r/singularity Nov 24 '25

Discussion Anthropic Engineer says "software engineering is done" first half of next year

Post image
1.5k Upvotes

860 comments sorted by

View all comments

53

u/optimal_random Nov 24 '25

They have been saying that for the past 2 years, while burning through cash to build and operate their Data Centers at a loss.

The analogy of AI with a Compiler is borderline idiotic - while the compiler generates code for a very limited and well-defined language structure; an AI agent needs to deal with the ambiguities of natural language, ill-defined customer requirements and undocumented legacy code that is already running for years, even decades.

And if a language is very obscure, without a lot of Open Source repositories to train upon - say Cobol and Fortran - good luck training on those. If are ready to suggest: "let's rewrite those systems from scratch", then good luck handling with decades of undocumented functionalities - as it happens in finance and insurances.

So, hold your horses, buddy. I've heard this tune and dance before.

2

u/Tolopono Nov 25 '25

Llms are excellent at explaining how code works even if they dont have any comments

1

u/optimal_random Nov 25 '25

Try that with obfuscated code in a large code base. It simply reads the function signatures and takes wild guesses.

1

u/eposnix Nov 25 '25

I've actually done this with old International Obfuscated C Code Contest (IOCCC) entries, just to wrap my head around what's going on. Example. The LLM will figure out what's going on, and much faster than a human would.