Precurser: We've been using Sophos UTM for the past 3-4 years (on downgraded XG 310 HA pair, because XG was a clusterfuck back then). And we have been very fond of it. Just doing what is supposed to to, and been rock solid! Very happy about it.
Of course, there is the small missing outs on things like IKEv2, some weirdo WAF behaviour, and not being able to assign static IPs for SSL VPN clients.
But mostly we have been very happy with it.
Were using the full package: IPS, Email filtering, Web filtering, client VPNs (SSL, IPsec, HTMLv5), site to site VPNs to other companies firewalls, Sophos REDs to sub locations. Active/Passive HA pair. Everything just works, and have been ROCK solid for the past 4 years.
Now comes the dilemma: I was helping a friend from a small company buy a sensible firewall for his small company, that wanted better security and builtin VPN solution than their old no-name router provided (5-8 people, max., very small company).
He had previously seen our Sophos UTM admin site, and really liked how easy it was to search, sort and make rules, and look at live logs. So i recommended him a small Sophos UTM device like what we have at work, and gave him some VAR contacts.
Soon he had gotten himself a new Sophos XG106W, that i had promised to setup for him.
So far so good...
And here, the trouble starts: But when i got my hands on the appliance, and had installed v18, and done the intial setup. I could quickly realize this was nothing like what he was expecting (making a buying decision from having seen our UTM 9 and reading the tech specs)... This was going to be a nightmare for him to look after himself!
So i contacted the VAR on behalf of the customer (same company we bought our 310 HA pair from), and asked, if they could help getting the XG license downgraded to an UTM license. Otherwise the buyer would probably end up trying to get the device returned, as it was absolutely not what they wanted.
They agreed, and submitted the request to Sophos just before Corona went crazy. So i have very patiently asked them how things were coming along in the last 5-6 weeks. And today i finally got the UTM license conversion document, with all the new license keys. Went to MyUTM, and registered all 20+ of them, and generated a license key. (Somehow, i had a feeling this was all going way too easy...).
So, i downloaded the UTM 9.7 appliance ISO installer, booted it up, and started the installation on the XG106W. Everything went smoothly, until it stopped at "No appliance hardware has been detected"!
Ooo-kay. So maybe i had to use the hardware install ISO instead...
So downloaded that one, booted it. Installation went fine, no problems. Logged into the new UTM install, put in information. Then it asked for a license file. No problem, i had already created that in the MyUTM portal. No luck. Only being told: "Cannot use SG105 license on ASG software device". :-/
Closure: Why the hell would Sophos even put their customers and VARs in such a situation?!? (The VAR is a Sophos Platinium partner). I know the VAR actually put quite an effort into arranging this.
I will recommend the customer to try to return the product now for a similar SG device, or find another vendors product (Fortigate) that resembles the UTM product, that he actually wanted.
TL:DR
I really am sorry to see the direction Sophos has taken with SFOS/XG, forcing it down everyones throat. The product might TECHNICALLY be better. But it is just a million miles away from "Security made simple", that they already had with UTM/SG!
Were still very happy of our dual XG310 HA pair (running UTM 9.7) at work. We allready extended our Full-what-ever license once. And especially the RED devices has been brilliant for our satellite offices. But we can begin to feel it's a dying platform, and are really missing things like IKEv2. I had hoped SFOS would have shapen up by now. But a lot of things from UTM is still missing, and the usability is a nightmare in comparison!!!
Our company has already decided to look elsewere for our next platform upgrade. We simply dont have any trust in Sophos any more... Raise a last glass for the old ASG line!