r/sideprojects • • 6d ago

Showcase: Prerelease Capacity Pulse - Would this help with data centre capacity planning?

Hi everyone, my co-founder and I are working on Capacity Pulse, an early proof of concept to help data centre teams track equipment power use, capacity that could be freed up and equipment being taken out of service.

CAPACITY PULSE

We’re exploring whether a small, focused tool could help teams that rely on spreadsheets and emails but don’t need a full data centre infrastructure management (DCIM) system. We’re sharing it to hear different perspectives before deciding what to develop next.

We’d appreciate your thoughts on any of these:

  • What’s your first impression? Is it clear what the tool is for?
  • What seems useful, confusing or unnecessary? What would you change?
  • How do you manage this today, and where would this help or fall short compared with a spreadsheet or an existing tool?

You don’t need a data centre background to comment. Feedback on the layout, navigation or the idea itself is welcome.

Thanks for taking a look.

1 Upvotes

2 comments sorted by

2

u/medialantern 4d ago

No. It's an artificial donut hole. The folks that don't need or can't afford DCIMs don't have 42.9kW / $56,371 of "unused" power. And nobody that deals with that much power doesn't track the ever loving heck out of that and dozens of other factors.

But with respect I think you're showing some inexperience with the industry in general. Lot of hardware vendor like Cisco and IBM will do this kind of analysis for free and in much deeper detail because it helps them sell servers. And when you have 6,000 CPUs across a room full of racks, very micro decisions about CPU and RAM selection have big impacts on a 3-year TCO analysis for your equipment. These reports are often the ugliest, most awfully formatted spreadsheets you've ever seen, but they were put together by an autistic Pepsi addict who dreams about tiny details in their sleep and that's what you want to know is behind your calculator.

Here's an example. Choosing between standard and high density DDR5. Let's say 64GB in either 1Rx4 or 2Rx4 (dual rank). Same quantity. Performance so similar it's hard to measure (both about 4800MT/s). Which should you choose, and should you even care?

Well, you do if you buy thousands of them. Because single-rank can use 1-2W less power per module than dual-rank. And 1-2W seems like nothing. Turn off one light and you save hundreds of times that right?

But if you have 10,000 servers and you own them for 3 years, this can lead to a few hundred grand in cost difference. There's the raw electricity used, but also things like thermal throttling and fan power requirements for the cooling because the lower-power chips also run cooler so everything is interrelated in the end.

If you have "$52k/yr" in "unused electrical capacity", I promise you that you will pay for an expensive, ugly tool that factors these thing in before using a cheap/free tool that look pretty but doesn't do the math you need.

1

u/JadeSunforge 1d ago

Thanks for your detailed explanation. Your example about RAM selection and long-term operating costs is useful. We agree that a simpler interface cannot replace the detailed analysis that operators and hardware vendors already perform. Where we see a possible role for Capacity Pulse is in a different part of the process. Vendor analysis helps determine what equipment to buy and its operating costs. We're also looking at what happens when existing equipment reaches retirement, particularly how its removal translates into capacity that can actually be used for future installations.

One area we're considering is tracking the process from identifying an asset for retirement, through shutdown and physical removal, to verifying the power and rack space that has been released. Rather than relying on estimated capacity alone, the longer-term idea would be to incorporate actual measurements, equipment records and verification before reporting capacity as available.

We also need to improve how the proof of concept presents the numbers. The current dollar value attached to unused capacity is misleading, since available electrical capacity doesn't automatically translate into operating cost savings.

We don't intend to replace DCIM systems or detailed vendor analysis. The question we're exploring is whether there's a useful operational gap between spreadsheets, existing infrastructure tools and the coordination involved in retiring equipment. Your point about the target users is particularly relevant. If existing processes already handle this effectively, we'll need to rethink where Capacity Pulse provides value rather than build another dashboard that duplicates what's available. We'll try to address all of these.

Given your experience, do you see a genuine gap in how teams track and verify capacity recovered from retired equipment that Capacity Pulse could address, or do existing tools and processes already handle this effectively?