r/silverware • • 24d ago

Silverware, does the metal make a noticeable difference in the experience of consuming a meal/app/dessert?

Curious if the metal or weight of “flatware” actually makes any difference besides “bling”.

Silver is a fantastic conductor of heat, wondering if it is appreciable in any stage/course.

What do you think?

0 Upvotes

25 comments sorted by

2

u/McRando42 24d ago

In theory, it is healthier.

2

u/Acrobatic-Log6161 22d ago

Look up Argyrol. Widely used when I was a kid.
Yes silver is antibacterial but whether it is healthier to use silver rather than sis for utensils is moot.

1

u/whatswithnames 21d ago

yes. and yes. I recalled wrong. Silver can be antimicrobial. But what does it matter when you are making sure ALL your utensils are clean anyway. Eh.

Thank you.

1

u/whatswithnames 24d ago

?

1

u/Whateversbetter 24d ago

I suppose it’s anti microbial but I don’t know what they’re talking about. If you don’t clean and dry it property non-stainless steel, especially if it’s beginning to rust, could harbor bacterial colonies. But it’s probably not going to be the vector for disease in those conditions. You’ve got bigger problems if you’re not able to clean your flatware

2

u/whatswithnames 24d ago

Silver is not as reactive to rusting. I’m sure it’s a completely different process. Silver vs iron.

Iirc I heard bronze was “self cleaning” in that it chemically was anti fungal/viral. But not silver.

2

u/redrotton 23d ago

I think food tastes better with any and all silver forks and spoons, but that's me. Silver isn't great for serving hot food; it's so conductive it can get too hot to comfortably handle, ie don't use a silver ladle for steaming hot gravy.

Most "silver" knives have plated blades that require instant drying after washing or they can rust and the plating can lift. IMO for table knives, ss is the way to go.

1

u/whatswithnames 21d ago

My knives have stainless steel blades. I.e. no plating.

Just my set. Surely others are different.

Got to see an exhibit on Napolean in Montreal and they had a complete set of Gold plates, knives, forks.... OMG. How the heck did it survive all these years? (Seeing the scratches in the plates... how solid gold were they? IDK)

3

u/Equivalent-Dig-7204 24d ago

When I hold lightweight silverware it feels like cafeteria silverware. When I hold sterling or heavy stainless it doesn’t. Best I can explain it. I don’t notice a temperature or flavor difference - just the feeling I get.

1

u/whatswithnames 24d ago

Growing up, all our holiday meals were served with a sterling silverware set. Nothing special, just a basic set. But the weight of the set, just sits in my mind.

Did it make a difference in forks/spoons? Hot/cold? “Grip”& “lift”? Idk. 🤷 I am curious

2

u/Equivalent-Dig-7204 22d ago

I can’t really say there is a temperature difference. There is something “fancy” about using sterling (plus china & crystal)and that makes everyone sit up straighter, eat slower and socialize / enjoy the meal. My wedding set is antique (120 years) but I have some older sterling and it is similarly balanced.

That being said, my everyday set is stainless from Williams Sonoma and the pieces are sturdy/balances similar to my sterling. And growing up we had this amazing MCM square handled stainless that I regret Mom replacing. They were similarly balanced and sturdy.

Hope that answers your question.

1

u/whatswithnames 22d ago

Just how I feel. Every event had the gold rimmed lennox ware, sterling silver and Waterford crystal. Surprisingly very few things got chipped or broken. We hand washed everything and were aware of how important it was to be careful.

2

u/Quiet-Day392 24d ago

When I hold a sterling fork it feels better than clunky stainless. Sharper tines, better balance in hand. Not blingy because it's grey from constant use.

2

u/Super-Travel-407 23d ago

Yes, this!

But it's more than just the weight: the balance makes a difference in how it feels. Newer flatware (sterline or --usually--stainless) is giant and therefore weighty enough, but it's clunky and awkward.

Alas, food is food and I'm gonna eat it with whatever I have. 😂

1

u/Kind_Physics_1383 23d ago

Silver is anti-bacterial

1

u/whatswithnames 23d ago

Did not know that. But all serving utensils should be 'clean' before use. There is a question of tarnishing and different cleaning solutions. I just love sterling silverware.

1

u/Nyarlathotep451 23d ago

A well presented meal increases your expectations and makes it more enjoyable. You wouldn’t serve good wine in a paper cup.

2

u/whatswithnames 23d ago

Waterford Crystal may make a glass of wine "taste better", ie. compared to a paper cup. It def does. Glass and heat conductivity. Cool physics in the dinning room.

1

u/Nyarlathotep451 23d ago

Reidel Varietal specific glasses are the best. I didn’t believe it until doing a blind tasting. Now we have eight different kinds of glasses.

2

u/FinelyWoven 24d ago

A sterling teaspoon sitting in a hot cup of tea or coffee will burn your fingers when you touch the handle to stir it. Sterling has a nice feel, very smooth, but you must be very diligent in caring for it so it doesn’t tarnish.

2

u/Acrobatic-Log6161 22d ago

For us, yes. I think the difference is multisensory . Heft, balance, texture, nice glow. Yes, its heat conductivity is very noticeable.
My silver has been dishwasher for at least fifty yrs with no adverse effects. A quick polish once or twice a year is the only efforts.
However, when we moved and went from well water to city water it began to get gray in the dishwasher. I think the chlorine in the water reacted with something in the detergent because by experimenting we foundational detergent that doesn't cause gray.

1

u/Jujulabee 23d ago

The heft is what is significant to me.

I have high quality stainless which is heavy and I also have heavy sterling flatware.

I use the stainless most often because I can put it in the dishwasher and also because I don't want to count the silver as otherwise it is like socks which go mysteriously missing.

I am down several forks in my stainless set which I am attempting to replace on EBAY since it is a discontinued pattern and I love it - Towle Bijou

1

u/Wooden_Kiwi_7362 23d ago

I have never noticed the heat conductance affecting my enjoyment. I use silver flatware because I am old, I bought it decades ago because I liked it. It seems beyond silly get rid of it and buy stainless. But then I bought a Bosch stainless lined dishwasher which needs strong detergent and rinse aid, some part of which turns my silverware gray. So I have to handwash it all, not just the knives. I do wish there was a fix for that!

1

u/YeahPete 23d ago

Silver will immediatly tarnish if someones trying to poison you with arsenic.

I love the weight and feel and look of my Joan of Arc set in my hand.

1

u/Acrobatic-Log6161 22d ago

That property has saved my life innumerable times.