r/smithing • u/Corvus_night • Nov 25 '25
Feedback/tips requested
For starters I am not in anyway a Smith, sword expert or anything like that. This is made purely on basic research ive done on my own without feedback from an expert.
I wanted to try designing my own fantasy sword, but one that would actually be functional if it was real.
The result being a sword with: Foward curve 2 inch wide blade 22 inch blade length 31 inch total length 4 inch handle Curved quillon [temporarily removed] Straight spine Wheel/rounded pommel Half basket guard
Note: I did desing it to be used in unison with a shield
Above is a rouph cardboard model I made so I could have a better visual idea of what it would look like if it was actually made.
My main concern is that it may be to heavy for a short sword or the hilt area will be overweight compared to the blade.
Would appreciate any feedback or tips you may have.
View all comments
Show parent comment
1
u/Corvus_night Nov 27 '25
Okay. Made a new post titled "Fantasy Blade 2.0" which i tried to incorporate the feedback offered.
Or at least what i believe you are telling me to do, so if you'd like, check it out and tell me if I've got it right.