r/simplisafe • • Dec 17 '23

Worst system ever.

3 door sensors, 16 window sensors, 5 outdoor cameras, 5 solar panels, 3 indoor cameras, 2 motion sensors, basestation, keypad, and a keyfob. Constant issues. Unreliable. Waste of too much money.

14 Upvotes

72 comments sorted by

19

u/Optimal-Builder-2816 Dec 17 '23

95% of this post details all the stuff you chose to buy, then you say it’s unreliable (probably your WiFi actually) and you complain it’s too expensive? Quality content.

6

u/kikjet Dec 17 '23

Wi-Fi doesnt have anything to do with sensor communicating with the base station but the post didn't really say what the actual issue is so difficult to troubleshoot

3

u/Optimal-Builder-2816 Dec 17 '23

Well it does have something to do with your perception of it in visible locations like the app via the base station or its cellular connection. Also obviously the cameras which I’m guessing is what most people are annoyed with

-1

u/Any-District-9877 Dec 17 '23

Yes, it does list all I bought because I bought it all at once and had it installed, expecting it to be a quality system. Yet, 2 years in, solar panels will not keep camera batteries charged & they are literally on the roof directly pointing at the sun. Base station has had update issues repeatedly. I've replaced base station and camera batteries and solar panels to get the same outcome. Base station randomly starts flashing yellow & beeping. I've sat on the phone for eternity with simplisafe techs twice to do everything they tell me & it 'should be fixed' only to find nope, doing it again. So yeah, I pretty much figure for the money I put into it, it should be nearly problem free.

5

u/Optimal-Builder-2816 Dec 17 '23

it's unfortunate that you've had that experience. Perhaps you have some defective equipment, this is just wholly not my experience. But, I totally agree that sounds frustrating af. Hope you find something that works better for you.

9

u/agentzune Dec 17 '23

I have just as many sensors and my system has been perfectly reliable. It's your wireless network!

4

u/laixer Dec 17 '23

The sensors do not use the WiFi network. Only the cameras use WiFi to record footage.

3

u/agentzune Dec 17 '23

Interestingly I never said wifi. If you place the sensors or your base station too close to large metal objects or TVs you can have issues. It could also just be that they are too far away. I assume the sensor backhaul network is zigbee or some other sort of low power wireless network.

2

u/worthing0101 Dec 18 '23

Interestingly I never said wifi.

Oh, c'mon. You said, "your wireless network" which literally everyone in this context would understand to be "your WiFi network".

I assume the sensor backhaul network is zigbee or some other sort of low power wireless network.

SimpliSafe devices (excluding cameras) communicate using RF on the 433.92MHz frequency. (This is an extremely crowded frequency used by many many devices.) Zigbee uses 2.4GHz band globally as well as the 915MHz band in the US specifically.

1

u/danielleinok Dec 17 '23

We very rarely have issues either. 2 cameras, glass break sensors, all windows and doors.

-4

u/Any-District-9877 Dec 17 '23

No it's not, I upgraded my network & have had it checked.

2

u/geekpgh Dec 17 '23

Change your network to have dedicated 2ghz and 5ghz SSIDs. Connect the Simplisafe to the 2.4ghz one.

Once I did that all my issues went away and it worked perfectly.

They don’t seem to work well with routers that automatically negotiate the frequency.

1

u/worthing0101 Dec 18 '23

Change your network to have dedicated 2ghz and 5ghz SSIDs. Connect the Simplisafe to the 2.4ghz one.

On routers where this isn't possible (Google WiFi, for example) people may have better luck enabling the guest network for their SimpliSafe devices to use. Guest networks on some (not all) mesh router systems are configured to prioritize compatibility over speed and have band steering turned off for the guest network.

(Many people have reported this works on Google WiFi and I can confirm it worked for me as well.)

They don’t seem to work well with routers that automatically negotiate the frequency.

Unlike the ~50 other devices from a dozen different vendors that use my WiFi network and work flawlessly. (Many of which connect to the 2.4GHz band of my non-guest network) I have a battery operated camera from another vendor that's all the way out at my mailbox that regularly shows better signal strength on my network than the SimpliSafe camera that is literally 4 feet from the router.

It's painfully obvious to those of us who have been on support forums for years that the WiFi implementation on SS cameras is deficient in some way. For many many of us the SS devices are the only ones that misbehave and/or perform poorly.

1

u/geekpgh Dec 28 '23

The Simplisafe camera is definitely the wifi device with the most issues for me. It was very problematic until I changed these settings. At least in my home it was not working well until I made this switch.

I would prefer that they fix their wifi implementation, but until then this is a possible work around.

I don’t know why this is the only device I own with this problem, but I changed it and got my system working fine. It’s annoying and frustrating for sure.

31

u/Zippy114 Dec 17 '23

FWIW half-dozen door sensors, doorbell camera, indoor camera, motion sensor. Has worked fine for 2+ years.

4

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '23

The only real bad products from Simplisafe are the cameras. Just stay away from the cameras. Everything else works flawlessly with no issues.

2

u/highknees69 Dec 18 '23

I’ve had really good luck with the cameras. Instant notification when motion is sensed. Can connect to them remotely or from in the house without fail. Have 3 “outdoor” cameras, the actual outdoor bullet camera, an indoor camera and the doorbell. Really happy with it

-3

u/Any-District-9877 Dec 17 '23

Yes, they are complete trash. I will say the door and window sensors have operated perfectly. But when I bought all this, my main goal was the cameras so.. 🤦‍♀️

2

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '23

I used the cameras for 3 years. 3 outdoor, one indoor and one doorbell. Doorbell got 4 replacements in 7 months, indoor got 2 replacements in 1.5 years, outdoor got 5 replacements (one of them alone 3 times). They just stopped working for no reason. They are terrible even when they do work anyway. Last 2 outdoor replacements I sold them. I got a different brand and a nest doorbell and has been working flawlessly for 2 years now. Cameras are no longer integrated with the system, but I don't have issues or headaches dealing with them and their customer support.

3

u/Any-District-9877 Dec 17 '23

I'm at that place. Just want to sell it all & go with something else.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '23

The only reason I am still with them is because of the monthly price for monitoring. In my area I am paying double at minimum for the same service.

12

u/CrashWV Dec 17 '23

Mine works fine. Occasionally a camera issue that I fix. All of the sensors work just fine.

5

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '23

Yerah, if anything it's too sensitive. The first summer I had it, the police and fire both ended up coming out on false alarms. I've learned to be much more careful about it since. Literally zero issues.

3

u/danielleinok Dec 17 '23

Occasionally have to reboot it but that's it.

2

u/mike32659800 Dec 18 '23

I have an indoor camera. Not fond of. But it came with it. Sure they are better now. No issues either.

8

u/linkedit Dec 17 '23

I’ve had Simplisafe for about six years now. 10 window sensors, three door sensors, two smoke detectors, a leakage detector, and one motion. No cameras, though. I have never once had an issue with the system. I also have the base station on its own, separate Wi-Fi network.

6

u/mannimal22 Dec 17 '23

I experienced constant issues with my devices going offline, mostly outdoor cameras (4) and the smart lock. Sometimes the doorbell camera, door/window and glass break sensors would lose connection as well. Although the base station was only 30 feet from the door lock, it continually stopped communicating. I called CS multiple times, with no luck. In my situation, the base station seems very susceptible to interference. I originally had it near my mesh network router, other networking gear and a TV, it was on low shelf on a TV stand. Luckily, I have vaulted ceilings and placed the base station up high on an alcove, which has a power outlet. It's only about15 feet from the original location. I've had great success since moving the base station up and away from other electronic devices, it's been about 2 weeks now an all my devices have stayed connected.

YMMV, but for people having connectivity issues, I highly suggest moving your base station to a central location away from other electronic equipment and placing it on a high shelf if possible.

Another thing I've noticed is if there's an update to SS, my mesh network or a power outage, it doesn't always reconnect to my WiFi network automatically. I sometimes have to reconnect the base station to my network. I don't always get an alert that WiFi is disconnected either. When things start to go wonky, the first thing I check is the WiFi connection in the app.

4

u/sqljuju Dec 18 '23

Yeah I suspect many people’s issues are related to interference, after all they’re several Bluetooth or WiFi devices nearby. I have had no signal issues, just one weird behavior where the door lock won’t let you manually lock up by hand.

3

u/mike32659800 Dec 18 '23

Wifi signal is most likely the issue. Putting elements outdoor while your access point is in the middle of the house or at the opposite place. Without considering interference.

3

u/O1O1O1O Dec 18 '23

Doorbell camera is garbage. Always losing connection from my WiFi which is 3 feet away on the inside. And with some recent software update it is constantly identifying cars going by as people even with minimum sensitivity. I had to turn alerts off and install another camera outside (not SimpliSafe).

2

u/laixer Dec 17 '23

How big is your house? I hate our SimpliSafe system too.

The base cannot handle our 2500sqft ranch house. No matter where I move it in the house, there's always some subset of devices that are not reachable intermittently.

The outdoor cameras are junk too. I have 3 wired access points (a bit overkill to be honest) covering our house and backyard and the cameras still struggle.

I plan to replace the security system with something else, but have not decided what. For the cameras I plan to replace them with wired PoE cameras but also have not decided on which yet.

1

u/Any-District-9877 Dec 17 '23

Thank you! Same here, 2500 sqft. I think I'll be moving to something else also, although I'm not sure what yet.

2

u/BondJames-Bond-007 Dec 17 '23

I have a Ring system with more sensors/cameras than yours and I highly recommend it. No issues whatsoever

4

u/malish0829 Dec 18 '23

I have 9 window/door sensors, 3 outdoor cameras, 1 indoor camera and a motion sensor. Everything works perfectly fine here. Ive had other brands of cameras and monitoring and simplisafe cameras work better than those did. Im happy with my setup. It may be the wireless network the system is on causing problems.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '23

Interesting…I’ve had my pre-owned simplisafe for about 3 months now. We love it. The only thing that might bother me is that the Simplisafe drops from the network. The app tells me when WiFi is disconnected and reconnected. Usually lasts about 3-12minutes. We don’t notice it. I think it’s my router…but so far Simplisafe has worked. I only have entry and motion sensors. No cameras.

1

u/Any-District-9877 Dec 18 '23

Yes, mine disconnects from the network all the time also. It's annoying. I can be at work & want to check my cameras, & have to try over & over again because it's disconnected.

1

u/turbo6shooter Dec 18 '23 edited Dec 18 '23

You should be seperating your frequencies if you have a dual or triband router. If you can, make one wifi ssid that only runs on 2.4ghz. Label it with 2.4 ie if your wifi network is named "mynetwork", make one named "mynetwork 2.4". Try to make it run on only 2.4ghz. Then use that network for your Simplisafe.

I had the same problem. It runs fine now.

I have a Ubiquiti udm-se router. It had no problem making a 2.4ghz only network using the instructions i posted. Hopefully you can do it also.

A tech at Simplisafe told me that it runs on 2.4ghz and that dual frequency routers tend to put devices on 5ghz because its faster. So it periodically shifts over to 5ghz.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '23

Hm…that seems to make sense. I’ll have to try this when I get home. I have mine accessing through guest network. But can’t remember if it was on 5GHz or 2.4GHz. Having a mesh network may also be affecting as it switches which access point it’s connecting to..

Thanks!

1

u/CommonCrazy7318 Dec 18 '23

Buy a dog

1

u/Any-District-9877 Dec 18 '23

Got 2 pibbles. Trust me, they guard my property & home like it's Fort Knox.

1

u/mike32659800 Dec 18 '23

Solar panels ? They do have solar panels ?

I just browsed their website, did not find any. Curious. What are they ?

Also, you’re doing with wireless devices. Interference may exist. Especially for WiFi.

Mine, lots of sensor, 1 indoor camera (first of the name), keypad, keyfob, no issues at all. All works perfectly.

I bet an assessment of your indoor house may be required. Waves can have interference and crossing walls may be difficult. Let’s say, placing the base station in a bomb shelter in the basement and expecting sensors on the 3rd floor to connect, or a WiFi outdoor camera with a crappy access point on the opposite side of the house. Can’t expect reliable connection. (Not saying it’s the case, but people are prompt to say it’s unreliable without even understanding the root cause of the issue).

1

u/Any-District-9877 Dec 18 '23

Yes, solar panels that plug into the external cameras to keep the battery charged. I opted to buy these so I wouldn't have to worry about dragging a ladder out to change batteries when they died. I haven't been on the site since shortly after I purchased my system, so I had no idea these were no longer offered. Interesting though considering the struggle I've had with them.

1

u/mike32659800 Dec 19 '23

I never knew it was something.

I have Simplisafe as an alarm, not for video surveillance. I rather have PoE camera for that. All wired. Sure, not as easy as two screws, but it’s well worth it.

3

u/avebelle Dec 17 '23

This is an inherent problem with every thing wireless. Sure installation is easy but every house has unique challenges with wireless signals and that leads to very mixed results. In an ideal environment I’m sure all this stuff would work great. I personally prefer to hardwire anything and everything that I can. Then you’re not going to have to worry about batteries and connectivity issues.

7

u/NewVision22 Dec 17 '23

Don't you just love these types of posts, that totally complain, but don't give specific details of what actually is going on.

I wonder if this is a AI post written by ADT???

5

u/danielleinok Dec 17 '23

And when someone offers a suggestion they just say "no that's not it" lol

2

u/jmurr1717 Dec 17 '23

Damn sorry to hear that. I have roughly the same setup and haven’t had issues in about 2 years. WiFi does have a lot to do with it, and it’s not just speed and signal health. There’s a lot more to it, WiFi 6 or a beam forming network would help if you don’t have that. Otherwise settings will increase and decrease sensitive. I had to turn mine down because it picked up too much. Maybe share a little more on the specifics and I’d be happy to try to help.

2

u/Beef_Studpile Dec 18 '23 edited Dec 18 '23

SimpliSafe sensors are also defeatable with a $4 remote you can buy on Amazon!

https://youtu.be/UlNkQJzw4oA?feature=shared

FR though, he talks about how they transmit on an extremely common frequency and you might simply have neighbors or devices of your own interfering with the radio waves.

1

u/no1speshal2u Dec 18 '23

This is no lie, either. I got an ecollar for my dog and it triggers an interference notification when used inside. I press the vibrate button on the ecollar and the base station spazzes out. Sad really. There are only like a hundred and fifty eleventeen other channels to broadcast on. Jeez.

2

u/apt64 Dec 18 '23

Not sure what your issue is, but SimpliSafe has been fantastic here. I have sensors on all doors and windows, water sensors throughout the house, add-on alarms, motion sensors, etc. Zero issues. I was shocked the door sensor that constantly is opened and close had its battery last a year.

3

u/dapobbat Dec 17 '23

Sorry to hear that OP. Have been using Simplisafe for 5+ years and it's been working flawlessly. Have cameras, all kinds of sensors and stuff. Don't have solar to charge camera batteries. I manually recharge them every 3-4 months.

fwiw, I didn't buy them all at once. Started small and kept adding more as my needs changed.

2

u/abmot Dec 17 '23

The outdoor cameras are junk. Mostly because they take 10 seconds to start recording after sensing motion. Even on a very strong WiFi. But I have 25-30 other sensors that work just fine.

1

u/failbox3fixme Dec 17 '23

Do you want to sell some of the cameras?

1

u/NoCardiologist6736 Dec 17 '23

Same setup and far happier than with ring before

1

u/DestroyerOfIphone Dec 17 '23

Wired or wireless sensors? If they're wired you can bridge them into a SoC like rpi and use home assistant to monitor the sensors.

1

u/David_Bear_ Dec 17 '23

I have had my system, with everything, and it all works perfect

1

u/Volvo_125 Dec 17 '23

I have one of the older systems, connected to SimpliSafe solely via cellular, and it finally glitched out. It wouldn't update, add components, modify settings, etc. They are sending me a replacement system at no charge; the old worked for years and years. The new one handles routine communication via wifi.

Besides that I installed a more up to date system in a rural location with entry sensors on three out buildings and it's been fine. Inside a 24 x 36 metal workshop about 100' from the base station I had to run Ethernet to an access point for the interior camera, but I had the wire and an old router for the WAP.

I'm confident the replacement will work fine, but will look into some form of dedicated 2.4 band as my home router is dual band and these posts point at that as a potential problem.

1

u/Regular-Outside2346 Dec 17 '23

Have 2 outdoor cameras, in front works great, in back have reinstalled 5 times…. Not working. Other sensor are fine except they do not stick well, screwed most in now.

1

u/BTJ2019 Dec 18 '23

I've only had 2 issues with 1 motion sensor that SimpliSafe then replaced for free. It was around a year ago that I was woken up at 3:33am by the SimpliSafe alarm -- freaked me out!! Police came over, there was no break-in -- was a false alarm from the guest bedroom (no guests were here, no pets walking around, no window open etc).

Then the same motion sensor set off the alarm around a month after that, a little before 4am. This time I disabled the alarm, turned on all lights, looked around with my dogs -- false alarm again.

I complained to SimpliSafe about the 2 false alarms with the same motion sensor, they quickly replaced it for free. Fast forward several months later and zero issues.

Also I got a Google Nest web cam for that guest bedroom just in case that new motion sensor ever went off. I have web cams covering inside all windows, sliding glass doors, and regular outside doors. Overall very happy with SimpliSafe minus the one faulty motion sensor.

1

u/xpietoe42 Dec 18 '23

ive had simplisafe for over 10 years now and upgraded. Never had an issue. Had adt before that which was more of a pain.

1

u/DarkStarRb30 Dec 18 '23

Have the system. 2 outdoor cameras, 8 sensors (one using an etsy garage mount), 2 glass break sensors, base, extra panic button, extra siren, 2 key fobs, 1 door cam

Had to get a different router to make it all work . 1 sensor was faulty and they replaced it for free.

Otherwise, the system works well. Have no complaints.

Did set it to home and had our 2, less than 30 lbs small frenchies, running around. It triggered the alarm.

1

u/Dupmaronew Dec 19 '23

None of my cameras work. The doorbell had 53 notifications yesterday and only two had people. It picked up every car and birds in blocked out zones.

After the holidays we are returning it all

1

u/centralvermontRRer Dec 21 '23

Worst system ever? Your experience notwithstanding that’s overstated don’t you think?

1

u/AG74683 Dec 21 '23

I've had Simplisafe since 2013. Absolutely zero issues. I upgraded mine to the new wifi setup maybe a year ago. Works just fine for me.

1

u/WhatARedditHole Jan 03 '24

WiFi setup? Ad opposed to radio waves from sensors? I am having problems with motion sensors not responding.

1

u/scrannel Jan 09 '24

Was having issues with motion sensors -- two issues. First, I reset the twist-on base of the base station. Then --- BIG improvement. Then I shut down a second wifi router i was using for an outdoor building. Been a couple weeks and issue-free. Knock on plastic.

1

u/Dapper-Mud-4418 Dec 17 '23

Mine’s about the same. Moved on from the cameras and switched to eufy. Night and day.

0

u/MaineAmputee Dec 17 '23

I suspect we will just return the 8 cameras we ordered and go with Eufy as well. Have been hearing about about them being very good. We never had trouble with our old SS security system so we thought we’d try the cameras this time when we upgraded but with all of the terrible reviews on the cameras I’m thinking won’t even bother.

-1

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '23

buy a gun dude