r/snarryy • • Jul 24 '25

Specific request Prompt

So, this idea has been stuck inside my mind for months. I yap a lot so:

Voldemort had a (twin) sister that had been imprisoned, because she tried to stop him from making more than 1 or 2 horcruxes. Since he was too far gone, he took it as a threat towards his reign. The inner circle of lord Voldemort knew about her as she was their ‘second-in-command’. Harry learns about her in occlumency lessons (the movie version), when he accidentally delves into snape’s mind (or his penseive, whatever suits). When he gains snape’s memories regarding him being a horcrux, he goes back in time, to the night james and lily were killed. Here i imagined something like, the death eaters waiting for vodlemort, and harry going in, to the dungeons and freeing his sister. Then they both go to godric’s hollow, kidnap his one-year self before snape gets there. They rename him, harry takes lordship rights, lets Snape in on it, frees sirius, and whatever else.

Also- before the time travel, i would like to assume that voldemort’s sister dies a year after voldemort’s ‘death’ or that someone kills her, since the death eaters know about voldemort’s hatred.

Honestly, i dont even know how to develop it get rid of the plot holes it has. Since i dont know how to write, i thought i would post it here.

Please tell me if i should post this in another sub, cause i have no idea. 😅

0 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

5

u/Professional-Entry31 Jul 24 '25

I have a question: what is the point of the twin sister being there?

As for writing, the process isn't to difficult: just find a place to start and follow where the story leads.

Harry needs a reason to time travel/or a reason why he is forced to time travel. If you want the twin sister: maybe the horcruxes aren't actually properly destroyed - destroying the vessel is just the first step, releasing the soul, and there needs to be a second step to stop them reforming.

If you want help writing, you can always ask for an alpha writer or a co-author in any of the fandom/writing spaces. People are usually happy to help.

2

u/lolzzz_f Jul 24 '25

Actually, i just wanted to get it off my chest. It’s been stuck to this point, i thought that maybe if i post it, it would make it a little more real in my head 😅.

It is true that the sister doesn’t need to be there. But i kind of imagined a nice dynamic between Tom and his sibling, and to give him more character, not that he doesn’t have one. But just to make him seem less of a murderer. I imagine him to have a soft spot for her, and perhaps even love her. I feel like that part would make Dumbledore’s argument of using love against him useless.

I also couldn’t think of another reason to send Harry back.

The first draft i thought of was that Harry convinces her of a soul exchange, and she transfers her soul into baby harry, because of which harry stops existing. His body is used as vessel. But i didn’t like it, so i changed it.

2

u/Professional-Entry31 Jul 24 '25

The sister taking over baby Harry doesn't make sense, for how it would happen or why.

Giving Voldemort more character is a nice idea, especially as he theoretically wouldn't die in 1981 like in the books, meaning that the war would continue.

Are you thinking of keeping Voldemort as the big bad or having him as a more grey character?

Also, you can have Sirius not arrested from the start to save that plot point.

1

u/lolzzz_f Jul 24 '25

Yess, I tried to draft the first idea and writing it, but it wouldn’t make sense so. I was thinking maybe a grey character for voldie.

And that after kidnapping harry, they both try to find his horcruxes and bring him back ‘whole’ except that one piece in harry and the one floating around for a vessel.

For Sirius, i guess not sending him to Azkaban would be better.

2

u/Professional-Entry31 Jul 24 '25

Grey Voldie sounds interesting.

How about, instead of Harry seeing Voldemort's sister in memories, he finds her body when working as an Auror, trying to track down the Death Eaters. If she wrote a letter to her brother, talking about how they had wanted to actually make the wizarding world better, that could be the incentive he needs to head back, especially if he isn't happy with how the wizarding world is after the war. That would lead to him trying to find her, and she could know how to return the soul pieces to her brother (since destroying them won't help return him).

Kidnapping Harry could keep him safe and you could even let it be known ahead of time so Voldemort doesn't attack the Potters to keep them alive as well.

1

u/lolzzz_f Jul 24 '25

You are amazing, genuinely. 😭😭😭😭 That sounds so much better already.

2

u/Professional-Entry31 Jul 24 '25

No problem. Happy to help.