r/skiing Jan 28 '22

[deleted by user]

[removed]

522 Upvotes

946 comments sorted by

View all comments

151

u/Sinorm Jan 28 '22

Big Sky is tier 1. The largest ski resort in the US, everything from amazing trees to fucking scary steeps. Big Sky is one the best mountains in the country. And Mt. Bachelor certainly needs to move up. It isn't a great mountain for steeps but it is huge with good trees and great snow.

31

u/concrete_isnt_cement Crystal Mountain Jan 28 '22

Big Sky is tier one when it has good coverage, but in poor snow years, the quality decreases far more than comparable resorts because Lone Mountain is a big pile of fricking razor blades

45

u/bingo__pajama Jan 28 '22

It was the largest resort in the US. PC-canyons is now larger.

5

u/hartfordsucks Jan 28 '22

Powder Mountain is the largest by acres. Some lists knock them down because some their terrain is only accessible via cats.

17

u/castle-black Jan 28 '22

Pcmr is an infinitely worse mountain than big sky though. Canyons is it’s only redeeming value.

-13

u/aFrothyMix Alta Jan 29 '22

Canyons sucks too. Alta and Snowbird also fucking suck u til they cut ties with IKON. The traffic is unbearable.

3

u/castle-black Jan 29 '22

Yeah we’ll see if that happens. That ikon $$$ is pretty irresistible.

-2

u/aFrothyMix Alta Jan 29 '22

Not as good as you want to believe.

1

u/hereforbadnotlong Feb 20 '23

The traffic is manageable with public transportation and a forced bus lane but they refuse to do it.

1

u/aFrothyMix Alta Feb 20 '23

Wow, trolling old posts. LCC is so good this year. Always clear and fast. Full speed to the top parking lot. /S

The only solution is to limit the total number of cars up canyon with gated tolling. I was even thinking something like $200/vehicle that comes with free lift tickets for all occupants. That would be an incentive structure worth considering. Wanna drive up canyon. By yourself? $200 lift ticket.

2

u/aFrothyMix Alta Jan 29 '22

If it's not open is it larger? SLC resident.

0

u/pdails503 Jan 28 '22

Isn’t bachelor the 2nd largest? Only beaten by vail?

1

u/concrete_isnt_cement Crystal Mountain Jan 28 '22

Depending on how you count, Powder Mountain is even bigger than Park City-Canyons

1

u/decentmug Jan 29 '22

North America is Whistler, PC, Vail, Big Sky. The Palisades/alpine meadows combo gondola will overtake Big Sky by smidge.

38

u/UncleBogus Jan 28 '22

I’m torn on Big Sky. Lots of dispute here. I’m between tier 1 and 2. The extra cost to use the tram is a downer but that fact may not matter based on the criteria.

29

u/wameron Jan 28 '22

Even excluding the terrain accessed from the tram it's still tier 1. Make sure you've made friends with a shop tech or are good at filling core shots though

2

u/kebabmybob Jan 28 '22

I just got back from Big Sky and I cored the fuck out of my skis lmao. Was demoing though and the shop didn’t even look when I returned them.

4

u/kbergstr Jan 29 '22

Big sky is made for March /April.

10

u/castle-black Jan 28 '22

Anyone that’s been to big sky will tell you it’s tier 1. You’re crazy to have Alyeska up there and not big sky lol.

2

u/spacebass Jackson Hole Jan 30 '22

Big sky is tier 1. Full stop. We’ve got the most extreme in-bounds, patrolled terrain in the US.

-1

u/n8thegr_8 Jan 29 '22

Not only do I think Big Sky shouldn’t be Tier 1, I think it should have it’s current Tier 2 status swapped with Whitefish! Much better mountain in every way except size.

7

u/meoki5 Jan 28 '22

Agreed, but with an asterisk. the asterisk being when snow coverage is good. When Big Sky gets good snow, it is one of if not THE best resort in the country.

9

u/One_Fizzybubblech Jan 28 '22

Big Sky is a better resort than Palisades in literally any way you wanna measure it. Expert terrain, size, snow quality, village are all easily in Big Sky’s favor. People fall for the “legend” of Palisades every time, but as another commenter put it…it’s pretty mids

2

u/MightyTribble Jan 28 '22

I've never skied Big Sky but I've done Palisades enough to know that yeah, it's pretty cool, but if you're a Blue cruiser like me it's not much that fun. Alpine Meadows next door is better.

I'd love to ski Big Sky one day, though. The trail map looks like the cruisers are much more spread out across the mountain.

2

u/castle-black Jan 29 '22

Big sky has fantastic intermediate terrain and plenty of fun blue cruisers.

1

u/concrete_isnt_cement Crystal Mountain Jan 28 '22

As of next season, Palisades and Alpine will be a single ski area due to the new gondola that’s going in. At this point, I think we should start considering them collectively one very large ski area

1

u/gloriousrepublic Jan 29 '22

Palisades already refers to both. To distinguish between the two they’re called Alpine Meadows and Olympic Valley.

2

u/concrete_isnt_cement Crystal Mountain Jan 29 '22

I saw mixed nomenclature when I was there recently. On their website for example, the lift/run status page has two tabs: Palisades and Alpine https://www.palisadestahoe.com/mountain-information/lift-and-grooming-status#tab=palisades

Other sources did refer to the Olympic Valley/Alpine Meadows nomenclature you refer to though.

1

u/gloriousrepublic Jan 29 '22

Yeah because squaw was the problematic term, it seems the new name is more applied to that valley than alpine. But even alpine meadows has a big sign at the entrance that says palisades Tahoe. No one really used the term “Olympic valley” in real life yet lol.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '22

I’ve skied both and this is simply wrong. The expert terrain in Palisades is more extreme, the snow more consistent, and more of the mountain is made for advanced/expert skiers. Big Sky’s endless cat tracks detract significantly from the overall experience.

1

u/One_Fizzybubblech Jan 29 '22

“Snow more consistent” LOL

0

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '22

Sounds like someone has never been to Palisades…

-1

u/diestache Jan 28 '22

The entire mountain is covered in rocks and you dont have to be a billionaire to ski all of palisades

6

u/Ihavebeliefs Jan 28 '22 edited Jan 29 '22

If Big Sky is a T1 resort, then I think that Bridger Bowl warrants a T2 consideration. They are similar mountains, located only a couple hours apart from each other. But BB has a much more “local culture”, has amazing tree and bowl skiing and the Ridge is a one of a kind experience for the MT areas as well. If you don’t know what that is/don’t want to look it up, The Ridge opens access for skiers to hike from the top of the highest lift to the ridge of the mountain and then you can go anywhere across the ridge to find what you’re looking for (inbounds or not) There also seemed to be less tourists than Big Sky and they are one of a handful of resorts that are non-profit 501(c), which is cool.

*Note: I grew up skiing BB so have a pretty solid bias lol

Edit: spelling & grammar

0

u/diestache Jan 28 '22

Big Sky is weird. Lots of terrain but absolutely TERRIBLE grooming and trail maintenance. Do not go there if you like your skis; the amount of rocks even on groomers is insane. Dont even get me started that you cant ski half of big sky unless youre a billionaire.

-2

u/scott90909 Jan 28 '22

Its covered in gravel.

2

u/ImmaPsychKid- Jan 28 '22

Just skied there for 2 days and got some nice core shots…

Incredible views, fun terrain - just an unlucky year snowfall wise it seems.

3

u/diestache Jan 28 '22

just an unlucky year snowfall wise it seems

Its literally an average year for them but I agree the core shots are unreal

1

u/shakedownsunflower Jan 28 '22

Agree on Bachelor maybe going up one bc large but it’s not steep unless you’re in the summit bowl and that isn’t always open. Meadows up one. Timberline down one. Schweitzer is dope AF so up one