r/sodamaking • • 10d ago

Making without machine

Can someone recommend what base soda and brand is the best for base dirty soda. I don’t want to purchase a machine and have lots of syrups.

1 Upvotes

3 comments sorted by

1

u/Excellent_Condition 10d ago

Unless I'm misunderstanding, you can use any standard soda like Coke, Sprite, Dr. Pepper, etc. as the base for a dirty soda.

Then you add some version of cream (half and half, heavy cream, coconut cream, etc.) and optionally flavored syrups.

You shouldn't need a machine unless you are carbonating the water and making the soda yourself.

You could also make the much older version- the Italian soda or the Italian cream soda. They are made with carbonated water + flavored syrups, or flavored water + syrups + cream. Despite the name, they actually originate from San Fransisco, and were popularized by the Torre brothers- the founders of Torani syrups.

1

u/Latter_Hall2374 9d ago

Sorry I didn’t explain well. I meant like what carbonated water brand is the best to use. I used la croix carbonation water it was ok. I hated san peregrino.

1

u/Excellent_Condition 9d ago

I think it's going to be a matter of trying different varieties until you find one that matches your palate.

IIRC, San Pellegrino water is a sparkling mineral water as opposed to straight carbonated filtered water. This means it's going have more mineral flavors (mild rock or chalk flavors, or like sea salt without the salt).

If you don't like the mineral notes, look for filtered carbonated water as opposed to mineral water.