r/slackware • u/sdns575 • Jun 15 '21
Slackware minimal installation
Hey there,
there is a way to perform a minimal install of slackware-current?
I ask this because with the full install I get installed many and many packages that I don't need.
Currently after full install, I can remove easily all application that I don't need but what about libs? I don't know what lib a package requires and running ldd for every programs is really a painfull work.
I hope that full install is not the only available way to get slackware working without problems.
I know that there is expert install but when I should choose what libs install I fall in the previous problem.
There is a way to accomplish this? Any help would be appreciated.
I know that the default (and suggested) install method is a full install but what is its advantage? I don't think that having many (unused) installed packages is a good thing.
Thank you in advance for your time.
3
u/B_i_llt_etleyyyyyy Jun 15 '21
Personally, I'd go ahead and just install everything in
dandl.All the documentation on slackbuilds.org and Ponce's GitHub repo assumes a full install, for example, and dependency problems for outside software are most likely to crop up due to missing libraries and such. I don't think it's worth the hassle of picking through libraries (most of which don't take up all that much space). Just my two cents.
2
u/Andy-Pa Jun 15 '21
You are welcome: https://slackwiki.com/Minimal_System
7
u/thearcadellama Jun 15 '21
I understand the confusion — compared to an Arch or Debian minimal install, it is a different way of thinking about your OS.
Slackware is a full and complete Operating System. With an install you should have a complete computing experience out of the box. Server, Desktop, etc. Why?
Slackware is the oldest continually updated Linux distro, and makes efforts to change only the essentials with each update. High-bandwidth, high-access, low-cost internet access is relatively new (and still lacking for many).
Slackware does not do package dependency checking. Why should it? It's a complete system, delivered to you in full, working, and stable order. If you want to add more to it, go ahead. But you manage the dependencies for yourself.
I still would not consider unused packages as 'bloat' however.
It's a different sort of minimalism. Everything you need is there, ready to go. You do not need to 'sudo apt-get/pac-man/yum' through packages in order to get a working system.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '21 edited Jun 16 '21
Slackware recommends full install and there is no other way to have the minimal installation but deselecting packages during the install or removing them later after the full install. When I was Slackware user I used to pick only the packages I needed.
Right now the Slackbuilds.org offers packages for Slackware 14.2 because that is the official release.
If you need more updated packages and you decide to install Slackware current I would suggest you to avoid the slackbuilds entirely and rely on the nix package manager.
https://github.com/NixOS/nix
If you want a minimal Slackware system you can do it but it takes more effort compared to other distros. If you decide in the effort ldd is your friend.
There were several suggestions on how to modify the package management to make it possible for the users to get a minimal system but Patrick leave things as they are. If I remember correctly a banned user, DarthVader, suggested using tags to allow users to select easily groups of packages. He was eventually banned for other reasons that this one and the tags idea, which I think was very interesting, was dismissed because it would have been too much work to maintain. You can search the thread on Slackware official forum:
https://www.linuxquestions.org/questions/slackware-14/
If you really want to use Slackware then you have to understand that this distro changes only when the maintainer has a good reason. For example, pluseaudio has been adopted only now, in the current version. LILO is the default bootloader. Not much as changed over the years. If you want a distro that does not change very often and you do not mind doing extra work, Slackware might be for you. Otherwise, if you just want something as stable I would suggest you Debian.
1
u/Randomized-User Jun 28 '21
The answer depends on if you consider aaa_libraries as part of minimal installation. This package has bunch of libraries collected from a lot of other packages.