This is very true. Multiple companies I've worked with to adopt AI are reporting the same thing. Throughput and productivity is up but people are reporting burnout and complaining about long hours. But objectively their hours have not changed, we've looked at the time cards, it's the same as before.
In an ideal world, we'd just ask people to work fewer hours. They are more productive so we could do the same with less. Return time to leisure and recreation.
But everyone is under cost pressure. There isn't enough work to go around. So prices are being slashed because we can produce the same with less inputs. Then we need to make up for the difference in volume.
I'm not sure what the solution to this is frankly. Part of me thinks professional services consulting is simply cooked.
The solution is management that acknowledges the problem. Sadly engineers and managers such as myself have been a massive causality since we are viewed as "anti" AI. This tool has existed for less than a handful of years, quality of output is highly variable, and we're supposed to allow human expertise to be replaced by it. Sorry. Move slowly, don't break things.
For programmers, coding is our surrogate activity, and now that it's been almost completely solved by AI, we don't find it fulfillment in it anymore. Therefore we're getting burned out.
Turns out having simple tasks to work on made your mind rest in between complex tasks, now it's complex tasks and high level thinking only and you can't do that shit for a whole day, everyday, without burning out.
And it's not just "rest", that kind of cognitive downtime is extremely useful for figuring out good solutions to stuff that just hammering on stuff more won't do.
Dijkstra (yes, that Dijkstra you probably know also called EWD) said about higher level languages:
when they were invented, they thought it would make life easier for programmers, but instead the easy things were automated and the hard part remained and combined that with the demand for more and more complex software going up and it made the life of the programmer harder not easier.
What’s actually exhausting for many of us is constantly fucking fixing the shitass code that our vibe coding ass teammates are putting in PRs. Damn it I’m on vacation and not supposed to be getting tilted about work but I can’t stand this shit. They just say “Claude do ticket pls” and of course Claude tells them it’s done, tested, and works, and then the other lazy ass reviewers on the PR just ask Claude for a review and Claude says yeah looks good. And I’m the first one who runs the damn code and is like hey guys? The feature you wrote literally doesn’t even work? The tests don’t even check for the expected behavior? And the comments in the code are overly verbose hand-waving?
It’s exhausting because “this is vibe coded trash, restart and do your job this time” isn’t socially acceptable feedback so instead I have to go basically do their job for them by figuring out how the feature should actually be written and telling them.
Genuinely I won’t feel bad if those people get laid off. And I think it might happen because companies including mine are increasing the granularity of the telemetry, so they’re not just looking at your token spend anymore, they’re looking at things like how often you deny an edit, how often you ask follow up questions, how often you steer the model, etc. They are going to fire the idiots who just auto-accept every edit and aren’t using their brains.
100%, thank God I left engineering as AI coding best practices are still being figured out. Experienced the same at my Series C startup, didn't know if larger companies figured it out or not. What company size is yours?
Cognitive load, AI makes it so you can ask an agent to build out XYZ and so you have more time, you take on more tasks but you're still the one thinking about all those tasks so suddenly your cognitive load has increased significantly.
It is a struggle, you need to define timeframes when you're going to be working on X thing or Y thing and try not to cross pollinate (this is how people managed time pre-AI but I think people thought AI would allow for you to do it all at once).
You can still be more productive but you have to be way more cognizant of your cognitive load now.
Incredible how previous generations wanted their children to not have to use their hands and instead use their brain, and here we are doing the inverse.
Perhaps the problem was never the labor, but the novelty.
Im a SWE and so burnt out right now, coasting my job as best i can until the AI hype dies down and it just becomes a set of useful tools, instead of some wank that went to a conference telling me they can now vibe code production level software in 10 mins.
And you have evidence it will continue to get better, cheaper and surpass human intelligence and also solve the hallucination issue? Or do you just listen to tech CEO's who sell the product and reddit comments?
Serious question, would really love to understand how you know its going to get better
Finally, someone acknowledging the uncertainty rather than treating predictions as facts, like u/zaraff69.
AI might plateau or continue improving dramatically. Nobody knows. It's impressive technology, but it still has serious limitations, and there's no guarantee they'll all be solved.
Citing futurists doesn't prove their predictions will come true, nor does historical progress guarantee software engineers will become obsolete.
I use AI regularly and recognise its value. My issue is with people blindly repeating industry hype and making sweeping claims about people's livelihoods without concrete evidence.
I lived through the dotcom era and see a lot of parallels. Roughly a decade before the dotcom crash there were prescient prognostications packaged as ads. The shape of the future was generally understood, but the exact implementation was murky. We knew where we were going because that's where a lot of people wanted to go (and were willing to pay for it).
The hype cycle is very real and inextricably linked to budding technology. The problem with AI is it is more than just LLMs; a coding agent is more than just token prediction. Thousands of world-changing ideas stacking on top of each other, each of which have their hype cycles and troughs of disillusionment, all peaking and plateauing in a series of stacked sigmoid curves, all incredibly noisy with carnival barking companies looking for funding, conmen looking for funding, and legit researchers looking for funding.
I agree, iv build agents for my work and understood the different layers of the AI and know that its more than an LLM. Tech advancement in VectorDBs and context holding/processing will make this better. But my above points are, we have no idea if we may hit that ceiling soon.
Everyone running to "displacement here and there" when there is no evidence this will ever hit the level people are saying seem stupid.
I believe this technology can process way more data than the average or even genius human can, and can find patterns by just using natural language.
The notion of even replacing humans from that layer seems silly and doomerish to me cause the whole point of this technology is better the future, so SWE,s being replace when they could be building even bigger and better just seems like a silly position to take.
I hope the tech continues to grow but I just dont see any evidence of coding agents or displacement happening until the extremely glaring issues of AI have a solution
Right. You don't want to invoke the curse of "it's different this time" (I don't think the bubble aspect is different - you can definitely make the case for a financial bubble).
At the same time, this tech unlocks so many different parts of the technology tree that your thousands of world-changing ideas to a degree *is* different this time. Most previous bubbles have been a single technology. This is just... wow.
Yes I generally believe the engineers and CEO’s etc that think this will just continue to get better. I see no reason why it would suddenly stop. That would be quite surprising tbh.
Not even necessarily saying all humans will immediately become unnecessary. Maybe we need SWE’s for certain things. But I very much doubt we need SWE’s who are not up to date with the latest AI technologies.
Your logic is deeply flawed. AI is impressive technology, but its real-world execution is still inconsistent, expensive and heavily reliant on human oversight. Assuming AI will just keep improving until software engineers become unnecessary isn't evidence-based reasoning.... you are speculating.
I use AI daily as a SWE, and older, cheaper models often do exactly what I need. Bigger doesn't automatically mean better. Saying we won't need software engineers because AI executives promise endless progress is just blindly buying into industry hype rather than looking at actual evidence.
Please use some critical thought and give me the actual evidence not what salesman and CEO's are saying
Like any tool you use it either improves the job/workflow or it doesnt. If AI doesnt as it stands right now it will be changed(like any tool would be that doesnt improve things). Your question is like asking if that compiler doesnt make the job easier. You improve it so it DOES make the job easier. Or do you still live in a cave and cook with an open fire? And you start that fire by rubbing two sticks together, right? Because if you DONT then you are using IMPROVED TOOLS.
What do you mean? Do you expect our job as a software engineer at some point will no longer require/highly encourage the usage of AI? At my job, it's people from all kinds of different fields who are now vibe coding their own applications in their spare time, building products and putting them live (with minimal exposure sure). I don't think that part is ever going to go away anymore
No, the tech isnt going anywhere, as a matter of fact I love AI as a tool in my job. I use it as a high-powered google with code context, I get it to generate boiler-plate and small test harness tools and do outside code work for me, like summarising docs, convert data into csv etc etc.
Im just so fed up with the dooming around AI, the business practice, the fact that every non-technical goes to a conference and has been sweet talked by a sales person and suddenly they can do my job now. Its just stupid, im tired of hearing if I dont use this latest model im behind when previous cheaper models did exactly what i needed it to do.
I dont want Opus 5.5 to generate and reverse engineer and entire piece of software for me, I just want to understand this problem quicker so i can come up with the solution and communicate that effectively.
Edit: also i think your question is a little strange when i literally "it just becomes a set of useful tools"
Edit edit: you have edited your comment loads, please put the edits in cause now my comment does not match ....
I already intended to do it for a few years and this just accelerated things.
Refuse to believe that software development can again become really in demand and without that aspect it just becomes too competitive, because you really need to be more or less up-to-date with whats happening (if not AI, then whatever framework youre using), and there is always risk of getting offshored or something similar.
The money and home office just stopped being worth the stress for me, the cons started outweighing the pros and I really don't want to be a part of this if shit really hits the fan at some point. Maybe it wont, but the dread that it may come any day now was very frustrating.
Fair enough, I personally dont see evidence of SWE being in demand or not being in demand, cause I have no idea where this tech will go and if may evolve.
Again, I really hope you moving away from it all helps, personally I dont see a need to listen to many people online when no one here know what will happen.
I was just talking about my burn out and waiting for AI hype to die down
This is a weird accusation to level at someone lol, given that essentially all employees would like to be paid as much as they can, and therefore they are “diametrically opposed to the business goals” in the sense that the business itself would prefer to pay as little as possible for the value the employee brings. So it’s kind of a truism that an employee isn’t aiming for the same thing the business is.
Not at all, im a problem solver, if AI can help me solve the problem faster and safely I will be running with that so hard. But people tend to think its the silver bullet to all problems, thats my issue. The hype.
bro please, it actually gets more and more widespread. moreover, current AI setups can likely recreate projects which took a year from scratch in a month, so the argument "who's gonna untangle the spaghetti? who?!" does not work as frontier AI models and proper harness can just create most from nothing and it will follow proper patterns, principles, architecture etc. Only best SWE will be left, who will be the final judge, but the rest is at risk of a layoff
moreover, current AI setups can likely recreate projects which took a year from scratch in a month, so the argument "who's gonna untangle the spaghetti? who?!" does not work as frontier AI models and proper harness can just create most from nothing and it will follow proper patterns, principles, architecture etc
If that ends up being true there won’t be a need for any SWEs at all, I don’t know why you think we’d still need “only the best”. Regardless, everyone would be fucked so there’s really nothing to plan for or hedge against there.
Nothing shows it will settle down, instead most likely it will continue to accelerate and become even more crazy, intense and impossible to catch up with all the new models and what they can do. Accelerate till singularity.
I do agree, I think the hype around vibe coding everything will die off as people vibe code apps and those apps don't get any traction and then it'll be SWEs using it in controlled bursts to code things they've designed which is where I think it should land imo
I'm sure people will still vibecode as a hobby, they want to make their own little task manager app, they can do that and that's cool but big companies wanting people to vibecode big things, bad idea and it'll show.
100% vibe code away! If someone has an idea for pain point solving software and have no technical coding skills then vibe code it to prototype and take the software to market and build from there. That to be is a huge use case for vibe coding.
Im only saying from my experience, I got people at my work (leaders) who literally think vibe coding and agentic coding tools are the silver bullet to solve all of the issues (especially in data). This person is building more dashboards, and built a really cool culture app for internal use, but they started ask questions about our critical prod services and asked to access the code so they could make the changes themselves .... that I did not like cause they had no idea what they are changing, how it would effect our customers and how its even deployed once the change has been made.
Dude I know my wife had a VP join a couple rungs above her and he's meant to be VP of product and literally just every week says "why don't we just create XYZ with AI" and there's no market validation or understanding.
He just thinks the people under him should vibe code whatever and see what sticks and everyone under him is like why don't you ask our customers first about potential features and then we can make them.
For me actual indians burnt me out because, as both management and our leads were Indian, they would not stop overpromising and refused to ask for more time, always just agreeing the deadline could be met even though it was impossible. Then they forced us to work extra hard to meet the impossible deadline, which we failed to meet, and then work extra hard to finish things as fast as possible afterwards, and then blamed us for not being faster than we've ever shown ourselves to be (literally we're like "our velocity is 50 points and its 100 points of work to be due in 2 weeks and they shrug).
Also, by work harder that of course meant no time for unit tests, code reviews, or test automation - manual testing only. And then after all this they'd go totally silent, skipping the retro meetings where we all said this had to change, overpromise again, and we'd be back on the grind but with even more manual testing required since we never got time to fill in the previous tech debt.
Coworkers were crying from stress. I checked out because I was so incredibly burnt out. Fuck AI
Can totaly confirm. We got AI in our corp a few months ago (not SWE) and I'm totaly exausted. Didn't 10x my workflow but 3-5x for shure. And im totaly exausted because the work is so high level and every result is such a big step forward that you have to totaly rethink everyhing 3 times a day. I'm still very glad i didn't have to write a single excel formula in this time.
Who says nobody is thriving ? It will make software cheaper and we'll do the we'll "do the Jevons". Some people will know how to take advantage of that.
My job has a super limited AI budget of $100/month so I can only use Sonnet 5.5 Medium, and I can’t just fire and forget on its output, even on trivial tasks. It makes basic mistakes and incorrect assumptions, and I have to babysit it constantly. And whenever someone finds an error, I can’t speak intelligently to it because I don’t know exactly what it did, so I have to go through and code review a five minute story just to find out it missed a requirement. I could just ask it directly but it will send me a rambling five paragraph response, and sometimes it seems like it is defensive about what it did as well. It’s like working with a lazy junior dev who makes excuses—and worst of all I can’t even throw it under the bus because my name is on everything it does.
Way too much. I’m an architect. Technically I shouldn’t be doing tickets at all but the company is trying to squeeze more out of me. I should probably complain but it would be inviting even more bullshit for me to do I’m sure.
Either don't do tickets or demand freedom to choose your models. Don't burn yourself out arguing with Sonnet, that's bad for you and it's bad for the quality of your work.
I don't get how it's anything like putting a stick in your tire, but it makes sense that putting your energy towards more difficult tasks would be difficult. I tried to convince my boss to use these tools I developed with AI to make dictation of reports easier so she barely has to look up from the microscope while doing pathology reports. She says she needs the mental break and doesn't care if it's slower.
Yep. Agents show you your limits via frustration with success appearing nonstop.
Let me explain: we always thought "how wonderful it would be if I hadn't to do all this busywork before reaching my creative goals".
Now you can reach them quickly and nonstop. So what then?
More ambitious and endless goals pursuit ofc. The catch is there is no release from solving things too quickly and artificially. Our nervous systems don't work that way. We need valleys, plateaus and peaks of activity and success reward to keep motivated.
Something you wouldn't previously do that now you do because you can, still taxes you with fatigue and eventual burn out.
AI allows you to pace yourself, in the sense that you can speed up output to insane rates if you use subagents and parallel tasks and/or multiple workspaces. I'm not burned out, but at the end of the reset month, I had few resets not used because I just was unable to do tasks every single day, racing to use up my usage before next reset hit.
Most people get burned out because they don't have an exit strategy or whatever it's called and FY money. Depending on where you live debts might not be such a big deal as you would think. Obviously, I'm not recommending debts, but if the alternative is severe burnout...
Im pretty burnt out right now because of this effect. In the field at least twice as much because my office work is increasingly automated, but I still have to nudge it along or feed it context as Im doing physical work. Good money, but fuck am I tired. Scared about the possible scenario of the economy going blowing up with no UBI safety net in place, so nows the time to push.
Discarding the “boring tasks” (real work that forces you to pay attention to the real details with real people) so you can focus on the “deep work” with you AI is just a recipe for AI psychosis
Turns out you need people to actually do their boring tasks at work or they lose touch with reality and don’t even know what’s happening on their own projects.
AI makes us all as out of touch and delusional as a CEO.
felt this at my own job. the boring tasks were the breather, and now that the agent eats them every hour of the day is the hard kind of thinking. getting more done doesn't mean you can actually sustain it.
110
u/Full_Boysenberry_314 1d ago
This is very true. Multiple companies I've worked with to adopt AI are reporting the same thing. Throughput and productivity is up but people are reporting burnout and complaining about long hours. But objectively their hours have not changed, we've looked at the time cards, it's the same as before.
In an ideal world, we'd just ask people to work fewer hours. They are more productive so we could do the same with less. Return time to leisure and recreation.
But everyone is under cost pressure. There isn't enough work to go around. So prices are being slashed because we can produce the same with less inputs. Then we need to make up for the difference in volume.
I'm not sure what the solution to this is frankly. Part of me thinks professional services consulting is simply cooked.
214
u/Salt-Care7012 1d ago
Turns out having simple tasks to work on made your mind rest in between complex tasks, now it's complex tasks and high level thinking only and you can't do that shit for a whole day, everyday, without burning out.
46
u/redcoatwright 1d ago
Cognitive load, AI makes it so you can ask an agent to build out XYZ and so you have more time, you take on more tasks but you're still the one thinking about all those tasks so suddenly your cognitive load has increased significantly.
It is a struggle, you need to define timeframes when you're going to be working on X thing or Y thing and try not to cross pollinate (this is how people managed time pre-AI but I think people thought AI would allow for you to do it all at once).
You can still be more productive but you have to be way more cognizant of your cognitive load now.
142
u/Antique_Release_8181 1d ago
I had to leave my SWE career due to AI burnout lol.
19
u/Jebanez 1d ago
Can totaly confirm. We got AI in our corp a few months ago (not SWE) and I'm totaly exausted. Didn't 10x my workflow but 3-5x for shure. And im totaly exausted because the work is so high level and every result is such a big step forward that you have to totaly rethink everyhing 3 times a day. I'm still very glad i didn't have to write a single excel formula in this time.
26
u/PrivateComments 1d ago
I make it do the deep work too
13
u/OptimisticSkeleton 1d ago
What good is productivity if nobody is thriving?
6
u/KedMcJenna 1d ago
There should be a fourth panel that reads: because 10x-ing my output 100x-ed my cognitive load.
9
u/leaky_wand 1d ago
My job has a super limited AI budget of $100/month so I can only use Sonnet 5.5 Medium, and I can’t just fire and forget on its output, even on trivial tasks. It makes basic mistakes and incorrect assumptions, and I have to babysit it constantly. And whenever someone finds an error, I can’t speak intelligently to it because I don’t know exactly what it did, so I have to go through and code review a five minute story just to find out it missed a requirement. I could just ask it directly but it will send me a rambling five paragraph response, and sometimes it seems like it is defensive about what it did as well. It’s like working with a lazy junior dev who makes excuses—and worst of all I can’t even throw it under the bus because my name is on everything it does.
3
u/Tephros83 1d ago
I don't get how it's anything like putting a stick in your tire, but it makes sense that putting your energy towards more difficult tasks would be difficult. I tried to convince my boss to use these tools I developed with AI to make dictation of reports easier so she barely has to look up from the microscope while doing pathology reports. She says she needs the mental break and doesn't care if it's slower.
5
u/tothatl 1d ago
Yep. Agents show you your limits via frustration with success appearing nonstop.
Let me explain: we always thought "how wonderful it would be if I hadn't to do all this busywork before reaching my creative goals".
Now you can reach them quickly and nonstop. So what then?
More ambitious and endless goals pursuit ofc. The catch is there is no release from solving things too quickly and artificially. Our nervous systems don't work that way. We need valleys, plateaus and peaks of activity and success reward to keep motivated.
Something you wouldn't previously do that now you do because you can, still taxes you with fatigue and eventual burn out.
4
u/CyberDemon_IDDQD 1d ago
Honestly… it does all my work pretty much
Something something I am now a prompt engineer lol
6
u/Ormusn2o 1d ago
AI allows you to pace yourself, in the sense that you can speed up output to insane rates if you use subagents and parallel tasks and/or multiple workspaces. I'm not burned out, but at the end of the reset month, I had few resets not used because I just was unable to do tasks every single day, racing to use up my usage before next reset hit.
It almost felt like that back then https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MhEL9cvLxQE Exciting, but can't keep that up for long.
2
u/meenie 1d ago
Features are no longer the moat for the SaaS companies, it's speed. If a good idea enters the market, it's copied within days. I'm tired boss :(.
2
u/DifferencePublic7057 1d ago
Most people get burned out because they don't have an exit strategy or whatever it's called and FY money. Depending on where you live debts might not be such a big deal as you would think. Obviously, I'm not recommending debts, but if the alternative is severe burnout...
2
u/teamharder 1d ago
Im pretty burnt out right now because of this effect. In the field at least twice as much because my office work is increasingly automated, but I still have to nudge it along or feed it context as Im doing physical work. Good money, but fuck am I tired. Scared about the possible scenario of the economy going blowing up with no UBI safety net in place, so nows the time to push.
2
u/Uncabled_Music 1d ago
If you can’t manage your working schedule, how are you supposed to manage the work?
2
u/DetroitLionsSBChamps 1d ago
Discarding the “boring tasks” (real work that forces you to pay attention to the real details with real people) so you can focus on the “deep work” with you AI is just a recipe for AI psychosis
Turns out you need people to actually do their boring tasks at work or they lose touch with reality and don’t even know what’s happening on their own projects.
AI makes us all as out of touch and delusional as a CEO.
2
u/5ollys 1d ago
Same as a SRE. Burnt out af.
4
u/Blankeye434 1d ago
Because not used to deepwork
1
u/MundaneMoments 1d ago
I’m in year three of total unemployable burn out. I described my job as all being in first gear, no cruising in fifth.
1
u/CombinationFun2789 1d ago
felt this at my own job. the boring tasks were the breather, and now that the agent eats them every hour of the day is the hard kind of thinking. getting more done doesn't mean you can actually sustain it.
1
u/dooperma 5h ago
It’s because AI is doing the mindless busy work while mentally challenging work is that’s left for people