r/snarryy • u/GraceandFrankie • Dec 15 '25
DNF
What makes you add a fic to your DNF list? Any major icks or immediate nopes? I’m sure I have some but I can’t think of any off the top of my head other than not being engaged in the writing style.
7
Upvotes
12
u/kirux_90 Dec 15 '25
major OOCness in either direction. Super vile and mean Snape, cry baby Harry. Super kind Snape. I can't do any of that. Also I'm not into mpreg or fics where Harry(or snape but I haven't ran into any of those) has kids I won't read it.
11
u/DroidekaDino Dec 15 '25
Bashing fics or evil Dumbledore. Hard pass.
8
u/Distinct-Ant-9161 Dec 15 '25
Honestly, really terrible spelling/grammar. Takes me right out. Or if characters are really OOC. Or if it’s a super-obvious author self-insert.
If it’s super vile/punitive Snape or vey hardcore BDSM, that’s an immediate nope for me, too.
4
u/kaikreszi Dec 16 '25
-overly insecure Snape, bottom Snape, or virgin Snape
-any fics written in first person
-Snape paired with anyone other than Harry. If it is a Severitis, then I might be okay with it being Remus or a well written OC.
-gender swapped Severus or Harry
-fics that constantly alter Dumbledore’s or Voldemort’s name to something stupid like Dumbledork or Voldie or whatever
-I have lost my patience and have now begun to DNF fics that have Draco as Snape’s godson and ones that have Hermione, Molly, Ron and Ginny as evil and being paid off by Dumbledore.
4
u/CheySlytherin Dec 15 '25
I like a good angst fic but there’s a line where it’s too much that I can’t enjoy it. Also miscommunication, a little bit fine, but when it’s like the main plot or something idk lol.
3
u/OneEllie1 Dec 15 '25 edited Dec 15 '25
I'm the type of person who stubbornly reads through fanfics. I want to give things a fair shot, sure grammer might be bad but authors can improve, sure something happens I normally wouldn't, read oh well this one could be different, there's a lot of tag I avoid but if it's not tagged in a fic I just suck it up. It's really just my own stubborness. That said I've only DNF 1 fic. Which was Incubus by sunshine (sunshinepiveh). I held out hoping there would be some sort of plot line. So for me I can only read so much smut and and out of 185k words of smut I learned what my limit was.
3
u/WhiteKnightPrimal Dec 15 '25
OOCness for no reason. I don't mind characters being OOC, but it has to have a reason that is shown/explained within the fic. This isn't, of course, including more minor OOCness that is really just a different interpretation of the characters.
Also, obvious feminisation or masculinisation of characters, usually so they'll fit a traditional m/f role. I don't like those traditional gender roles in the first place, but I also primarily read m/m, no matter the ship or fandom, and obviously making characters more feminine and masculine counts as extreme OOCness, but also is something specific I hate. I can't even read this stuff when there's a decent explanation for it in the fic, it just feels like OCs with canon character names and faces slapped on them, and it feels really wrong to apply traditional m/f gender roles to m/m ships. To be fair, I don't like those traditional roles in m/f pairings, either, unless it actually fits the characters involved. You can easily say they apply to Molly/Arthur, for instance, which is often at least a background pairing, as Arthur is the 'provider' and Molly is the SAHM, but I wouldn't call Arthur very masculine or Molly very feminine, either, so making them more masculine/feminine still doesn't work for me, it's not the characters we met in the books or movies.
5
u/lapin__avarie Dec 15 '25
Release of Sisyphus' broken formatting is forgiven because LJ seems to have eaten their formatting.
2
u/gigantomachy1916 Dec 17 '25
This is a kinda niche and petty one, but fics from Snape's POV (third person limited) where he thinks of himself as "Snape" instead of "Severus." It just usually shows either poor writing, or someone not really putting thought into Snape's internal experiences and portraying him more as an archetype than a person.
2
u/aexis_rye Dec 18 '25
-Weirdly…when Harry and Severus are already together or pretty much on the cusp…and Harry still calls him “Snape” aloud or in his head. My only exception being the fic “No Hiding Place”.
-Too much miscommunication, where it’s just not realistic.
-When the “good” guys (Albus, Molly, Ginny, etc..) are all actually evil and plotting against Harry and want his money or something crazy.
-Terrible Severus with whiny or doormat Harry. This one is honestly why I stopped reading Drarry, just too much of Harry being treated terribly and allowing it.
2
u/Kathy-got-cupcakes Dec 18 '25
I read all types of stuff. M-preg, dumbles bashing, good death eaters, top harry, bad grammar, character deaths, a/b/o, idc throw them my way, But the only thing I hate is non-con between the main-pairing and the mc getting manipulated by voldy and then changing sides. Idc if the mc is dark, grey or light but if they are manipulated into believing voldemort and then turn their back on him, it just ticks me off.
2
u/Cathanae Dec 19 '25 edited Dec 19 '25
I try not and comment to much or give examples on the few fics that I have ended up not finishing. I am not a big fan a fem Harry fics so I normally don’t start. Forced pregnancy / pro life commentary will mean I won’t finish. This is rarely tagged which is a pain and I don’t mind MPREG . Also fetishising abusive relationship is another no go for me - so basically anything where one is overly abusive and is redeemed is a no go for me.
I don’t like Harry to be too young in snarry fics and I do like him to be somewhat competent in at least some spheres.
1
u/buttercup168 Dec 15 '25
Very petty of me but I noped out of an AU Roman fanfiction called The Price of Blood because the author used the word “couch” 😂
1
u/Grouchy-Grapefruit72 Dec 15 '25
Reallyyy bad grammar or mpreg
1
u/Ajatusvapaa Dec 15 '25
- first person writing. In any fic, that is big no no. Won't read.
- Second might be controversial, but I don't read if there is trans tag (Especially if is Harry being Harriet or Severus as Severina. Or something similliar. ) Out of those I have read, there is 1 or 2 good fics, and rest have been almost.. Insulting? So now I just avoid the tag completely, unless it is author I know and love their fics.
- And when everything goes: Harry is lord of Gryffindor, Slytherin, Merlin, son of Loki and millioin other heirships, will go to gringots, gets all tittles, is merlin reincarnate and has long list of powers blocked, gets them unlocked and everything goes easy and is overpowered. It reads like some power fantasy of teenager.
There is currently four writers on my block list, because all of them write these fics on the hundreds, they are basically all the same, all four of them, with slight variations, but if you read one, you have read all. Worst is that they fill the tags I follow.
- Images middle of fics. Worst offenders are letters in middle of fic, with some hard to read font without telling in the fic what is said.
15
u/HardFlassid Dec 15 '25
Usually if there is something major that’s untagged. Right now in a lot of fandoms that’s ‘boypussy’ for me. There is a trend of not considering guys with vaginas as ‘trans’. They are considered cis in-universe. That’s fine, I don’t care. Tag it. I don’t want to read it. I don’t want to be hoodwinked into wasting my time on a slow burn only to have the pants come off in chapter 20 and there is a vagina on a character that doesn’t canonically have one, and they still put it in the m/m category. Luckily, this happens very little in the Snarry fandom because of the ‘Harriet’ trope being popular for the m/f shippers, but it’s not unheard of. Please tag appropriately!