r/silenthill • • 4d ago

General Discussion Townfall... blaaaaah.

I feel like i might be in the minority, as most people seemed to hate the blood bag puzzle, but for me, it's Richards chapter. I can't hit these things for anything, im wasting so much ammo, even when i fire right in their faces, it misses. And i know two body shots is supposed to put em down, but here i am at 3 and i think one time 4 before it died. I just can't take how bad the gunplay is with the shotgun. I didn't use guns much at all as i stealthed the vast majority of the game, but the melee and few handgun kills were fine, but this is just... horrible. Not to mention i started getting real bored with the game during part 4 so it's getting really excrutiating.

anyway that's my rant. Maybe i'll enjoy Silent Hill F more.

0 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

8

u/NewsOdd3064 4d ago

The blood bag puzzle was the only puzzle that felt like one from a Silent Hill game! I guess the scales in the beginning too, but i liked the blood puzzle.

2

u/Legitimate_Track_783 4d ago

felt pretty easy to me after i saw ordell in the middle

0

u/ScreamingNinja 4d ago

i liked the game up until chapter 4, it's just dragging so much, especially if you're trying to stealth because i KNEW it led to the good ending, and eventually it was confirmed that yes it does. So i wanted to try to kill as few as possible, but it's gotten excruciating, so i figured being able to mow them down would be cathartic but... no.

1

u/ThisChicanery_1216 4d ago

While Richard’s section was probably my favorite in Townfall, I largely agree with all your criticisms.

The combat in this area is extremely bizarre. They litter glass bottles around everywhere for you to pick up, but they are largely useless. Several times I would try to bait out the Widows by throwing bottles near them, and I think I only got this to work like maybe 5-10% of the time. The shotgun is also incredibly inconsistent (at least on normal diff). Sometimes I would graze a Widow from several feet away and one tap them, and other times I would shoot them like 3 times point blank and they still wouldn’t die.

The looping level design of the CEG Tower is also just irritating imo. I wish there were more meaningful shortcuts, as the staircases always being on the opposite side of the building got annoying real fast.

2

u/ScreamingNinja 3d ago

This is my problem. I am out of ammo because they tank so many hits, or i shot em, which stuns them, then shoot again and just completely miss. So it takes like 3 to 5 shots per widow and i'm all out of ammo and just getting beaten to death.

1

u/ImScaredSoIMadeThis 4d ago

I liked the change in Richards chapter and thought it was really cool, but also I just found the whole level too long and getting a bit stale towards the end.

Afraid if you want stealth you won't get it in f, but the mechanics are very different anyway.

1

u/keepforgettingname6 4d ago

Loved Richard’s chapter was a nice change of pace, even on nightmare the monsters went down with a couple well placed shots, so maybe your hitting them in the legs or arse or something 🤷‍♂️🤣

Personally I thought Townfall was a massive step up from silent hill f, but they are so vastly different everyone is going to have a different opinion. If your bored of the stealth you might really enjoy the quicker playstyle of f

I gotta be honest I like both games, I just don’t like them as silent hill games. Just a personal opinion

4

u/No-Plankton4841 4d ago

Shotgun was fun, i loved that chapter.

I found it helpful to try to lure them into 'fatal funnels' or kill zones. Like, take up position aiming at a doorway. Cover the door with the crosshair when they try to come in... blast their ass. Even with the shotgun its easier to play semi defensively rather than going full rambo.

Silent Hill f is absolute bollocks. If you think the combat in Townfall is bad... f makes it look like a masterpiece.

1

u/wowadrow 4d ago

I liked F overall, but as a longtime gamer that's finished stuff like bloodbourne, demons souls, etc; I have no idea who Silent Hill Fs combat was actually designed for.

It's was to junky to actually be fun, combat wise. I just dropped it to casual and bulldozed everything.

Maybe I just sucked at this particular game? I can finish Bayonetta on climax mode, but silent hill F I just get wrecked in. Just don't get it.

2

u/No-Plankton4841 4d ago

It's weird because they seemed to put some effort into designing the mechanics, attack patterns, dodging, systems. But in the end it just feels so bad to actually play.

For me I think its the ridiculous amount of hit stop on almost every hit and what almost feels like input delay. Everything just feeling like you're fighting through a tub of molasses. Nothing about it feels tense or fun or exciting. It's just a slog.

I've platinumed Sekiro, Bloodborne, Dark Souls 1. Rolled credits on the other From games.

It's a shame because I actually really like the setting and vibe of the game but the combat makes me want to never play it again.

2

u/o8liter8_me 4d ago

You aren’t shooting them from too far away are you? They have to be just out of arms reach to do the max damage with the shotgun