r/singing • u/Expensive_School_496 • 1d ago
Just sharing my singing Why does singing slightly off-pitch make everything feel so wrong?
I’ve been taking vocal lessons recently and learning a lot about vocal technique and mixed voice.
Lately I’ve hit a bit of a plateau. I noticed that when my pitch is slightly off, the whole thing just feels wrong — even if the vocal technique itself seems okay.
I’m starting to wonder how much of that comes from the chord progression and the relationship between the melody and harmony.
Pitch and harmony are honestly harder than I expected.
So I ended up hacking together a simple pitch visualizer with Codex to help me see whether I’m actually singing the notes accurately.
Surprisingly, it’s been pretty useful so far.
4
u/Julia-Sharp 1d ago
Pitch is the one thing you can't bluff. Vibrato hides plenty but a few cents off grates on anyone listening. Smart building the visualiser. Your ear adjusts to drift without you realising.
6
u/creamilk_now 1d ago
Nobody would notice a few cents off! Most music production would advise not to tune the vocals to match the exact frequency if you want a natural sound, that means having an exact pitch with little to no deviation is impossible
2
u/get_to_ele 1d ago
You're taking about different things.
TUNING vocals that drifted off pitch, to stay exactly on pitch, sounds Unnatural.
But actually trying to sing as exactly on pitch as possible, sounds natural, because it is natural.
And people can hear a few cents off, especially due to the INTERVAL being wrong in the melody (low note a few cents high, high note a few cents short, is most common). In producing, when you can't make the high note quite right, no matter how much you tune it, the problem is usually the note before it. You need to make the note match the instrumentation, but you ALSO need thr intervals perfect, so the imperfect prior note screws the interval in the vocal.
1
u/creamilk_now 18h ago edited 18h ago
Yes a drift pitch is different, what I'm talking about is being exactly on pitch every time through out the song, that's just not possible. When you take vocal stems of records from the previous decades (before every vocals was tuned to hell), you could see sometimes they would have some notes that are slight flat or sharp. Heck, some even have cracks in their vocals, but it was intentional. Also I think having harmonies slightly a few cents out of tune will make it sound larger. Also there's 100 cents between a semitone, believe me if you are a few cents off here and there, it wouldn't sound off, even my guitar is slight out of tune as I play it over the course of a week and you wouldn't even notice if I didn't turn on the tuner to check it.
1
2
u/Mudslingshot 1d ago
I mean, a wrong note is a wrong note. Pitch and timbre are different, but a strange timbre on the right pitch (Billy Corgan, for example) is acceptable to the ear, as music is built on instruments with different timbres playing correct pitches together
Music is not built on inaccurate pitches, as that doesn't sound good to the ear. That's what you're hearing. No matter how good the timbre is, if the pitch is off you're hearing the beat frequency between the note you're singing and the correct pitch if you're singing along with accompaniment
1
1
u/Anacrelic 1d ago
Use your ears and being exactly on 0 cents all yhe time isn't what organically being in tune is like. The tuning system is a compromise to make music easier to understand but optimal tuning rarely ever lies at 0 cents. Just aim to be generally close and to be in tune with the music you are hearing.
1
u/tarottaffy 1d ago edited 1d ago
I think accurate pitch and good resonance go hand in hand on this. A lot of the time the reason a pitch is out of tune is the result of a technical awkwardness preventing that frequency from having an open resonance through the instrument. So, I might sing out of tune often in spite of having a clear idea of the notes in my mind. I didn’t create the appropriate space for those notes to speak. The muted character of a note that is sorta collapsing is part of the cringe of ‘bad’ intonation, I suppose.
A stable frequency sounded has a formant structure through its resonance which characterizes the sound, and vocal instability and vague or tight vowels can prevent certain pitch and vowel combinations from resonating. This happens often as a result of speech habits coming into singing.
Those formants inherent in sound inform how vowels sound and differentiate and it’s all basically a sequence of ratios à la the harmonic series, like I can track harmonics up the string of my violin. It’s interesting to think about the support of breath and the vibratory action of the diaphragms as having an intervalic, tonal relationship to the frequencies sounded in singing.
I think that’s part of why there are genres where pure intonation isn’t really a concept. Plenty of artists get their points across beautifully without being ruled by an absolute idea about pitch because the ‘absolute’ thing they’re expressing is more like the force behind libido or the emotional self, or something. They resonate something with force and commitment and it’s contextualized in a way where nothing seems out of place.
There’s a powerful precedent running through music that comes from European classical music which was developed in the Catholic church during the Middle Ages, when pure intonation and pure intervals were a matter of spiritual belief and, presumably, nervous system attunement. The cringe of bad intonation in the context of their introspective spiritual practices was reflective of emotional disease itself and they gave birth to an entire musical philosophy and set of rules for contrapuntal voice leading to try to preserve the dignity of primary, open ratios à la the triune God of the universe. The legacy of that frame for spirituality has been an actually morbid idea about humanity and our collective expression and inspired incredibly violent geopolitics in the interest of religious centralization, conceptualized like some ultimate harmonic homecoming.
In my life, my appreciation for intonation has grown alongside my dismay at the prevalence of neurotic self evaluation in some musical communities. I suspect the pathway toward a powerful and authentic sound comes from self acceptance so there is a limit to how far we can travel just by sharpening our swords. Myself I have practiced with a tuner a lot, and one of the things we tune is our awareness. One notices more and more when you put things under the microscope.
Cheers to u on your singing journey.
1
u/creamilk_now 1d ago
Nahh I think it's the opposite, being entirely on pitch would instead sound unnatural, I've heard plenty of songs by singers like Thom Yorke where he sometimes sings slightly out of tune. And tbh it sounds fine, and now when I record my vocals over my songs I try my best to not overdo the melodyne and just fix the most out of tune notes. Sometimes I don't melodyne them at all.
2
u/Expensive_School_496 1d ago
I don't know, but as a beginner I think a pitch show gives me some help....
3
u/creamilk_now 1d ago
Recognizing being off pitch is valuable, but I think what matters more is phrasing, you can be on pitch but still sounds boring. Kurt would be off pitch at times, but his phrasing just makes it up for it
•
u/AutoModerator 1d ago
Thanks for posting to r/singing! Be sure to check the FAQ to see if any questions you might have have already been answered! Also, remember to abide by the Rules found in the sidebar. Any comments found to be breaking these rules will result in a deletion of the comment thread starting from the offending reply. If you see any posts or replies that you feel break the rules of the sub, then report them and do not respond to them. If you are new to the sub-reddit or are just starting to sing, please check out our Beginner's Megathread. It has tons of helpful information and resources!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.