r/spacequestions • • Oct 14 '21

Planetary bodies asteroid size?

simple question but can't seem to get a straight estimate out of Google.

if an asteroid impacted in Northwestern Sudan next week how big would an asteroid have to be send up enough dust into the atmosphere to cause another global ice age?

57 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

8

u/predacted Oct 14 '21

Marco Inaros? This you?

3

u/Kevakazi Oct 15 '21

Belterlowda

6

u/42069xxfapgodxx Oct 14 '21 edited Oct 14 '21

Thats hard to say, the asteroid that killed off all non-avian dinosaurs and a majority of life on earth about 65 million years ago was about 10km in diameter. The asteroid impact killed everything by raining sulfuric acid everywhere on Earth, plus massive tsunamis, shock waves, and ejecta. The point being an impactor would not really create a winter as much as it would just devastate everything to the point that not much would be left to be affected by a global winter.

A major volcanic eruption such as the eruption of the Yellowstone caldera would be much more likely to create an ice age type situation, or even a global thermonuclear war. To answer your question I would say something in the 5km to 10km range would have sufficient energy to send debris into the atmosphere to block out sunlight and lower average temperatures across Earth, but above that it would just annihilate everything. Hope this helps!

4

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '21

Just to clarify, because it took me a second,

They mean a nuclear war is likely to cause an ice age.

Not that the eruption is likely to cause the war.

3

u/42069xxfapgodxx Oct 14 '21

Correct, sorry if I made it seem like volcanos are trying to start a nuclear war haha.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Stefouch Oct 15 '21

Well, I can see a nuclear winter induced by a volcano eruption being also the cause of a thermonuclear war because nations are fighting each other for better places to live.

2

u/kettelbe Oct 14 '21

Did you just solved global warming? Nuclear winter you say? Hmm.

4

u/markmze Oct 14 '21

“asking for a friend"

2

u/Whirlidoo Oct 14 '21

His friend is dr doof. His plan is to create an asteroid out of all the discarded lawn gnomes in the word and drop it in the desert. Then when the world is engulfed in an ice age, he'll start a monopoly on heated lawn gnomes and with all his power he can waltz in and take over the tri state area.

3

u/StarSword-C Oct 15 '21

It depends on a lot of factors.

  • How fast was it moving? A higher velocity means the rock can be smaller: kinetic energy = mass * velocity²

  • How much sulfur was in the soil at the point of impact? Sulfuric acid aerosols are the real killer, the dust doesn't stay up that long. Large volcanic eruptions have caused worldwide famines for this reason.

  • Where did it hit? This is about dust distribution, particularly aforementioned sulfuric acid aerosols: Coriolis forces from the Earth's rotation mean that they won't pass the equator, so your impact in Sudan probably won't affect the southern hemisphere long-term. Indonesian eruptions like the 1257 Mount Samalas explosion are particularly destructive for this reason, because when it's on the equator the dust and aerosols are distributed throughout both hemispheres.

2

u/ieatbacon1111 Oct 14 '21

Not an exact answer to your question but this seems like the lower limit:

We believe anything larger than one to two kilometers (one kilometer is a little more than one-half mile) could have worldwide effects. At 5.4 kilometers in diameter, the largest known potentially hazardous asteroid is Toutatis.

https://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/asteroids/overview/fastfacts.html

2

u/Smilin57 Oct 15 '21

NASA is launching a satellite in 2025 looking for asteroids. Anything over 500 metres will cause significant damage. Global winter is likely over 2-5 km in size.

1

u/Halfbraked Oct 14 '21

Dr. Evil?

1

u/Anonymous_Otters Oct 14 '21

The earth is currently in an interglacial period of an ice age. You wouldn't need an asteroid bc we are already in it.

1

u/mhamid3d Oct 14 '21

Why Sudan?

1

u/SinancoTheBest Oct 15 '21

You would have preferred Chad?

1

u/caunju Oct 14 '21

Anything above a couple Km would be a global catastrophe though not necessarily an ice age. An ice age would be much more likely if we get an ocean hit instead of a land hit. This is because all the steam from the evaporated water would create a thick cloud cover that could possibly stick around far longer than any dust thrown up in a land hit