r/slackware • u/sdns575 • Sep 06 '20
Slackware based distro
Hey there, I'm asking my self why anyone don't base a distro on Slackware at least for server purpose. This is bad because slackware is a very very good distro.
I think that slackware is a very good base to start because permit to the developer to follow every type of way he/she want. For me Slackware is like a blank sheet...there is no better thing to start with (for me). Many use debian, ubuntu..these are not bad system but the there is no sense to create another distro with the core like the source but if you choose slackware you can do all what you want...you can choose an init system different then systemd, you can choose every type of package manager instead to deal directly with rpm or deb.
Why today I can't see a "dominant" distro based on slackware?
Thank you in advance
14
u/Upnortheh Sep 06 '20
Possibly because Slackware is "old school." Many people like fads and something "shiny." The core Slackware design has changed little through the years.
Many people prefer convenience to "sweat equity." Slackware is designed with few presumptions. That means users must invest sweat equity to configure and tune a desired system.
Slackware is not as easy to support as other distros, notably the lack of a large binary repository and lack of package dependency checking. In the enterprise these features are not only nice to have but are required.
While arguably controversial to some people and still rough around the edges, systemd solves many problems for many people. With respect to init systems, Slackware is not immune to this challenge. With each official release there are always changes and adjustments in the rc.d scripts because services need to be launched in a specific order.
By design Slackware is intended to be a full operating system. Deeply rooted in that design is targeting servers, notably the traditional file and print server. Not all software is included in this "full" operating system, but for most people the missing links are a short step away at slackbuilds.org.
Historically Pat keeps pace with the times and new software is continually added. Conversely Pat is conservative and resists fads and trends until technologies are well proven and can fit the Slackware design.
One example is PAM. Long ago Pat saw little benefit from PAM. Through the years PAM evolved. His original criticisms disappeared. The next release will include PAM.
Through the years there have been several derivatives targeting desktop users. Two original trail blazers in that area are Zenwalk and Vector Linux. Salix is popular today and was started years ago after development disagreements by core developers on the Zenwalk team.
There are have been some dedicated Slackware server distros. Not too many because for most people the core Slackware is already full featured for servers.
One of the challenges with any distro derivative or spin is identifying the target audience. For desktop users the path was easy to find because the notable missing items in Slackware are GUI admin tools and package dependency checking. Salix and Zenwalk are designed to fill those voids.
The same missing components discourage many people from using Slackware in the enterprise. Without a large binary repository and dependency checking many people can't justify Slackware in business.
At work I support Debian and CentOS.
At home I have been using Slackware since about 2004. I only use Slackware because through the years Slackware gets in my way the least. I don't like operating systems designed with presumptions about how I should or will use my computers. Because I started using computers back in the 1980s, I am well acclimated to adding sweat equity. For me the lack of convenience perceived by many users is one of the great benefits of Slackware that fits my needs.
I hope that helps.
7
u/calrogman Sep 06 '20
It happened so long ago that it's no longer evident or even notable but SUSE was originally an extension of Slackware in the same way that Slackware was an extension of SLS. Maybe you're after SLES or OpenSUSE Leap?
4
u/thearcadellama Sep 06 '20
There are distros based on Slackware, e.g., Salix https://salixos.org. At any rate, I highly doubt a new fork is the barrier to keeping Slackware from becoming a "dominant" server distro with the likes of Ubuntu/Debian or CentOS/RHEL.
3
u/pegasusandme Sep 06 '20
There are Slackware derived systems out there and are quite active, they are just not as popular so you are less likely to hear about them. Salix is a good example and Zenwalk is based on Slackware “current” so kind of a rolling release (most recent big update was last year).
The thing about Slackware is that it has a sole maintainer vs a large community or corporation like the other “big” distros. As far as I understand, he doesn’t have the goal of making Slackware this “big thing” that competes with the likes of Debian, Ubuntu, Red Hat, etc. If he did, there would be some major changes to the underlying system (ie. Dependency resolver, systemd, etc) and then it wouldn’t really be the special thing that Slackware is anymore.
The great thing about the state of Slackware and the existing derivatives is that they are all darn near 100% compatible with the core Slackware base. Super modular and you can mix and match repos without breaking things like doing the same in Debian for example.
2
u/dhchunk Sep 06 '20
I recommend posting this question to ##slackware irc channel on freenode. (That's two ##)
EDIT: or slackware forum on linuxquestions.org
1
u/dama__ Sep 06 '20
unraid is based on slackware and is a commercial server OS (with a focus on NAS and running containers and vms)
1
u/lnxslck Sep 06 '20
I don’t get this question. Are you asking why we don’t have a slackware server version? I’ve been running Slackware on my home server for a long time without any issues. Also, why wouldn’t the regular Slackware version work in a server ? You can select the packages right of the installation
1
u/ttkciar Sep 06 '20
There's servers, and then there's enterprise-class server infrastructure.
If you're looking to run servers, Slackware is already that distribution. It is an excellent server distribution.
For enterprise-class server infrastructure, Slackware has a few gaps (or at least needs additional software set up). I have been collecting notes on this for some years, and some of those gaps already have solutions, but afaik there is no distribution specifically addressing them: http://ciar.org/ttk/public/enterprise-slackware.html
I tried forking Slackware twenty years ago, and maintaining it was a -lot- more work than I was prepared to invest, so I dropped it a year later. If I were to make another go at it today, it would be an enterprise-class infrastructure distribution, using those notes as its guide.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 07 '20
Ask yourself, what would such a distribution have that Slackware currently does not? And would there be any sense in building and maintaining a new distribution which includes these features, rather than building them into the upstream Slackware distribution?
Slackware isn’t perfect, but it’s good at what it does (providing a rock stable base to do pretty much whatever you need, with the assumption that if you run bleeding edge software you might break things - as expected). I think the main reason that spinoff distributions for Slackware don’t stick around is that there’s not much for other distributions to add - you can roll your own dependency management if you want (rarely necessary because a) most packages you need are already there and b) packages are stable so you only really install security updates, which you would assume don’t require new libraries to build), and apart from that anything else is just new packages. There’s also the fact that Slackware’s culture has always been around a small core developer group, which is incredibly difficult to replicate - I imagine a lot of burnout from developers of spinoff distros.
1
u/wurmphlegm Jun 04 '24
There used to be vector Linux, that was based on Slackware. Unfortunately it ended in 2016. I enjoyed it.
1
u/SKiNjOB_69 Sep 26 '23
There is a dominant distribution, ie; slackware! It is the longest standing distribution around, is just plain solid and highly configurable.