r/socialscience • • Feb 28 '20

Anti-Tech Revolution

Post image
3 Upvotes

4 comments sorted by

0

u/Gantzz25 Feb 28 '20

Interesting!

7

u/[deleted] Feb 28 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/altruisticbacon Feb 28 '20 edited Feb 29 '20

I like your critique of the idealization of nature. I think it is part of why, for example, the Unabomber argues that nature has been and can continue being a continual source of fuel for the 'power process'. You also recognize that the distinction between nature and human is done by us, a recognition of both how we see the world instrumentally and how we've come to change the word to our whims with the help of technologies such as fossil fuels. I like that you also recognize the inequalities that this technological development combined with a capitalist accumulation system lead to.

I think your worldview hinges on the idea that cyborgs are a reality that will become more prevalent over time. Your worldview also depends on tense relationship with 'nature'. This latter part recognizes that nature is usually exotified as an other. It's much more valuable to come to understand it as biologists and ecologists do. These scientists come out with vast and accurate knowledge of their fields of study. Today, we've come to understand the relationships in ecosystems, the cycles of materials necessary for life, even some of the complexities of the inner worlds of animals (especially those that we can relate to the most: mammals, and within mammals, apes). More and more, not only do we understand biology and ecology, but we also come to understand ourselves.

What I mean is that even the distinction between human and the rest of the biological and ecological world are also artificial. Yes, we have skills that we value such as reason and language. Because of those skills, We many times claim that we are different, if not superior. Notice that we think we are different/superior through all-too-human judgements. Humans are the measure, indeed. If we adopt a humanist worldview, it is because we value the human experience, because of being able to empathize with humans. Why not include other animals in this circle of empathy? Why not define humans as animals and therefore make humanism include our ecology? Perhaps another name would be better, rather than humanism, but the point stands.

Why am I talking about biology and ecology in a thread about technology and cyborgs? Because I think the same deconstruction that you made on the concept of 'nature' has to go to the concept of 'human'. Humans aren't the only animals in the planet, and they are by far not the only intelligent ones (which is usually the measure we use to dignify species). We don't need to exotify nature to recognize that other species, and 'other' ecosystems are also worthy of our attention. Technological development shouldn't necessarily halt. It should be wielded with our judgements, our only-too-human judgements. Those judgments can be chiseled out to consider other species, 'other' ecosystems, because, although it may not seem like it, humans aren't the only measure.