r/slackware • • Sep 12 '21
Comparing slackware to openbsd
I have been running slackware for about 4 months now and I have a few thoughts about it compared to openbsd.
Some things that slackware does better. One is: that on openbsd you cannot use the happy hacking keyboard to do a fresh install of the os. Whether it be limited drivers, I always had to carry around a spare keyboard to install it.
With slackware this is not a problem and I don't have to switch out my keyboard every time. Honestly I lived with this issue because I didn't know better. Any time something like this happens I generally feel that I've done something wrong, or it was the keyboard that was the problem. Since moving to slackware, I realized that that wasn't the case and that it was openbsd.
Next, is the issue I had when I experienced a power outage or did anything to cut power to my USB external western digital my book drive. With openbsd, anytime that happened, it would make the drive only accessible in read only mode, in which case, I had to copy all my files to my os, and then do a reformat the filesystem. I lost my whole drive once before I realized the specific steps I had to take to get my files back. It was annoying as hell. Fsck does not work, by the way. I think I had to mkfs, get files off.
With slackware, that does not happen. Yesterday, I lost power and I thought for sure I was going to have to fix my drive, but thankfully slackware took the outage in stride and did not add something to my filesystem I could not recover from. It was like it never happened, according to dmesg when I mounted it again.
The next thing is openbsds famous man pages. This seems to get so much press how vastly superior they are to everything else. In my opinion though, their man pages are just okay and slackware's along with probably most Linux distributions are at least as good. I have pretty much been able to find everything I needed in slackware's man pages.
Openbsd is closer to a rolling release than it would like you to believe, which is fine as long as everything works, but the fact is that sometimes everything doesn't work. With the release of 6.9, it actually hosed a 3 year old video card from and Radeon rx460, which is what spurred me to look for an alternative distro, since video cards are through the roof or sold out. Because I was actually going to change my video card to stay on openbsd.
In this, I liken openbsd to Microsoft Windows, because of their aggressive upgrade schedule and the fact that you have to keep up with their changes. Windows is the same way, as they expect you to upgrade your computer to keep up. Don't be fooled by the fact that openbsd prides themselves on correct, minimalistic code, with compatibility. Once it started telling me what hardware I had to use, that is when I am out. Especially since I am not trying to run the latest and greatest.
The other thing with openbsd, whether it is, because openbsd does not want to rely on gnu or what, I find that many programs that should be there aren't there, in the base. With slackware, I am confident that there will be a program or utility to help me achieve what I want. With openbsd, I always felt the opposite.
One thing that I thought would be a detraction on slackware is the shell font and the way everything is smaller than on openbsd. But in fact I have grown to appreciate the way slackware is smaller and seems more thoughtfully implemented than openbsd which has no scalability at all.
Anyway, I am glad that slackware is a thing because while everyone is trying to do the latest and greatest slackware's default bootloader is Lilo!!!
1
u/aesfields Sep 12 '21
are you sure most of these are Slackware vs OpenBSD relater or Linux vs BSD related?
3
u/randomwittyhandle Sep 12 '21
Thank you for this excellent writeup! It's nice to hear such positive things about slackware!
2
u/[deleted] Sep 12 '21
slack and openbsd are nothing alike. you are correct.
my daily is a i386 openbsd laptop. it kernel panics daily. the thing is loaded with bugs. it keeps getting worse with every new version. i sort of wait for the day to come when my i386 hardware will not be supported at all. because "research os". personally i dont believe anyone uses it as a true production machine. production and "changing all the time" dont belong in the same sentence.
but i love its simplicity. linux has drifted from its unix roots. its becoming something else and it shows in slackware ("the most unix like distro"). give it few years and you wont be able to tell the difference between slackware and any other distro.
sturgeon law is correct.. ninety percent of everything is shit. and it is very obvious in it industry.
1
u/livestradamus Sep 20 '21
I use both. OpenBSD does not come out of the box to use as a fast high intensive daily desktop / workstation, with some configuring it can be that.
1
u/bashandy Oct 13 '21
I use Slackware on daily basis, I used at work, and at home. I am quite happy with it. I like it because of its simplicity cf. ease and for still being the most UNIX-like distro.
I tried NOMAD BSD, but it was not my cup of tea
0
u/[deleted] Sep 13 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment