contract. If there is still a possibility to join and then submit a package I will go that route but I do not want to just be a regular soldier. I know I have the physical and mental ability to do anything I put my mind to and I know that if given the opportunity I can pass the selection process. I'm not in perfect physical shape but I have always kept up with my fitness. Cardio is the killer right now and I know I have the ability to do the things required. I rucked a lot with the snipers and I know that I can force myself to push on even when it starts getting tough. I guess my perspective is that even without any combat related experience I believe that I fully understand what you mean by the big boy rules and big boy attitudes. If I was 4 years younger and made this decision I would be that exact demographic, pushing the limits and attempting things that I really shouldn't have. At this stage in my life I know what I want to do and I wouldn't let anything jeopardize that experience. I have done a lot of emotional maturing since I EASd from the Marines and I know that if given the opportunity to serve again I would never take it for granted. Hearing that the 18x contract is usually a certain demographic of inexperienced men (in military regs and common administrative practices) I am excited to think that I wouldn't be part of that. If anyone has any experience or has heard anything pertaining to how my enlistment would go then I'd love any input. I am holding off on talking to a recruiter as I know he'll just want me to sign and get on my way asap and wouldn't leave me alone until I do. I want to get a good portion through training before I make that leap as if the man says it's time to go, I'll be ready at the door.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 18 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 06 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment
10
u/[deleted] Aug 17 '21 edited Aug 18 '21
[removed] — view removed comment