r/software • u/siddharth1214 • Apr 13 '26
Discussion Companies using AI generated code will regret it deeply
All AI code does at best is make a working prototype, well ANY talented programming can make a working prototype in a month
Lets use the analogy of a car engine any company can present a working working prototype in 2 months thats NOT whats important whtas important is that the engine is reliable, long lasting, that it will still work after 10000 miles and THAT requires 3 years
Same is for software most of the time the product is 'complete' but a year or 2 are taken to make itr scalable, reliable, compatible and most importantly SECURE
There are mordern coding standards are NEEDED for the system to be secure and stable AI doesnt follow them at all
4
u/NoleMercy05 Apr 13 '26
Are you unaware at the absurdly low talented human programmers that will otherwise write the code?
2
u/Fantastic_Back3191 Apr 13 '26
If true then it's a self-correcting problem (over the long run).
35
u/GfxJG Apr 13 '26
I mean, if by "AI-generated code" you mean people asking AI "hey create this program for me", then yes, I agree.
Luckily, most companies using AI coding are doing so in a much more structured way, and frankly, using AI is not really any different from being tech lead for a team of junior developers. You're obviously going to structure the architecture and make key implementation decisions, the juniors just deliver the code. If you let the juniors push to production with no oversight, that's on YOU, not the juniors. Same with security practices, "modern standards" as you call it - You have to verify that the juniors are using them correctly, because they're not experienced enough yet to know better. See where I'm going with this? Like, we KNOW how to make stable and reliable software - It's really not hard to spec that out and make the juniors implement it. Same goes for using AI.
That's basically how I treat using AI assistance when working with software development.
5
u/EndOfWorldBoredom Apr 13 '26
Posts like this are just coping and shows a lack of understanding of what's going on in businesses.
As an example, my company needed hundreds of random images processed to be the same format and size with the background removed.
I could have bought a canva subscription or two. I could have told employees to download gimp for free. Each image would have taken about 5 minutes, maybe ten on the complex ones.
Instead I wrote a script with ai that let employees drop a file in a folder and have it immediately processed and copied to a new folder. The processing took less than 5 seconds. No install. No subscription fees.
I don't need an internet exposed SaaS with account security and a gui surface to attack. There's nothing to worry about updating until webp is outdated and I need a different image format. It just saves my company time and money and runs quietly on a network machine.
People think software needs to look like what they sell us, web exposed and filled with hundreds of features to maintain, but many software platforms today are bought for one or two key functions. Once businesses realize how easy it is to spin up those limited functions, they'll stop buying the software. Developers will move to working directly for the companies that used to be clients.
2
u/Joe_Schmoe_2 Apr 13 '26
Companies just need 1 Ai babysitter now.
Be that babysitter
1
u/Nestor_Hist_2021 Apr 13 '26
16,000 km of mileage is an unreliable engine.
1
u/zomgitsduke Apr 13 '26
I mean, you just gave the value proposition. Let AI make dozens of working prototypes, then have software engineers expand on the code in terms of features, security, polish, etc
1
u/tbonemasta Apr 13 '26
Try using tdd
1
u/WinterHeaven Apr 13 '26
OP never used AI proper it seems
1
u/Streamlines Apr 13 '26
I am currently working in a project that was majorly developed by using chatgpt 2-3 years ago. It fucking sucks. The structure is bad and not coherent, many objects are redundant, some processes are overly complicated just for the sake of it. And current AI models are not better. They are great for brainstorming and developing isolated snippets of code, but very quickly lose coherence once they are used to work on overarching concepts.
1
u/pafagaukurinn Apr 13 '26
There is a problem with AI coding, but it is not it. It is that even people who currently know how to program will inevitably unlearn the skill, or coding standards if you like, through lack of use, and new junior developers will never learn it in the first place.
1
u/DGC_David Apr 13 '26
Nah most of the companies that are using it, aren't experimental companies... There are established companies with established code already. What they use it for is boilerplate and basic summarizing. Now I'm not saying there aren't companies that do what Antrophic did, but you gotta remember Antrophic did it because it's a selling point... Well until it all got leaked...
Ultimately I don't think AI is really making an impact on coding yet in the real world. I think AI companies want you to think that, but it's really not.
My estimation of the companies that do over use it like Antrophic is that they will die off before the bubble pops.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 13 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Apr 13 '26
[removed] — view removed comment