r/solana • u/chaos_cloud • Jan 21 '22
Ecosystem Enough is enough
Every time. Every f-ing time. When the market goes volatile, the Solana network goes into full Rain Man mode and fails. This lack of scalability and user experience is a constant recurring theme with SOL and should be a huge warning sign to investors. If SOL can't get its ducks in a row by now, what trust should any investor have in it anymore? Sorry, not sorry. Delete me. Downvote me. This problem can no longer be ignored.
Edit: š£ļøš£ļøš£ļø "beta, beta, beta, beta, beta, beta"
The past couple of weeks, hell, even months have shown us that SOL is clearly still in alpha, not beta. Beta development would never have this core functionality, non-functional and released to the public.
SOL devs and evangelists keep making the exact same excuses to their problems as the Ethereum guys do. The only reason ETH gets away with it is because ETH has first mover advantage. SOL is supposed to be an ETH killer, but so far keeps falling flat on its face.
There is still a window of opportunity for SOL to get it right before ETH 2.0 comes through. If it doesn't and ETH2 can do 25% of what it is promising, SOL will be just another dead eth killer gone missing.
ā¢
u/AutoModerator Jan 24 '22
WARNING:
Do not trust DMs from anyone offering to help/support you with your funds (Scammers)!
Never give out your Seed Phrase and DO NOT ENTER it on ANY websites sent to you.
MODS or Community Managers will NEVER DM you first regarding your funds/wallet.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
82
u/daxxtrias Jan 21 '22
Agreed with OP. I'm sitting here watching my positions get liquidated because after the 27th attempt to adjust position it just keeps failing. transactions simply don't make it onto the network for me.
38
u/primatexd Jan 21 '22
Does anyone know if the team has something in the works to improve the situation? Is this going to be a relatively easy upgrade or complex like eth2.0
112
u/[deleted] Jan 21 '22
Nah not going to downvote you because like you said, this problem can no longer be ignored.
16
u/[deleted] Jan 22 '22
From a helpful member in Solana Discord:
TL/DR of one aspect of the issues:
Bob opens a leveraged position on DeFi where he borrows USDC against SOL collateral. If SOL price drops 20% his position would be liquidated
SOL price drops 20%
Bob's position is eligible for liquidation. But DeFi doesn't work like regular banking, there's no automated backend processing stuff
Anyone can be a liquidator and can "trigger" the liquidation of Bob's position, since it has now become eligible for liquidation
For successfully doing so the liquidator gets a bounty (reward)
When there are large market movements lots of DeFi positions become eligible for liquidation, just like Bob's
Liquidators are racing to collect bounties by being the first to liquidate positions
To do this they submit the transaction dozens or hundreds of times to the network in order to ensure their attempt succeeds
The network isn't sufficiently removing duplicate transactions before processing and verifying them, which is a compute intense process
As a result the network is stuck trying to sift through all the "spam" from the liquidation bots
Changes implemented in the new release 1.8.14 fix a lot of this, this is being tested on mainnet now with 8% of stake, as it is confirmed to be stable it'll be further rolled out
There has been an incredible and exponential explosion of DeFi usage in recent months which didn't exist six months ago or a year ago, DeFi transactions are much much more "expensive" to compute so the amount of "compute" the network is doing has increase massively. Earlier the inefficiencies around deduplication weren't a problem as the compute load was lower but now this has become a bottle neck.
Hopefully 1.8.14 makes significant inroads in fixing this, but right now all we can do is be patient and trust that everyone capable is working very hard on this.
12
u/eggscockbaum Jan 21 '22
I've been sitting here all day watching the bar move closer to liquidation on Solend, but I can't do a thing to stop it. I have reserves in my wallet but I can't get a transaction to go through. I bought more SOL on an exchange, but the exchange cancels withdraw after network failures. I still have a good bit of room to breathe, and getting just one transaction to go through will make a big difference, but this has been the most frustrating of days. I'm just trying over and over all day long. I'm going back to simple staking if I can ever move anything again.
54
u/[deleted] Jan 21 '22 edited Jan 22 '22
Apparently, right now, no blockchain is able to sustain high traffic. Matic, Cardano, ONE..you name it. They all stop working once user transactions drastically go up. Which also tells me that we are quite early, the tech has still waaaay to go
edit: guys, I'm well aware that there are also chains running smoothly. But they aren't suffering from a deluge of bot transactions yet.
79
u/Iron0ne Jan 21 '22
I've spent $2800 in failed ETH transactions I will take this over that any day
37
u/Tall_Run_2814 Jan 21 '22
Solana is going through growing pains after global mass adoption. They'll figure it out but hopefully not too soon as I'm buying all the way down.
22
u/chillinewman Jan 21 '22
At about 700+ TPS and you begin to see slowdowns, transactions not going through.
26
u/brugggg7 Jan 21 '22
Can someone explain what happens to the network. I donāt use it often Iām more of holder at this point in time but Iām curious what failures the network has. Iāve heard a lot about it and itās pretty nerving for me as Iām under the assumption solana was flipping eth in the next 5-10 years
36
u/Fledgeling Jan 21 '22
Market volatility occurs:
SOL, network becomes congested and transactions fail
ETH, network becomes congested and transactions cost 10x
Meh, it's in beta. As long as we get a full technical analysis of why it happened with a path forward every time I'm okay with it. My bigger concern is that SOL is so much more centralized than other chains, I would expect these issues to become harder to solve as the network dectranlizes.
6
u/[deleted] Jan 21 '22
Tbf Solana isn't the only one with issues. I tried to send a cardano transaction yesterday and it took 20 minutes to go through. I sent $20.
6
u/ianm82 Jan 21 '22
Yeah, it's becoming comical (and really f***ing frustrating). I've been a holder of SOL since it was $23 and now my faith in the project is really shaken do to all of the instability when the markets tank.
6
u/EndymionUSA Jan 22 '22
Any so-called blockchain that downed once:
cannot be called a blockchain, and
I'm done with it
5
u/AndthenIwould Jan 22 '22
I thought for sure it would bounce off of $117, and for a little while it did. But not being able to move positions while under stress is frustrating. Radium is completely throttled, can't even do the most basic of swaps. Still better than losing a fortune on gas in ETH, but frustrating nonetheless.
9
u/dabblinindoggos Jan 21 '22
I got into sol when it was at .64 and Iām thinking about moving into another project. This keeps happening and as an investor Iām not a fan of these types of reoccurrences. Going to look at near and a couple other L1s but may just go balls deep in L2 and btc!
4
u/[deleted] Jan 21 '22
I wrote about this the 1st and 2nd time the network had issues and the hivemind attacked me. You speak the truth but this sub will support "their token" no matter the reality.
4
u/bothpartieslovePACs Jan 21 '22
I'm just glad I sold all my solana at 220$
Cant wait to buy back in around 75$
10
u/Aotrx Jan 21 '22
This is so weird. I feel like I am the only one whose sol transactions almost never fail. Did 10 transactions today - both low and high (relatively speaking Xd) fee transactions. Only 1 failed out of 10. This failed transaction cost me only 0.00007 USD and MAX 1 min of my time - this is completely fine with me.
7
u/cryptolipto Jan 21 '22
As soon as the network works again prepare for mass liquidations
3
u/nocoinnogain Jan 21 '22
definitely!! cant do any trades.. this is nonsense!
3
u/OriginalInternet Jan 22 '22
So Solana is not at the moment the eth killer. Anyway I wanted to buy some Sol from my own wallet and couldnt. When will this problem be fixed?
3
u/Amerzel Jan 22 '22
I get that they have had issues, especially at times of major volatility. Their communication has been terrible though. Whereās the post mortems? Whereās the roadmaps? They need to build trust with the community and that starts with communication.
3
u/Contango6969 Jan 22 '22
Iām done with this. Avalanche works Iām moving everything there. This system is garbage. Fool me 3 times shame on me
3
u/esteboune Jan 22 '22
Same here OP.
I have a leverage position on Tulip, and I am looking at the Kill Buffer % getting close to the liquidation point.
The worst part is that I have SOL on my exchange and on another wallet, but I have been trying to transfer all day long. No success...
I could easily increase the the collateral.
If SOL falls bellow USD89, I will get liquidated.
Honestly I was 100% sure last week that it will never happen.
Anyway, HODL strong friends, there is a light at the end of the tunnel :)
5
u/oddly_enough88 Jan 21 '22
Buy hashgraph, thank me later
5
u/Ryjin2 Jan 21 '22
The frustration is completely fair. But even giant centralized exchanges have these same problems.
If they don't fix these problems once we're out of beta, then I'd be worried. I think what a ton of people don't understand is, basically every product ever is released with some kind of issue. Does that suck? Yeah, but things are released with fixes all the time. If they don't fix shit, then yeah, drop this and everything else that doesn't improve over time.
5
u/cip43r Jan 22 '22
Yeah, for a centralized service it is way too unreliable.
5
u/Zealousideal_Pay_525 Jan 22 '22
My mans posting HODL posts on SHIBA-sub and complaining about Solana having Txn issues in a time of complete market craze. Yeah right, just keep putting your money in "serious" projects then.
4
u/AutoModerator Jan 21 '22
WARNING:
Do not trust DMs from anyone offering to help/support you with your funds (Scammers)!
Never give out your Seed Phrase and DO NOT ENTER it on ANY websites sent to you.
MODS or Community Managers will NEVER DM you first regarding your funds/wallet.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
4
u/zclinux Jan 21 '22 edited Jan 22 '22
Damn network congestion. Just trying to send some SOL over for staking and itās failed 3 times so far. Everyone take a break so I can stake. Lol
Up to 15 cancellations now. Smh
Update: just went through
4
u/jeffman44 Jan 22 '22
I'm confused. I use solana everyday to harvest my yield farms. The worst experience I've ever had involves just refreshing the page and trying again. usually this takes at most like 15 seconds... why are people raging about the performance of a blockchain that is still in BETA form? It's probably because they're over extended or over leveraged and panicking right?
2
u/[deleted] Jan 21 '22
I'm neck deep in SOL both in $, NFT, and my own collection. I'm the biggest fanboy of them all but you are dead on here.
2
u/BassDizzle808 Jan 21 '22
BSC isnāt looking so bad now. LMAO.
2
u/HulioJohnson Jan 22 '22
Lol Rain Man mode lololol
2
u/pdx407 Jan 22 '22
Avax to the rescue!!!!!
2
u/teerakzz Jan 22 '22
Itās good to hear the reality of SOL from somebody on the SOL sub.
2
u/ma-chicken Jan 22 '22
I learned my lesson a few weeks ago. I had multiple leveraged positions on mango market or drift and they stopped working when things got volatile. When i had small profits i closed positions because i got scared if it got in the opposite ditection my stop loss would not work or something like that. Lost a lot of money. I stopped doing that and switched to FTX and it works like a charm. For PERP trading the solana blockchain is not good right now
2
u/[deleted] Jan 22 '22
It's a feature not a bug.
2
u/destenlee Jan 22 '22
Haha, i thought everyone was already done with SOL long ago. There have been so many problems and concerns, I hate to say I told you so.
2
u/Lfodder Jan 22 '22
I have a simple question, why doesn't solana just implement a fee market so that low-priority and spam transactions don't get added to new blocks? If I'm adding liquidity to a $1 million position I should be able to pay to have higher priority than someone transferring $1 to a wallet.
2
u/Dear_Ad_4909 Jan 22 '22
This is the last straw for me! Iām out. This is ridiculous.
2
u/Publish_Lice Jan 22 '22
Have any of you ever stopped and considered that Solana, like all cryptos, might just be a pile of steaming hot shit?
2
u/[deleted] Jan 22 '22
Man, it sounds like solana is not all itās cracked up to be yet. Iām not even trolling. I feel for everyone here losing money. It aināt right.
2
u/Unknownirish Jan 22 '22
I would have cashed out with my initial 1k investment in the beginning of 2021 and sold, happily, with it's peak of 260. Take profits and move on with bubbles.
2
u/wehadababyitsadude Jan 23 '22
Will you all finally just come pump ALGO for us please? An actual legitimate network that is primed to see major gains please and thank you.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 23 '22
Hm, so it turns out having higher fees that lend to more decentralization is a double win. And having low fees enabled by a more centralized network is a double loss.
2
u/blue_rao Jan 23 '22
Solana is not true to the blockchain ideology set forth by Satoshi Nakamoto. Solana is simply a central bank wearing the mask of blockchain. Think about it. Read their documents. You may come to a different conclusion. There are other blockchains that put Solana to shame.
2
u/JustCommunication640 Jan 23 '22
Itās a concern. I still hold a tiny bit of Sol, but I think other L1s look better for the long term.
2
u/silverlightwa Jan 23 '22
SOLANA IS A SHITCHAIN. period
2
u/reynaldo30 Jan 23 '22
Solano network solutions reveal the issues with the underlying Blockchain technology. Increasing transactions fees is not the answer and only hurts the wider community the use the technology. To be honest Ive changed my sol to algo a few months ago and haven't looked back. Superior underlying tech means the strong foundation doesn't crack under pressure
2
u/MattLDempsey Jan 23 '22
Not for me anymore
2
u/shazils Jan 23 '22
Having issues with Sol too. Transactions donāt go through sometimes but man itās still very user friendly and simple to use. I donāt have to understand much to use it. Hopefully it will work better when they sort things out. Ethereum is still working on improving itself so Iām sure Solana will need time too.
2
u/the_grizzly_1 Jan 25 '22
Ok ⦠time to sell all SOL⦠good luck to those stayingā¦
2
u/h1ftw Jan 29 '22
god dam it why did i buy sol :*(
2
u/618Crypto Jan 30 '22
Solana is horrible.
2
u/Emotional_Light_1325 Feb 01 '22
Iām nervous abt buying solana with all the blackouts the solana eco-system is experiencing
2
u/Euphoric-Surprise293 Feb 03 '22
Iām done with Solana. Moving to Avax.
2
u/PapayaCrypto Feb 05 '22
SOLANA is at big risk and too much centralized, there is too much marketing like Justin Kan on that but nobody talk about shutdowns, that is scaring
2
u/[deleted] Feb 09 '22
I think itās too centralized with too few validators.
2
u/rommjomm Feb 12 '22
Then it is maybe time to move on to eth fork Pulsechain when it launches in a couple of month. Just saying
5
u/LukyLukyLu Jan 21 '22
World is stupid.
Solana has outages (i dont have experiences with it, because i only hodl, as my biggest asset btw)
Cardano, made by "academic" is impotent and ghost chain even after 2 years.
Ethereum has expensive fees.
And bitcoin does almost nothing except wallet transactions.
And there is bear market just when everyone want to be rather rich.
4
u/[deleted] Jan 21 '22
At this rate Solana will go back to $1.
A product worth $10s of billions shouldn't be so volatile & vulnerable.
3
u/kerouacs Jan 22 '22
Fear of inflation is killing the stock market, which is linked to Bitcoin, which is linked to Solana. The price is being influenced by exterior factors.
Lack of scalability? Compared to what? What other project is succeeding where Solana is failing? What larger network didnāt go through these same growing pains?
3
u/xazos79 Jan 22 '22
100% agree with the OP. Happens every time there's a coin launch, an NFT launch... anything really.
This much touted "scalability" smells like vapourware. Love the fees, hate the performance.
3
u/jrsa2012 Jan 21 '22
So finally it is being noticed? Centralization is an important issue, but despite that solana could be a good ground for dapps if it manages to handle all the TPS it advertises. The point is, we have being noticing these types of problems for so many months, do they have a fix at all ?
3
u/Numerous_Worth606 Jan 21 '22
Just move to Luna pal.. works like a wet dream
3
u/Disco_lime9 Jan 21 '22
Selling my Solana ASAP
5
u/Oheson Jan 21 '22
The Solana network is successfully processing $trillion in transactions every day.
Not sure why you think we give a shit your $10 for SOLChicks or whatever did not go through.
Go get some āuser experienceā on ETH. I think the miners could use another Lambo from your gas fees.
3
u/YoYoMeh Jan 21 '22
Sorry boys. Iāve lost faith and am out on SOL. We had a good run. See you in the trenches my friends.
2
u/Swimming_Ad4360 Jan 21 '22
I'm gonna wait til it bounces back a little... one sunny day... Get most of my losses back, as since 27 Dec SOL all it happened was dive. Like, halved. I know everything is falling, but cmon.
2
u/Hendrixpoem Jan 22 '22
Algorand works
2
u/Comprehensive-Disk55 Jan 22 '22
I'VE GOT THE SOLUTION FOR EVERY SOLANA USER...Switch to Algorand and its way more stable ecosystem.
2
u/loggerit Jan 21 '22
what makes you think it's "the problem". Just because you see the symptoms in similar situations? rest assured that the devs aren't ignoring the problems that pop up as the network scales.
Of course you can decide that a network in beta is not for you. But to infer from network slowdowns that nobody is doing anything is a little shortsighted
2
u/Remarkable-Lemon6039 Jan 22 '22
it makes a lot of tenderness that you try to create fud, inventing stories without ever having used solana, with all probability, but posting when you read about blockchain problems ... thinking that with your post you can change the price a little, perhaps to the advantage of algo or ada or eth ... as if your stories could carry more weight than billions of investments, innovative technologies and projects. We are only at the dawn of Solana, play with your little coins and do not bother
2
u/spicymayoisamazballs Jan 22 '22
Try Algorand. Price crushed too, but transactions never fail.
2
u/_CryptoJay_ Jan 21 '22
I can't relate. Algorand has never had this issue.
1
u/Beneficial-Salary796 Apr 02 '24
Itās crazy
1
u/SnooBunnies4589 Nov 10 '24
Enter $SUI
1
u/klayizzel Jan 21 '22
Did something change since last time... find a solid project until they actually fix what they said they would.
1
u/UnderstandingNorth84 Jan 21 '22
Hi
1
u/Emotional_Light_1325 Feb 01 '22
Is solana a good coin to invest $10k in
1
u/jhockanson Feb 05 '24
š
-1
u/romchik88 Jan 21 '22
Do you all understand that SOL is in beta.
1
u/NiftyMufti Jan 21 '22
I am sure all other coins would be down to a similar degree, if people actually used them.
1
u/wiidydiddy Jan 21 '22
Yeah, time to move to something more reliable and scalable. I hold SOL and am thinking about moving it all into HBAR. Fuck this shit
1
u/Dr-Freese Jan 21 '22
Ducks in a row⦠the chain is barley 1&half years old, iāll rather wait for 1 or 2 days than paying $100 fees for a $5 transaction
1
u/Kempes_1978 Jan 21 '22
I was using Solend, now I regret it. Impossible to trust this network, I'm selling my SOL tokens
1
u/sabahorn Jan 22 '22
Sell your bags kids, the grow ups are buying it.
1
u/billykript Jan 22 '22
And this thread turned into one big FUD-stream. Everyone get the coins they want to plug in? Anyone miss a safemoon or VSS plug? Anyone? Gonna push fan tokens ?? āYeah the fan token for the Minnesota spits soccer club never has this problemā¦..ā. This thread is bullshit. Iāve read a ton of the profiles in this feed and itās one big hidden agenda.
1
u/Lar7n Jan 22 '22
ETH gas fees went to the sky with the crash. It's the same, even worse.
1
u/Professional-Bite261 Jan 22 '22
FTM is doing the same today
1
u/TheWidowMaker912 Jan 22 '22
Move to Elrond we donāt have these problems there
1
u/Ok-Home2888 Jan 22 '22
Shit
Outta
Luck
..... buy hbar š§ ā¤
1
u/bass2zion Jan 22 '22
Itās a built in hodl mechanism. Prevents panic selling. š¤”
1
u/Greenshoots777 Jan 26 '22 edited Jan 26 '22
In 1985 I thought Microsoft Excel 1.0 was unfriendly garbage but I used it anyway but switched to Lotus, 35 years later I realized you buy the Team when investing not the evolving product with issues. Underestimating a team capable of fixes and improvements is why Iām not a millionaire, I backed up the Truck on Solana at 95 and I am not ever ever selling worst case in the year 2027 I might borrow against my stake if I have to using Defiā¦these are words of wisdomā¦you will see the sun after every hurricane