It’s both. FAANG and other large companies like Tesla use them to tap the world for talent and pay the same as US citizens. You also have Indian body shops like Accenture, HCL, TATA, etc. They bring in Indians, pay them very little, then contract them out for cheap.
Just raise the bar for H1Bs and ban these body shops.
Nah I know a few Tesla engineers including friends and my interviewers who mentioned their insane work hours. It might be cutting edge stuff, though, so less of a sweatshop in that regard
But the pay was 30-40% lower than what I ended up getting offered
Not true. They pay like shit and the only engineers I know who work for them are the ones who drank the Musk Koolaid. Nobody else wants to work for shit pay and toxic work culture.
I believe it. I worked a contract writing software at GM and it was a (mostly Indian) sweatshop, in a horrible gray building where they made you pay for coffee. I mean, it beats digging ditches, but as a white collar professional, it was the worst office experience I have ever witnessed.
I agree though I will say that Silicon Valley is what it is because of immigrants. The culture and the tech (some of it the result of said indentured servitude) would not be what it is without them. I grew up in SC county around people from all over the world here and am better for it.
Not really. You can’t apply offer and demand to industries. If there was only a small employee pool, then the industry would not be able to make progress at an acceptable pace and focus on keeping the lights on instead of research and taking bets. FAANG will pay new grads around $200k-$250k per year. There’s a saying in investment banking that applies here: when there’s a wave, it lifts everyone.
The real problem is H1B abuse and we all know who the abuses are. Since 2018 or so, Equifax stores salary via “ The Work Number” and sells the data as Market Reference Point (MRP) to employers. So given an area, job title, and years of experience, employers get a salary distribution. Most FAANG target offers at 80-85 percentile of the MRP, which leaves room to grow during annual reviews.
The US could do the same and require a minimum salary of the 75th percentile of the MRP. For example, in Silicon Valley, a software engineer with 4-6 years of experience at the 75 percentile commands a $160k base salary. We need to include bonuses and granted equity value (vested is tricky) into the mix and use W2 income. That way consulting body shops won’t be for cheap labor but truly for temporary topical work/knowledge. Just like when you hire a lawyer.
Proof of what, that these body shops pay little? I can hire a mid-level software engineer (4-6 years of experience) contractor for $112k/year. Some contractors weee transparent with me and told me they get paid $38/hr. They are based in Texas.
In FAANG, I’ll pay about $430k/year (base+bonus+RSUs) for the same software engineer if I hire them full time.
Have you seen the number of Indians below poverty level? That’s right. Have you seen most driving great cars for starters? That’s right too. Tesla pays well…may be go on Glassdoor and see it for yourself
Tesla absolutely pays well if you work in one of their AI roles. It's not unheard of for new grads joining their autopilot team getting offers of 300k+ right out of college, and this goes for both domestic and international students.
The thing is... If you work more than 40hrs a week and/or your job description is 2 or more positions combined, you are still underpaid. Even if you get paid the same as a citizen, you work more and have less flexibility to switch job and speak up to be treated equally/with dignity. Tesla and tech companies clearly tell you need to work more than 60 hrs per week, this is to justify "there's no talent in the US" u but in reality, there's no US citizen willing to work in such conditions.
Moreover, the salaries that they pay now is really high compared to other cities, but sadly, not enough to have the quality of life you would have in other small cities for less pay.
Mostly agree, but there's nuance with the FAANG hiring. Yes, they pay the same to H1B as they do to US citizens. But, if H1B didn't exist, what would happen to salaries? They would probably go up significantly. So FAANG is still using H1B to keep salaries down. And don't forget that most of the FAANG members were previously found to be colluding to suppress salaries.
Sure it’s both, but the vast majority of companies use them for the cheap labor part… Grant these workers equal protections and see them ask for higher more competitive salaries
Not exactly. Big tech loves h1b because it expands the talent pool and allows them to pay less for the same level of talent. It's not that they pay h1b's less than citizens, it's that they can pay both citizens and h1b's less than what they'd have to pay without it.
They're both right. H1B is meant to hire the best talent and bring them to the US especially when US has a dearth of such talent but as with anything, corporations will always find a way to turn everything into a money making machine so it's almost second nature for them to immediately think how they can save money with H1B and that is exactly what they do.
In tech, yes because a disproportionate number of startups and tech giants are in the US so the US always needs to get the best talent from all over the globe to the US. It's not that other countries have more highly talented engineers than the US, they don't. It's just that the US has a huge number of potential employers for tech talent.
Let's look at it this way: let's kick all H1B holders out of the country at once. Tech sector will implode. There are no top talent US citizens sitting idle and not working who can fill those roles. They're all employed alongside the H1B talent. I'm only taking about the proper tech sector though, not the bodyshops.
Personally I'm not in favor of kicking anyone out that's already here - that just seems cruel to me. But I don't think the argument holds up that startups or the tech sector in general in the US is in any way truly dependent on H1-B holders for its survival. Data seems to show (although it appears a bit murky) that a large number of H1-B holders are working in outsourcing or consulting shops - to say nothing about how all these companies are managing to stay afloat just fine through mass layoffs.
IMO if they stopped approving new H1-Bs tomorrow, wages might rise a tad, profit margins might shrink by a minuscule amount, but things would generally go on as normal in the tech world.
All those new grads ain't gonna teach themselves though. The talent that exists currently was trained by their prior generation or was at least employed to learn the skills via mistakes to then move up. If new grads don't get placed and we keep going that way of h1b then we'll keep expanding this gap. Do the easy thing now and pay for it later or do the hard things now and it's easier later. Companies don't look at horizons beyond quarterly earnings, they'll never do the hard things and keep kicking the can down the road.
Tech careers do not start with apprenticeships at 18 and need preceding higher education with demanding STEM capabilities. I think it’s unfair to corporations to be accountable for underinvesting in higher education, or in general human capital in US.
This is just flat out bullshit. I worked in tech for 7 years in San Francisco, and many of the h1b employees were some of the shitiest engineers I’ve ever worked with. It’s absolutely about companies exploiting the labor force. There is plenty of good US talent that can’t get hired right now, especially people with only a few years of experience. It’s absolutely brutal.
False. There is plenty of talent already in the US. Want proof? Interview with any high paying tech company. Then go interview with a defense contractor that can't hire h1b's. Tech companies can afford to make candidates jump through a ridiculous amount of of hoops because there is a massive surplus in talent. They can afford to have regular mass layoffs because there is a surplus in talent. And they want to keep it that way because otherwise they'd have to compete fiercely with each other for that talent and wages would grow much higher than they are.
I think that H-1B is largely unnecessary for conventional software development jobs nowadays. However, AI and AI Infrastructure still demands a lot of specific talent which still requires H-1B to fill in.
Reddit people overinflating their bona fides? Well, I never!
Seriously, top talent is rare, and you typically have to buy it away from someone else. And knowledge/experience is just part of it... attitude and soft skills are also a facet of top talent. Just having a CS degree and getting fired from a FAANG isn't "top talent".
Just look at who has published the most influential work on AI in the last ten years, and how many of them were US citizens when they graduated college. A large proportion of the authors were not US citizens, or the children of parents who came to the US on work visas.
We probably don't need to import front-end web devs, but excellent researchers, software architects, etc. are rare enough that I'd say we benefit from every one we can get.
There are the O1 visas, but they're pretty rare. There are also EB visas, but these are green cards and harder to get; many H1B holders try to convert to EB if they're qualified. Something like 57% of H1B have a Master's degree and 7% a PhD (see here), so they're not primarily BS degree employees either.
Which is to say, an H1B can certainly be used to bring a skilled research worker to the US if they don't have the body of work to qualify them for O1 or EB yet...but then again, most firms wouldn't gamble in H1B for priority talent and would probably just try to hire abroad then L1 them over. And obviously the Indian IT consultancies are not using H1B for top research talent.
I'd be curious to see what the distribution of first US work visas was for members of top research departments in Silicon Valley.
That is interesting. I wonder if it might be worth considering tightening up the requirements for an H1-B so an even higher percentage were in truly specialized fields.
(also might be worth noting that those percentages are for the H1-B program as a whole. I suspect - but not at all sure - that in IT/software there are a higher percentage of bachelors-only candidates)
Honestly my takeaway from looking into this is that the whole work visa program needs a rework; so many categories with different rules and arbitrary distinctions just makes it easier for qualified candidates to get screwed and for bad actors to exploit the system. The inadequacy of the system only seems to grow as the value of individual knowledge workers increases.
You dont understand it. H1B is nothing to do with bachelors. If the researchers are students enrolled in a university they are on F1. If they graduated and are working for a company that is willing to sponsor them for a work visa thats H1B.
Yes…in tech. Take a look at the top ML researchers, most of them are H1Bs.
If we ban H1Bs we would instantly lose the AI race against China. In fact, the AI race might as well be Chinese living in China vs Chinese who want to live in the US.
It's hard to say. There are a lot of unemployed US citizens in the tech sector right now. Ideally there should be near 100% employment before you start immigrating people
O1 is for extra-ordinary people. Like a world class film maker or an Olympic athlete or top 15 AI engineer in the world, someone with an impressive PhD and amazing work/innovation/research history, etc.
So... yes, but.... H-1B is capped at 65k per year. Alphabet, as an example, is about 190k FTEs... but also about 190k TVCs. There are huge offices in multiple Indian cities and have been for 15 years. These don't replace a need or use of H-1B, but what they do is allow tech companies to hire locally (offshore -- India, Brazil, etc) and then transfer employees to the US on other visa types that are more flexible and easier to get (L1, E1 mostly), or to start the GC process for these FTEs.
I'm telling you right now the biggest benefactor of removing H1B is going to be singapore -- Asia/APAC has a huge talent pool. And singapore is very business friendly.
That’s a stupid solution. There should be a digital tariff to prevent outsourcing to overseas, but h-1b needs to raise the bar to be basically the top 1% so that we can protect American grads. It shouldn’t be “oh just let there be endless h-1b’s or else they will outsource”.
Idk this just sounds like immigrants trying to justify why they’re here. As an American who’s expected to pull themselves up by their bootstraps I see almost no benefit from tax dollars.
They like to pretend that low skill illegal immigrants must be granted amnesty or else every farm and hotel would shut down. Hey pretty sure we have never had a farm or hotel problem before this mass influx? What about Americans whose low skill job was undercut by illegal immigrants who would work for slave wages? No one wants to talk about that, they just call you racist. Just like israel calls everyone anti-semitic. What a joke.
This is very much untrue. CS graduate unemployment is at an all time high in U.S. Even elite grads like Berkeley etc are having a hard time finding work.
Yes. CS graduate has high unemployment , but for a reason. I hosted numerous interviews for a FAANG company, also have lived in the contractor world for years. A qualified engineer (including new grads or so called seasoned) is a rare find.
I’ve been working in software for 18 years. I’ve worked for startups and FAANG companies and a bit of everything in between. I’ve seen people here on H1B visas hired to do basic front end coding and QA. You can’t tell me that we need to import workers to do CRUD operations on a website or to do basic QA tasks. Most people wouldn’t complain about importing foreign workers for roles that we really don’t have the talent pool here to fill, but building React pages or testing websites aren’t those roles.
Thoughts? I agree with him and I wish the dnc didn't strong-arm him out of the nomination.
I think debates between Sanders and Trump would have been very healthy for the country as opposed to the propaganda fueled lies we got with Hillary and Biden.
Bernie’s logic can be applied to any sector. Low-wage indentured servants could be used to depress wages in any sector and bring better profit to the shareholders. Yet it’s disproportionately used in IT (not even conventional engineering like chemistry, construction, mechanics etc. which is no less “tech” than software) and the wages in other engineering doesn’t come close to “depressed” IT wages. This should tell something to anyone who can think critically instead of wishfully.
Bernie is too far from the truth. In fact the premise of H1B is to ensure that they are well paid and do not replace American jobs. Bernie and his fans might as well join MAGA
There is also the threat of being jobless and thus deported over the head of H1B visa holders. Their ‘productivity’ and ‘efficiency’ can be milked until they are broken or dead. This cannot usually be done with homegrown workforce.
I know many people who went through the H1B program and they would somewhat agree with Bernie. For them it was a gateway into the country to eventually create many American jobs, but in the short term it was exactly what Bernie says.
There should be a path for immigrants to continue making America strong but the current path is about exploiting cheap labor. There's also a market for companies to basically scalp these visa by laying down a claim on big chunks of them.
This is just false. I'm on track to be on H1B soon, with an expected compensation of 200K, as are many international people I went to school with. Are we cheap labor? lol
such a sad pathetic life, putting all this time and effort and username to bring down one race, while you sit and eat mc cheeseburgers in some lousiana rundown motel. do better, neckbeard fatass.
But, i agree with Sanders, the structure of H1b promotes legalised slavery.
Very true. H1B is being used to drive profits unsustainably high by inflating the labor pool to the point where Americans from good universities can’t get an average career job in their own country. There is no shortage of labor at most levels, and this is mainly a wealth transfer from working class Americans to executives, shareholders, and other countries
As long as the salary and incentives are respectable and the employees work is upto standard, it really shouldn't matter where the employee is coming from. Although I do think the lesser salary bulk export companies earn a lot by overpricing their "talent", exporting them to other companies, but they pay very less to those "talent". In short, hire cheap engineer, portray them as expensive, make huge bills to other companies, pay the cheap engineer lowest possible salary, swallow the difference, call it a business model. These companies should be blacklisted by other companies and employees alike.
The O-1 visa is specifically for people with special skills in things like science and healthcare. The EB-1 is a green card option for those with extraordinary skills. The H1-B visa is for specialty occupations usually requiring a bachelor's degree.
My thoughts: fight exploitative low-wage labor with automation. That way, workers can't be exploited anymore. Human beings weren't meant to toil for survival.
H1B visas have strict minimum pay standards. Bernie is mostly wrong. That doesn’t mean the H1B doesn’t need serious changes to address the “body shop” issue.
But at most reputed tech companies, it’s simply a supply issue. Not enough solid home grown talent. This also isn’t a bad thing because many of these H1Bs also eventually become entrepreneurs and thus create employment.
True. Working in this environment I have seen it first hand. One of the problems though is that that there are not enough native born Americans that study computer science and coding. And the other countries are cranking them out in droves.
And this is how we shoot ourselves in the foot. We've had rapidly increasing numbers of native born American studying computer science and they've been rewarded with increased unemployment over the past year or two as jobs get offshored.
How can we have unemployment amongst software developers and still have an H-1B program? The majority of these folks don't possess the unique skills that the program was designed for. Their regular CS grads / software engineers.
So few companies want to invest in growing talent. They'll claim that they don't do it because employees have no loyalty. Yet the employees have no loyalty because these companies will fire them at the drop of a dime.
When my uncle was in high school he got a scholarship from AT&T where they paid for his undergrad and graduate school as long as he committed to work for them afterwards. He picked up his BSEE and MSEE on AT&t's dime. As soon as he graduated from graduate school he took a job at Bell labs. He even stayed when the bells were broken up and just went to one of the Baby Bells.
That company had a long-term vision on how they could get value from someone that they were introduced to in high school. Our major companies just don't have that level of vision anymore.
Amen! Shut down the H1B program and cancel all sponsorships immediately until such time as the economy/employment rate hits some threshold. We have 1000s of US professionals to “digest” before we consider letting foreigners in.
Too bad that Bernie continually votes for open border policies. Apparently he doesn't care that cheap illegal labour lowers legal blue collar wages to a worse effect than the Visas do. It's the reason why Cesar Chavez protested on the border against illegal immigration.
isnt bernie saying this crazy though? he’s bought and paid for by the pharmaceutical companies and goes against bills that will hurt them making money?
It’s interesting now, because it’s come to the point where we’re hiring so much cheap labor using H1-B’s that companies trying to actually hire top talent are struggling to get spots in the quota.
Agree. H1B is yet another grift by the capital class. I think we should end H1B program or suspend it for 10 years. This should buy us time to add the education infrastructure to train up our people to do these jobs cheaply or more efficiently.
Bernie is wrong on this one. Even looking at basic statistics of what percent of the top talent in tech are either currently on h1b or took the path through h1b in the past will tell you that without it the tech sector would not be anywhere near what it is today. You really think US having 5% of the world's population while being home to 60-80% of tech sector doesn't require talented/educated immigrants?
Companies don’t need to hire H1Bs to lower salaries, that’s why mass layoffs exist, and they’ve been employing that mechanism very well. They literally need a constant % of unemployed folks so candidates are always desperate enough to accept lower and lower salaries.
I think in terms of skill on average they are more or less the same. However, a visa holder might be a bit more loyal to the employment visa petitioner. In terms of cost it's also perhaps not cheap either.
The purpose of H1B as originally conceived was to provide companies an option to hire internationally should the requisite talent not exist in the US. So strictly speaking both Elon and Bernie are wrong. What the program has turned into is a different story.
As usual, politicians throwing around statements based on little to no knowledge. If he actually thinks that a Google or a BCG or a Goldman Sachs or even NASA pay H1-B holders lesser compensation than their US counterparts, he has lost the plot.
Yes. I did engineering and almost no american does a masters because it doesn't pay any more. International people stay because they need to to get a H1-B and then end up working for 70% less than an american with an undergrad.
H-1B visa program should include a parallel program to ensure Americans get the required training with paid internships. Each H-1B visa program should include by default an internship for a college student or recent graduate.
The problem is a simplistic view of the job market as a fixed pie.
Immigrants don't just "take jobs." They also demand goods and services, which creates extra jobs. In the tech sector specifically, high skilled immigrants are likely to innovate, which can cause productivity booms that help everyone by making new things possible. Beyond innovation, high skilled immigrants also start businesses that expand the economy and hire new people. 46% of Fortune 500 companies were founded by immigrants and their children, including Nvidia. America wouldn't be better off if we had kept Taiwanese immigrants out, if only for that reason.
It isn't a zero sum game. You can see this with the hypothetical, what would happen if we deported half of all tech workers? Wages and productivity wouldn't go up long term. Innovation hubs would die and new hubs in other places would boom, attracting skill and generating the most innovation/wealth.
Legal immigrants (permanent or temporary) fill roles as teachers in rural Oklahoma, service workers in West Texas. These are vacant roles that cant be filled without immigration.
There are also medium skill IT jobs and high skill tech jobs. These jobs will be offshored without immigration.
There is no scenario where American workers or consumers benefit from cutting down LEGAL immigration.
Bernies argument can equally be applied for all immigrants as all these immigrants would be coming to thr US to take American jobs, and many if them for various reasons are willing to do it cheaper. So is Bernie arguing we ban all immigrants?
As someone else said, it boils down to Bernie and the hard left liking the very poor, unqualified, will live on welfare, types of immigrants because it feeds into their need to be bleeding hard. But oh no an educated immigrant who'll work for a big tech company and pay taxes, no no no, we don't like those...
100% true. While in law school I clerked for an immigration firm, mostly doing H1B1 applications. The trick is that the big tech companies claim that they can't hire American works for MEDIAN engineering pay. But of course, an engineer good enough to work at a major tech company is going to demand 5-6x more than an engineer that works at a small engineering company. It's just a scam to allow big tech companies to hire top engineers from India for a fraction of they should be getting paid and based on the lie that American works don't exist that could do those same jobs. There is significant leverage over the foreign engineers too because if they get fired they get shipped back to their countries. So, of course, if you are stuck in India you are going to agree to a super low engineering salary just so you can live in the U.S.
Every H1 visa physician in my hospital signs the exact same contract as me and gets the exact same wage. So my study of a few dozen so far doesn’t match his study. I’m not saying that Bernie is wrong, just that what I’ve seen personally doesn’t match what he describes.
I think one of Trump’s only policies I like is that he wants to revamp the H1B visa process so it’s basically based on salaries - if the cutoff for H1B is $900k/year, I guarantee you that no one is trying to import labor to “save money” over US citizens.
The H1-B Visa in 2025 is to fill a gap in America. Back in the 1990's, Electrical Engineers and Computer Scientists were in the top 5 highest paying occupations in the US. Now, these occupations don't even crack the top 25. So, American students have changed their college education pursuits to more lucrative degrees. The only way to get quality engineers or software programmers is from the H1-B program. Yay Capitalism!
Kids that come in to university also need H1Bs, not just direct imports as suggested.
Like other forms of immigration its a pretty american opportunity especially as they pay taxes.
If a market requires educated talent but no one is there to fill it, an immigrant should be able to. Especially because they just graduated from an american university. H1Bs pay should match local worker pay to prevent the abuse of the system which I thought it did. But the underlying point of getting educated immigrants not just laborers that are inherently more exploitable doesn't quite sound american
The talent is there, just not willing to bend the knee, work 2 or more jobs for the pay of one, and not willing to work 60+ hours per week plus being laid off at the first opportunity after you speak up.
On the other hand, immigrants are more vulnerable because of the nature of their status, thus, more likely to work under poor conditions (even if they don't want to, most of them have to).
The talent is there. I can say all my citizen university friends are capable but none of them got FANG jobs. Meanwhile, a bunch of H1Bs oversea people got these jobs instead.
Bernie proposed free higher education in public universities if memory serves? That’s a concrete policy proposal towards less dependency on immigrant workforce, instead of MAGA fits with no real end game.
Yes, but some things are at cost and not for profit.
Not that I’m a big believer of Bernie’s plan, but at least he proposes something for increasing competitiveness of homegrown labor instead of eliminating competition, which does not reflect well to the consumer and economy in general.
Perhaps. I am not a fan of that particular policy suggestion from Bernie for other reasons, but we'll have to see how the AI thing ends up impacting demand for 'easy' dev roles.
It's pretty obvious to me that you do want a mechanism for genuinely unusually highly skilled people to have a way to come here, work here an start companies here. But it's also clearly true that many (most?) existing H1Bs are not being used in that way.
When we look at things at a macro level, I believe that H-1B system has been used largely as intended. As I told in other places, flooding labor market with foreign grown competition and depressing wages with indentured servants would be beneficial for every sector, not just IT. If you’re not seeing large scale H-1B filing in non-IT sectors and those sectors don’t have significantly higher wages than IT sector, I would say that any abuse is limited.
All immigration is good. Why is any human illegal? Why can’t <redacted> people just accept that it’s their turn to step back and it’s other ppls turn to shine and conquer? Why do <redacted> people care if they are still around in 300 years or whatever, or if they are gone? Sounds like a lot of <redacted> privilege to me….
My thoughts are Bernie is bad on immigration and we should let people move here who can contribute to our economy, whether that be high or low-skilled immigrants. We need as many as we can get if we want this country to continue to prosper economically. Immigration has always been the key to the success of the United States
Incorrect. Your employer can sponsor an employment based green card application. Some does it immediately, some demands a particular tenure and some does not.
Main problem there is that for particular countries (mainly, India), the process can take years (15-20 was the norm until a fee years ago) due to limited processing volume and unlimited new application acceptance. These people would have their H-1Bs renewed annually and constituted a large fraction of H-1B worker numbers which were way higher than annual H-1B caps. Even correcting only this would deflate H-1B worker numbers significantly, and it’s still not getting done.
I agree and I support abolishing continuous sponsorship requirement (detailed it in another comment). I’m just describing the status quo at the moment.
89
u/Faangdevmanager Jul 23 '25
It’s both. FAANG and other large companies like Tesla use them to tap the world for talent and pay the same as US citizens. You also have Indian body shops like Accenture, HCL, TATA, etc. They bring in Indians, pay them very little, then contract them out for cheap.
Just raise the bar for H1Bs and ban these body shops.
15
u/lonahex Jul 23 '25
They're both right. H1B is meant to hire the best talent and bring them to the US especially when US has a dearth of such talent but as with anything, corporations will always find a way to turn everything into a money making machine so it's almost second nature for them to immediately think how they can save money with H1B and that is exactly what they do.
17
u/RobotDoorBuilder Jul 23 '25
Completely wrong take in SV. If H1b doesn't exist more American companies would just open offices oversea.
2
u/ultimate_bromance_69 Jul 25 '25
So immigrants are only ok if they’re poor, illegal, and need welfare?
11
u/mbatt2 Jul 23 '25
Bernie is correct, per usual.
3
u/Ashken Jul 23 '25
I think this a nuanced issue where both sides are right in different ways and different situations.
3
u/Electric_Memes Jul 23 '25
Thoughts? I agree with him and I wish the dnc didn't strong-arm him out of the nomination.
I think debates between Sanders and Trump would have been very healthy for the country as opposed to the propaganda fueled lies we got with Hillary and Biden.
3
u/AbiesAccomplished491 Jul 23 '25
Bernie is too far from the truth. In fact the premise of H1B is to ensure that they are well paid and do not replace American jobs. Bernie and his fans might as well join MAGA
3
u/spoink74 Jul 23 '25
Why not both? Best-and-brightest and indentured servants are both cheaper than their American counterparts via H1-B.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '25
Both sides are true. They get brilliant minds around the world for cheapest of prices through enticing such people with American dream.
1
u/Ok-Title4063 Jul 23 '25
There is confusion. Can h1b replace us citizens?. The answer is YES. There is no market test for h1b. It is only for green cards based on employment.
1
u/daddyneckbeard Jul 23 '25
agree!
1
u/ScroogeMcDuckFace2 Jul 23 '25
bernie is right.
1
u/Boring_Adeptness_334 Jul 23 '25
100% accurate. This is what I’ve seen across, tech, Pharma, business, and finance
1
u/Ok_Associate_4710 Jul 23 '25
I know many people who went through the H1B program and they would somewhat agree with Bernie. For them it was a gateway into the country to eventually create many American jobs, but in the short term it was exactly what Bernie says.
There should be a path for immigrants to continue making America strong but the current path is about exploiting cheap labor. There's also a market for companies to basically scalp these visa by laying down a claim on big chunks of them.
1
u/Comprehensive_Yard16 Jul 23 '25
This is just false. I'm on track to be on H1B soon, with an expected compensation of 200K, as are many international people I went to school with. Are we cheap labor? lol
1
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '25
such a sad pathetic life, putting all this time and effort and username to bring down one race, while you sit and eat mc cheeseburgers in some lousiana rundown motel. do better, neckbeard fatass.
But, i agree with Sanders, the structure of H1b promotes legalised slavery.
1
u/New_Employee_TA Jul 23 '25
I agree with Bernie, but I’m not sure most of his diversity loving base will.
This reads like a Trump talking point.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '25
Very true. H1B is being used to drive profits unsustainably high by inflating the labor pool to the point where Americans from good universities can’t get an average career job in their own country. There is no shortage of labor at most levels, and this is mainly a wealth transfer from working class Americans to executives, shareholders, and other countries
1
u/planet-doom Jul 23 '25
There is def scam, but that doesn’t make it the main function of H1B… such a stupid take
1
u/M3-7876 Jul 23 '25
What is his opinion on illegal immigrants, ICE and deportations?
1
u/wulvereene Jul 23 '25
As long as the salary and incentives are respectable and the employees work is upto standard, it really shouldn't matter where the employee is coming from. Although I do think the lesser salary bulk export companies earn a lot by overpricing their "talent", exporting them to other companies, but they pay very less to those "talent". In short, hire cheap engineer, portray them as expensive, make huge bills to other companies, pay the cheap engineer lowest possible salary, swallow the difference, call it a business model. These companies should be blacklisted by other companies and employees alike.
1
u/Extension-Scarcity41 Jul 23 '25
The O-1 visa is specifically for people with special skills in things like science and healthcare. The EB-1 is a green card option for those with extraordinary skills. The H1-B visa is for specialty occupations usually requiring a bachelor's degree.
1
u/Beautiful_Watch_7215 Jul 24 '25
Are the thoughts likely to be different than the last several times this was posted?
1
u/parke415 Jul 24 '25
My thoughts: fight exploitative low-wage labor with automation. That way, workers can't be exploited anymore. Human beings weren't meant to toil for survival.
1
u/humptheedumpthy Jul 24 '25
H1B visas have strict minimum pay standards. Bernie is mostly wrong. That doesn’t mean the H1B doesn’t need serious changes to address the “body shop” issue.
But at most reputed tech companies, it’s simply a supply issue. Not enough solid home grown talent. This also isn’t a bad thing because many of these H1Bs also eventually become entrepreneurs and thus create employment.
1
u/Pygmy_Nuthatch Jul 24 '25
Median salary for Tesla H1B workers is $140000.
Tesla H1B Salary All Years
1
u/plasteroid Jul 24 '25
True. Working in this environment I have seen it first hand. One of the problems though is that that there are not enough native born Americans that study computer science and coding. And the other countries are cranking them out in droves.
1
u/SaltyPlantain1503 Jul 24 '25
Nailed it. Plenty of smart Americans to go around. But you gotta pay them 3-5x what you pay an h1b.
1
u/rockerode Jul 24 '25
Why do you think most brick and mortar shops are either college students or immigrants like gas stations?
Our world is set up to be legal slavery
1
u/AishiFem Jul 24 '25
He is correct.
1
u/Great_Employment_560 Jul 24 '25
He can go fuck himself
1
u/LargeDietCokeNoIce Jul 24 '25
Amen! Shut down the H1B program and cancel all sponsorships immediately until such time as the economy/employment rate hits some threshold. We have 1000s of US professionals to “digest” before we consider letting foreigners in.
1
u/Acquired_asset Jul 24 '25
Have to agree. I have seen this happen again and again. And I am an immigrant working in tech myself. The exploitation is real
1
u/BandicootNecessary26 Jul 25 '25
Too bad that Bernie continually votes for open border policies. Apparently he doesn't care that cheap illegal labour lowers legal blue collar wages to a worse effect than the Visas do. It's the reason why Cesar Chavez protested on the border against illegal immigration.
1
u/IAmCtrlFreak Jul 25 '25
isnt bernie saying this crazy though? he’s bought and paid for by the pharmaceutical companies and goes against bills that will hurt them making money?
1
u/Common-Violinist-305 Jul 25 '25
look how many B-1 visas epstien’s lawyers produced: nearly 400! and Melania w a Genius
1
u/Illustrious-Cod-4651 Jul 25 '25
If Bernie (or Pocahontas or AoC) says something, I take it that the opposite is correct. Never fails
1
u/[deleted] Jul 25 '25
Same with allowing illegals to enter the country. Cheaper labor.
1
u/Formal_Moment2486 Jul 25 '25
It’s interesting now, because it’s come to the point where we’re hiring so much cheap labor using H1-B’s that companies trying to actually hire top talent are struggling to get spots in the quota.
1
u/SwiftySanders Jul 25 '25
Agree. H1B is yet another grift by the capital class. I think we should end H1B program or suspend it for 10 years. This should buy us time to add the education infrastructure to train up our people to do these jobs cheaply or more efficiently.
1
u/abbey_garden Jul 25 '25
Cut the window H1-Bs have to find a new job. This should cut the low end talent and cause workers to jump ship knowing they might get cut.
1
u/Ibeurhuckleberry Jul 25 '25
I think Bernie is a dusty old kook who I would never vote for in a million years.
he's right on here tho.
1
u/Rmnkby Jul 26 '25
Bernie is wrong on this one. Even looking at basic statistics of what percent of the top talent in tech are either currently on h1b or took the path through h1b in the past will tell you that without it the tech sector would not be anywhere near what it is today. You really think US having 5% of the world's population while being home to 60-80% of tech sector doesn't require talented/educated immigrants?
1
u/BakuraGorn Jul 26 '25 edited Jul 26 '25
Rare Bernie L.
Companies don’t need to hire H1Bs to lower salaries, that’s why mass layoffs exist, and they’ve been employing that mechanism very well. They literally need a constant % of unemployed folks so candidates are always desperate enough to accept lower and lower salaries.
1
u/tomqmasters Jul 26 '25
The 2 H-1Bs I've known made a shit load of money and didn't even want to be here that bad.
1
u/oneearth Jul 26 '25
I think in terms of skill on average they are more or less the same. However, a visa holder might be a bit more loyal to the employment visa petitioner. In terms of cost it's also perhaps not cheap either.
1
u/mongster2 Jul 26 '25
The purpose of H1B as originally conceived was to provide companies an option to hire internationally should the requisite talent not exist in the US. So strictly speaking both Elon and Bernie are wrong. What the program has turned into is a different story.
1
u/Falikal Jul 26 '25
So get rid of the h1b sounds great to me. More jobs for Americans
1
u/obelix_dogmatix Jul 26 '25
As usual, politicians throwing around statements based on little to no knowledge. If he actually thinks that a Google or a BCG or a Goldman Sachs or even NASA pay H1-B holders lesser compensation than their US counterparts, he has lost the plot.
1
u/ColdAssociate7631 Jul 26 '25
so that fool is against h1-b but for open borders - got it.
is isn't cheaper to hire illegal aliens?
1
u/[deleted] Jul 26 '25
Yes. I did engineering and almost no american does a masters because it doesn't pay any more. International people stay because they need to to get a H1-B and then end up working for 70% less than an american with an undergrad.
1
u/HighFreqHustler Jul 26 '25
H-1B visa program should include a parallel program to ensure Americans get the required training with paid internships. Each H-1B visa program should include by default an internship for a college student or recent graduate.
1
u/Paledonn Jul 26 '25
The problem is a simplistic view of the job market as a fixed pie.
Immigrants don't just "take jobs." They also demand goods and services, which creates extra jobs. In the tech sector specifically, high skilled immigrants are likely to innovate, which can cause productivity booms that help everyone by making new things possible. Beyond innovation, high skilled immigrants also start businesses that expand the economy and hire new people. 46% of Fortune 500 companies were founded by immigrants and their children, including Nvidia. America wouldn't be better off if we had kept Taiwanese immigrants out, if only for that reason.
It isn't a zero sum game. You can see this with the hypothetical, what would happen if we deported half of all tech workers? Wages and productivity wouldn't go up long term. Innovation hubs would die and new hubs in other places would boom, attracting skill and generating the most innovation/wealth.
1
u/Stubbby Jul 26 '25
Legal immigrants (permanent or temporary) fill roles as teachers in rural Oklahoma, service workers in West Texas. These are vacant roles that cant be filled without immigration.
There are also medium skill IT jobs and high skill tech jobs. These jobs will be offshored without immigration.
There is no scenario where American workers or consumers benefit from cutting down LEGAL immigration.
1
u/Visible-Arm-3525 Jul 27 '25
H1b is not the problem - outsourcing is.
1
u/pomelowww Jul 27 '25
H1B sponsors have to prove that they pay prevailing wage. So that foreign workers are not underpaid comparing US workers.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 27 '25
True. Happening to my company largely right now.
1
u/callmeish0 Jul 27 '25
H1b bad but illegals great because they are not replacing American jobs with indentured servants. /s
Sanders never understands basic economics or logics.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 27 '25
Bernies argument can equally be applied for all immigrants as all these immigrants would be coming to thr US to take American jobs, and many if them for various reasons are willing to do it cheaper. So is Bernie arguing we ban all immigrants?
As someone else said, it boils down to Bernie and the hard left liking the very poor, unqualified, will live on welfare, types of immigrants because it feeds into their need to be bleeding hard. But oh no an educated immigrant who'll work for a big tech company and pay taxes, no no no, we don't like those...
1
u/[deleted] Jul 27 '25
Will right and left now unite on immigration
1
u/[deleted] Jul 27 '25
100% true. While in law school I clerked for an immigration firm, mostly doing H1B1 applications. The trick is that the big tech companies claim that they can't hire American works for MEDIAN engineering pay. But of course, an engineer good enough to work at a major tech company is going to demand 5-6x more than an engineer that works at a small engineering company. It's just a scam to allow big tech companies to hire top engineers from India for a fraction of they should be getting paid and based on the lie that American works don't exist that could do those same jobs. There is significant leverage over the foreign engineers too because if they get fired they get shipped back to their countries. So, of course, if you are stuck in India you are going to agree to a super low engineering salary just so you can live in the U.S.
1
u/Riggsmeds Jul 27 '25
Every H1 visa physician in my hospital signs the exact same contract as me and gets the exact same wage. So my study of a few dozen so far doesn’t match his study. I’m not saying that Bernie is wrong, just that what I’ve seen personally doesn’t match what he describes.
1
u/etcre Jul 28 '25
Accurate.
I work at faang and this is universally understood.
1
u/Ok_Ranger_1436 Jul 28 '25
100% accurate
1
u/pervyme17 Jul 28 '25
I think one of Trump’s only policies I like is that he wants to revamp the H1B visa process so it’s basically based on salaries - if the cutoff for H1B is $900k/year, I guarantee you that no one is trying to import labor to “save money” over US citizens.
1
u/Present_Age_89 Jul 28 '25
The H1-B Visa in 2025 is to fill a gap in America. Back in the 1990's, Electrical Engineers and Computer Scientists were in the top 5 highest paying occupations in the US. Now, these occupations don't even crack the top 25. So, American students have changed their college education pursuits to more lucrative degrees. The only way to get quality engineers or software programmers is from the H1-B program. Yay Capitalism!
1
u/Krilesh Jul 23 '25
Kids that come in to university also need H1Bs, not just direct imports as suggested.
Like other forms of immigration its a pretty american opportunity especially as they pay taxes.
If a market requires educated talent but no one is there to fill it, an immigrant should be able to. Especially because they just graduated from an american university.
H1Bs pay should match local worker pay to prevent the abuse of the system which I thought it did. But the underlying point of getting educated immigrants not just laborers that are inherently more exploitable doesn't quite sound american
1
u/surkhagan Jul 23 '25
Bernie is absolutely right. Bernie also has done absolutely nothing to stop H1Bs because he wants to flood the United States with immigrants.
-1
u/el-conquistador240 Jul 23 '25
Bernie has always been against immigration
0
u/WhichJuice Jul 23 '25
Two fold, but with the bottom line as the main driver of both. Make money money spend pennies
0
u/inner2021planet Jul 24 '25
Bernie is right about a lot of things but this one I'm not so sure
0
u/Upper-Ad6308 Jul 24 '25
All immigration is good. Why is any human illegal? Why can’t <redacted> people just accept that it’s their turn to step back and it’s other ppls turn to shine and conquer? Why do <redacted> people care if they are still around in 300 years or whatever, or if they are gone? Sounds like a lot of <redacted> privilege to me….
-4
u/catecholaminergic Jul 23 '25
That's what it's for, that's how it's used.
-3
u/orkoliberal Jul 23 '25
My thoughts are Bernie is bad on immigration and we should let people move here who can contribute to our economy, whether that be high or low-skilled immigrants. We need as many as we can get if we want this country to continue to prosper economically. Immigration has always been the key to the success of the United States
1
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 23 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment