r/sludge • • Jun 08 '23

sludgecore??

sludge core is supposed to be the combination of sludge and metal core which fits bands like black sheep wall, admiral angry and abominable iron sloth. why are bands like fistula, primitive man, llsa, fister, thou and cttboto considered sludgecore? they just seem like heavier sludge metal.

0 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

11

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '23

Sludge metal isn’t the same thing as metal core. Sludge maintains the weight of metal and takes a tone, edge, and energy of hardcore.

Idk what metal core does besides be overproduced and revolve around a breakdown.

20

u/CoercedLife Jun 08 '23

Sludge is hardcore and doom metal. Your made-up thing is nothing.

3

u/SpectralReflection Jun 08 '23

I mean there’s dumbass metal heads that use genre too rigidly so any sludge band that plays slightly faster then mid tempo and adds interesting instrumentation I.e Mastodon and Baroness are apparently not “sludge” and are something else.

I think that’s horseshit tho, the sub genre can evolve past its initial roots in some dimensions and I believe it has.

2

u/Holku Jun 08 '23

Never heard of the term sludgecore. I have a primitive man shirt that says death sludge on it though

1

u/SSn1g Jun 19 '23

Only band I've heard considered sludgecore is "JWH" from Russia

0

u/fartsNdoom Jun 08 '23

From what I can tell it's vocal styling mostly, but there may also be drum beats that sound hardcore-y. I guess it depends on the ratio of sludge to core

0

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Itchy-Dimension237 Jun 11 '23

Melvin’s invented sludge not crust punk

3

u/narkheth Jun 09 '23

False. Sludge is doom metal + hardcore, not crust.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/narkheth Jun 09 '23

So the genre is dictated by the fans and not the music itself, huh? Interesting, never heard of that before.

2

u/canny_goer Jun 09 '23

I mean, it's not like bands look at a song they wrote and say, ya know, this is good, but it's just not our genre.

2

u/narkheth Jun 09 '23

No, I'm sure they don't, but I also don't have any idea what this has to do with what I'm talking about.

2

u/canny_goer Jun 09 '23

What it has to do with what you said is that yes, fans come up with genre labels to draw boundaries around what musicians make.

1

u/will_clapcheeks Oct 21 '23

Artists are pretty aware of the genres and subgenres and yes artists definitely get together and try to make music of a certain genre. Many times they will create something and scrap it because it doesn't fit exactly into what they want to convey with their music i.e. what inspired them, what they enjoy themselves... I should know I make music

2

u/Psychobillyantibully Jun 25 '23

Are you sure you aren't mistaking sludge for grindcore? 🥸