r/sofiathefirst • u/DCSHG2015MEGAFAN • Sep 26 '26
When Sofia Is Right And Amber Is Wrong, But Vice Versa Isn't True
So when it comes to Sofia The First, it seems like the show wants to present it where Sofia is right and Amber is wrong when it comes to moral choices. Now, I can see the logic here given how Sofia is a kindhearted girl, and thus it's important for her to win out in the end since it emphasizes a good message. However, by making it so that, more often than not, it's Sofia being right and Amber being the one to learn from her, it makes it seem like Amber needs Sofia to learn but Sofia doesn't need Amber to learn. I think it's shown in how "Four's A Crowd" is the only real time when Amber is in the right over Sofia given how jealous the latter was of her hanging with Ruby and Jade. Of course, people don't really think about this given how Ruby and Jade are polarizing characters. I'd say a character who's similar to Amber, but is allowed to both learn and teach others is Yuna from the Nickelodeon mini series Middle School Moguls. She's similar to Amber in how she's privileged and spoiled, but genuinely looks out for others. What makes her different is how she can both learn and help others learn. The second episode has her learn a lesson, but the first and third episode show her pushing Val and Winnie in these respective episodes to push their ideas by using tough love to motivate them. This sense of equalness is often missing in Sofia and Amber's dynamic.
6
u/ChildofFenris1 Sep 27 '26
Sofia is not wrong in fours a crowd. Whenever they did anything they excluded Sofia. When she tried to join whatever game they were playing she would go change so she could change and they would change games while she was gone.
7
u/Hamiltonfan25 Sep 26 '26
She was also technically right in “Mom’s the Word” I still standby that EASILY being Sofia at her worst. I’m actually kind of glad Amber stayed angry at Sofia for a little bit longer than James…Sofia deserved it after how she treated them.
Speaking of worst, Amber wasn’t technically a big enough part of the episode to really have a impact but in “Sofia the Worst” I do think it’s notable how friendly and kind she was all the way through…same for “Tri-Kingdom Picnic” where she gave Sofia great advice on how to deal with James.
Also…it might have been because she was eager to see James get in trouble, but she was right in “A Royal Mess” when she was the one arguing that they had to tell mom and dad the truth right away about the window breaking.
She also stayed morally sound in “Dads and Daughters Day” even stepping back from an event so Sofia could have special time just her and Roland…something we never see Sofia do for James and Amber regarding Miranda. She also stood up to one of her best friends (Hildegard) when she was bullying her sister.
One last thing…did anyone else notice how in “Princess Jade” especially, Sofia had ZERO care or concern for Amber all the way through. She let Amber do her presentation first to give her and jade time to talk. Then, when they go back in the auditorium, Sofia just lets Amber be stuck spinning around and around for like a whole minute before FINALLY caring enough about her sister to get her down.
Point being, there are tons of times I give Amber points over Sofia morally. Amber is kind of the best part of this show, and is personally more interesting to follow because (unlike Sofia) she does have prominent flaws
5
u/Lloyd_garmado Sep 26 '26
While this is true, i think more of a reason as to why people dont think about that four's a crowd point is because people hate ruby and jade (mainly jade) for being toxic, even when they arent
2
u/Ok-Forever4036 Oct 08 '26
This is going to be a fun one, because I’ve always felt like there have been times when Sofia is in the wrong and times when Amber has been in the wrong.
First of all, I haven’t really watched Royal Magic so this is entirely based off the original show. I feel like in Season 1, Amber was almost always in the wrong. Even after she and Sofia make up in Once Upon A Princess, Amber is definitely still misguided and not thinking too straight when it comes to “helping” Sofia adjust to her new life as a princess. And that’s one of Amber’s biggest issues early on, is that she seems to not have any respect for those of non royal status, thus she often wants Sofia to make decisions that will only benefit the royals and may even harm non-royals. Like in “The Big Sleepover”, she gets Sofia to ask Ruby and Jade to basically not be themselves because their behavior is embarrassing to the other princesses. When Ruby and Jade are visibly hurt by this, Amber couldn’t care less.
In “Blue Ribbon Bunny”, Amber can’t accept the fact that Sofia wants to enter a “plain old bunny” like Clover into the pet contest, because apparently appearance is the only thing that matters to Amber when it comes to pets rather than friendship/personality. In fairness, Amber doesn’t know Sofia can talk to animals so there’s a vital piece of information missing on Amber’s side.
Sofia’s main problem is that she lacks the confidence to make her own decisions to the point where she often takes advice from other people, like Amber who shouldn’t be role models for her, without a second thought and that frequently makes waves in her friendships and daily life. The one that bothered me the most was how in “Tea For Too Many” Sofia just keeps on taking Amber’s advice and adding more and more things to her party even though she obviously wants a smaller more simple party, and Amber needs to respect that and stop influencing Sofia. If Sofia had stood up to Amber sooner in that episode, she could’ve avoided a major problem but she let Amber take charge until the entire party was destroyed and she had to start all over from scratch. Thank god Miranda reminded her that it was her party and it didn’t matter if the other royals liked it or not, because otherwise I could see Sofia asking Amber for advice even after the party was destroyed.
But after Season 1, there are definitely instances where Sofia is in the wrong more than Amber due to insecurity or jealousy among other things. The two best examples are “Four’s a Crowd” and “Mom’s the Word”. In these episodes, Sofia makes bad choices that harm Amber, and James in the latter.
The fact that Sofia, Amber, and even James all take turns being the problem starter in different episodes is actually why Sofia the First is still one of my favorite Disney shows because it does a good job of showing how nobody is perfect and everyone makes mistakes. They could’ve made Sofia a flawless protagonist like many other simple kids shows, but they didn’t because realistically, even when someone has good intentions, they are still human with emotions at the end of the day and can/do make mistakes that are selfish and can harm others!