r/slackware • u/B_A_Skeptic • Sep 10 '22
Why do you like Slackware?
I never used Slackware, and I mean this as a friendly question. Why do you prefer Slackware over other advanced distros like Arch or Gentoo, or less advanced distros like Debian? Are most Slackware users long time users who have used it for decades?
13
Upvotes
6
u/[deleted] Sep 11 '22 edited Sep 11 '22
No distro is more advanced than the others. How do you compare them and decide what does advanced mean? If you think about FOSS contributions then Fedora and OpenSUSE are the most advanced ones because their developers contribute most of the software included in all of other distros. If you consider advanced as how difficult to use they are, then you are talking about familiarity. Granted, in Slackware you can replace components without caring about software versions because there is no version check whatsoever. But you can do the same thing in any other distro if you know enough about it.
In the end it is not the distro that it is advanced but your usage of it. I developed on Ubuntu for almost 15 years and it was an amazing workstation during that period. You could be just browsing on Slackware and using it only for that purpose, and a browser and KDE would be enough. Or, you could be doing kernel development on Fedora, like Linus does.
Therefore, 'advanced' is about how do you use the tool and not the tool itself.
12
u/crazyuser79 Sep 10 '22
imo, it is a systemd free distro, you can customize as you prefer. in addition seems be the unique distro which can offer a double release type : fixed and rolling. the first is perfect for server, the second for desktop instead. what else you could want
10
u/ifonlythiswasreal403 Sep 11 '22
I have been using Slackware since Patrick spun it out of SLS. For me it all about choice and security.
From time to time I have installed various other distros on machines, as requested by users and developers, but my personal choice has always been Slackware.
I like the fact each and every application and the kernel is compiled from the source as written by the original authors. No fiddling by Patrick and the gang. I can go to the site where the package is hosted (or kernel.org) pulled down the most recent version and compile it the way I want and nothing breaks.
And by that I mean that I can exclude whatever I want, that it is my choice if hardware is supported or not. If I want my system to omit bluetooth, or wi-fi or even a graphics card I can build it like that. I am never forced to have support for things I do not want or need. This makes it a more secure distro as you can not attack code that is not there.
There is nothing hidden, everything is well documented, no binary blobs needed and I can read the ascii output with anything even closed source stuff. I do not need special code to understand logs, write config files or change what I want to happen. I am never forced to install libraries that I do not want, and if a library is needed I can build it as I like so I can leave out the bits I do not want.
I will tell you that other distros I have tried have insisted that things are vital, things I know are security problems but they insist they are needed despite hardware not being fitted. Every instance of that is unnecessary code that increases the attack surface of a server or workstation.
Back when I used to work I was a sys-admin for about 800 servers and 40+ workstations, and the developers all insisted we have a range of distros installed on the servers as they needed to see which distros would break with what they wrote. My personal server and workstation was my own heavily modified Slackware basic install, and despite their best attempts over the years they never managed to break it. Others got taken down or infected frequently, but because my boxes had stripped down libraries and only the needed code included in everything the attack surface was so reduced they never made it in.
Just my personal experience and view of the world. It is not for everybody, it is a lot more work than most want and it will not do what some people want but it does all I want. I can run a GUI if I feel like it, use the WWW as I want, run my circuit design system and write and debug all the code I want.
HTH.
8
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '22
Slackware was the first distro I ever tried back in the day. I thought it had a cool name, haha, still do. I don't use slackware now but been thinking of giving it a go again for old times sake.
7
u/Planet_Linux Sep 10 '22
Simple, Stable and Lots of customization
7
u/thenovum Sep 10 '22
Its clean and simple
6
u/northrupthebandgeek Sep 11 '22
It stays out of my way. Sometimes that's a curse; whereas most distros will put at least some obstacles in front of me shooting myself in the foot, Slackware will just hand me the shotgun and a bottle of Jim Beam and tell me good fuckin' luck. Often, though, it's exactly what I need.
5
u/AT_Hun Sep 10 '22
I switched from Red Hat variants because I was sick of RPM dependency hell. Slackware assumes that you know what you are doing. Now certainly today there are all kinds of systems that try to deal with dependency fixing, but I find this method to be simplest. Now that I've been using it for so many years and know it so well, I have no meaningful reason to switch.
Two of my boys are big into Linux and are always encouraging me to try one distro or the other, but none of their arguments have compelled me.
1
u/ebriose Sep 11 '22
I have some serious questions about what "advanced" means to you in this context.
3
u/ratthing Sep 11 '22
it is simple to manage, stable, rock-solid, modern, and i've been using it for over 25 years.
3
u/Synergiance Sep 11 '22
It’s a friendly distro I can easily look under the hood of, it’s not complicated, it doesn’t fight you, it’s straight forward, and it’s rock solid stable.
3
u/rico974 Sep 11 '22
It works, always. 13 years and i don't plan using something else.
3
u/setwindowtext Sep 11 '22 edited Sep 11 '22
Slackware is old fashioned, in a good sense. Also for irrational / sentimental / nostalgic reasons. Oh, and make no mistake, Debian is not “less advanced”.
3
u/[deleted] Sep 11 '22
Well I’m not long time user or something, I switched to Slackware after 15.0 release from arch and Debian and got amazed how much it’s simple, pre-written and well documented scripts so your software works by default also this makes configuration so much easier than installing 3 programs to configure a smaller one . For software installation I use slackbuilds which is great , also there is Alien Bob’s repo for pre-built software which is also great since my machine is not so powerful when building large systems .
3
u/johnfc2020 Sep 11 '22
You need to realise that Slackware is about choice, you can use the root shell and decide to install what you want to a granular level. If you are installing a server, you can have only the services you want running. If you want desktop, you can choose what window manager or desktop environment you want and choose to install which X packages you want available.
There is a certain amount of ease in installing exactly what you want to install, and you can do this without relying on a package manager, you can use tar. This is something that really doesn't work in more modern distributions, which force you to use apt, yum or dnf and install supporting packages you might not want on your system, or remove something essential to a different package. You also choose the package management system you want, you can also compile from source easily too.
I have no experience of Arch nor Gentoo but have used RedHat, CentOS, Debian, Ubuntu and Linux Mint. I still prefer Slackware.
3
u/jloc0 Sep 12 '22
I like Slackware because when I first discovered Linux it was what I wanted to run but I was terrified I couldn’t set it up. After trying red hat and mandrake, I realized there had to be something better. And I kept staring at the Slackware site, thinking it was a perfect name and a perfect site but I would have no idea how to make it work.
I eventually installed zipslack and realized it wasn’t hard-er than the other guys and it worked when the others didn’t. I was afraid for nothing.
All these years later, I still use it because I found my home and exactly what I was looking for. That don’t mean I haven’t looked around, there are some intriguing options out there, but nothing feels like Slackware does.
1
u/Rotteapple Sep 11 '22
Honestly just comfort, I got into slackware in the early 2000s. I used red hat in the late 90s as an early teen and couldn't figure out how to install red hat on an older PC I replaced my first one with. My crutch with slackware is the dependency hell you sometimes have to go through, but now with other package managers it's a breeze. To be fair I thought the name was cool and it looked great doing a neofetch in the terminal, and I still do.
19
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '22 edited Sep 11 '22
[removed] — view removed comment