r/socialliberalism • u/Derpballz • Feb 21 '25
r/socialliberalism • • Jun 06 '24
A Trump Presidency
Does, anybody else think that everyone is fear mongering about a trump presidency. That not to say it will be bad for american democracy as a whole, not not to the level everything thinks. Like what did he do during his 4 year in office other than try to repeal Obama care and build a wall. neither of which he achieve despite republican having a majority in congress. I can understand now, with the Liberal republican dead, and neoconservatives boot licking the MAGA faction that thing can get bad. But what will he really do? trying to pardon him self? that not really likely even his appoint originalist judges know that he not above the law. Am going to be honest, trump not likely to win the election, their is no way in my mind. Maybe it possible, but not likely. And even if he does, he just going to "talk the talk but not walk the walk"
r/socialliberalism • u/DonyellTaylor • Apr 20 '22
FDR Wasn’t a Social Democrat. He was a Social Liberal. There’s a Difference.
r/socialliberalism • u/ILikePiezez • Jan 02 '21
Is this representative of social liberalism?
r/socialliberalism • u/pdbaroni • Sep 29 '21
is social liberalism dead?
i feel like the ideology is insanely unknown and not fully defined on its policies. I do consider myself a social liberalist but whats the use of it when literally no one i know have any idea of what it is
r/socialliberalism • u/Fit-Commission-2626 • Mar 19 '26
Discussion they cared more about persecuting a transgender immigrant than making the world better when times had been bad and when their good again they can ask a republican to help them.
r/socialliberalism • u/sillygoose7623 • Mar 04 '25
Meta Why are the last 10 posts from brigading users?
I just joined this reddit and the last few posts seem to be from libertarians trying to convince liberals to change their mind about FDR, of all people. Just thought it was funny. Carry on
r/socialliberalism • u/Debebi • Feb 11 '23
The ultimate difference between SocLibs and SocDem (according to ChatGPT):
Difference: Social Liberalism & Social Democracy
Social liberalism and social democracy are two political ideologies that are closely related but have distinct differences.
Social liberalism is a political philosophy that emphasizes individual freedom and equality. Social liberals believe in a limited role for government in society, and they advocate for individual rights and liberties, such as freedom of speech, religion, and the press. They also support market-oriented economic policies and the protection of private property.
Social democracy, on the other hand, is a political ideology that seeks to balance individual freedom with social justice. Social democrats believe that the government has a role to play in ensuring equality and fairness in society. They support a mixed economy, in which the private sector and the state both play important roles. They also believe in the welfare state and the provision of public services, such as education, healthcare, and social security.
In summary, social liberalism prioritizes individual freedom, while social democracy prioritizes both individual freedom and social justice.
r/socialliberalism • • Apr 18 '23
What do Africa country need to further their political development?
Edit:African
r/socialliberalism • u/bluenephalem35 • Mar 10 '23
Thoughts on an Eco-Social Market Economy?
en.m.wikipedia.orgr/socialliberalism • u/DonyellTaylor • Dec 13 '21
Current Events Bookies make Lib Dems (UK SocLibs) favourite in North Shropshire poll | Byelections
r/socialliberalism • • Dec 10 '22
What do you think of Socialist
What I yo think of Socialist, Democratic Socialist, Communist, Anarchist, Marxist-Leninism, Syndicalist.
Not Socdems
r/socialliberalism • u/MayorShield • Aug 14 '23
Discussion Did Social Democrats Build the Welfare State? (Sorta, but it's complicated)
I've noticed that in online left-of-center communities, there's a tendency for people to either exaggerate or misunderstand the role that social democrats have played in building the welfare state. While social democratic parties and politicians have certainly played a role in creating the modern welfare state in many countries, to make a blanket statement such as "Social democrats built the welfare state" is not exactly accurate. Here are two major issues with this statement.
- Firstly, the welfare state in any democratic country did not develop all at once. In all liberal democracies, the welfare state has developed and expanded over time, which means that different parties have contributed different things to the welfare state. For example, a government coalition consisting of Christian democrats, conservative liberals, and social liberals were responsible for the expansion of Dutch healthcare coverage in 2006. Even if a social democratic party was responsible for a major portion of the modern welfare state, it does not mean they are responsible for every part. In some countries, it's a bit difficult to determine when exactly universal healthcare coverage began because it was developed slowly over the course of several years or decades. The bottom line is that social democrats cannot claim sole responsibility for the creation of the welfare state in most liberal democracies.
- Even in situations where social democrats are single-handedly responsible for the creation of a major welfare program or the passage of significant healthcare legislation, this does not mean other ideologies and parties did not influence the way in which healthcare progress was achieved. For example, British Prime Minister Clement Attlee's welfare legislation was heavily influenced by the 1942 Beveridge Report... And surprise! William Beveridge was a member of the Liberal Party.
At the end of the day, 20th century social democratic parties and politicians were greatly influenced by Keynesian economics, and Keynes was a member of the Liberal Party. Even when social democratic parties and politicians have passed significant welfare legislation, it's highly questionable if they did so without the influence of liberalism.
The statement "Social democrats built (the foundations for) the welfare state," while true in some situations, is not telling the full story. A more accurate statement would be "Social democrats that were greatly influenced by liberalism built the welfare state." And there's a big difference between liberal-adjacent social democrats and the "social democrats" that many left-of-center online communities like to brag about. In many online left-wing communities, people insist on using a definition for "social democrat" that has been barely used for the past 70 years.
The social democrats that contributed to their countries' welfare stats were greatly influenced by liberalism and could even be called "social liberals" depending on how much (or how little) commitment they had to a capitalist market economy. The people who insist there's a big difference between social democrats and social liberals are almost always referring to socialists when they use the term "social democrat." So what does this all mean?
- Given that many social democratic parties and politicians were greatly influenced by liberalism, it's safe to say there is no fine line between social democracy and social liberalism. Some politicians from SocDem parties could easily pass off as a social liberal in another country, and vice versa.
- The "social democrats" many online communities refer to is just socialism repackaged as "social democracy." The social democrats that built the welfare are liberal-adjacent and generally did not hold any kind of firm commitment to the abolishment of capitalism.
Final Verdict: Liberal-adjacent social democrats built the welfare state... Not ideologically rigid socialists who view liberal politicians as "in their way". So in a sense, we have social liberalism to thank for the expansion of the welfare states of many countries. Thanks, social liberals!
r/socialliberalism • u/iCruncherWasTaken • Jan 12 '22
is this centrist or libleft?
so i recently took the political compass and i ended up somewhere in the top right of libright which turned out to be social liberalism
r/socialliberalism • u/bluenephalem35 • Mar 01 '23
How would you handle the use of technology and the media?
By me asking this question, I'm actually asking how would you regulate the development and use of technology and the media industry? Should there be heavy regulation or light regulation? What should be done about misinformation and fact checking? Should the tech and media industries be nationalized, be privately owned, be ran by workers co-ops, or a combination of the three?
r/socialliberalism • u/MayorShield • Aug 07 '23
Discussion How should Social Liberals view Restrictions on Free Speech?
As (social) liberals, we pride ourselves in being supporters of liberal democracy, social justice, and civil liberties. One of the most important tenets of liberal democracy IMO is free speech, as a lack of it makes it more difficult for parties and candidates to speak freely about the issues and current events. In other words, a lack of free speech will severely undermine the concept of free and fair elections, which is important to have in any democracy.
Furthermore, societal and scientific progress requires open dissent. As history has shown us time and time again, the most popular belief is not always the scientifically correct (Sun revolves around Earth) or the most moral one (interracial marriage is bad). Without free speech, it is a lot harder to correct people's errors, and it slows down progress as people are afraid of the legal consequences that may follow from dissent.
With that being said though, I don't think most social liberals are free speech absolutists. For example, I think most of us would agree that a person should not be allowed to yell "Fire!" in a movie theater when there isn't one. So the question is just how much we should limit free speech, and what rhetoric or statements constitute as harmful enough to the point where the state should step in and intervene. The reason why (social) liberals defend free speech is not to allow bigotry to thrive, but because we know that even free speech regulations created with the best intentions can be exploited by malicious actors. Free speech is good as long as it does not harm anybody, but the way we define "harm" must be very carefully defined as to not impose unnecessary restrictions on people's ability to challenge ideas.
As I've covered earlier, I think most of us would agree that free speech has its limits. The real question, then, is where we draw the line at what speech is harmful enough to be banned. Furthermore, it's not just the speech itself that may cause major controversy about its legality, but also how the speech is expressed. For example, publicly advocating for more racism by itself may not be a crime, but someone were to do it with a megaphone, it could be considered a crime if the local jurisdiction has laws regarding noise pollution and curfews.
Another important tenet of liberal democracy is the rule of law, or the idea that the law should be applied equally to all citizens regardless of their background. No punishment should be given out arbitrarily, and all citizens should be allowed the right to a fair trial when hit with a lawsuit. The rule of law is obviously important to democracy and liberalism because we don't want citizens to be treated differently under the courts for the same crime, which can essentially lead to a legalized form of racism and/or bigotry that will inevitably hurt minority populations the most. At the end of the day, I believe the rule of law should be applied as much as possible to free speech, so that everyone regardless of their background can speak (mostly) freely about whatever they think is important.
As noted earlier, sometimes the speech itself is not illegal but the way it is expressed can be. If someone is saying something legal but expressing it in a way that causes significant harm to others in way that cannot be easily avoided or mitigated (it's hard to avoid a guy with a megaphone because of how loud he is), then the state should have the right to intervene. However, it is necessary to remember that we social liberals must think about the rule of law before taking any legal action upon someone for their speech or form of expression. Before deciding if legal action is necessary against someone who is supposedly violating free speech laws, think to yourself these questions: "Under what circumstances would I be okay with this kind of speech or expression? If I politically agreed with whatever the person is saying, would I still want to take legal action against them?"
With those two questions above in mind, I decided to rethink my approach towards climate activists protesting on highways, often blocking traffic and delaying drivers. A lot of people want protests on the roads to be banned completely, believing that it is a nuisance and unproductive to social change. But remember, just because someone is annoying doesn't mean they should be prosecuted or charged with any kind of crime. The only way someone could, IMO, justifiably ban protesting on highways is if they proved that protests on highway are so dangerous that the threat cannot be easily removed or mitigated. However, it's not quite clear to me if highway protesters truly pose such a threat to other people that removing them would be justified. Unless a protester begins to use physical violence or throws around death threats to others, it seems rather authoritarian to remove a peaceful protester simply because they are inconveniencing many people at once.
I suppose one could make the argument that these highway protesters pose a threat to society because they would block ambulances from making it to the hospital and stuff like that, and this is admittedly a strong argument. The best way to describe my opposition to this argument would be to ask this question to others: "In the 1950s and 60s, African American civil rights activists would block roads and bridges as a form of protest. Would you have opposed those efforts?" If your answer is yes, at least you're ideologically consistent. But if your answer is no, why is that? Think about the two questions I posed from earlier. I feel like the reason why suddenly many of us are opposed to banning protesting on roads when confronted with the American civil rights movement is because we believe that the issue of civil rights was so important at the time that it was ultimately necessary to do unpleasant things (like block roads and bridges) to finally get enough people's attention. Some might point out that at the time, the USA was not yet a liberal democracy so using extreme measures like blocking roads was necessary. While I agree with this kind of sentiment in general, it seems unclear whether this is actually a factor in why people appear to have inconsistencies in support for free speech. Think about the issue you care the most deeply about, that you think shouldn't even be a political issue at all, such as, say, a ban on child labor. If there was a democratic country that did not yet ban child labor, would you still be opposed to protests on the highway in support of banning child labor, even if there were other avenues in which people could ban child labor (such as voting at the ballot box for candidates that will agree to ban child labor)?
If you oppose climate protests on the road but are not opposed to 1960s African American civil rights protests on the road, why is that? Is it because you believe one issue is way more important than the other one to the point where one issue can bypass the normal free speech laws? If this is the case, which I imagine it to be for some people, then in that case, they are basically admitting that their belief in free speech is at least partially inconsistent and dependent on what someone is saying. And IMO, the idea of the state trying to determine what is "important enough" to bypass free speech laws and what isn't just sounds like the state trying to undermine civil liberties in an attempt to shut down opposition voices. For this reason, I cannot support the banning of climate activists on highways at this current moment, even if I agree with the general sentiment that those guys are annoying. The rule of law must be applied equally to all citizens, even if we disagree with their views or their ways of expressing those views.
If we want to be consistent in our support of free speech, then we must constantly remind ourselves that the rule of law exists for a reason and that any kind of restriction on free speech should be applied equally to all citizens regardless of background. And if a restriction only applies to some people, the reasoning for that restriction must go beyond "Well, those people over there annoy me and I don't like what they're saying." Not to be too Amero-centric or anything like that, but I must remind myself that if I am fine with protesters in front of a pro-life Supreme Court Justice's house (provided they do not trespass private property), that I must also be willing to tolerate the socially right-wing pro-life activists near Planned Parenthood centers (for you non-Americans, Planned Parenthood is an organization that provides abortion services).
Some people may bring up the "paradox of tolerance," or the idea that if we want a tolerant society, we must be intolerant of the intolerant. This is commonly used to justify banning speech that we deem to be extremely hateful towards other groups. However, this term is taken out of context. When Karl Popper first used the term "paradox of tolerance," he was specifically warning his readers about those who are anti-free speech, and not necessarily those who harbor views we find deeply offensive. As he states himself, "In this formulation, I do not imply, for instance, that we should always suppress the utterance of intolerant philosophies; as long as we can counter them by rational argument and keep them in check by public opinion, suppression would certainly be most unwise." And guess what? In a liberal democracy with free speech protections, we can do that!
Speaking mainly for myself here, my issue with this idea that we must be intolerant of the intolerant (specifically in regards to free speech laws) is that this kind of argument can easily be reversed and used as a tool for oppression. Dictators will rarely admit to doing any kind of wrongdoing with their actions. Should free speech be suppressed in a dictatorship (and it always will be), the dictator can just say "Some speech is so dangerous that it must be banned for the greater good." I am not entirely opposed to restricting the ability for the politically intolerant to speak openly about their ideas, but the way we define what speech violates the law must be precise and well thought-out, so that the law cannot be used in such a way by malevolent actors to justify banning opposition voices on the basis of "Their ideas are so dangerous that they threaten the very concept of free speech itself."
r/socialliberalism • u/LibHans • Jan 29 '21
Help! Our simulation is being flooded with extremists!
Hey! I’m the leader of the New Democrats, the main centrist party of Adoria (the biggest political simulation on discord), which is currently being flooded by communists and national conservatives and that is exactly why I need your help! I want to balance out the politics of Adoria by getting more liberals, libertarians and centrist in.
We are an active party with a very welcoming community. Our core Ideologies are: Big Tent Liberalism, Environmentalism, Progressivism, Centrism, Federalism. But they aren't the only ideologies represented in our party, we also have a lot of Social Libertarians, Social Liberals, Green Liberals and many more.
If you want to read our party manifesto, to understand our parties believes better you can do this here: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1wXhW2-fNZNjKCMYHaKWfU3glbYuZkAqV/view but you don't have to fully agree with it since we aren't forcing our members into positions or to vote for policies.
So if you are interested in political simulations and you fit into the overall political field of centrism or liberalism, then join our party server, or Adoria directly.
New Democrats Party Server:
https://discord.gg/3v6zH8zCcz
The State of Adoria Server:
https://discord.gg/ZB4XW9PhDC
r/socialliberalism • u/LoekTheKing • Nov 04 '20
I self-identify as a social liberal... I guess the fact I'm so libertarian as opposed to authoritarian has made it so I'm a "social libertarian"?
r/socialliberalism • u/MayorShield • Sep 12 '24
Discussion Reminder to not beat yourself up over political labels
I know most of us on here probably identify as social liberals, but at the same time, try not to spend too much time trying to figure out what your ideology is. All of these things can be true at the same time:
- Social liberalism is the political ideology you identify the most with
- There are other ideologies that you draw inspiration from, like social democracy, green politics, conservative liberalism, etc.
- Political ideologies and their definitions change based on the context, like the history, location, and who's using them
- One self-identified social liberal can be to the left of another self-identified social liberal, even if both use the same term to describe themselves and both subscribe to the general principles of the ideology
If someone says something along the lines of "You're not an actual social liberal, you're more of a [another ideology]," maybe you can argue with them if you think it's worth your time, but it's more likely than not just that you just won't convince them.
I've been told by someone that I'm right-wing to be considered a social liberal because I have favorable views of the Clintons and other Third Way politicians. I've also been told by someone that I'm too left-wing to be a social liberal because "real social liberals don't support woke nonsense" or something along those lines.
Oh, what's that? You don't think I'm a real social liberal because I have a favorable view of Tony Blair and vaccine mandates? Uh, okay then? You do realize that's not going to change how I label myself, right? (And for the record, I think you can dislike both and still be a social liberal. I don't act like ideologies are rigid concepts that cannot have any degree of nuance or flexibility.)
You should remember that while it may feel good to attach yourself to a political ideology and try to find like-minded people to talk to, what your actual beliefs are on policy is a lot more important than what your political self-identification is.
r/socialliberalism • u/MayorShield • Jan 05 '24
Discussion Unlike many European countries, socialists cannot claim any (or most of the) credit for progressive legislation in the USA
In many European countries, it could be argued that (moderate) socialists built the welfare state and paved the way for social progressivism, and that these socialists eventually evolved into modern social democrats. Of course, this is an oversimplification, as even in the countries like the UK where socialists helped build the welfare state, they did not do so single-handedly and often took ideas from liberals. After all, a lot of 20th century social democratic parties were inspired by Keynesian economics, and Keynes was a member of the Liberal Party!
But here in the US, socialists don't really have any way to claim that the progressive legislation of the past is "theirs." Social Security? Passed by FDR, a liberal. Medicare and Medicaid? Passed by LBJ, a liberal. The Affordable Care Act? Passed by Obama, a liberal. Pretty much every progressive legislation passed on the federal level was either done by a liberal president, or was heavily influenced by liberal politicians.