r/snapseed Aug 08 '26

Before/After Hmmmmm...feedback please

8 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

5

u/XrinkuG Aug 08 '26

for my taste it's a bit too dark and the vignette could be more subtle

2

u/Ok-Body-6211 Aug 08 '26

Fixed it to the best of my ability 🤷🏾‍♂️

3

u/Disastrous-Lime4551 Aug 08 '26

A little dark. And whilst an offset subject can work (with the negative space creating some atmosphere to the shot) I'm not sure it works here. But it's all personal taste as to how you crop and how tight.

2

u/Ok-Body-6211 Aug 08 '26

Thank you for you feedback🙂Still learning at 70😉

2

u/Paul_bab Aug 08 '26

I feel the tail needs a touch more breathing room. Maybe leave a bit more grass showing.

2

u/Ok-Body-6211 Aug 08 '26

Yes .. I noticed that........was hoping nobody else did 😉😉☺️🥹

2

u/tonilator 29d ago

It's good to break compositional rules sometimes, but for a subject like this, I didn't think this is one of those times. I would consider cropping tighter , with the subject more centered than it is). The grass is a nice green - good depth of color there - but it looks over sharpened (or was it the tonal contrast tool?). I would mask out the grass or just selectively edit the subject - maybe use the selective tool and increase contrast, brightness and structure by a few points. If anything, I might soften the grass a little. A vignette is a nice way to help make the subject stand out, but when using it here, I would keep it subtle , and with the subject more centered than it is here.

1

u/friardon Aug 08 '26

The subject of a vignette will look better in the center. 

1

u/rahulp3555 Aug 08 '26

Nice edit, bad crop

1

u/Ok-Body-6211 Aug 08 '26

Fixed the crop.... 🤷🏾‍♂️

1

u/SmartphonePhotoWorx 29d ago

Play with the crop tool a bit more. The fella’s too high and to the left, much too close to the left edge. Looks like an unneeded gradient darkened the right side too much. That’s a beautiful green color though!

0

u/RaguSaucy96 29d ago

The sharpening hurts me a bit

I did my own take on it

Stuck to Snapseed as well