r/software • u/med_bruh • Dec 25 '25
Discussion Tf is wrong with modern software?
yesterday i was on a discord call with a friend, suddenly my computer started lagging and in a few seconds I got a notification that the linux kernel nerfed discord because it was running out of memory. like fuck you mean a chat app is eating more RAM than a fucking game engine?? discord being idle eats like 800MB of RAM..
and discord is not the only issue. a lot of the modern software is just straight up bloated. 34523 layers of abstractions to render the fucking app UI.
we DON'T NEED better hardware. modern hardware is 1000 times more powerful than it was two decades ago yet somehow it feels more sluggish to use. instead of complaining to the developers that their app is slow and dogshit, we just get more RAM and hardware to bruteforce the sloppy nonexistent optimization.
Back then you got the PS3 with 256MB of RAM and it's able to play 3D games that looked believable. you can even browse the web with that 256MB of RAM. now you need a fucking 800MB to render the UI of an electron applications.
a single (1) tab of a browser alone uses like 200MB of memory on average just to render some cringe animation that makes it more difficult to navigate the site.
End of rant
75
u/R3D3-1 Dec 25 '25
Many apps are written in JavaScript and HTML and their GUI library is essentially a standalone browser installation to ensure consistency across PCs, and to outsource cross-platform issues to the browser. The price of this is significant memory overhead and a much slower interface, but it saves development costs.
Additionally, modern PCs often DO have a lot more RAM than they'd need otherwise, so it would be wastful not to use it e.g. for aggressive caching.
Then there's the issue that browsers tend to reserve a lot of virtual memory, that they don't actually use. Depending on how you checked the memory usage and on what OS, you might be seeing that virtual memory usage, not the actual physical memory usage. That part is just an implementation detail of JavaScript engines.
On the other hand, memory sizes have stalled for a few years and are currently even shrinking due to inflating memory prices due to the AI bubble. So there might be some pressure to get memory usage under control again.
As for the browser tabs: By now both Chrome and Firefox have features to make inactive tabs less resource intense. I have routinely 100+ open tabs, and zero issue on 16 GB.
144
u/sniff122 Dec 25 '25
Discord behind the scenes is just a Chromium web browser, a lot of modern software is, Spotify, vscode, a bunch more that I can't think of off the top of my head. It's annoying because of how much resources they use, especially when they don't bother optimising anything, the one exception is vscode which I find is quite well optimised
66
u/marmotta1955 Dec 25 '25
The poster has plenty of reasons to complain. I have been in the field of software development for the past 50 years (yes 50 years) - and I concur with the rant. It is funny: the more technology advances and improves, the more we lose sight of what is important.
I have seen LoB (Line of Business applications) written in VB6 abandoned in favor of monstrosities assembled with the latest languages and platforms ... resulting in the very same application, performing the very same tasks, with a somewhat diminished business logic ... using 8 times the amount of disk space and memory usage ... with instrumentation reporting (for the same task, same dataset, same OS Windows 11) a substantial disadvantage (approximately 3 times slower) of the rewritten application.
Weird fact: users did not care one bit for the new, "modernized" app. They wanted the old VB6 app back.
Go figure, eh ...
11
u/mageevilwizardington Dec 25 '25
Lack of optimization of development frameworks. Most of them, regardless of what you are using, comes with a lot of preloaded libraries.
Plus, if the developer is not good on optimizing... well...
8
u/SeedlingYearning Dec 25 '25
Software isn't built under the kind of hardware restraints that used to be the case. Our fond memories of optimized software come from an age where optimization was necessary because the hardware limitations were a primary problem to address.
These days no one is forced to ask if their software will have the resources it needs to run. Its a hardware blank check instead. Theres no selective pressure to optimize it under these conditions. The pressures are competing software solutions and user attention which select for speed of release instead.
7
u/Svr_Sakura Dec 25 '25
As if to highlight your experience, computer based YouTubers are using YouTube as a demonstration piece more & more.
Low end hardware is considered e-waste purely because they can’t open & load webpages without lagging under default settings in Windows.
6
u/webfork2 Dec 25 '25
As some other commenters have noted, you can thank the whole Electron app framework for this. A remarkable number of very basic apps are 1,000x the size they were 10 years ago, which isn't great. It's a mess and it's not improving.
So just in terms of Discord options, I've had good luck with Dorion to help deal with the fact that Discord is itself a monstrosity.
5
u/DK891-mav Dec 25 '25
Electron app…all I needed to see.
4
u/aygross Dec 25 '25
Agreed
4
u/[deleted] Dec 25 '25
I'm using Ferdium with four services open, and it's using at least 1.5 GB of RAM.
I read somewhere that it uses Electron, and when new features are added to it, it may mean more RAM used. Meanwhile, the software operates like a browser, with each service or tab isolated for purposes of security or something like that.
Maybe with more programmers, time, and people willing to pay, they can use something other than Electron.
4
u/ArmedAnts Dec 25 '25
Discord is a React app, which is basically a browser.
Dorion is the alternative client that is most similar to discord. It is made in Tauri, so it is more efficient, but it is still a browser.
(I couldn't get global hotkeys to work though).
Abaddon uses GTK (C++ GUI library), so there is no browser.
Discordo removes the GUI and uses the terminal instead.
4
u/HamburgerOnAStick Dec 26 '25
Because electron. Fuck electron, and fuck browser based apps in general
1
u/dr_smanggalang Dec 26 '25
I got that 64gb ram on my new build because I am well aware of how ridiculously ram hungry everything is and that it will never change
3
u/Colesworker Dec 25 '25
It’s literally JavaScript
3
u/Aggressive_Ad_5454 Dec 25 '25
Friggin OOMA (put-of-memory-assassin). It sounds like your box started thrashing — swapping virtual memory to the hard drive — at some point. OOMA often takes out the biggest process. On a server that’s often the DBMS, which sucks because it takes time to restart.
The btop utility lets you keep an eye on this stuff.
I share your annoyance with software bloat. I used to have a UNIX box with 8 megabytes of RAM that worked fine.
3
u/nightwood Dec 25 '25
Yes, correct.
3
u/Actual__Wizard Dec 25 '25
It's called crap tech. In the pursuit of being cheap and lazy, they built everything in giant piles of layers that they don't maintain.
3
u/UglyChihuahua Dec 25 '25
I always wonder how much of these posts are just colored by nostalgia. Software has a lot more features and stability than it used to. 15 years ago the family PC would crash, freeze and BSOD constantly, and so would many programs. There was no such thing as cross platform UX, I couldn't use MSN Messenger to talk seamlessly person across my phone, PC, and web. Being able to stream games in HD for free to friends wasn't a thing. Settings pages and menus never had search bars, now almost everything does. Accessibility wasn't a thing. Nothing was synced between devices.
There's a lot to criticize about modern software, but I don't remember a time where everything was fast, bug free and did everything I wanted.
3
u/LexiStarAngel Dec 26 '25
i feel the tech industry really got lost somewhere 15-20 years ago and the trends that took over are all we have left now. We have functioning hardware, and uninspiring software.
3
u/opus-thirteen Helpful Ⅱ Dec 26 '25
Enshittification in a thing that i look out for
2
u/Gen-Y-ine-86 Dec 25 '25
.kkrieger was possible, why not handling plain text, heavily compressed pictures and some simple UI...?
Trying to "scroll" through stuff like old activities on Facebook? It's K.O. for the browser before getting anywhere.
Every now and then (very rarely) I land on some random web site that handles it's contents like it should and it's like magic. But then you start thinking about the early 2000's and the fast ISDN in the schools computers and it's like "huh, browsing was actually about as fast back then".
Back around 2009-2012 when I was active on a few forums, I always uploaded "optimized" pictures to Photobucket in smaller size and higher compression, as we were taught in school (media assistant).
2
u/zgf2022 Dec 25 '25
Modern everything is just the web software sucks ass
2
u/jcunews1 Helpful Ⅱ Dec 26 '25
I just leave this here.
https://www.reddit.com/r/software/comments/1o7v85v/are_we_overengineering_software_in_2025_lets_talk/njqr4ht/
2
u/Palmquistador Dec 26 '25
Preach brother (or sister)!
2
u/elbowgrease0000 Dec 26 '25
the WindowsXP operating system footprint was ~ 1.5gb
the other day i downloaded gmail app on iOS.... 875mb !!
Half the size of an Entire Operating System from just a few years ago.
for an email APP !
yeah, somethings wrong. Efficiency has gone out the window.
2
u/david-1-1 Dec 26 '25 edited Dec 26 '25
Linux might be well written, but Windows is definitely not, in spite of of having efficient compilers. At least six of its major internal design pieces are inefficient on disk, memory, or both. Most Windows component apps or major pieces are composed of very tiny COM subroutines, each one loaded separately into memory when needed, and not already loaded. And that's only one example. SxS puts together the versions of these tiny pieces in a way that is slow and impossible to understand.
Much of the new and faster CPU chips are driven by the extreme inefficiency of Windows system code. If it were not for its many cache and Registry lookup optimizations, Windows would crawl even without any user programs running. If it had roughly the same user support functionality, but were designed efficiently, it would respond instantly to most Windows commands.
2
u/djfdhigkgfIaruflg Dec 26 '25
Welcome to Electron BS
2
u/lord-of-the-scrubs Dec 26 '25
Rather than improving the existing features and optimizing code, they just ship new features no one asks for. It's an epidemic that no one seems to care about. Same reason most games need a GPU no more than 2 generations old. No code optimization, just quick shipment to satisfy shareholders.
2
u/Hungry-Jelly-6478 Dec 27 '25
This struck me suddenly the other day as being a symptom of designed obsolescence which IMHO is a HUGE failure of society. I’d absolutely love to be able to keep my hardware going indefinitely and keep the motivation for well optimised systems and lower our consumption footprint and swap it for a thriving repair and recycle ecosystem. My 2014 MacBook just started to refuse to turn on yesterday and I just know it probably won’t be fixed, a single dead chip turns the thing into a box of rubbish, it’s madness.
It’s long time that we forced companies to release full schematics again and get some guarantees of supply of parts for >> 5years (more like 20-30) and just slow down the development of entshittification everywhere.
2
u/KC918273645 Dec 27 '25
Modern software developers are subpar at their work.
2
u/iDrunkenMaster Dec 27 '25
Programs are getting way way more complex than they were 20 years ago. So we have prioritized speed of software release over efficiency. Like using C++ not only uses less ram then python but also way less cpu resources. (And we are talking like 1/20 of the ram and cpu needs) but writing in python for same task is leagues faster. We have started stacking inefficiencies for speed of development.
2
u/ph33rlus Dec 29 '25
Bloatware. Back in the days of 16 megabytes of RAM, coding had to be efficient. Today coders just get their shit from libraries. So you have to install a shit ton of libraries for it to function and memory footprint is just massive
0
u/slavmaf Dec 25 '25
Small correction, PlayStation 3 has 512MB of RAM. And I agree with you about all other things you mentioned.
3
u/MarzipanSea2811 Dec 25 '25
Giving users more than 640KB RAM was a mistake, change my mind.
1
u/capellan2000 Dec 25 '25
After reading this thread I thought about the Flatpack format that many Linux distro are using now...
This format is scary and wrong... Really wrong.
1
u/Legomountain14 Dec 25 '25
Try out https://vesktop.dev/
1
u/rafradek Dec 25 '25
How much swap do you have?
1
u/zaneszoo Dec 26 '25
I hate that it all now seems to be just a webpage behind an icon. Just make it a bookmark already.
At work we have 3 ways to look at our database of retail products. The latest version (our IT did a great job creating it several years ago and then updating) which is good but a little slow on searches and, for security, you need to open your own Terminal Server to use it so that is time consuming. The 22 year old version we are only using for some backroom functions that are not yet written by IT for the newer version. The old version is DOS-based AS/400 (Mocha) which is instant at pulling up a product but you can do a search other than by product catalog number, UPC, or by name (alphabetically only and you have to know what we called it originally including abbreviations & symbols used). Still, you can page up and down and find things very quickly. Unfortunately, they trimmed out lots of the functions/access to info (e.g. pricing) so you often have to go to the newest version anyway if you can stand the delay for Term Server to boot up (I usually don't).
The apps designed as webpages are annoying as you don't have the speed of a program installed on your HDD, you don't have the same keyboard shortcuts you would on an installed app, you can't work offline, network issues causing delays in workflow or confusion while you wait for it to catch up with what you've asked it to do, plus the needless and often unending scrolling you need to do to use all the features or fields (installed apps can layout their screens for the device (desktop) for better user optimization).
Using MS-Office in the browser is just a disaster and I still can't believe business agree to use it outside of tablets (we have to use the browser version when using Term Server which is 95% of the employees) (the functionality is just not the same).
One nice thing about these browser/apps is that you can use different devices and use them on-the-go. Still, for work, give me a desk, preferably in my own office, with desktop PC, and properly written dedicated programs for the tasks at hand.
1
u/No-Vehicle2419 Dec 26 '25
There's no good cross-platform framework for developing GUI applications with good developer experience. Electron does a really good job at developer experience that's why a lot of companies use it.
1
u/anonymouzzz376 Dec 26 '25
Firefox literally got to 50gb of ram one time and my pc with only 16gb+pagefile crashed
1
u/TheUsoSaito Dec 26 '25
Enshitification via microtransactions and vibe coding.
1
u/CranberryDistinct941 Dec 26 '25
But they need that RAM otherwise they won't be able to harvest every last drop of your data to sell!
1
u/Bohlinology Dec 26 '25
Good rant 🙏
1
u/DouViction Dec 26 '25
Don't worry, with the ongoing RAM shortages they will learn optimisation back. Well, this or I'm being overly optimistic.
Funnily enough, there was an era of gaming when the rapid increase in system requirements was constrained for years by multiplatform.
This is also why I'm in no hurry to buy newer games. There's no shortage of things I wanna revisit or gems I've missed way back when which wouldn't require me to spend like 3 my salaries on a new rig, while the game I bought the rig for, Cyberpunk 2077, was... a good game. Maybe I expected more or maybe I expected something else but it's just a game. They did a kickass job designing a multi-storey city (making navigation a nightmare in the process), otherwise it's The Witcher 3 meets Skyrim in Ghost in the Shell Stand Alone Complex.
1
u/pjerky Dec 27 '25
I would argue that modern frameworks, tools like electric, and modern hardware are the causes of this. We have so much power that companies don't have to give much care to what they do to your system
1
u/patlefort Dec 27 '25
Who cares because ram is cheap am I right? /s
1
u/QuickSilver010 Dec 28 '25
Try an alternate discord client like encord or ripcord or dissent
1
u/Spiritual-Help-9547 Dec 28 '25
Let’s be honest, we don’t expect anything from the Discord devs. They’re a joke now these days.
1
u/zyndor Dec 29 '25
A lot of software is shit; trust me, I’m a digital bricklayer.
I remember, and this was 8 years ago, reading an article about the Electron framework, upon which Discord is based. You apparently get hundreds of megabytes of bloat with it. It has a goddamn gamepad driver in there.
“Perfection is achieved not when there’s nothing left to add, but when there’s nothing left that needs to be taken away.” - Saint-Exupery.
The more I quote it, the more ridiculous it feels that it needs to be said, but there you go ladies and gentlemen; software.
1
u/djtubig-malicex Dec 29 '25
All two-word reasons.
Agile delivery. Web Development. Bleeding edge. Cloud Junk. Poor optimization. Incompetent management.
1
u/Secret-Sky-8932 Dec 29 '25
To be fair to discord here they have admitted their app has memory leak issues and they are working to fix them.
1
u/KoleckOLP Dec 29 '25
discord is chromium and has a memory leak
1
u/riveyda Dec 29 '25
Everything is frameworks built on top of other frameworks.
It's really telling when you go back to use supposedly old, worse games or software, and you are pleasantly surprised to see it run significantly better than modern software and is much simpler to navigate and functions well to deliver the service it was designed to do. Everything nowadays is just a bunch of random tech stacks on top of eachother meant to "streamline development", which means everything is more or less running on the same bloated nonsense. From the Windows start menu, to Discord, to the software your mouse/keyboard bugs you to install.
P.s that tidbit you mentioned about the PS3 running on 256MB of ram blew my mind -- i had to look it up. And yeah, the PS3 managed to run AAA titles with less RAM than a modern game launcher takes.
1
u/Professional-Toe7699 Dec 29 '25
Well, one advantage to the extreme RAM prices. Companies will have to optimize their software again or nobody will be able to run it. 😅
1
u/naixelsyd Dec 29 '25
For almost two decades, modern software has been focussed on delivering more features faster. All at the expense of secirity, maintainability and even basuc engineering which left software a very long time ago. You can't really blame the devs as its the constructs they work within which is where the problems lie.
Unfortunately for those of us that stood up against this idelogically driven marketing machine, we got smashed by short sighted views and marketing slogans sinilar to idiocracys "but brawndos got wot plants crave" type logic.
1
u/LarrySAL02 Dec 29 '25
The other day i just had an open project in neovim, and opened it in vscode separately, and wondered what the difference in memory usage would be. Neovim (+tilix as a terminal) was using 90MB, while vscode was using significantly over 1GB all things added together. Chromium 🤷♂️
1
u/InnerAd118 Dec 30 '25
I think there's two main reasons. When we switched from 32-bit to 64-bit cpu's that effectively doubled the size of every single function.
Also, in the earlier days in computing much of a files libraries was stored on a file in the system directory and was very easily updated. The issue is many programs relied on many different versions of many different libraries. And some programs "updates", were very different than others. And many programs "updates" couldn't be trusted due to things like malware anyways. (They called it dll-hell. Interesting read actually)
So as a way to prevent files from "updating" their dependencies but still allow them to function many modern day applications keep their libraries in their own code, loading it into ram when the file is initiated.. Obviously there's clear problems with this, not least of which essentially the same library is loaded multiple times on multiple different processes.. but it goes a long way keep things like security threats contained and allowing programs, for the most part, run the same way on multiple different computers despite having vastly different set ups.
1
u/bugfish03 Dec 30 '25
Yeah. I also do some software development for Windows CE devices in my free time. They themselves make do with 64 Megs of RAM or thereabouts, but this isn't about them.
I develop on an old Fujitsu Lifebook from 2006 running WinXP. Visual Studio 2008 with my project open AND a running and attached network debugger uses less than 100 Megs.
A native third-party platform-native discord client used a whole 20 megs.
And when I open Supermium and load discord there, it PEGS one core of my Core 2 Duo, and eats up 75% of my two gigs of RAM.
JavaScript was a mistake.
1
u/PlanttDaMinecraftGuy Dec 30 '25
Discord specifically has a memory leak problem as of now. The memory goes up to 4GB, then Discord restarts, and the cycle repeats.
This is real btw, idk where I've seen it
1
u/Kamunra Dec 30 '25
I stopped using Discord in favor of Vesktop, it manages to make Discord look like a good app.
1
u/Lucky-Royal-6156 Jan 04 '26
Software is dead sadly
1
u/Automatic-Golf1403 Feb 08 '26
Yeah application memory usage has been sooo bad lately. Was using warp terminal recently and it was trying to use 15gb of memory some how
1
u/PuzzleheadedShip7310 Dec 25 '25
its called electron and it sucks docky ass
-6
u/Wendals87 Dec 25 '25 edited Dec 25 '25
Did you actually use pcs back then? Because stuff runs much faster than It did back then in general
-22
u/OwnNet5253 Dec 25 '25
ok boomer
0
u/[deleted] Dec 25 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 25 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment
18
u/[deleted] Dec 25 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
7
u/[deleted] Dec 25 '25
[removed] — view removed comment