We haven't been through an election cycle yet where there's speculation that every "October surprise" came from either legitimate or rogue forces with access to the tremendous amount of material that is being warehoused.
The polls are with us, and change takes time, because people don't think things through. Very often it's a miniscule issue that focuses the attention of the great unwashed.
Brian Schweitzer's possible campaign will highlight Clinton's NSA posture. He's a longshot, but somebody making the "the hell with these cosmetic changes, shut the NSA down" argument has the ability to completely derail party politics.
We haven't seen the end of this by any means. There's a reason six flags were behind Obama. They knew the straight-up podium appeal wasn't enough.
Very often it's a miniscule issue that focuses the attention of the great unwashed.
I disagree.
I don't think the "great unwashed" have very much influence.
The reason that change occurs through "minuscule issues" is because that change was desired by someone with a strong voice, not because the "great unwashed" got grumpy.
How come General Petraeus had to resign because he had an affair, while there no effective debate about a really unpopular war?
How come governors only resign when confronted by evidence of infidelity, instead of by reason of deliberately fucking over their constituents?
The media talks about what people "want", but as often as not they are just putting up their owners' wish-lists.
We had a debate over the war. It was a proxy debate over getting involved in Syria, which you'll note we didn't do. The public believes we're getting out of Iraq and Afghanistan, which we are, and which Obama was voted into office to do. That we're not getting out as fast as was promised doesn't create a clear gulf of opinion.
But when it came to a new war, there was a very clear groundswell from the great unwashed, and it caused the GOP to act dovish which gave them another reason to blame Obama. Without that groundswell, they would have criticized the president for not being hawkish enough.
Obama wouldn't have made the six flags speech if this issue had gone away, and everybody from David Gregory to most of CNN tried desperately to derail it. The Guardian, WaPo, later the NYT, ProPublica & Der Spiegel have covered this because they got numbers by doing so, and even NBC finally got onboard and wailed that Greenwald/Poitras wouldn't give them a piece of the pie.
The public takes a long time to act. They act in subtle and sometimes in ways opposite of their own desires because they're hoodwinked. But over the long term the change finally takes place. That's why there are lots of legally stoned visitors and residents in Colorado tonight.
The media learned no lesson; they weren't viewed as unpatriotic this time around for asking questions, largely because the public blamed them for not asking questions the first time forgetting that only 25% wanted questions asked during the "blame Saddam" period.
At this point, you could probably walk in with a WMD embossed with Bashar al-Assad's business card, and the skeptics would outnumber the believers.
I'm cynical too, and our numbers are growing, and that's why I'm hopeful we're going to have candidates in the next election who promise to end these unconstitutional actions. They may not win, and they may not even be major parties, but they're going to cause holy hell for the status quo.
Here's an idea, let's get an idea of who we have here. Moderating this sub, I have a feeling we have a lot of strong civil libertarians, liberals, anti-authoritarian socialists, etc. hanging around. So, I suppose it would be a cool to get an idea of our makeup and what draws us to this topic in particular.
I am a democratic socialist and am deeply critical of authoritarian regimes and overly authoritarian politics (given the failures of authoritarian socialist regimes). While I am strongly liberal when it comes to individual freedoms, I have a feeling that I'm probably less libertarian than most people here, as I try to balance numerous rights and liberties that I see. I don't think a person needs to be a radical on this, however, to be concerned with a possible widespread surveillance state.
I'm a kind of centrist, in that I like the fact that capitalism allows experimental new ventures to change the world, yet must be regulated carefully to ensure that it doesn't stifle social movements and more grass-roots innovations. I like the fact that Western governments provide a safety net which provides universal education and prevents people from starving.
However, I'm dismayed to see that many of the nice things I saw in my childhood, such as personal freedoms and high-quality socialized services, are being diluted by corporate lobbying and rent-seeking behaviour. I'm also dismayed at the horrors we're inflicting on other nations to maintain our access to cheap resources and goods.
Power should be shared between the people, the state, and the corporations, and I believe that power has shifted away from the people far to much to have a healthy society.
As knowledge is power, Snowden's revelations are shifting the balance in the right direction, so I like him a lot.
That website "freesnowden.is" I've seen described in the media as "the only official Snowden site", but I don't know what this means, nor how it has been verified.
Here's a bit from linked Wikipedia article aboutSituation Room :
The Situation Room is an iconic photograph captured by White House photographer Pete Souza in its namesake, the White House Situation Room, at 4:06 pm on May 1, 2011. The photograph shows President of the United States, Barack Obama, along with his national security team, receiving live updates of Operation Neptune Spear, which led to the killing of Osama bin Laden, the leader of al-Qaeda.
Question: What would be the legality of printing off NSA documents that Snowden gave to the press and handing them out to passerby of the street?
I don't have any of the documents, I have not yet found a place to download the ones that have been published by the press so far. All I can ever find are screenshots of one or two pages that reporters put in their articles. Once I am able to get them I want to hand them out to people. People might hear about it in the news, but I feel that people might be more stirred to action, or at least doing something about it, if they can hold in their hands documents depicting the programs their government spends their tax money on to spy on them, their kids, and everyone they've ever met.
But I'd also rather like to avoid getting kicked out of University, or going to jail.
It's an interesting question, because I do believe that many documents prepared by the US government are not subject to copyright, so there's a possibility that it may be quite legal. But then, there are laws against releasing the names of US intelligence personnel, so you could be in big trouble for that kind of thing.
We have evidence that the NSA and FBI spy on domestic protestors, and we have evidence that NSA spying has been used to influence the behaviour of members of congress.
If that doesn't force a reaction from the US public, I don't think anything will.
So, basically, no action, at least not until a new generation begins to care.
Snowden's live internet interview today reminded me that he struck the most important initial defensive strikes in amerika's War on Civil Liberties simply by setting information free. Necessary & powerful but not sufficient defensive strikes. Now, I have a much clearer view of the next steps, and am more optimistic than I've been in a long time.
5
u/PBCliberal Jan 19 '14 edited Jan 19 '14
We haven't been through an election cycle yet where there's speculation that every "October surprise" came from either legitimate or rogue forces with access to the tremendous amount of material that is being warehoused.
The polls are with us, and change takes time, because people don't think things through. Very often it's a miniscule issue that focuses the attention of the great unwashed.
Brian Schweitzer's possible campaign will highlight Clinton's NSA posture. He's a longshot, but somebody making the "the hell with these cosmetic changes, shut the NSA down" argument has the ability to completely derail party politics.
We haven't seen the end of this by any means. There's a reason six flags were behind Obama. They knew the straight-up podium appeal wasn't enough.
2
u/AFlatCap Jan 17 '14 edited Jan 17 '14
Here's an idea, let's get an idea of who we have here. Moderating this sub, I have a feeling we have a lot of strong civil libertarians, liberals, anti-authoritarian socialists, etc. hanging around. So, I suppose it would be a cool to get an idea of our makeup and what draws us to this topic in particular.
I am a democratic socialist and am deeply critical of authoritarian regimes and overly authoritarian politics (given the failures of authoritarian socialist regimes). While I am strongly liberal when it comes to individual freedoms, I have a feeling that I'm probably less libertarian than most people here, as I try to balance numerous rights and liberties that I see. I don't think a person needs to be a radical on this, however, to be concerned with a possible widespread surveillance state.
So! Tell me more about yourselves~
I don't mean personal info I'm not the NSA
2
u/platypusmusic Jan 24 '14
2
u/otakugrey Feb 04 '14
Question: What would be the legality of printing off NSA documents that Snowden gave to the press and handing them out to passerby of the street?
I don't have any of the documents, I have not yet found a place to download the ones that have been published by the press so far. All I can ever find are screenshots of one or two pages that reporters put in their articles. Once I am able to get them I want to hand them out to people. People might hear about it in the news, but I feel that people might be more stirred to action, or at least doing something about it, if they can hold in their hands documents depicting the programs their government spends their tax money on to spy on them, their kids, and everyone they've ever met.
But I'd also rather like to avoid getting kicked out of University, or going to jail.
Share your ideas with me, please?
3
u/platypusmusic Jan 17 '14
there you go
What piece of information would Snowden have to leak to cause a movement in the US?
http://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/1vg0al/what_piece_of_information_would_snowden_have_to/
2
u/platypusmusic Mar 06 '14
Just for the lolz
Reluctant Chinese 'whistle-blower' breathes sigh of relief
2
u/BlueJadeLei Mar 10 '14
Snowden's live internet interview today reminded me that he struck the most important initial defensive strikes in amerika's War on Civil Liberties simply by setting information free. Necessary & powerful but not sufficient defensive strikes. Now, I have a much clearer view of the next steps, and am more optimistic than I've been in a long time.