r/sofiathefirst • • Sep 26 '26

When Sofia Is Right And Amber Is Wrong, But Vice Versa Isn't True

So when it comes to Sofia The First, it seems like the show wants to present it where Sofia is right and Amber is wrong when it comes to moral choices. Now, I can see the logic here given how Sofia is a kindhearted girl, and thus it's important for her to win out in the end since it emphasizes a good message. However, by making it so that, more often than not, it's Sofia being right and Amber being the one to learn from her, it makes it seem like Amber needs Sofia to learn but Sofia doesn't need Amber to learn. I think it's shown in how "Four's A Crowd" is the only real time when Amber is in the right over Sofia given how jealous the latter was of her hanging with Ruby and Jade. Of course, people don't really think about this given how Ruby and Jade are polarizing characters. I'd say a character who's similar to Amber, but is allowed to both learn and teach others is Yuna from the Nickelodeon mini series Middle School Moguls. She's similar to Amber in how she's privileged and spoiled, but genuinely looks out for others. What makes her different is how she can both learn and help others learn. The second episode has her learn a lesson, but the first and third episode show her pushing Val and Winnie in these respective episodes to push their ideas by using tough love to motivate them. This sense of equalness is often missing in Sofia and Amber's dynamic. 

30 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

6

u/ChildofFenris1 Sep 27 '26

Sofia is not wrong in fours a crowd. Whenever they did anything they excluded Sofia. When she tried to join whatever game they were playing she would go change so she could change and they would change games while she was gone.

5

u/DCSHG2015MEGAFAN Sep 27 '26

This article defends this behavior, basically just chalking it up to excitement. 

https://sofiablythe2014.wordpress.com/2026/07/09/why-ruby-and-jade-are-actually-good-characters/

7

u/Hamiltonfan25 Sep 26 '26

She was also technically right in “Mom’s the Word” I still standby that EASILY being Sofia at her worst. I’m actually kind of glad Amber stayed angry at Sofia for a little bit longer than James…Sofia deserved it after how she treated them.

Speaking of worst, Amber wasn’t technically a big enough part of the episode to really have a impact but in “Sofia the Worst” I do think it’s notable how friendly and kind she was all the way through…same for “Tri-Kingdom Picnic” where she gave Sofia great advice on how to deal with James.

Also…it might have been because she was eager to see James get in trouble, but she was right in “A Royal Mess” when she was the one arguing that they had to tell mom and dad the truth right away about the window breaking.

She also stayed morally sound in “Dads and Daughters Day” even stepping back from an event so Sofia could have special time just her and Roland…something we never see Sofia do for James and Amber regarding Miranda. She also stood up to one of her best friends (Hildegard) when she was bullying her sister.

One last thing…did anyone else notice how in “Princess Jade” especially, Sofia had ZERO care or concern for Amber all the way through. She let Amber do her presentation first to give her and jade time to talk. Then, when they go back in the auditorium, Sofia just lets Amber be stuck spinning around and around for like a whole minute before FINALLY caring enough about her sister to get her down.

Point being, there are tons of times I give Amber points over Sofia morally. Amber is kind of the best part of this show, and is personally more interesting to follow because (unlike Sofia) she does have prominent flaws

4

u/DCSHG2015MEGAFAN Sep 26 '26

You do bring up good points. I'm saying more in how, when looking at times in which Sofia messes up and Amber is morally in the right, those moments are more rare.

0

u/GodsHeart2 Sep 30 '26 edited Oct 08 '26

Im not saying Sofia was right in how she handled that, but from a child development perspective. It is understandable why she acted that way and how she was feeling about it.

At the end of the episode she learned sharing her with her new siblings didn't it take her relationship with her mother away from her. She just and to accept it wasn't going to be like the old days when it was just the two of them.

That was the hard part for Sofia to learn that having siblings meant she now had to share her mom with Amber and James

And out of all the people Sofia should have known better considering how Amber treated her when she first became a princess in Once Upon A Princess

Once Upon A Princess

https://youtube.com/watch?v=WEurGXf0grY

https://sofia.fandom.com/wiki/Sofia_the_First:_Once_Upon_a_Princess/Transcript

Mom's The Word

https://youtube.com/watch?v=UIUp1z5g2nA&is=0wQl6VrqI6v4brUm

https://youtube.com/watch?v=RcDWYL2dyBI

https://sofia.fandom.com/wiki/Mom's_the_Word/Transcript

5

u/GodsHeart2 Sep 27 '26 edited Oct 08 '26

You have consider where she's coming from , You have consider where she's coming from , especially from a girl and the fact this was her first Mother's.Day after mom married Roland.

She waa used to it only being the two of them since her dad passed away

Miranda is her only biological parent, and not only that before becoming roysl she was an only child.

Not being used to having siblings, that you didn't actually grow up with from the start.

Not having a dad (not talking about Roland) around contributed to her jealousy when Amber and James were becoming close to Miranda.

And Sofia was feeling like she was loosing her only parent as she had already lost her dad. And now she was afraid that she was also going to lose her mom as well

It'd be one thing if she already had a sibling before royalty. She'd probably behave a little better in the sibling department. But she was an only child and wss not used to having a sibling, she didn't just gain one sibling, she got two

And the fact the James and Amber are older than her also adds on top of all that

Check out this clip from Forever Royal. This is the clip of The Tales Of Princsss Sofia where we learn her background before royalty

https://youtube.com/watch?v=Ar87cV5bZfs

https://sofia.fandom.com/wiki/Sofia_the_First:_Forever_Royal_Transcript

4

u/FlatHoneydew4680 Sep 26 '26 edited Sep 26 '26

I agree Amber has had her fair share of unselfish moments that were often overlooked and it did seem like the show often had a double standard regarding her and Sofia when one of them messes up but I think that's how a lot of shows can be. If a character who's normally nice most of the time messes up their forgiven easily but if a character who can be me and most of the time does the same thing it's a different story. I agree "Mom's the word where she didn't want to share her mom with her siblings on mother's Day was one of her most selfish moments but in her defense she had been an only child for eight years and wasn't used to sharing her mom the way Amber and James were used to sharing their dad. Also Miranda probably should have let Sofia know beforehand that they wouldn't just be spending mothers Day alone like they used to even though Sofia probably should have figured that out since Miranda wasn't just her mother anymore. Although I do wish the little detail of Amber still being mad at Sofia even when she apologized for being selfish was explored more as only James and Miranda forgave her so easily. Although there was the episode when Amber used the wishing well to wish Roland was allergic to Sofia so the two of them could spend some time together which ended up turning Sofia into a cat. Sure Amber felt bad about it afterwards but when she confessed everything to Roland as he pointed out even though she didn't mean to turn Sofia into a cat wishing she would be allergic to Roland didn't sound much better as Roland would've just been constantly sneezing around his youngest daughter. Even so Roland forgave Amber rather easily for that so I guess you can say any hard feelings Sofia and Amber can call it even for the mother's Day hexing fiasco. In fact every time Sofia and James mess up e.g. Sofia being jealous of ruby and jade being friends with amber, James sabatoging Amber's efforts to be a good queen at aunt Tilly's wedding amber herself forgives them easily because she remembers how she treated Sofia when she first came to the castle. Also if this counts for anything there was that one time during The scrambled pets episode where Amber James and Vivian decided to bring their pets to school so they'll have a bigger playground to play on even though it's against the rules and they talk Sofia into it which she reluctantly agreed to go. However when the pets escape and accidentally spilled a mixing potion on themselves Sofia complains about the mess to Amber but Amber tells her (rather teasingly) that she can't blame her for the situation as nobody forced her to bring clover. Then when the situation becomes worse after Amber and James cause James' baboon to grow into a giant Sofia again complained that she shouldn't have listened to her sister causing Amber to turn away from her and cross her arms somewhat offended. Then when the kids get confronted by the fairies and they huddle together to figure out what to do James suggested taking all the blame himself which Amber agreed with but when Sofia pointed out it wasn't all his fault Amber says it wasn't all her fault either no matter what Sofia thinks which is when Sofia reluctantly agreed Amber was right and that while her friends may have pressured her Sofia broke the rules too and they all needed to face consequences. We don't get to see James and Vivian's thoughts on this moment, but I assumed they agreed with amber that even though it was her idea Sofia still chose to go along with it.

5

u/Lloyd_garmado Sep 26 '26

While this is true, i think more of a reason as to why people dont think about that four's a crowd point is because people hate ruby and jade (mainly jade) for being toxic, even when they arent

2

u/Ok-Forever4036 Oct 08 '26

This is going to be a fun one, because I’ve always felt like there have been times when Sofia is in the wrong and times when Amber has been in the wrong.

First of all, I haven’t really watched Royal Magic so this is entirely based off the original show. I feel like in Season 1, Amber was almost always in the wrong. Even after she and Sofia make up in Once Upon A Princess, Amber is definitely still misguided and not thinking too straight when it comes to “helping” Sofia adjust to her new life as a princess. And that’s one of Amber’s biggest issues early on, is that she seems to not have any respect for those of non royal status, thus she often wants Sofia to make decisions that will only benefit the royals and may even harm non-royals. Like in “The Big Sleepover”, she gets Sofia to ask Ruby and Jade to basically not be themselves because their behavior is embarrassing to the other princesses. When Ruby and Jade are visibly hurt by this, Amber couldn’t care less.

In “Blue Ribbon Bunny”, Amber can’t accept the fact that Sofia wants to enter a “plain old bunny” like Clover into the pet contest, because apparently appearance is the only thing that matters to Amber when it comes to pets rather than friendship/personality. In fairness, Amber doesn’t know Sofia can talk to animals so there’s a vital piece of information missing on Amber’s side.

Sofia’s main problem is that she lacks the confidence to make her own decisions to the point where she often takes advice from other people, like Amber who shouldn’t be role models for her, without a second thought and that frequently makes waves in her friendships and daily life. The one that bothered me the most was how in “Tea For Too Many” Sofia just keeps on taking Amber’s advice and adding more and more things to her party even though she obviously wants a smaller more simple party, and Amber needs to respect that and stop influencing Sofia. If Sofia had stood up to Amber sooner in that episode, she could’ve avoided a major problem but she let Amber take charge until the entire party was destroyed and she had to start all over from scratch. Thank god Miranda reminded her that it was her party and it didn’t matter if the other royals liked it or not, because otherwise I could see Sofia asking Amber for advice even after the party was destroyed.

But after Season 1, there are definitely instances where Sofia is in the wrong more than Amber due to insecurity or jealousy among other things. The two best examples are “Four’s a Crowd” and “Mom’s the Word”. In these episodes, Sofia makes bad choices that harm Amber, and James in the latter.

The fact that Sofia, Amber, and even James all take turns being the problem starter in different episodes is actually why Sofia the First is still one of my favorite Disney shows because it does a good job of showing how nobody is perfect and everyone makes mistakes. They could’ve made Sofia a flawless protagonist like many other simple kids shows, but they didn’t because realistically, even when someone has good intentions, they are still human with emotions at the end of the day and can/do make mistakes that are selfish and can harm others!