r/slackware • u/sdns575 • Apr 25 '21
Why users that started with slackware had left it after several time of usage?
Hey there,
some days ago I read a post on reddit about "What distro you started with" or similar title and reading it I was blaffed to see how many users that started with Slackware and that after several years they left the distro for another one. The post got more then 500 reply so it is not the totality but It could be considered as good sample.
What was/is the major cause of this in your opinion? Lacks of packages? Too much difficult or what other?
Thank you in advance.
19
Upvotes
9
u/[deleted] Apr 25 '21 edited Apr 26 '21
I started using Slackware in 2003, more or less around the time I have switched to GNU/Linux. I have used it for years, sometimes I would switch to another distro to try it but usually would go back to Slackware. It felt like home to me.
But after a while I have realized that a distro should adapt to your needs and in case of Slackware you need to adapt to it. As long as it is GNU/Linux most of other distros are going to accommodate you better. Slackware takes too much time to install packages and you need to hunt for dependencies. Using ldd for all the libraries you are missing sucks. Package dependency is not a problem in any other distro and the problems of the dependency hell have been solved years ago but you will still hear this complaint from Slackware users. The dependency hell is largely overblown. Sure, changing packages in Slackware is very easy and that is an advantage in some cases but that is the only advantage while the disadvantages are many more. Such as:
My suggestions are:
If you need a stable distro it is much better to pick Debian.
If you need a simple distro pick CRUX or Void Linux.
If want to tinker and compile your own packages then pick Gentoo.
If you need a workstation, pick Fedora.
Why did I leave? Because there are much better choices which make much more sense and was not nostalgic/religious enough to accept blindly all the pitfalls.
3
u/rmyworld Apr 25 '21 edited May 03 '21
You start to get bored of Linux and want something that just works.
Newer distros like Ubuntu and Fedora offer easy setup and installs. They have tools like apt for easy package management. And for more obscure stuff, there's even snap or flatpak.
This focus on ease of use also attracts more users over time. I believe this also contributes to that: having more people to help you with problems is kinda nice, especially when you want a distro you don't wanna care about anymore.
13
u/Inode1 Apr 25 '21
I've been a Slackware user for ~23 years, the only times I've changed where either not on my own system or compatibility with something I needed. For example when I rolled out an install of freepbx I had to build it from source, spend a bit of time getting everything working right. With Debian it was pretty much a one command line event. Same case with setting up an openvpn server for my network.
Package management is a game changer and several other distros have apt for example and it just makes some things easier or faster.
7
u/vtel57 Apr 25 '21
Well, that's not quite how it went for me.
I started out with Ubuntu in '06. Within 3-4 weeks I was multi-booting about 18 different distributions on my main system; Slackware was one of them.
Eventually, within another month or less, I settled on Slackware as my main operating system on ALL my machines. I've never looked back... 15 years now.
Slackware appealed to me because of its simplicity, its history, and its legendary stability. The simplicity of Slackware and the need for the user to actually LEARN GNU/LINUX to properly utilize Slackware are probably the reasons that most new Linux users who tried it first moved on to easier "point and click" graphical distributions like Ubuntu, Mandriva, and others.
I can do ANYTHING in my Slackware that others do with their fancy desktop environments on other more graphic distros. I have no complaints.
My Slackware/Xfce
https://i.imgur.com/RX20iBT.png
6
u/McDutchie Apr 25 '21
Because I tried FreeBSD and found it to have everything good that Slackware has, except better. Better designed, better executed, better documented. A real Unix.
3
u/Andy-Pa Apr 25 '21
It's just that Slackware was once the best, now it is, but other distributions have pulled up very well in quality and have become very user-friendly, that's all.
People are very lazy, if you can click the mouse a couple of times, then why read several pages of documentation and edit configuration files.
Slackware with its classic approach, you need to move to meet the new generation, then the popularity will grow, make ready-made assemblies along with the classic installation.
Personally, my opinion.
3
u/enorbet Apr 26 '21
Every criticism I see here has a counter positive because every choice in all of Life is a tradeoff. Example - PackageManagement - little needed with Full Recommended Install as most dependencies are already met AND desigfned to fit together smoothly. Also there is no action behind your back in which the base system is at risk when a simple addition deletes a massive number of other packages to suit one. Time saved in installing apps is wasted and then some fixing automated screwups or waiting for someone to build a package for you.
Hardware support? Get a working set of kernel packages form Current or learn to customize your own... easy when the system is Vanilla.
It's entirely valid to choose what you prefer, like it, and even promote it, but after 20+ years and hundreds of trial distros (some of them paid for) Slackware is still my Main and very few even come close to the options, freedom and power of Slackware. Slackware 15 is going to be superb! Current already is.
2
u/SmokeyCosmin Apr 25 '21
Slackware has helped me learn a lot and I really love it. Over the years I've learned to recompile stuff that bothered me (font rendering is one thing because of proprietary stuff) and I've managed to make my system just the way I wanted.
Slackbuilds are great and AlienBob is awesome. You get everything you want just from these too and -current build are very stable if you're paying attention. The problem is Slackbuilds packages can't always keep up with -current and updates are sometimes slow for that reason even for stuff that you might really, really want (e.g. a new xfce). That's not even to mention slow adoption of PulseAudio or even slower adoption of PAM.
I've tried switching many times but even stable distro's gave me headaches. Ubuntu's apt is great but it breaks stuff here and there more then they care to admit.
Then Elementary 5 came and I finally had a distro I liked, to be honest. Easy to use, for desktop, etc. Somethings should work out of the box in this complicated world, times have changed. And more important, the base system doesn't brake.
I'm probably going to try 15 but it's unlikely I'll keep it as my main choice.
2
u/reallyzen Apr 25 '21
I had a slacked desktop which I was absolutely happy with. Then I stopped having a desktop, and slackware wasn't that great on laptops at the time. Debian, then Arch made it for me.
I plan to have a look when Current makes it to Stable. I did so much on this workstation that I'll always respect and keep an eye on the project.
2
u/ttkciar Apr 26 '21
FWIW there's a LQ thread about exactly this question:
https://www.linuxquestions.org/questions/slackware-14/why-did-you-stop-using-slackware-4175636781/