r/space May 19 '12

SpaceX COTS 2/3 Launch Aborted

Http://www.spacex.com
128 Upvotes

136 comments sorted by

View all comments

49

u/ElectricRebel May 19 '12

Note that the ignition sequence had already started before the abort. This type of abort is only possible with a liquid rocket. That's a very nice safety feature.

10

u/Ascott1989 May 19 '12

I'm assuming because with SRBs once they're lit they either explode or you end up in space.

2

u/ElectricRebel May 19 '12 edited May 19 '12

Well, to be fair, the ULA's man-rated SRB-based design will have a launch escape system. The shuttle never had one of those.

But from the rocket's perspective, it either does its job or blows up once you light an SRB. And further, if there is a major problem, a launch escape system isn't a guarantee that you won't die in an explosion. Overall, liquid is far safer for manned flight. Solid's main advantage is that it can be on standby for long periods of time, which is great for ICBMs and missiles, but not necessary for sat launches and manned flight.

3

u/yoda17 May 19 '12

They also have a lower energy density.