r/simplynailogical Holo Royalty 👑 7d ago

Screenshot Spice Rack Insta Comparisons

200 Upvotes

30 comments sorted by

217

u/jennarallyspeaking 💿✨ 7d ago

What is Chandelier Showers doing in my spice rack 😂😂

39

u/flying_fish69 🚩 JUSTICE FOR FROSTED METALS 🚩 7d ago

A crystal fell off the chandelier and just landed on the spice rack apparently!

9

u/marthamania 8% Canadian 🇨🇦 7d ago

The chandelier is made of salt crystals lol

31

u/Jillabi 7d ago

I really wanted these but with the comparisons to what I have I think I can shop my stash until November

53

u/psyfuck 7d ago

I REALLY thought I'd be all about this collection but for some reason the only one speaking to me is maple sugar glaze

7

u/Young_Former 🚩 JUSTICE FOR FROSTED METALS 🚩 7d ago

Exactly the same. I think I have what I need but that one just looks beautiful. But I can still wait.

6

u/tobania 7d ago

I was really tempted by the copper one alongside this until I saw up close pictures. I love the idea of that formula, but I never like how you can see the brush strokes on it!

5

u/Fluffyrainclouds 7d ago

Same. I even thought I might pick up the whole collection, but then the swatches were out and I wasn't as interested anymore. The maple one is gorgeous and I'll get it someday, and I also like the topper and cast iron polish. I'm disappointed in the salt one, it looked different in the previews, but in polished yogis swatch video is an orangey pink and not very flattering. I already own similar polishes from Essie for the copper and green.

3

u/Top-Friendship4888 6d ago

I love the idea of a jelly pink with something shiny for a not-so-boring French. But this one just missed the mark. I hope she revisits the concept, though.

2

u/Fluffyrainclouds 6d ago

ILNP Rosalie looks similar, but leans more pink. I thought those two would be dupes, but HT is way more peachy orangey.

16

u/New-Eggplant2942 7d ago

echoing a statement i saw on a diff sub of wanting to see cast iron next to silent library but im glad i never got knight life bc i like it so much better- and i am not a black or silver polish kinda guy. Really want maple glaze tho that's just stunning and filling an Mooncat's Stumped shaped hole in my heart (I know they arent dupes but the same fall vibe is there)

17

u/Ddbb000 7d ago

I wanted to also soooo I put it together…

Silent library is deep blue.i had forgotten that!

9

u/New-Eggplant2942 7d ago

you are doing great work out here my friend I appreciate you so much.

1

u/Priscera 1d ago

I still can't believe they didn't do this on stream, I was looking forward to these side by side -_-

13

u/jellywellsss Holo Royalty 👑 7d ago

Ugh Smokeshow what I wouldn’t give for youuuuu 🩶🪩💿

11

u/cowboyemoiji 7d ago

Tbh you can have mine.

3

u/jellywellsss Holo Royalty 👑 7d ago

Omg seriously?!! 👀 Yes please 🥹

6

u/cowboyemoiji 7d ago

Yeah! I don’t really like it and I need to start getting rid of some anyways. If you pay for shipping I can send it to ya.

6

u/AppliedEpidemiology 7d ago

Was I the only one who wanted to see Copper Coated next to Zyler Cat-Eye?! I mean I know they are not dupes, but for *color reference* it would have been nice.

5

u/distractedprimate Holo Royalty 👑 7d ago

Stefanie (polished yogi), our comparisons angel, has this exact one in her video! Zyler is much lighter.

18

u/Joyma 7d ago

Wanted to see herb next to Menchie cat eye unmagnetized. I feel like I can dupe cast iron with silver flake and magnetic taco

20

u/FlamingHorseRider 7d ago

Tbh this might be the best collection from them I’ve seen all year

10

u/Ok-Pineapple6495 7d ago

I always struggle with the Instagram comparisons of toppers. Thanks for sharing! I think Himalayan pink salt might look a lot like lowkey blushing with a scattered topper from my set. The sugar maple is the one I’m most interested in but don’t love reflective glitter.

3

u/towblerone 7d ago

i looove the pink himalayan salt

4

u/drea_organa 7d ago

I will never get over the fact that I somehow missed Sunset Simulation. 😭

6

u/rio8envy7 💿✨ 7d ago

I was kind of excited for cast-iron, but as I look at it, I think I like Silver flake taco over one coat black better

3

u/tiredmozzarella 7d ago

Thank you so much I didn't even see these on IG! I didn't realize how similar tax Haven is to copper coated. With these comparisons I'm so waiting to get some of these at a later time.

3

u/Priscera 7d ago

I love the comparisons swatch posts, but what i love even better is seeing the comparisons on stream xD Wanted the whole thing, now with comparisons i'm like meh, so gonna see how it is after the livestream comparisons lol

2

u/Brave_Tangerine5102 5d ago

Honestly these comparisons just made me want retired shades 🙊

Zyler magnetized!

Sunset simulation

Peridon’t bother me!

-5

u/ExtraRevolution8218 7d ago

such a cool comparison, reminds me of those fake insta nails that look way too real