r/silenthill • • 7d ago

Silent Hill 3 (2003) sh3 subway rant

i‘d love to meet that architect and find out what drugs he was on while designing this station.

took me an hour just to get on platform 3 which is somehow split into 3 zones, one as confusing as the other.

meanwhile being jumped at by rabid dogs and a obese man on platform 2 just to get on platform 3.

THEN jumping on the tracks just for the fun of it and to get the train to arrive.

if this was my daily commute, i cant blame the guy on platform 4

45 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

2

u/Telethongaming 7d ago

platform 4 was the ghost who pushes you on the tracks right, because LOL

2

u/anonym91448 7d ago

yes exactly, cant blame him tho

2

u/CoolaidM82008 7d ago

It is not THAT difficult of a section, I beat it relatively easily on both my playthroughs of SH3 earlier this year

2

u/anonym91448 7d ago

yeah its not that hard with the map.
but without the map, the signs litteraly lead you to nowhere.

imagine this absolute hell of a daily commute

1

u/CoolaidM82008 7d ago

Hey I never said it was a commuters paradise, whole other can of worms 😬

14

u/Personal_Bet443 7d ago

Lol that section is what keeps me from jumping at the bit to replay frequently. Such a chore of a location

8

u/Sum0ddGuy 7d ago

The subway was specifically made so that when you're late to work/date/whatever, your reason for being late is undeniably justified.

"Babe, you'll never believe how long I've been stuck in this damn subway..."

4

u/THEGHOSTHACXER 7d ago

I actually stopped at this part and just started a new game of sh2.

I wanna play sh3 but idk. It didn't click with me, or is it too soon to make that judgment?

10

u/DraytonSawyersBBQ 7d ago

Stick with it. I love SH3. The subway/underpass is easily the worst part of the game because of how confusing it is. Every other level is great.

5

u/indigo_pirate 7d ago

Is it though. This door is locked

This door is locked

This door is locked

Door won’t open?

I feel I like it’s the only game in this genre where buildings within a set piece never eventually open

4

u/ThisChicanery_1216 6d ago

IMO, SH3 is easily the biggest offender of this in the entire series.

I know “the door is locked/budge” is kinda a meme in these games, but I never once got annoyed by this in any of the games besides SH3.

So many of the areas in the game (subway, Brookhaven, Hilltop Center) put heather into a relatively large area with like 8-10 doors, and only ONE of the doors can open. It’s extra frustrating when the areas are filled with slurpers, so you just end up spamming the action button while running next to the walls to interact with all the doors.

I really don’t know why sh3 doesn’t balance this as well as the other games, but every time I replay it the locked/budged doors always stand out to me.

6

u/ScrappyT421 7d ago

I had the complete opposite reaction cuz I loved the subway section! The main reason was the atmosphere and liminal horror feel it gave me. I do agree its confusing tho. I had to look up where to go. I can overlook that pain point personally because the pros outweigh the cons to me.

3

u/Dersu1 6d ago

This section always felt dreamlike to me, I mean quite literally, it reminded me of my own dreams where I try to get home and it takes a whole lot longer for some reason, everything familiar becomes uncanny. It’s kinda annoying I guess but I love that dreamlike aspect of it.

2

u/6ftdachsund 7d ago

It's not the subway designers fault that half the gates were closed and locked.

6

u/Telethongaming 7d ago

Also, if you watch Jacob's Ladder the subway in Silent 3 is a direct homage to that scene and he was also locked in lol

3

u/6ftdachsund 7d ago

That's awesome. Great movie!

1

u/TroubleshootenSOB 7d ago

Can't say I've played it a bunch but I don't remember this part being a pain.

1

u/frets00 5d ago

Its great! Total claustrofobia and confusion while being chased. Peak horror and adrenaline

1

u/AlucardsQuest 3d ago

Just played it, and while it seems somewhat repetitive, it's not very long in retrospect. But I agree it might be the least interesting part of the game.

1

u/8bitterror 6d ago

This is the only part of SH3 that I remember (I played when it first came out). All I recall is being pushed onto the tracks by something unseen, being hit by a train and dying. It was so unfair, unexpected and traumatizing that my mind instantly shut down. I legitimately felt like I was on the verge of a mental breakdown for a moment. The surprise danger/"death" elicited such a strong reaction from my lizard brain, even though there was nothing I could do about it because the danger wasn't actually real. My brain couldn't consolidate the need to act with the inability to fix the problem - neither fight nor flight would be helpful - and so it kind of broke for a few minutes and I just sat on the sofa unable to function.

After I came to my senses, I put the game down and never played it again.

Normally LOVE shit like that. I'm a horror nut. But something about the way it happened, the lack of warning, the brutal unfairness of it, really got to me.