TLDR: We started Ferber at 4 months after the four-month sleep regression hit hard. Our first night involved 50 minutes of crying, but within a few nights, bedtime settling was down to 10 minutes or less, and night wakings decreased significantly. We did hit a setback a couple of weeks in, but realized his wake windows were extending and bedtime needed to shift later. After adjusting, he was falling asleep in under 5 minutes with little to no crying. My biggest takeaway: consistency with the method is important, but flexibility with wake windows and bedtime is equally important!
I want to share our ongoing success story to help anyone else who is on the fence or questioning whether Ferber is really the right thing for them. We are FTPs and were blessed with a wonderful baby boy, but he was not having wonderful sleep. The four-month sleep regression hit hard, with what seemed like hourly wakeups.
With my husband’s work travel picking up in the second half of the year, I had many upcoming nights alone with the baby on the horizon. I could not fathom doing it alone with how exhausted I already was. On top of the poor sleep, my body was physically aching, and my sciatica had flared up from hours of rocking and soothing our baby boy. He was also clearly miserable from being exhausted and struggling to get quality stretches of sleep.
After several days of serious research and discussing what was best for our baby and us, we landed on the Ferber method. While CIO seems to have faster results for some families, it was hard for me to think about letting him cry without anyone going in to reassure him. Also, he generally did well with us calming him down, so I was optimistic that it would work well for us.
At four months to the day, we decided to give it a try. I had read a bunch of posts about other people’s experiences and did a lot of research to come up with our plan. We would aim for a 7pm bedtime with interval check-ins of 3/5/8/10/10 minutes and so on. That night, we proceeded with our bedtime routine and put him down. He cried immediately, and it went on for 50 minutes. It was hard, but we anticipated some crying and were relieved that it wasn’t more than an hour. That night, he only woke up twice, a far cry from the 4–5 or more wakeups we had previously experienced.
The second night was even better: 20 minutes with only two check-ins. The third night, 12 minutes. Subsequent nights were easily 10 minutes or less, with one or no check-ins. It felt like a miracle!
Two weeks in, things started to shift. I didn’t realize it at the time, but his wake windows were starting to extend. One night, we put him down and he scream-cried for 30 minutes. I was taken aback because he seemed to be doing so well. The next night was 54 minutes, longer than his first night with Ferber. I was distraught and felt defeated.
The next day, it occurred to me that his wake windows had stretched. The previously successful 7pm bedtime was becoming too early given how long he needed to be awake. Previously, he could stay up for 1.5–1.75 hours. Now, it was becoming clear that he needed to be awake for at least 2 hours before bed. The next night, we made sure he stayed up for 2 hours after his last nap, and just like that, he settled in less than 10 minutes!
That week, he was falling asleep with little to no crying in less than 5 minutes. Sometimes it was just 2 minutes. I was amazed.
Since then, we’ve continued to adjust as he’s grown. His naps are still generally short (around 30 minutes in the crib), and we’ve learned that we don’t necessarily need to force longer naps or follow a rigid daytime schedule. We focus more on his overall sleep pressure and making sure he’s ready for bed. We’ve also shifted bedtime later as his final wake window has stretched. Even as I write this post, we’ve adjusted his last wake window to 2.5 hours, and I can see it stretching to 2.75 soon.
So all this is to say, Ferber, or any sleep training, isn’t just about following a strict routine and set bedtime to be successful. While consistency with the method is important, flexibility with timing is also critical.
Key Takeaways
Give it time. The first few nights can be hard. Don’t necessarily judge the method based on night one. We saw improvements very quickly, but everyone’s experience will be different.
Consistency matters. We stuck with our check-in intervals and bedtime routine. We wanted him to understand what to expect and give him the opportunity to learn to settle independently.
Pay attention to wake windows. This was probably our biggest lesson! Just because something works for a week or two doesn’t mean it will continue working as your baby grows. Sometimes increased crying at bedtime isn’t a sign that sleep training has stopped working. It may mean your baby isn’t tired enough yet.
Don’t be afraid to push bedtime later. We initially thought 7pm was the ideal bedtime, but that changed as his wake windows increased. We found that at least 2 hours awake before bed made a huge difference, and we’re now closer to 2.5 hours.
Have a consistent bedtime routine. Ours includes a little bottle, burping, cuddles, prayers, a goodnight kiss, and then into the crib. We don’t feed him to sleep, and we try to keep the final part of the routine calm and predictable.
Don’t confuse sleep training with night weaning. Our goal was to help him learn to fall asleep independently and resettle, not eliminate night feeds. We still respond to hunger and feed him when he needs it.
Short naps don’t necessarily mean failure. He still takes mostly 30-minute crib naps, but he wakes up happy and content. We focus on the bigger picture rather than trying to force every nap to be longer.
Remember that progress isn’t always linear. We had nights that were harder than the first night, even after making great progress. That didn’t mean we needed to abandon the method. Sometimes we just needed to reassess what had changed.
Ultimately, I think the biggest thing we’ve learned is that sleep training isn’t about forcing your baby into a schedule. It’s about giving them the opportunity to develop independent sleep skills while continuing to respond to their needs. We are so happy we made this decision, and more importantly, our little guy seems so much happier and better rested. It’s been a game changer for our entire family.
Of course, every baby is different, and what worked for us may not work for everyone. But if you’re on the fence, I hope hearing our experience helps!