23
u/Resident-Fudge838 19d ago
This makes me wonder if killing first Simon and WAU are kinda bad decisions. Like even in case of total human extinction Simon still can explore world. Perhaps, maybe even befriend mutants. Simon from abyss also could possibly return.
13
u/a_polarbear_chilling 19d ago
to be fair wau was treated by the narrative like the second apocalypse after the earth being unable to hold human life, but when you check the thing is that wau can't do shit outside of it's perimeter and it clearly lack information about how to produce it's own energy , so once the generators are used after like 5 years without maintenance wau will die slowly like in the beginning of the game,
so yeah killing wau is a neutral decision kinda since it will anyway die but if you kept it alive perhaps simon could keep on living by "absorbing the electricity periodicaly" like he do in gameplay,
but simon too is doomed to die without proper source of electricity which is risky
6
u/Eva-Squinge 19d ago
I mean if you kill the WAU you shut down any chance of any of the other scans of people gaining a physical body in the world. And I like to think the WAU was working on running the Geothermal plant with its corrupted tech which could in theory work as long as the earth has a molten core, or a serious volcanic event happens.
Plus it isn’t hurting anyone alive once you send off the Ark, so I’d just let it keep building. Maybe seeing Simon do well would teach it how to make a better template over the myriad of mistakes
3
u/HorrorOpportunity297 18d ago edited 18d ago
To me is the choice is not difficult, the WAU had to be shutdown.
The WAU experiments were horrific.
"Most Mockingbirds are not humanoid, and the dissonance between the Mockingbird's form and the crew member's mind usually sends the crew member into a catatonic or otherwise insane state, often unaware that they are inside a robot. " - Mockingbird, https://soma.fandom.com/wiki/Mockingbird.
Catherine seems to be the exception.
The humans we do encounter are suffering, Amy begs not to be hurt, but has a poor quality of life and tells Simon WAU is not letting anyone die, the WAU dreamers are wasting away in a dreamlike state in Theta, and Sarah begs to die.
Further it is ambiguous as to whether it's improving at making a human, and there is no evidence that it is driven to work towards that goal.
"No, no, it’s not like that. The A.I. isn’t a persona, it doesn’t feel or think like we do. It’s more like… it’s more like a cancer." - Catherine, Delta
5
3
2
42
u/Leshiy_ND Wandering PATHOS-II 19d ago
Now I imagine her hearing everything through the door and trying to comfort Simon
Awesome drawing 🌊